Separating Diversity from Accusation and Discord: Potentiality of Complementarity Model of C. Taylor

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to reexamine the reason why we should respect diversity in our society. For this inquiry, we focus on the complementary model of our commonality presented by Charles Taylor. This model regards humans as interdependent beings and demonstrates that we can develop humanity only in a sufficiently diverse condition. Though it has attractive aspects, this model may not be final answer. By looking at the dispute about affirmative action in the USA, we also understand that respecting diversity without consideration for historical and structural injustice could make the conflicts in our society more serious. On the other hand, the details of changes of the purpose of affirmative action teach us that one-sided accusation and requirement for redress could also deepen discord. Through those philosophical and policy-based investigations, we conclude that it is important to separate diversity from accusation and discord, and not to separate it from consideration for justice.