Introduction:In the treatment of dysphagia,a subjective assessment of certain factors,such as the patient's quality of life,is important.However,their studies in Japan are insufficient at present.In this article,to examine the usability of generic and disease-specific measures on people with dysphagia,we tested the MOS 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey (the SF-36) Japanese version 1.2 (Fukuhara et al., 2001),and the SWAL-QOL and SWAL-CARE outcomes tool (McHorney et al., 2000,2002) in Japanese.
Method: We tested both questionnaires on people with dysphagia,in a mail survey protocol.The number of subjects analyzed was 23,18 male and 5 female,aged 58.7 on average.Seventeen of them had cerebro-vascular disease,three brain tumor,two traumatic brain injury,one hypoxic encephalopathy.
Result:We tested the SF-36.Cronbach's α ranged from 0.59 to 0.72 for all eight scales and it exhibited internalconsistency reliability.All scales except one (Body Pain) were significantly lower than the standard scores for Japanese.The profile obtained was similar to that of people with cerebro-vascular disease.We pretested the SWAL-QOL/CARE.All the scores showed extensive distributions.The Cronbach's α ranged from 0.86 to 0.90 for all scales and it exhibited the internal-consistency reliability.In the results obtained from the same question and the rate of missed data,significant differences were not obtained between the SWAL-QOL/CARE and the SF-36.Hence,we obtained reliability on external criterion.The discriminant validity was assured by the low correlations of the total scores toward the SF-36 (the SWAL-QOL 0.26,the SWAL-CARE 0.25,on average).The convergent validity was also assured by the certain correlation of the scores between similar scales of them (the Mental Health 0.50, p>0.5).
Conclusion: We found that the SF-36 is useful for people with dysphagia,and confirmed the operational validity of the SWAL-QOL/CARE in Japanese.Revising our questionnaire and continuing investigation and psychometric tests to increase the clinical usability remain as future work.
View full abstract