The Japanese Accounting Review
Online ISSN : 2185-4793
Print ISSN : 2185-4785
ISSN-L : 2185-4785
Accrual-Based and Real Activities Based Earnings Management Behavior of Family Firms in Japan
Tai-Yuan ChenZhaoyang GuKeiichi KubotaHitoshi Takehara
Author information

2015 Volume 5 Issue 2015 Pages 21-47


We have explored the extent of accrual-based and real activities-based earnings management using data from family and non-family firms in Japan. Family firms are expected to have lower agency costs because family shareholders and management are more congruent in their pursuit of mutual firm goals and seek lower levels of earnings management. However, this collusion may lead to entrenchment and higher levels of earnings management, which becomes opaque to outside shareholders. A founding family is concerned with the reputation of their firm for sustained socioemotional wealth and family firms may conduct cosmetic earnings management to conceal bad news. We empirically assess the levels of earnings management and investigate whether the level will be lower or higher for family or non-family firms, and identify which method is more costly. The level of accruals and cost may vary among the family firm types; that is, whether or not shareholdings are large or the CEO is from the founding family. We find that the level of both accrual-based and real activity measures is lower for family firms. With cross-section regressions, we find that family shareholding increase the level of abnormal accruals management, whereas the family CEO decreases the level of abnormal accruals, but in both cases the amounts were not significant. We also find that family-related variables decrease the levels of real-activities earnings management. When we introduce economic measures related to the costs of earnings management, we find that Japanese family firms utilize accrual-based earnings management more often than real activities-based earnings management.

Content from these authors
© 2015 Research Institute for Economics & Business Administration - Kobe University
Previous article