The Asian Journal of Biology Education
Online ISSN : 1447-0209
Characteristics of the Virus Education Curriculum in Contemporary Japanese Elementary Schools
Tsubasa Hidaka
著者情報
ジャーナル オープンアクセス HTML

2026 年 18 巻 p. 99-115

詳細
ABSTRACT

The subject of viruses has become more prevalent in students’ language following the COVID-19 pandemic, highlighting the need to update the curriculum. In this study, virus-related content in the Japanese elementary school curriculum was analyzed, including the 2017 curriculum guidelines and accompanying explanatory documents published by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT), as well as all textbooks and workbooks published in 2022-2023. The analyzed materials did not mention viruses in their learning objectives, and the curriculum guidelines lacked descriptions of learning methods. However, teaching materials included two approaches: learning through activities (e.g., organizing information, research, discussion, and problem-solving) and non-activity-based learning (e.g., dialogue, diagrams, and illustrations). Content could be broadly divided into two categories. The first addressed viruses’ relationships with the human body and daily life (e.g., transmission and infection prevention) and societal connections (e.g., public health issues). HIV was the most frequently mentioned virus. Overall, viruses were rarely discussed and often grouped with bacteria under “pathogens.” No beneficial aspects of viruses were presented. These findings suggested the need to define clear learning goals across grades and subjects, systematically incorporating viruses into teaching materials. Rather than merely presenting isolated data, the curriculum should expand into a more comprehensive framework covering viruses’ general properties and positive roles, effectively integrating this content into activity-based learning. This study is the first comprehensive survey of MEXT-certified virus-related teaching materials, providing a foundation for improving virus education in Japanese elementary schools, ensuring that students learn scientifically accurate information and the broader significance of viruses.

INTRODUCTION

Since 2019, primarily due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the term “virus” has become increasingly prominent in society. It has become a familiar word even among preschool children (Brandone, 2024). It is likely that new viruses will continue to emerge. As society learns to coexist with viruses, educating the public about them has become a priority. This ongoing health crisis has triggered intensive international discussions regarding the urgent need to reshape biology and science education. In these debates, curriculum researchers emphasize that instead of merely overloading textbooks with temporary pandemic-related facts, educators must systematically utilize these socio-scientific health crises as meaningful case studies to reinforce foundational biological concepts, or "powerful knowledge," thereby fostering robust scientific literacy (Roberts, 2021). This call for curriculum calibration is further echoed by Erduran (2021), who reviewed contemporary science education research addressing "manufactured risks" and critically evaluated pervasive misinformation. Developing this basic “virus literacy” from an early stage is increasingly recognized as vital for enabling individuals to critically evaluate information and make informed, safe decisions in a society coexisting with and responding to viruses.

A number of studies have been published on the subject, including Simon (2021), who summarized the state of virus education in schools in several countries other than Japan, such as Austria and Germany; Auld et al. (2020), who discussed how health literacy should be developed in K-12 education in the United States; Kushner and Pekosz (2021), who reviewed current pedagogical approaches and challenges in undergraduate- and graduate-level virology education; and Karpudewan and Chan (2022), who investigated the effectiveness of teaching infectious diseases in primary schools in Malaysia. Importantly, these educational challenges extend beyond infectious diseases to health-related textbook depictions as a whole; for instance, Barros (2020) documented significant qualitative deficiencies and real-world misrepresentations in how chronic diseases are presented in Brazilian primary school textbooks. Similarly, a few studies have been conducted in Japan regarding education about viruses. For example, Uchiyama (1993) discussed the structural analysis and problems of the curriculum on AIDS education based on several teaching plans; Araya et al. (2022) analyzed a unit on COVID-19 in elementary science in the United States; and Takemura (2024) reviewed and compared research trends in virus education in Japan, especially the development of teaching materials on viruses, with that in the rest of the world. While Takemura (2024) provided a comprehensive literature review on historical trends and laboratory-based material development for high school and undergraduate university courses, his synthesis did not explore the practical realities of the elementary school curriculum.

To understand the “implemented curriculum” that young children experience in classrooms, a systematic “textbook analysis” serves as an essential empirical methodology, as textbooks remain the dominant media for knowledge conveyance in school contexts (Valverde et al., 2002; Fuchs, 2011). The interpretation of the operationalization of virus education also requires an understanding of the systemic relationship between national policy and textbook publishing in Japan. The Japanese educational system relies on a highly centralized framework where MEXT-approved textbooks are legally mandated to strictly align with the Course of Study (Gakushu Shido Yoryo) and the Commentary on the Course of Study (Cave, 2011; Yamashita and Fujioka, 2022). Under this system, textbooks are the primary medium through which official state curriculum goals are translated into daily classroom realities. However, as previous curriculum studies demonstrate, although the Course of Study sets the authoritative “minimum standards” for learning content, it does not function as an absolute ceiling. Textbook publishers retain the legal autonomy to include supplementary topics and contextual illustrations to enhance student interest (DeCoker and Bjork, 2013). This unique structural flexibility could potentially lead to a structural discrepancy between the official curriculum standards and actual textbook content, where contemporary terms like "viruses" might be introduced across non-science subjects without synchronized scientific explanations within the formal science framework.

Currently, empirical studies that systematically analyze how the specific goals, methods, and contents regarding biological viruses are operationalized across the entire elementary curriculum are lacking. Therefore, descriptions of viruses were extracted from all the textbooks, reference books, and workbooks used in elementary schools in Japan (referred to as “the teaching materials”) and from The Commentary of the Course of Study, which serves as a guideline for these materials. This study examined how the topic of viruses is treated in terms of three perspectives—learning objectives, methods, and contents—to elucidate the characteristics of virus education in Japanese schools.

METHODS

To achieve the objectives mentioned above, the study employed the following procedures.

  1. 1)   Through visual inspection, all the sections/texts containing the word “virus” as well as specific virus names were extracted from 14 volumes of The Commentary on the Course of Study for Elementary Schools issued in 2017 (comprising Japanese language, social studies, mathematics, science, environmental studies, music, arts and crafts, home economics [HE], physical education [PE], foreign language activities/foreign languages, special subject morality, integrated learning period, special activities, and general provisions) and analyzed from three perspectives: learning objectives, methods, and contents.
  2. 2)   Through visual inspection, the sections/texts containing the word “virus” and the aforementioned specific virus names from the 301 teaching materials approved by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT; see Table A1), were extracted and analyzed in terms of the same three perspectives: learning objectives, methods, and contents.
  3. 3)   Finally, the information from steps 1 and 2 was comprehensively examined to clarify the distinctive features of how viruses are addressed in contemporary Japanese elementary school curriculum and to organize the key issues.

