Studies in British Philosophy
Online ISSN : 2433-4731
Print ISSN : 0387-7450
Adam Smith on the irregularity of moral sentiment
Akifumi Shimanouchi
Author information
JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

2008 Volume 31 Pages 35-52

Details
Abstract

Smith proposed an equitable maxim requiring that our moral sentiments of merit and demerit should be based on the expected consequence of the action. But in practice, these sentiments vary with the actual consequence. Smith called this ‘irregularity of moral sentiment (hereafter IS)’. In this paper I would like to suggest Smith's possible explanation and justification of IS in reference to the contemporary debates on moral luck and responsibility. Smith can explain IS in terms of epistemic value of consequence of action. Smith's justifications of IS are based on the practice of atonement and the agent's guilt feeling, which admit of both consequential and non-consequential interpretations.

Content from these authors
© 2008 Japanese Society for British Philosophy
Previous article Next article
feedback
Top