Journal of Atherosclerosis and Thrombosis
Online ISSN : 1880-3873
Print ISSN : 1340-3478
ISSN-L : 1340-3478
Case Report
A Case of Acquired LCAT Deficiency with the Discrepancy between Spontaneous Resolution of Proteinuria and Continually Low HDL Cholesterol Levels
Miki MatsuoMasatsune OguraMasayuki KurodaTetsuya ArisatoMasatsugu KishidaMariko Harada-ShibaJun WadaKoutaro YokoteFumiki Yoshihara
著者情報
ジャーナル オープンアクセス HTML

2026 年 33 巻 2 号 p. 228-236

詳細
Abstract

A 79-year-old Chinese man was referred for nephrotic syndrome (proteinuria 4.4 g/day). In blood tests, serum high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol was undetectable, and the esterified cholesterol to total cholesterol ratio was very low. Lecithin: cholesterol acyltransferase (LCAT) activity was also undetectable. Since he had neither corneal opacity nor pathological mutations in the LCAT gene and anti-LCAT antibodies were detected in serum, a diagnosis of acquired LCAT deficiency was made. Renal biopsy revealed glomerulopathy associated with LCAT deficiency and membranous nephropathy (MN). Since the patient’s proteinuria did not improve despite prescribing an angiotensin II receptor blocker (ARB), we suggested the prescription of prednisolone, but he returned to China due to the expiration of his residence visa for Japan. One year after the initial visit, his proteinuria had improved to 0.9 g/day without immunosuppressive therapy. However, his HDL cholesterol level was still low at around 3 mg/dL, indicating a discrepancy between remission of nephrotic syndrome and lack of improvement in lipid levels.

Of the 11 patients with acquired LCAT deficiency reported to date, 4 with undetectable LCAT activity and MN on renal biopsy required immunosuppressive therapy to alleviate proteinuria. The present patient was prescribed only an ARB according to his preference, which happened to be consistent with the MN treatment guideline that states, “Wait 6 months for spontaneous remission while using maximal antiproteinuric therapy.” The clinical course of acquired LCAT deficiency varies, and further case reports are needed to determine the necessity of immunosuppressive therapy.

Introduction

Lecithin: cholesterol acyltransferase (LCAT) is an enzyme synthesized mainly in the liver that hydrolyzes lecithin into lysolecithin and free fatty acids and synthesizes cholesteryl esters from the free fatty acids and free cholesterol. LCAT plays a crucial role in cholesterol efflux from peripheral cells, particularly in the formation of high-density lipoprotein (HDL)1-3).

Familial LCAT deficiency (FLD) is an autosomal recessive genetic disorder caused by an LCAT gene mutation and results in markedly decreased serum HDL cholesterol levels. In patients with FLD, lipid deposition in organs occurs, which is complicated by corneal opacity, hemolytic anemia, and renal dysfunction1, 3, 4). It has been reported that an abnormal lipoprotein with a high phospholipid (PL) content, called lipoprotein X (LpX), is involved in proteinuria and renal dysfunction in FLD patients5, 6). FLD is defined as a designated intractable disease by the Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare (MHLW) of Japan.

Acquired LCAT deficiency is a disease caused by autoantibodies to the LCAT protein, with no mutations in the LCAT gene7-12). There have been only a few case reports, mainly from Japan7-16). According to some case reports, patients with acquired LCAT deficiency present with proteinuria and nephrotic syndrome, as in FLD, and most of them have stated that immunosuppressive therapy, such as with prednisolone, has been effective7-9, 13). We experienced a case of nephrotic syndrome which improved in the absence of immunosuppressive therapy, although serum HDL cholesterol levels remained low.

Case Presentation

The patient was a 79-year-old Chinese man. He had visited his primary physician in China, who had made the diagnosis of nephrotic syndrome based on his clinical symptoms and laboratory data. He was referred to our hospital at the request of his family, who lived in Japan. He was admitted for further investigation and treatment of nephrotic syndrome.

His medical history was benign prostatic hyperplasia and hyperuricemia at age 70, and he was taking febuxostat 20 mg/day. He had not previously been diagnosed with dyslipidemia or any urinary abnormalities. There was no family history of dyslipidemia and he did not smoke or drink alcohol.