 To ensure high descriptive validity and prevent potential omissions due to coder fatigue across the 315 reviewed documents in total, a two-tiered visual inspection protocol was implemented rather than relying on automated content analysis software. These 315 total documents comprise the 301 MEXT-approved textbooks and workbooks plus the 14 volumes of The Commentary on the Course of Study. For elementary school textbooks, automated keyword searching presents significant challenges in accurately distinguishing biological viruses from digital ones (computer viruses) and in interpreting contextual nuances, such as illustrative dialogues. Therefore, manual reading and human judgment were indispensable for maintaining strict analytical precision. Under this protocol, the general term “virus” was comprehensively searched and extracted. Simultaneously, a cross-check was conducted focusing on specific viral pathogens, such as HIV, norovirus, influenza virus, coronavirus, measles virus, and rubella virus, to ensure that no specific mentions were overlooked, even if the general term was absent in the immediate context.

Furthermore, the entire data extraction and analysis process was conducted independently by a single researcher (the author). Consequently, statistical measures of inter-rater agreement, such as Cohen’s Kappa, were not calculated. To maximize interpretive consistency and mitigate subjectivity, a rigorous intra-rater cross-check protocol was applied by re-examining the extracted texts at multiple distinct intervals.

The sub-categories of learning methods presented in the results (e.g., “learning through activities” and “non-activity-based learning”) were not predetermined frameworks applied deductively to the text. Rather, they emerged inductively from the empirical characteristics and qualitative textual features of the analyzed teaching materials. Furthermore, to enhance the qualitative validity of the analysis, a data triangulation method was employed. The extracted data and emerging patterns were systematically compared and triangulated across different subjects (e.g., mathematics and physical education) and multiple grade levels, confirming the institutional consistency of the identified curricular gaps.

RESULTS

How the Curriculum Treats Viruses as a Study Subject

Commentary on the Course of Study

None of the documents reviewed in Method 1 mentioned viruses.

Teaching Materials

The documents analyzed in Method 2 contained several references to viruses. Table 1 summarizes the presence or absence of virus mentions by subject and grade level. It should be noted that some publishers categorize elementary school textbooks and supplementary materials into two volumes for each grade. For instance, in fifth-grade mathematics, Kyoiku Shuppan, Keirinkan, and Dainippon Tosho offer a single textbook, whereas Gakko Tosho, Tokyo Shoseki, and Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan provide two separate volumes. Consequently, the textbooks were counted by publishers.

Table 1. Presence or absence of the mention of viruses in the teaching materials for each school subject.

Grade Japanese Social Studies Mathematics Science Environmental Studies Music Arts and Crafts HE PE Foreign Language Moral Education
Calligraphy
1 × × × × × × ×
2 × × × × × × ×
3 × × × × × × × × ×
4 × × × × × × × × ×
5 × × ○1/3 ○1/6 × × × × ○1/5 × ○1/8
6 × × ○1/4 ×

○

1/6

× × ×

○

5/5

× ○1/8

Note. Entries with a mention are marked with a ○, while those without are marked with an ×. Numbers in the table represent the proportion of publishers that included content about viruses.

 Table 1 provides an initial, comprehensive mapping of virus-related descriptions across subjects and grade levels. This baseline screening indicates the presence or absence of such descriptions rather than quantitatively evaluating their physical page area or word counts. The qualitative depth, density, and distinct characteristics of these mentions, including whether they are handled briefly or incidentally, are systematically analyzed and synthesized in the subsequent sections: Perspective 1: Objectives, Perspective 2: Methods, and Perspective 3: Contents. 

As shown in Table 1, teaching materials for fifth-grade social studies, mathematics, PE, and moral education included descriptions of viruses, with the PE and moral education materials focusing solely on computer viruses. Additionally, sixth-grade textbooks on social studies, science, PE, and moral education contained information about viruses, with the science and moral education materials focusing solely on computer viruses. Notably, PE teaching materials from all publishers featured descriptions of viruses.

Computer viruses were excluded from analysis in this study. While Table 1 maps all literal mentions of the term to provide an initial baseline curriculum screening, subsequent qualitative analyses focused exclusively on biological viruses. The following observations were made about the presence of viruses in the curriculum:

  1.    In Japanese elementary schools, biological viruses are addressed in social studies, mathematics, and PE classes.
  2.    Japanese elementary school students begin learning about viruses in the fifth grade (specifically in social studies and mathematics). However, whether students actually encounter this topic at this stage depends on the textbook publisher selected by their local municipality or private school. Nonetheless, all sixth-grade PE teaching materials include descriptions of biological viruses, ensuring that all elementary school students are exposed to the topic.

Characteristics of Education about Viruses

Perspective 1: Objectives

The learning objectives of the analyzed teaching materials—curriculum guidelines, their explanations, and textbooks—did not mention viruses.

Perspective 2: Methods

The curriculum guidelines included no descriptions of learning methods related to viruses. However, the teaching materials identified several methods, which can be classified into two categories: 1) learning about viruses through activities and 2) learning about viruses through modes other than engaging in activities (through textbook contents, diagrams, dialogues, and illustrations). In the first category, five subtypes of learning-through-activities were identified:

1) Learning about viruses through activities

The first important method involves organizing information. For instance, the PE textbook Minna no Hoken: 5-6-nen features a learning unit titled “How Illness Occurs” (Mori et al., 2023, pp. 34-35), which prompts students to “organize how illness occurs.” Accompanying this instruction are images that illustrate four factors contributing to illness, namely, pathogens, such as bacteria and viruses; the body’s resistance; lifestyle factors, such as the lack of exercise and sleep; and environmental factors, such as extreme temperatures. Students are expected to synthesize this information by analyzing the visual aids in the learning unit.

