In the late 1990s, a debate emerged over whether coral reefs are net sources or sinks for CO2. The prevailing consensus held that coral reefs, through calcification, act as short-term sources of CO2. However, Kayanne et al. (1995) challenged this view by presenting observations that the Shiraho Reef on Ishigaki Island was, in fact, absorbing CO2. Despite further surveys, research, and discussions—both directly and indirectly related to the debate—the consensus that coral reefs are CO2 sources remained in place, and by the 2000s, the debate was considered settled. Nonetheless, the discussions significantly advanced our understanding of the relationship between coral reef community metabolism and the marine carbon cycle. Additionally, the measurement techniques and models developed during this period continue to play a key role in current ocean acidification research.
The initial motivation for this debate was rooted in an engineering perspective, exploring whether the hypothesis of coral reefs as CO2 sinks could be applied for carbon sequestration. This contrasted with the established scientific view that, at a global scale, coral reefs function as CO2 sources within the natural carbon cycle. In recent years, as emission reductions alone have proven insufficient to mitigate global warming, geoengineering approaches that enhance CO2 fixation have gained interest. The expansive photosynthetic areas of coral reefs, created by calcification, warrant re-examination for their potential use in CO2 fixation via photosynthesis, not only by corals but also by seaweeds and seagrasses. Additionally, the capacity of coral reefs to buffer against ocean acidification through the dissolution of calcium carbonate presents another area for exploration.
To fully understand this potential, it is essential to analyze the spatial and temporal dynamics of coral reefs, situating the fate of organic matter and nutrient cycling within the coral reef food web. This requires the development of 3D models that integrate physical processes and carbonate systems, ultimately proposing engineering solutions that combine CO2 absorption with sustainable fishery resources. This review revisits the CO2 sink/source debate in coral reefs, reevaluates the current understanding, and discusses potential future research directions and geoengineering applications.
View full abstract