His height, body weight, body mass index, and blood pressure were 159.9 cm, 66.9 kg, 26.2 kg/m2 and 113/74 mmHg, respectively. Corneal opacity was not observed. The patient had pitting edema in his lower extremities when he visited his primary physician, but upon admission to our hospital, edema was no longer present due to furosemide prescribed at 20 mg/day by his primary physician.

The patient’s laboratory data are presented in Table 1. He had proteinuria (4.4 g/day) and hypoalbuminemia, resulting in a diagnosis of nephrotic syndrome. Urinalysis results included 3+ for occult blood and sediment containing 30 red blood cells per high-power field. His estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) was 52.5 ml/min/1.73m2. Blood examinations revealed severe dyslipidemia with an undetectable HDL-C level. Plasma Apolipoprotein A-I, Apolipoprotein A-II, and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol levels were also markedly reduced despite the nephrotic syndrome, and the triglycerides level was elevated. He was not taking any medication to reduce plasma high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol, such as probucol. On examining the ratio of esterified cholesterol to total cholesterol (CE/TC), we found it to be very low (0.07; normal range, 0.70-0.80), suggesting that esterification of free cholesterol was impaired. Liver and thyroid function tests were normal. The IgG level was not low despite nephrotic syndrome, probably because it was measured early in the onset of nephrotic syndrome. The IgG level first measured was 1698 mg/dL, but had dropped sharply to 1499 mg/dL when remeasured 9 days later, suggesting that IgG was being exposed in the urine. Alternatively, IgG may not be exposed into urine easily in nephrotic syndrome associated with acquired LCAT deficiency because the serum IgG levels of some previous reports of nephrotic syndrome associated with acquired LCAT deficiency whose serum IgG levels were measured were 1600 mg/dL and 1282 mg/dL, which were also not low9, 10) Unfortunately, we did not evaluate the selectivity index in the present patient.

Table 1.Patient’s laboratory data on admission

Blood Reference range Reference range
Total protein 5.4 g/dL 6.7~8.3 CRP 0.14 mg/dL 0~0.3
Albumin 2.3 g/dL 4.0~5.0 IgG 1698 mg/dL 870~1700
Total bilirubin 1.1 mg/dL 0.3~1.2 IgA 414 mg/dL 110~410
Direct bilirubin 0.5 mg/dL 0~0.4 IgM 90 mg/dL 33~190
Aspartate aminotransferase 40 U/L 13~33 CH50 47.6 U/mL 25.0~48.0
Alanine transaminase 20 U/L 8~42 C3 99.8 mg/dL 65.0~135.0
eGFR 52.5 ml/min/1.73 m2 ≧90 C4 29.3 mg/dL 13.0~35.0
Blood urea nitrogen 20 mg/dL 8~22 Antinuclear antibody 40 <40
Creatinine 1.05 mg/dL 0.60~1.10 White blood cells 8200/µL 4000~9000
Sodium 143 mEq/L 138~146 Red blood cells 362×103/µL 420~550 ×103
Potassium 4.2 mEq/L 3.6~4.9 Hemoglobin 11.5 g/dL 13.5~18.0
Haptoglobin 76 mg/dL 25~176 Hematocrit 34.5% 36.0~54.0
HbA1c 3.6% 4.6~6.2 Platelet count 19×104/µL 15~35 ×104
Total cholesterol 123 mg/dL 128~219
Triglyceride 260 mg/dL 30~149 Urine
HDL-C <2 mg/dL 40~96 Urinalysis
LDL-C 56 mg/dL <140 Protein 4+(4.44 g/day)
Ester from cholesterol 9 mg/dL 80~200 Blood 3+
Cholesterol ester ratio 7% 70~80 Urinary sediments
ApoA-1 53 mg/dL 119~155 Red blood cells 30-49/HF
ApoA-2 7.2 mg/dL 25.9~35.7 White blood cells 1-4/HF
ApoB 34 mg/dL 73~109 Granular cast 1+
ApoC-2 4.7 mg/dL 1.8~4.6 Erythrocytic cast 1+
ApoC-3 9.8 mg/dL 5.8~10.0 Urine M-protein negative
ApoE 6.8 mg/dL 2.7~4.3
LCAT activity undetectable
LCAT antibodies Positive