The second activity is research-based learning. The PE textbook Watashitachi no Hoken 5-6-nen includes a unit titled “Pathogens and Disease” (Narita et al., 2023, pp.34-37). Within this unit, “Learning Activity 1: Let’s Investigate” asks students, “What are the different routes of pathogen infection?” Underneath this question, examples illustrate various routes of infection for influenza and food poisoning. While the influenza route shows how the virus can spread through airborne droplets from a patient sneezing or coughing, the food poisoning route highlights how pathogenic Escherichia coli O157 can enter the body via contaminated food or tableware. Additionally, electron microscope images of norovirus, measles virus, rubella virus, and tuberculosis bacteria are presented on the following pages, suggesting that the “Let’s Investigate” activity encourages students to explore routes of infection for pathogens beyond influenza and E. coli.

The third activity prompts students to reflect on their prior knowledge and consider future learning, thereby connecting it to their personal experiences. For instance, the physical education textbook Watashitachi no Hoken: 5-6-nen features a learning unit titled ‘How Illness Occurs’ (Narita et al., 2023, pp. 31-33), which includes an exercise titled ‘Learning Activity 3: Let’s Think’ that instructs students to “consider the causes of illnesses you have experienced in the past.” Directly below this prompt, there is an illustration depicting a boy stating, “I played video games until late at night and went straight to sleep,” to which a girl responds, “That is mainly caused by your lifestyle habits.” A blank space is provided right next to the illustration for students to write down their responses. In other words, students are required to analyze what factors caused their past illnesses by cross-referencing their personal experiences with the conceptual information regarding the causes of disease they have learned so far.

The fourth activity involves discussion-based learning. For example, the PE textbook AtarashiiHoken 5-6 includes a unit titled “Prevention of Infectious Diseases” (Toda et al., 2023, pp. 53-56), containing an exercise that reads, “How do we become infected with pathogens and get sick? Let’s discuss this based on the following materials.” The accompanying illustrations present the transmission routes of the influenza virus and examples of other similar pathogens, such as the measles virus and tuberculosis bacteria. The transmission route of norovirus is illustrated, with pathogenic bacteria such as E. coli O157 and Campylobacterdepicted in the same manner. While the specific focus of the related discussion is not explicitly stated, an illustration shows a child asking, “How do we become infected with pathogens?” and another child inquiring, “What can we do to prevent this?” Given that the materials explain the methods of infection, it is implied that the discussion focuses on “prevention methods.”

The fifth category includes activities that incorporate viruses into problem exercises. For example, the math textbook AtarashiiSansu 5-jo. 1 features a section titled “Challenge an Interesting Problem” (Fujii et al., 2023, pp.142-146), which prompts students to “summarize the mechanisms of integers and decimals,” with several problems provided. One problem explains that 1/1000 of 1 mm equals 1 μm and then poses the following question: “Masks prevent the inhalation of tiny particles and droplets containing these particles, such as those shown below: Pollen: approximately 30 μm, yellow sand: approximately 4 μm, bacteria: approximately 1 μm, viruses: approximately 0.1 μm. How many mm is the size of a pollen particle? Also, express the size of the other particles in mm” (Fujii et al., 2023, p.142). In this activity, the concept of viruses was used to facilitate conversions between the previously learned unit of mm and the newly introduced μm.

2) Learning about viruses without activities

Viruses were incorporated into teaching materials discussing pathogens and diseases, as well as in dialogues featured in illustrations of animals and other subjects. Most lessons about viruses were presented in this format. For instance, the PE textbook TanoshiiHoken 5-6 included a unit titled “Pathogens and Disease Prevention” (Otsu et al., 2023, pp. 38-41) with images of various viruses and bacteria and an illustration of a gorilla and a bird discussing pathogens. The gorilla states, “Pathogens are divided into viruses and bacteria and others, and the symptoms of disease vary depending on the type of pathogen,” and the bird adds, “Influenza is caused by influenza viruses.”

Perspective 3: Contents

Although the curriculum guidelines did not include learning content about viruses, teaching materials featured a range of information about viruses. Two main types of content were identified.

1) The relationship of viruses with human lives and society

Regarding the connection between viruses and daily life, the PE textbook Minna no Hoken: 5-6-nen features a section titled “Pathogens and Disease” (Mori et al., 2023, pp. 36-39), which discusses diseases, such as influenza, cancer, food poisoning, and AIDS. In the section on cancer, it briefly explains that “when pathogens enter the body or cancer cells form, white blood cells in the blood play a central role in attacking them” (Mori et al., 2023, p. 38). However, in the case of influenza and food poisoning, students are expected to learn how these diseases are contracted in everyday life, recognize their symptoms, and understand specific prevention methods. The textbook also covers how AIDS is contracted, stating, “HIV is transmitted when an infected person's blood or other substances enter the body through a wound or other opening. HIV is very weakly contagious and cannot be transmitted through the air or food” (Mori et al., 2023, p. 39). Notably, it does not address sexual transmission or mother-to-child transmission. While prevention methods are not discussed, students are referred to sections on preventing other infectious diseases, such as influenza and food poisoning, suggesting that AIDS is categorized similarly to these diseases.

The contents of teaching materials consider the relationship between viruses and human society. Meanwhile, the social studies textbook ShogakuShakai 6 includes a “Historical Timeline” section (Oishi et al., 2023, pp. 70-71), which notes that “COVID-19 spread globally,” framing it as a significant social event of the era. Additionally, the PE textbook Watashitachino Hoken 5-6-nen contains a unit titled “Pathogens and Disease” (Narita et al., 2023, pp. 34-37), featuring a description along with a statistical graph of the monthly number of food poisoning cases in 2018, sourced from the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, highlighting the link between health and social conditions: “Food poisoning cases occur year-round. In 1996, a nationwide outbreak of pathogenic E. coli O157 resulted in fatalities. Norovirus has also been a frequent cause of food poisoning. Due to the highly contagious nature of both O157 and norovirus, preventive measures are being reinforced” (Narita et al., 2023, p.35).

Moreover, the PE textbook Tanoshii Hoken 5-6 features a learning unit titled “Pathogens and Disease Prevention” (Otsu et al., 2023, pp. 38-41) that addresses societal perceptions of AIDS, stating, “People infected with HIV not only endure the disease but also face discrimination stemming from misinformation in their communities. It is essential to have an accurate understanding of AIDS to foster a society where those infected can coexist” (Otsu et al., 2023, p. 41).

