Standardization of the Japanese National Standard, equine botulinum antitoxin Type A, and factors affecting standardization

Abstract

Equine botulinum antitoxin is one of the most popular countermeasures for human botulism. The unitage of the antitoxin product is defined according to national minimum requirement or pharmacopoeia in each country by referring to national standard antitoxins for four types (A, B, E, and F). With the expected depletion of the national standard antitoxins, replacement national standard antitoxins are produced and standardized through collaboration of the National Control Laboratory and other participants, including manufacturer(s). Therefore, Japanese National Standard Botulinum Antitoxin Type A, Equine, was replaced according to the results of a collaborative study involving the National Institute of Infectious Diseases and KM Biologics Co., Ltd. The unitage of the replacement material was determined through mouse neutralization tests, which involved toxin-antitoxin mixture injection at pH 7.0. Potency value of 440 units/vial was obtained. However, the Japanese Minimum Requirement for Biological Products was revised, and the neutralization reactions were repeated at pH 6.0, for which considerably different potency value (656 units/vial) and survival profile of mice were obtained. In September 2021, the replacement material, Japanese National Standard Botulinum Antitoxin Type A, Equine, lot 2, was established with potency value of 656 Units/vial. The impact of pH-dependent change in potency on antitoxin quality control is discussed.