A renal biopsy was performed. In total, 91 glomeruli were observed, and 7 of them were globally sclerosed. The irregular thickening of the glomerular basement membrane (GBM), marked lipid deposition in the GBM and mesangium, and occasional foam cell influx into the capillary lumen observed are characteristic of FLD (Fig.1A, B). In addition, there were foam cell deposits around arterioles (Fig.1C). In electron microscopy, electron-dense deposits were found in the GBM (Fig.1B). Immunohistochemical examination revealed granular deposits of IgG and C3 along capillary loop walls (Fig.1D, E). Our diagnosis was glomerulopathy associated with LCAT deficiency and membranous nephropathy (MN).

Fig.1. Histological findings of renal biopsy

(A) Periodic acid-Schiff staining. Glomerular basement membrane (GBM) was irregularly thickened. There were foam cells in the GBM and mesangium influxing into capillary lumen.

(B) Electron microscopy findings. There was lipid deposition in the GBM and mesangium. Electron-dense deposits were found in the GBM.

(C) Periodic acid-methenamine silver staining. Foam cells were observed around arterioles.

(D, E) Immunohistochemical examination showed granular deposits of IgG (D) and C3 (E) along capillary loops.

There was no mutation in the patient’s LCAT gene exon sequence. His serum LCAT activity was below the detection limit. To evaluate LCAT activity in serum, we incubated serum from a patient with an artificial proteoliposome substrate containing tritium-labeled free cholesterol, 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine, and ApoA-1 for one hour at 37℃. After incubation, esterified cholesterol was quantified as previously described 17). Measurement of autoantibodies against LCAT was performed using the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) method, which we recently reported12). Therefore, we diagnosed the patient as having acquired LCAT deficiency. Since MN is often associated with collagen diseases, malignancies, and hepatitis, we performed additional blood tests and imaging studies, but no underlying condition was found to be associated with MN.

We used losartan 25 mg/day to reduce proteinuria because it was reported that angiotensin II receptor blockers (ARBs) delayed the progression of renal failure in patients with FLD18), and renin-angiotensin system inhibitors reduced proteinuria in nephrotic syndrome patients including those with MN19-21). However, four months after starting losartan, the proteinuria had not decreased, and serum HDL cholesterol levels remained undetectable. We therefore recommended that he be treated with prednisolone, but due to the impending expiration of his visa to stay in Japan, he was unable to begin treatment. He returned to China and revisited our hospital one year after the initial visit. Interestingly, at the time of the return visit, the urinary protein level had spontaneously decreased to 0.91 g/g Cr and the serum HDL cholesterol level had recovered to a measurable level of 3 mg/dL. Therefore, we decided to observe the patient without using prednisolone. At 17 months, the HDL-C level had increased to 10 mg/dL, and proteinuria had decreased to 0.27 g/g Cr. At 30 to 34 months, proteinuria was further reduced, up to 0.08 g/gCr. Nephrotic syndrome remained in remission up to 44 months. However, after 25 months, HDL-C levels were reduced again, at 3-5 mg/dL. His serum HDL cholesterol level did not eventually rise to within the normal range, indicating a discrepancy between resolution of proteinuria and the continually low HDL cholesterol levels (Fig.2). Since our patient could not visit our hospital regularly before 25 months, we examined LCAT activity and anti-LCAT antibodies on admission, at 25 months, and at 34 months. Table 2 shows that LCAT activity was detectable, rising to 24.5±0.7 nmol/hr/mL at 25 months and had further recovered, to 46.6±2.3 nmol/hr/mL at 35 months, though it was still not in the normal range. LCAT antibodies were still positive at 25 and 35 months. However, LCAT antibody concentrations were reduced compared to the time of admission (Table 2). During the period he stayed in China and was unable to visit our hospital, there were no significant changes in his lifestyle and no events of other diseases, and he continued taking the same medication.