2) Virus-related content

 The word “virus” appeared 95 times in teaching materials, with many of them being referred to by specific names or as a generic category: HIV (41%, 39), simply “virus” (17%, 16), norovirus (15%, 14), influenza virus (13%, 12), measles virus (5%, 5), novel coronavirus (4%, 4), rubella virus (2%, 2), cold virus (2%, 2), and Zika virus (1%, 1). It should be noted that several viruses cause colds. They are referred to collectively as one type for convenience, consistent with the terminology used in teaching materials. HIV, a virus responsible for sexually transmitted diseases, is the most frequently occurring virus. This prevalence is significantly higher than that of the second and third most common viruses, norovirus and influenza virus, respectively. Overall, HIV remains a particularly significant virus as visually summarized in Figure 1 to highlight this curricular imbalance. In general, most content about viruses focuses on their visual presentation. For instance, the PE textbook Watashitachino Hoken 5-6-nen features a unit titled “Pathogens and Disease” (Narita et al., 2023, pp. 34-37), which presents microscope images and magnifications of various pathogens, including the influenza virus, O157, norovirus, measles virus, the rubella virus, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and HIV. The unit focuses on the pathogens’ visual features rather than their detailed biological mechanisms. As descriptions of general biological viruses are extremely limited in the contemporary Japanese elementary school curriculum, Table 2 provides an exhaustive list of all relevant descriptions identified across the 301 MEXT-approved textbooks reviewed in this study. This comprehensive list represents every instance in which virus definitions or general properties are mentioned rather than a selective compilation of examples.

Figure 1

Frequency Distribution of Virus Mentions by Name and Category in Elementary School Teaching Materials (N = 95).

Table 2. General descriptions of viruses.

Subject Description
Social Studies No relevant description.
Mathematics Pollen: approx. 30 μm, yellow sand: approx. 4 μm, bacteria: approx. 1 μm, viruses: approx. 0.1 μm (Fujii et al., 2023, p. 142).
P E

“Pathogens are small organisms that cause disease. Pathogens include bacteria and viruses” (Mori et al., 2023, p. 35).

“There are also cancers whose main cause is bacterial or viral infection” (Mori et al., 2023, p. 44).

“Pathogens are small organisms that cause disease. The main pathogens are bacteria and viruses. Pathogens are so small that they cannot be seen with the naked eye, but they are all around us” (Watanabe et al., 2022, p. 41).

“Pathogens are divided into viruses, bacteria, etc., and the symptoms of the disease vary depending on the type” (Otsu et al., 2023, p. 38).

“There are also cancers whose primary cause is bacterial or viral infection, rather than lifestyle factors” (Otsu et al., 2023, p. 54).

“Pathogens are viruses, bacteria, and other organisms that cause disease. Pathogens are too small to be seen with the naked eye, but they exist in abundance all around us” (Toda et al., 2023, p. 50).

“Pathogens are tiny organisms such as viruses and bacteria that cause disease” (Narita et al., 2023, p. 32).

“Diseases caused by pathogens occur when viruses or bacteria enter the body through the air or food” (Narita et al., 2023, p. 35).

“There is type 2 diabetes, which is caused by lifestyle habits, and type 1, which is congenital or caused by a virus. Most cases that develop in people under the age of 25 are type 1” (Narita et al., 2023, p. 38).

A side-by-side textual analysis of these exhaustive descriptions clearly demonstrated a consistent pattern where viruses were ambiguously grouped with bacteria under the general umbrella of "pathogens," without any conceptual differentiation between the two entities across all identified instances. Additionally, several phrases may mislead readers into thinking of viruses as living organisms, which contradicts biological definitions, for instance, “Pathogens are tiny organisms such as viruses and bacteria that cause disease” (Narita et al., 2023, p.32). Such descriptions may foster misunderstandings in children.

In summary, two distinct types of educational content related to viruses were identified: one focusing on their relationship with people and society, and the other addressing the general characteristics and scientific classification of viruses. However, no content highlighted any positive aspects of viruses for humans. Moreover, because the descriptions of viruses are limited, children learned only that they were pathogens. The materials offered no opportunities to learn about their classification; they were not distinguished from bacteria, thereby leaving their nature ambiguous. Some descriptions also mistakenly equated “viruses” with “living organisms.” Furthermore, computer viruses were categorized as viruses, with insufficient distinction made between biological and digital types.

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

Summary of Virus Education in Japan’s Elementary Schools

This section presented a summary of the findings regarding the characteristics of virus education in modern Japanese elementary schools. Elementary school curriculum guidelines and their commentaries did not mention viruses. This suggested that virus-related learning was not explicitly anticipated at the policy level. However, viruses were actually covered in the teaching materials used by elementary school students. Excluding computer viruses, as shown in Table 3, the subjects that covered biological viruses were social studies (5th and 6th grades), mathematics (5th grade), and PE (6th grade). Notably, biological viruses were completely absent (marked with an ×) across all grades in both Science and Moral Education. Social studies and mathematics were the earliest subjects in which biological viruses appeared (5th grade); however, only one out of six publishers included such content in mathematics, and one out of four in social studies, thus limiting exposure to students using that material. Notably, PE—which comprehensively covered biological viruses across all publishers (5/5)—was not introduced until the sixth grade.

Table 3. References to biological viruses in teaching materials by school subject.

Grade Japanese Social Studies Mathematics Science Environmental Studies Music Arts and Crafts H.E. P.E. Foreign Language Moral Education
Calligraphy
1 × × × × × × ×
2 × × × × × × ×
3 × × × × × × × × ×
4 × × × × × × × × ×
5 × × ○1/3 ○1/6 × × × × × × ×
6 × × ○1/4 × × × × ×

○

5/5

× ×

Note. Entries with a mention are marked with a ○, while those without are marked with an ×. Numbers in the table represent the proportion of publishers that included content about viruses.

The curriculum guidelines and their commentaries did not describe educational objectives and methods related to viruses. Meanwhile, teaching materials approached these aspects in two ways: learning through activities (activities to organize information; research; activities linking prior knowledge with new content; learning through discussions; and solving written exercises, such as calculation problems, short-answer questions, or fill-in-the-blank items, which are commonly used in Japanese examinations) and non-activity-based learning (mentioned in written explanations, reference materials, diagrams, and dialogues by illustrations). The latter accounted for the vast majority of instances, where specific viruses were only briefly and incidentally mentioned in explanations of various problems in human society.

