2016 Volume 90 Issue 3 Pages 291-296
In October 2014, the varicella vaccination policy in Japan was changed from a single voluntary inoculation to two routine inoculations. This paper reports the results of booster vaccination in children who did not show seroconversion after initial vaccination (i.e., primary vaccine failure：PVF) over a 7-year period prior to the introduction of routine varicella vaccination. Between November 2007 and May 2014, 273 healthy children aged between 1.1 and 14.5 years (median：1.7 years) underwent varicella vaccination. Before and 4 to 6 weeks after vaccination, the antibody titers were measured using an immune adherence hemagglutination (IAHA) assay and a glycoprotein-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (gpELISA). In addition, side reactions were examined during the fourweek period after vaccination. Children who did not show IAHA seroconversion (PVF) were recommended to receive a booster vaccination, and the measurement of antibody titers and an assessment of side reactions were performed after the booster dose. In May 2015, a questionnaire was mailed to each of the 273 participants to investigate whether they had developed varicella and/or herpes zoster after vaccination. After initial vaccination, the IAHA seroconversion rate was 75% and the mean antibody titer (Log2) with seroconversion was 4.7, while the gpELISA seroconversion rate was 84% and the mean antibody titer (Log10) with seroconversion was 2.4. Among children with PVF, 54 received booster vaccination within 81 to 714 days (median：139 days) after the initial vaccination. After booster vaccination, the IAHA seroconversion rate was 98% and the mean antibody titer (Log2) with seroconversion was 5.8. Both the seroconversion rate and the antibody titer were higher compared with the values after the initial vaccination (p＜0.01). After booster vaccination, the gpELISA seropositive rate was 100% and the mean positive antibody titer (Log 10) was 3.6；similar results were obtained for the IAHA assay, with a significantly higher, antibody response than that after the initial vaccination (p＜0.01). Side reactions were generally minor, including fever (≧37.5ºC), rash at the injection site, and rash at other sites. There were no significant differences in the incidences of side reactions between the initial and booster vaccinations. A total of 185 participants responded to the questionnaire (response rate：68%), and the period between receiving the initial vaccination and their response to the questionnaire ranged from 1.0 to 7.5 years (median：4.0 years). The prevalence of breakthrough varicella after the initial vaccination was 17% among seroconverters who did not receive booster vaccination and 14% among non-seroconverters who received booster vaccination, showing no significant difference between the two groups. In conclusion, there are no safety issues regarding the administration of a booster vaccination to children with PVF after an initial varicella vaccination, and a good antibody response can be expected.