Fig.2. Clinical course of patient

Proteinuria was reduced to 0.91g/g Cr at 12 months, 0.27g/g Cr at 17 months, and maintained below 0.3g/g Cr after that. HDL-C level became detectable at 12 months and had increased up to 10mg/dL at 17 months. However, it decreased again after 25 months, while it was still detectable. HDL-C had still not reached the normal level at 44 months.

Table 2.Clinical course of LCAT activity and LCAT antibody concentrations

on admission at 25 months at 34 months
LCAT activity (nmol/hr/mL) undetectable 24.5±0.7 46.6±2.3
LCAT antibody concentration (µg/mL) 1.85±0.05 0.115±0.004 0.140±0.008

LCAT activity: 415±5 nmol/hr/mL (healthy control)

LCAT antibody concentration: Owing to the lack of a standard human antibody, we used an existing standard antibody and converted the concentrations obtained with it. Calibration curves were prepared using an anti-LCAT rabbit monoclonal antibody (clone #EPR1384Y; Abcam Ltd., Cambridge, UK).

Discussion

In this report, we describe a case of acquired LCAT deficiency with nephrotic syndrome in which proteinuria spontaneously resolved, while HDL deficiency remained. Similar to several previous studies7-12), autoantibodies against LCAT were detected in our patient with acquired LCAT deficiency.

Since renal insufficiency defines the life prognosis of FLD patients22), proteinuria and renal function trends are considered clinically meaningful in patients with acquired LCAT deficiency. However, the mechanism of renal failure in LCAT deficiency is not fully understood. Some mechanisms of renal failure in FLD patients that have been suggested are: accumulation of oxidized phospholipids in the glomeruli23), and entrapment in capillary loops of abnormal lipoprotein particles, namely LpX, consisting of phospholipids and unesterified cholesterol. Although LpX appears to be accompanied by reduced LCAT activity and migrates toward the cathode during agarose gel electrophoresis24), we found no evidence for presence of LpX in the present case. A large TG-rich LDL fraction (Lp8), which was detected recently in high-performance liquid chromatography with a gel filtration column, was reported to be associated with progression of renal dysfunction25).

In FLD, accumulation of lipid components is a characteristic feature of renal lesions, and it occurs both intracellularly and extracellularly. FC and PL deposition in the GBM, subendothelial lesions of blood vessels and accumulation of foam cells lead to thickening of the GBM5, 6). In the present case, renal biopsy revealed not only a lipid deposition characteristic of FLD but also that characteristic of MN: electron-dense deposition at the epithelial side of GBM and IgG deposition along capillary loops (Fig.1D).

Based on previous case reports, including ours, we discuss the relationship among severity of proteinuria, LCAT activity, and serum HDL cholesterol levels. We compared 7 cases in which proteinuria was 3.5g/day or more and 5 cases in which it was lower than 3.5g/day. There was no difference in HDL-C levels or CE/TC ratio. However, LCAT activity was likely lower in the former cases (Table 3A) than in the latter cases (Table 3B). Next, among patients with proteinuria of 0.5 g/gCr or more, we compared 6 patients who received immunosuppression therapy or did not recover and 3 patients in whom proteinuria spontaneously resolved. In the former (Table 3C), LCAT activity was likely lower than in the latter (Table 3D). Moreover, in 2 cases other than the present case in which proteinuria spontaneously resolved, there were no findings of MN in renal biopsies (Table 3D). From these comparative analyses, low LCAT activity and pathological diagnosis of MN were considered to be characteristics of severe cases requiring immunosuppressive therapy. However, in the present case, proteinuria spontaneously resolved despite the undetectable LCAT activity and findings of MN (Table 3D). The clinical course of the present case suggests that immunosuppression therapy may not be necessary for improvement of nephrotic syndrome in acquired LCAT deficiency. However, in a younger patient not receiving immunosuppression therapy, end stage renal disease developed14), so further case reports on characteristics that determine the need for immunosuppressive therapy are needed.