In addition, the curriculum guidelines and their commentaries did not include any educational content related to viruses. By contrast, as shown in Table 3, mentions in the teaching materials were broadly divided into two types. The first type concerned the relationship between viruses and people’s lives and society. The curriculum covered various infectious diseases, including how they spread in daily life, the symptoms they cause in the human body, and specific methods for preventing infection. Diseases that have garnered significant social attention, such as COVID-19, AIDS, and food poisoning, were also actively addressed. In all these cases, viruses were treated as case studies. This constituted the majority of the learning content. Another aspect was the focus on viruses themselves. The curriculum centered on specific viruses, with HIV being the most frequently discussed. However, the fact that AIDS is a sexually transmitted infection was not mentioned and, unlike other viruses, the transmission routes were not shown. Furthermore, the general aspects of viruses—that is, their definitions and properties—were treated very briefly, and some explanations contained potentially misleading expressions. The differences between viruses and bacteria, or computer viruses, were not explicitly distinguished. Because these were all treated collectively as pathogens without conceptual differentiation, many of the negative aspects for humans were discussed, but the positive aspects were not depicted.

DISCUSSION

This study aimed to clarify the characteristics of virus education in elementary schools in contemporary Japan from three perspectives: learning objectives, methods, and content. The analysis was based on primary sources, including the Commentary on the Course of Study and teaching materials. This section compares the findings of this study with those of previous studies of the curriculum on viruses in Japan. Uchiyama (1993), based on a lesson plan for secondary school health education at the time, pointed out the importance of presenting ecological models because the areas of humanity, society, and culture were missing from AIDS education. However, it has become clear that this has actually become central in elementary schools in modern Japan. Araya et al. (2022) analyzed how the COVID-19 pandemic was treated in slide presentations used for students in grades 3–5 in American elementary schools, reporting that they included children, families, and the communities to which they belonged. In addition, its relationships with society and individuals were mentioned while keeping the topic in the scientific context. However, in the case of contemporary schools in Japan, this study found that the relationships between viruses and society or individuals were mentioned without a scientific setting and in subjects other than Science. Thus, this study identifies key gaps in the modern Japanese virus education curriculum, which has received limited attention in previous research, not only in terms of content but also in terms of objectives and methods. Based on these findings, a key question emerges: “What should be our approach to virus education when revising the elementary school curriculum in Japan in the future?” The issues can be summarized as follows.

First, it became clear that while there are no specific goals, national policies, or standards regarding viruses in current Japanese elementary schools, viruses are actually being covered in teaching materials across multiple subjects, but without any clearly defined learning goals. This raises concerns regarding the appropriateness of including viruses in the curriculum without established learning objectives. The elementary school curriculum guidelines state that “School education requires children to actively confront various changes, collaborate with others to solve problems, identify various information, achieve a conceptual understanding of knowledge, reconstruct information, and connect it to new value, and to be able to reconstruct goals in complex changing situations” (MEXT, 2017c, p. 1). For example, the COVID-19 pandemic illustrates that viruses are indeed one of these “changes.” Given that viruses are currently presented in textbooks without clear goals, this approach may limit students’ ability to effectively “identify various information and achieve a conceptual understanding of knowledge.” Therefore, establishing clear learning goals should be prioritized in considering the future of education about viruses. As the MEXT has approved the use of viruses as teaching material, it is necessary to establish teaching guidelines for virus education if the topic is to be treated as study content. Guidelines for each subject area should specify learning contents and the competencies students are expected to achieve as a result of learning.

Furthermore, while students begin learning about viruses in mathematics and social studies from the fifth grade, they do not cover viruses at all in science, a foundational subject for learning about the human body and viruses themselves, and they do not begin learning about biological viruses in PE until the sixth grade. In other words, students may lack a foundational understanding of viruses. The lack of subject-specific learning objectives for virus education has also contributed to this situation.

In addition, viruses appear in all sixth-grade PE textbooks from all publishers, despite the fact that no learning objectives regarding viruses are set in the curriculum guidelines, their explanations, or the teaching materials themselves. When considering how to build a core concept of viruses within the overall curriculum, educational researchers and the MEXT should prioritize discussions on the subject and grade-level objectives related to virus learning.

In terms of methodology, the study found that there are few opportunities to learn about viruses through activities, and viruses are often simply presented as isolated pieces of information. It would be difficult to expect a broader or deeper understanding from this alone. One potential solution is to integrate more content into activity-based learning. Furthermore, accurate information about viruses should be included so as not to foster social stigma or impede students' progressive learning in later stages. Even if children obtain information through media or other means, it is difficult for them to judge for themselves whether that information is reliable, and it is not realistic for teachers to grasp all the information and judge its reliability.

Furthermore, text analysis in this study revealed a potential structural contradiction in the current elementary curriculum: while physical education (health education) textbooks explain viruses as pathogens, mathematics and social studies textbooks introduce the term “virus” with the tacit assumption that students are already familiar with it, offering no baseline scientific explanations. Leaving this educational gap unaddressed may be problematic because it could force children to navigate everyday terms without sufficient scientific grounding. This, in turn, may foster deeply rooted misconceptions and social biases. To resolve this issue without overburdening the existing curriculum, this study proposes an “infusion approach” rather than establishing an independent, systematic unit on virology. This framework aligns with the core curriculum design principles advocated by Roberts (2021), who warned against overloading curricula with isolated, transient pandemic data, arguing instead that health crises should be anchored within existing "powerful knowledge." By organically embedding virus-related concepts into existing subject units across three developmental phases, the curriculum can achieve scientific rigor without causing institutional overburdening. This proposed framework guides educators through three specific phases. First, as an introductory phase, 5th-grade mathematics (learning decimal structures with micrometers) can be linked with 5th-grade science (microscope usage) to help students intuitively conceptualize viruses as distinct, sub-microscopic entities before encountering them as pathogens. Second, during the 5th-grade science unit on “Animal Reproduction,” a supplementary focus on how ancient viral genes contributed to the evolution of the mammalian placenta can be introduced, providing a balanced perspective on their positive roles. Third, in the 6th grade, health education in physical education (disease prevention) should be tightly coordinated with science (ecosystems and matter cycles). While physical education teaches the mechanics of infection, science can introduce how viruses drive marine nutrient cycles by breaking down plankton. This cross-disciplinary framework argues that elementary schools can foster essential virus literacy and mitigate social biases.

