The endoscopic approach and endaural incision for localized congenital cholesteatoma have been reported in the literature, but the high residual and recurrence rates are problematic. In order to clarify the surgical indicators for endaural incision and tympanoplasty for congenital cholesteatomas, we retrospectively reviewed data in our hospital.
From 2005 to 2012, there were 16 cases of congenital cholesteatoma in children who were treated surgically in our hospital and followed up for an average of 52 months. Endaural incision was undertaken for localized cholesteatomas in the anterior part of the tympanic cavity, and tympanoplasty for advanced cases. Potsic's staging system was used for classification, in which stages I and II are localized and III and IV are advanced. Cholesteatoma was classified into the closed and open types. Efficacy was assessed according to recurrence rate and hearing results.
As the results: the cases of stages I, II, III and IV were comprised of 3, 3, 8, and 2 patients, respectively. Endural incision was undertaken in four patients, two stage I (both closed type) and two stage II patients (one closed and open, respectively) with cholesteatomas in the anterior part of the tympanic cavity, and the recurrence rate was 0% and 100% for stages I and II, respectively. Two cases with recurrent cholesteatomas were found around the tendon of the tensor tympani, and the complete removal of cholesteatoma was difficult because of the blind area behind the malleus handle. The remaining 12 cases underwent tympanoplasty, (single-stage ossicular chain reconstruction in 5 closed type patients, staged tympanoplasty in 7 open type patients), and recurrence rates were 0% for stages I and II, 25% for Stage III, and 100% for Stage IV. After excluding two cases due to a short follow-up period and one case without postoperative hearing test, the postoperative AB gap was 0-10dB in 10 cases, 11-20dB in 2 cases and 21-30dB in one case.
Conclusion: Potsic's stage I, and closed type congenital cholesteatoma in the anterior part of the tympanic cavity are surgical candidate for endaural incision, but a care must be taken for residual cholesteatoma around the tendon of the tensor tympani. Stage II to IV cholesteatoma are good surgical candidates for tympanoplasty, including staged surgery for open type cholesteatomas. Our results indicated that congenital cholesteatomas have better postoperative hearing results compared to the acquired form.
View full abstract