Table 3.Previously reported cases of acquired LCAT deficiency and present case

A. Patients with proteinuria of 3.5 g/day or more
Reference 7 8 13 9 14 10 Present case
Age/Gender 67/M 63/F 62/M 70/M 33/M 70/F 79/M
Country Japan Japan Japan Japan Italy Japan China
Proteinuria (g/gCr or day) 6.38 4.1 5 7.7 4 5.6 4.4
Cr (mg/dL) 1.18 0.58 0.9 1.15 N/A 1.26 1.05
HDL-C (mg/dL) 7 3 11 3 11 2 <2
CE/TC ratio 0.11 0.11 0.05 N/A 0.23 0.15 0.07
LCAT activity undetectable undetectable undetectable undetectable N/A 62.5*1 undetectable
*1 62.5 nmol/ml/h (normal range; 260-560)
B. Patients with proteinuria of lower than 3.5 g/day
Reference 9 15 16 11 12
Age/Gender 74/M 53/F 36/F 71/F 59/F
Country Japan Japan Japan Italy Japan
Proteinuria (g/gCr or day) *2 1.6 0.2 N/A Negative
Cr (mg/dL) 1.41 0.50 0.7 N/A 0.5
HDL-C (mg/dL) 1 2.5 2 5 2
CE/TC ratio 0.02 N/A 0.15 0 0.26
LCAT activity undetectable 22.9*3 10*4 N/A 9.3*5

*2 Urine albumin was around 1400 mg/gCr

*3 22.9 U (contrast; 408.2)

*4 10 UI/mL (normal range; 53.5-95.5)

*5 9.3 nmol/hr/mL (normal pooled serum; 375±4.9)

C. Patients who received immunosuppression therapy or did not recover
received treatment did not recover
Reference 7 8 13 9 9 14
Age/Gender 67/M 63/F 62/M 70/M 74/M 33/M
Immunosupression therapy PSL PSL PSL PSL none none
Clinical course remission improved not improved ESRD
Renal biopsy FLD+MN N/A FLD+MN
Proteinuria (g/gCr or day) 6.4 4.1 5.0 7.7 *2 4.0
HDL-C (mg/dL) 12 3 11 3 1 11
LCAT activity undetectable undetectable undetectable undetectable undetectable N/A
PSL: prednisone, ESRD: end stage renal disease, FLD: foam cells in GBM and mesangium, MN: findings of membranous nephropathy-like electron-dense deposits at epithelial side of GBM
D. Patients in whom proteinuria spontaneously resolved
Reference 10 15 Present case
Age/Gender 70/F 53/F 79/M
Clinical course remission
Renal biopsy FLD FLD+MN
Proteinuria (g/gCr or day) 5.6 1.6 4.4
HDL-C (mg/dL) 2 2.5 <2
LCAT activity

62.5 nmol/ml/h

(normal range;

260-560)

22.9 U

undetectable

(contrast;

408.2)

FLD: foam cells in GBM and mesangium, MN: findings of membranous nephropathy-like electron-dense deposits at epithelial side of GBM

Strategies for treating idiopathic MN may be helpful in the choice of treatment for acquired LCAT syndrome. In this regard, measurement of anti-phospholipase A2 receptor (PLA2R) antibody titers is used in practice to diagnose idiopathic MN26). Like LCAT, PLA2 is an enzyme that hydrolyzes the ester bond at the sn-2 site of glycerophospholipids, and PLA2 and LCAT have structural homology. In addition, the Kidney Disease Improving Global Outcome (KDIGO) 2021 Clinical Practice Guideline for the Management of Glomerular Diseases notes that approximately 30% of patients with idiopathic MN will resolve spontaneously within 2 years and that low-risk patients with progressive loss of kidney function can be managed with renin-angiotensin system inhibitors alone26). Furthermore, the guideline states that it is reasonable to wait 6 months for spontaneous remission, while the use of maximal antiproteinuric therapy and immunosuppressive therapy is considered if proteinuria does not improve after 6 months of conservative treatment. We await further case accumulation to help determine whether the treatment guideline for idiopathic MN can be adapted to acquired LCAT deficiency as well.