Without a sufficient understanding of a virus, learning through activities will not be sufficiently effective. Regarding virus-related content, most of the learning content about viruses focused on the relationship between viruses and people’s lives and society. The General Provisions section of the Commentary on the Curriculum Guidelines states that “it is important to enrich learning activities that allow students to realize the significance of what they have learned in relation to society and the world” (MEXT, 2017c, p. 38). This approach is important for children to approach their studies with a sense of responsibility and realize the significance of their learning.

However, the virus that is given the most attention in the teaching materials is HIV. For Japanese children aged 10–12, AIDS is not a familiar disease, and it would be difficult for them to perceive it as something that concerns them personally. In that respect, it may not fully align with the intended objectives. Moreover, unlike other viruses, the route of infection is not clearly explained; textbooks do not explicitly mention that AIDS is a sexually transmitted disease and only describe transmission routes that do not lead to infection. This counterproductive educational reality closely parallels the findings of Barros (2020) in Brazilian primary schools. In analyzing textbook depictions of chronic conditions, Barros (2020) explicitly highlighted that depictions of HIV/AIDS, in particular, frequently reinforced superficial societal stereotypes and overemphasized fear rather than providing children with realistic, empowering literacy. In both institutional contexts, a textbook's failure to present scientifically complete and socially nuanced explanations ironically undermines the very pedagogical goal of mitigating social biases and discrimination. While it is noted that “there is still no complete cure” (Mori et al., 2023, p. 39), the lack of clarity regarding the route of infection worsens student anxiety. Additionally, teachers encourage students to combat discrimination by stating, “Some people infected with HIV suffer from discrimination due to the incorrect knowledge of those around them” (Watanabe et al., 2022, p. 46) but achieving this goal may be difficult without providing a proper understanding of the virus. One reason for this lack of understanding may be that textbook publishers often avoid discussing sexual intercourse. This avoidance is heavily reinforced by a pervasive institutional "brake" in Japanese schools: the combined restrictions of the fifth-grade science guidelines—which state that “the process leading to human fertilization will not be covered” (MEXT, 2017b, p. 70)—and the junior high school health guidelines, which exclude “the process of pregnancy” (MEXT, 2017a, p. 227). Consequently, this dual restriction creates a strong shared assumption among publishers and educators that any explicit mention of sexual intercourse must be strictly avoided at the elementary stage. This raises concerns about how effectively discrimination can be addressed without clearly explaining transmission routes. It is important to carefully select the types of viruses to cover while considering diseases with a high incidence rate among children. The restriction against covering the process leading to fertilization may also hinder students from scientifically understanding pregnancy and fertilization; thus, it bears further review.

Moreover, the study revealed that specific virus-related learning content—namely, their definitions and properties—was extremely limited and often misleading. Such content would not allow students to learn about the differences between viruses and bacteria or computer viruses. As students progress further in middle and high school, the preconceived notions they have acquired (such as bacteria and viruses being similar) may hinder learning. These misconceptions might persist and hinder their ability to understand issues that have become problematic in recent years, such as the prescription of antibiotics. Therefore, it is crucial to provide ample coverage of the concept, definition, and properties of viruses. While it is understandable that providing a clear definition of a virus can be challenging in a rapidly evolving field, it is crucial to establish guidelines for how viruses should be perceived at each school level and grade as standard contents in the curriculum. At the very least, developing teaching materials and methods that help students understand that viruses are generally not classified as living organisms and that they multiply within the host’s body is crucial. Even if teaching methods are changed to allow for learning through activities without addressing this limitation, if students have a poor understanding of viruses, they will find it difficult to engage in meaningful discussions and learning activities. This lack of clarity may also create challenges for teachers when providing instruction. As learning activities involve the term “virus,” it is necessary to revise the curriculum to ensure a systematic structure of virus-related educational content, such that students can learn, at the least, the basic scientific role of viruses before engaging in activities.

Furthermore, a major problem is that the positive aspects of viruses were not addressed at all. As things stand, this may reinforce the perception that all viruses are “scary things that cause disease.” Rather than reducing discrimination, this may exacerbate it. The positive aspects of viruses, such as protecting the Earth’s environment and helping our bodies take their current form, should be actively addressed.

For elementary school students, it might be easier to capture their interest by focusing on the following three points and presenting them from the perspective of “viruses as unsung heroes of the Earth.” First, human fetal development may be partially enabled by viruses. Research suggests that the placenta, the mechanism that allows humans (mammals) to nurture babies in the mother’s womb, was created from genes carried by viruses a long time ago. Without viruses, we may not have been born in the form we are today. The current curriculum includes learning about “the birth of animals” in fifth-grade science, where this discussion can be linked. Second, viruses can be seen as “heroes” that fight off harmful bacteria. Not all viruses make humans sick. Some viruses attack bacteria that harm humans and help cure diseases. Research is underway to use this property to create new drugs and treatments. Learning about this will help students realize that bacteria and viruses are different entities. The current curriculum includes “disease prevention” in sixth-grade PE, where this discussion can be linked. Third, viruses provide food for marine life. When viruses break down plankton, the nutrients in their bodies dissolve into the ocean, which become a valuable source of nutrition for other small organisms. Without viruses, the ocean’s nutrient cycle would not function properly. Learning about this will help students distinguish between viruses and organisms invisible to the naked eye, such as plankton. In the current curriculum, sixth-grade science students learn about plankton in the section on “living organisms and the environment”; thus, it is possible to connect this aspect to the current curriculum.

Considering the current state of society, where viruses have become a familiar term for children, it would be impractical to ignore this topic in education. Assuming that viruses will be used as teaching material, the curriculum should be systematically reviewed and structured to determine what aspects of viruses should be taught in which subjects and at which grade levels. Ultimately, systematically reviewing the curriculum through an infusion lens ensures that students build a robust scientific foundation before entering secondary education, preventing deep-rooted misconceptions. By treating viruses with educational neutrality—balancing their pathogenic risks with their ecological benefits—this cross-disciplinary framework addresses the critical need to prepare citizens for "manufactured risks," directly responding to the call for curriculum calibration highlighted by Erduran (2021). Furthermore, applying the core curriculum design principles advocated by Roberts (2021) provides a more realistic and enduring framework for virus education. Although Roberts (2021) cautions that school curricula cannot be the sole vehicle for maintaining public health or responding rapidly to crises, structuring virus learning around foundational biological concepts—rather than isolated pandemic data—enables elementary schools to foster essential baseline literacy. This approach acknowledges these institutional boundaries while ensuring that future citizens possess the powerful knowledge necessary to critically evaluate health messages.

AUTHOR’S NOTE

 This paper incorporates and expands upon findings the author presented at the 29th Biennial Conference of the Asian Association for Biology Education.

 

REFERENCES
APPENDIX

This appendix presents basic information on all the instructional materials analyzed in this study.

Table A1. The teaching materials used for the examination (301 books).

Subject Title Publisher Authoriza - tion Year of Publication
Japanese Minna to Manabu Shogakko Kokugo 1-nen Jo, 2-nen Jo, 3-nen Jo, 4-nen Jo, 5-nen Jo, 6-nen Jo Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
Minna to Manabu Shogakko Kokugo 1-nen Ge, 2-nen Ge, 3-nen Ge, 4-nen Ge, 5-nen Ge, 6-nen Ge Gakko Tosho 2019 2022
Hirogaru Kotoba Shogaku Kokugo 1-jo, 2-jo, 3-jo, 4-jo, 5-jo, 6-jo Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Hirogaru Kotoba Shogaku Kokugo 1-ge, 2-ge, 3-ge, 4-ge, 5-ge, 6-ge Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2022
Atarashii Kokugo 1-jo, 2-jo, 3-jo, 4-jo, 5, 6 Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Atarashii Kokugo 1-ge, 2-ge, 3-ge, 4-ge Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2022
Kokugo 1-jo Kazaguruma, 2-jo Tanpopo, 3-jo Wakaba, 4-jo Kagayaki, 5 Ginga, 6 Souzou Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2023
Kokugo 1-ge Tomodachi, 2-ge Akatonbo, 3-ge Aozora, 4-ge Habataki Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2022
Calligraphy Minna to Manabu Shogakko Shosha 1-nen, 2-nen, 3-nen, 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
Shogaku Shosha 1-nen, 2-nen, 3-nen, 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Atarashii Shosha 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Shogaku Shosha 1-nen, 2-nen, 3-nen, 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Shosha 1-nen, 2-nen, 3-nen, 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2023
Social Studies Shogaku Shakai 3, 4, 5, 6 Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Tanoshiku Manabu Shogakusei no Chizucho 3-4-5-6-nen Teikoku Shoin 2019 2023
Atarashii Shakai 3, 4, 5-jo, 6 Rekishi-hen, 6 Seiji Kokusai-hen, Atarashii Chizucho Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Atarashii Shakai 5-ge Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2022
Shogaku Shakai 3-nen, 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Mathmatics Minna to Manabu Shogakko Sansu 1-nen Jo, 1-nen Ge, 2-nen Ge, 3-nen Ge, 4-nen Ge, 5-nen Ge,6-nen Ge Gakko Tosho 2019 2022
Minna to Manabu Shogakko Sansu 2-nen Jo, 3-nen Jo, 4-nen Jo, 5-nen Jo, 6-nen Chugakko e no Kakehashi Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
Shogaku Sansu 1, 2-ge, 3-ge, 4-ge Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2022
Shogaku Sansu 2-jo, 3-jo, 4-jo, 5, 6 Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Wakuwaku Sansu 1, 2-jo, 3-jo, 4-jo, 5, 6 Keirinkan 2019 2023
Wakuwaku Sansu 2-ge, 3-ge, 4-ge Keirinkan 2019 2022
Tanoshii Sansu 1-nen, 2-nen, 3-nen, 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Dai-Nippon Tosho 2019 2023
Atarashii Sansu 1-1 Sansu no Tobira, 1-2 Sansu Daisuki!, 2-jo, 3-jo, 4-jo, 5-jo, 6 Sugaku e no Jump! Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Atarashii Sansu 2-ge, 3-ge, 4-ge, 5-ge Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2022
Shogaku Sansu 1-nen Jo, 1-nen Ge, 2-ge, 3-ge, 4-ge, 5-ge Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2022
Shogaku Sansu 2-jo, 3-jo, 4-jo, 5-jo, 6 Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Science Minna to Manabu Shogakko Rika 3-nen, 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
Mirai o Hiraku Shogaku Rika 3, 4, 5, 6 Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Wakuwaku Rika 3, 4, 5, 6 Keirinkan 2019 2023
Tanoshii Rika 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Shinkyo-pub 2019 2023
Tanoshii Rika 3-nen, 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Dai-Nippon Tosho 2019 2023
Atarashii Rika 3-nen, 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Music Shogakusei no Ongaku 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Kyoiku Geijutsu Sha 2019 2023
Ongaku no Okurimono 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Arts and Crafts Wakuwaku Suru ne Zuga Kosaku 1-2-jo, Dekitara Ii na 3-4-jo, Kokoro o Hiraite 5-6-jo Kairyudo 2019 2023
Mitsuketa yo Zuga Kosaku 1-2-ge, Chikara o Awasete 3-4-ge, Tsunagaru Omoi 5-6-ge Kairyudo 2019 2022
Zuga Kosaku 1-2-jo Tanoshii na Omoshiroi na, 3-4-jo Tameshita yo Mitsuketa yo, 5-6-jo Mitsumete Hirogete Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Zuga Kosaku 1-2-ge Tanoshii na Omoshiroi na, 3-4-ge Tameshita yo Mitsuketa yo, 5-6-ge Mitsumete Hirogete Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2022
PE Minna no Hoken 3-4-nen, 5-6-nen Gakken 2019 2023
Shogaku Hoken 3-4-nen, 5-6-nen Kobunshoin 2019 2022
Tanoshii Hoken 3-4-nen, 5-6-nen Dai-Nippon Tosho 2019 2023
Atarashii Hoken 3-4, 5-6 Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Watashitachi no Hoken 3-4-nen, 5-6-nen Bunkyosha 2019 2022
HE Watashitachi no Kateika 5-6 Kairyudo 2019 2023
Atarashii Katei 5-6 Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Foreign Languages English Junior Sunshine 5, Junior Sunshine 6 Kairyudo 2019 2023
JUNIOR TOTAL ENGLISH 1, JUNIOR TOTAL ENGLISH 2 Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
ONE WORLD Smile 5, ONE WORLD Smile 6 Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Blue Sky elementary 5, Blue Sky elementary 6 Keririnkan 2019 2023
CROWN Jr. 5, CROWN Jr. 6 Sanseido 2019 2023
NEW HORIZON Elementary English Course 5, NEW HORIZON Elementary English Course 6 Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Here We Go! 5, Here We Go! 6 Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2023
Moral Education Minna de Kangae, Hanashiau Shogakusei no Dotoku 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Akatsuki Kyoiku Tosho 2019 2023
Shin Minna no Dotoku 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Gakken 2019 2023
Kagayake Mirai Shogakko Dotoku 1-nen Kizuki, 1-nen Manabi, 2-nen Kizuki, 2-nen Manabi, 3-nen Kizuki, 3-nen Manabi, 4-nen Kizuki, 4-nen Manabi, 5-nen Kizuki, 5-nen Manabi, 5-nen Kizuki, 6-nen Manabi Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
Shogakko Dotoku 1 Habatakou Asu e, Shogaku 2 Habatakou Ashita e, 3, Shogaku Dotoku 4, 5, 6 Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Shogaku Dotoku Yutaka na Kokoro 1-nen, 2-nen, 3-nen, Shogaku Dotoku 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Kobunshoin 2019 2022
Shintei Atarashii Dotoku 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Shogaku Dotoku Ikiru Chikara 1, 2, 3, Shogaku Dotoku 4, 5, 6 Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Dotoku 1 Kimi ga Ichiban Hikaru Toki, 2, 3, Dotoku 4, 5, 6 Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2023
Moral Education Workbook Jibun o Mitsume, Kangaeru Dotoku Note 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Akatsuki Kyoiku Tosho 2019 2023
Shogakko Dotoku Ikiru Chikara 1 Dotoku Note, Shogaku 2, 3, Shogaku Dotoku 4, 5, 6 Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Life Studies Minna to Manabu Shogakko Seikatsu Jo Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
Minna to Manabu Shogakko Seikatsu Ge Gakko Tosho 2019 2022
Seikatsu Jo Minna Nakayoshi Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Seikatsu Ge Nakayoshi Hirogare Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2022
Wakuwaku Seikatsu Jo Keirinkan 2019 2023
Ikiiki Seikatsu Ge Keirinkan 2019 2022
Seikatsu Jo Aozora Shinkyo-pub 2019 2023
Seikatsu Ge Soyokaze Shinkyo-pub 2019 2022
Tanoshii Seikatsu Jo Nakayoshi Dai-Nippon Tosho 2019 2023
Tanoshii Seikatsu Ge Hakken Dai-Nippon Tosho 2019 2022
Dokidoki Wakuwaku Atarashii Seikatsu Jo Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Ashita e Jump Atarashii Seikatsu Ge Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2022
Watashi to Seikatsu Jo Minna Nakayoshi Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Watashi to Seikatsu Ge Fureai Daisuki Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2022
Seikatsu Jo Mainichi Atarashii Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2023
Seikatsu Ge Daisuki Mitsuketa Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2022
Foreign Languages English Junior Sunshine 5, Junior Sunshine 6 Kairyudo 2019 2023
JUNIOR TOTAL ENGLISH 1, JUNIOR TOTAL ENGLISH 2 Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
ONE WORLD Smile 5, ONE WORLD Smile 6 Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Blue Sky elementary 5, Blue Sky elementary 6 Keririnkan 2019 2023
CROWN Jr. 5, CROWN Jr. 6 Sanseido 2019 2023
NEW HORIZON Elementary English Course 5, NEW HORIZON Elementary English Course 6 Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Here We Go! 5, Here We Go! 6 Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2023
Moral Education Minna de Kangae, Hanashiau Shogakusei no Dotoku 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Akatsuki Kyoiku Tosho 2019 2023
Shin Minna no Dotoku 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Gakken 2019 2023
Kagayake Mirai Shogakko Dotoku 1-nen Kizuki, 1-nen Manabi, 2-nen Kizuki, 2-nen Manabi, 3-nen Kizuki, 3-nen Manabi, 4-nen Kizuki, 4-nen Manabi, 5-nen Kizuki, 5-nen Manabi, 5-nen Kizuki, 6-nen Manabi Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
Shogakko Dotoku 1 Habatakou Asu e, Shogaku 2 Habatakou Ashita e, 3, Shogaku Dotoku 4, 5, 6 Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Shogaku Dotoku Yutaka na Kokoro 1-nen, 2-nen, 3-nen, Shogaku Dotoku 4-nen, 5-nen, 6-nen Kobunshoin 2019 2022
Shintei Atarashii Dotoku 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Shogaku Dotoku Ikiru Chikara 1, 2, 3, Shogaku Dotoku 4, 5, 6 Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Dotoku 1 Kimi ga Ichiban Hikaru Toki, 2, 3, Dotoku 4, 5, 6 Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2023
Moral Education Workbook Jibun o Mitsume, Kangaeru Dotoku Note 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 Akatsuki Kyoiku Tosho 2019 2023
Shogakko Dotoku Ikiru Chikara 1 Dotoku Note, Shogaku 2, 3, Shogaku Dotoku 4, 5, 6 Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Life Studies Minna to Manabu Shogakko Seikatsu Jo Gakko Tosho 2019 2023
Minna to Manabu Shogakko Seikatsu Ge Gakko Tosho 2019 2022
Seikatsu Jo Minna Nakayoshi Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2023
Seikatsu Ge Nakayoshi Hirogare Kyoiku Shuppan 2019 2022
Wakuwaku Seikatsu Jo Keirinkan 2019 2023
Ikiiki Seikatsu Ge Keirinkan 2019 2022
Seikatsu Jo Aozora Shinkyo-pub 2019 2023
Seikatsu Ge Soyokaze Shinkyo-pub 2019 2022
Tanoshii Seikatsu Jo Nakayoshi Dai-Nippon Tosho 2019 2023
Tanoshii Seikatsu Ge Hakken Dai-Nippon Tosho 2019 2022
Dokidoki Wakuwaku Atarashii Seikatsu Jo Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2023
Ashita e Jump Atarashii Seikatsu Ge Tokyo Shoseki 2019 2022
Watashi to Seikatsu Jo Minna Nakayoshi Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2023
Watashi to Seikatsu Ge Fureai Daisuki Nihon Bunkyo Shuppan 2019 2022
Seikatsu Jo Mainichi Atarashii Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2023
Seikatsu Ge Daisuki Mitsuketa Mitsumura Tosho 2019 2022
 
© Asian Association for Biology Education

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons [Attribution 4.0 International] license.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
feedback
Top