So, what was the reason for the discrepancy between resolution of proteinuria and lack of an increase HDL cholesterol in the present case? As our first hypothesis, we speculate that there are differences between the threshold of LCAT activity at the onset of HDL deficiency and that of MN. In most previous reports of acquired LCAT deficiency, onset of nephrotic syndrome was preceded by HDL deficiency, and there was resolution of nephrotic syndrome if HDL deficiency was preceded by nephrotic syndrome. The clinical course of LCAT activity in our case supported this hypothesis (Table 2). However, in some cases, resolution of nephrotic syndrome has been followed by HDL deficiency, so this hypothesis does not always hold good. Our second hypothesis is that there is an optimal ratio of antigen and antibody when deposits that occur in MN develop. It has been reported that the antigen to antibody ratio is important in one of the mechanisms regulating the development of subepithelial immune deposits in MN27). In the present case, when the nephrotic syndrome reached remission, the patient was still positive for LCAT antibodies but their concentration was reduced (Table 2, Fig.2), which supports this hypothesis. The third hypothesis is that MN was coincidentally accompanied by acquired LCAT deficiency in the present case. At the time, we could not examine anti-PLA2R antibody titers and immunohistochemical examination of PLA2 and LCAT was not performed. However, this hypothesis is unlikely to be correct and we consider that secondary MN associated with LCAT deficiency is more likely than primary MN in the present case. It is because immunohistochemistry and immunofluorescence detected LCAT along parts of the glomerular capillary walls in some previously reported cases of MN accompanied with LCAT deficiency7, 8), suggesting that LCAT was an antigen responsible for the MN. Moreover, in the present patient, the onsets of HDL deficiency and nephrotic syndrome were considered to have occurred nearly simultaneously and both urinary protein and serum HDL cholesterol level were showing signs of improvement when the patient returned for a follow-up visit 13 months after the initial visit.

This case report has several limitations that should be taken into consideration. First, the present patient did not bring a referral letter detailing his medical history and progress with his primary physician in China. Hence, the details of the clinical data in China were unclear. Second, given that LCAT activity was assessed at only three sample points, fluctuations of LCAT activity might have occurred during unmeasured intervals. Third, because some previously reported cases of acquired LCAT deficiency had underlying diseases such as lymphoma and sarcoidosis, there remains a possibility that an underlying disease may be identified in the present patient subsequently.

In conclusion, we report a patient who had acquired LCAT deficiency with severe HDL deficiency and nephrotic syndrome. This novel case is interesting because the pathology indicated MN and only proteinuria spontaneously resolved without recovery in LCAT activity or serum HDL cholesterol level. Although immunosuppressive therapy could not be administered in view of the expiration date of the patient’s residence visa, the natural history of the kidney in this case was similar to that of low-risk cases of idiopathic MN. Further case reports and discussions are needed.

Acknowledgements

The author sincerely thanks Chie Nishiguchi for technical assistance.

We thank CellGen Tech, Inc. for performing our patient’s LCAT activity and anti-LCAT autoantibody measurements.

Conflicts of Interest

Masatsune Ogura has received honoraria from Amgen, Kowa Company, and Ultragenyx Japan. Masayuki Kuroda has received patent royalty and licensing fees from CellGenTech, Inc. Mariko Harada-Shiba holds stock of Liid Pharmaceuticals, and has received speaking honoraria from Amgen, MEDPACE, Kowa, BML, Protosera, and Novartis. Koutaro Yokote has received honoraria from MSD K.K., Kowa Company, Ltd., Sanofi K.K., Sumitomo Pharma Co., Ltd., Daichi Sankyo Company, Limited, Taisho Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., Mitsubishi Tanabe Pharma Corporation, Boehringer Ingelheim International GmbH., Novartis Pharma K.K., Novo Nordisk Pharma Ltd., Bayer Yakuhin, Ltd., and Pfizer Japan Inc., as well as clinical research funding from CellGenTech, Inc. KY has also received scholarship grants from Abbot Japan LLC, Eisai Co., Ltd., Otsuka Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., Kowa Company, Ltd., Sumitomo Pharma Co., Ltd., Taisho Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., Takeda Pharmaceutical Company Limited, Mitsubishi Tanabe Pharma Corporation, TEIJIN PHARMA LIMITED, Eli Lily Japan K.K., Boehringer Ingelheim International GmbH, and MOCHIDA PHARMACEUTICAL Co., Ltd.. The other authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.

Grant Support

This work is supported by a Labor and Welfare Sciences Research Grant for Research on Rare and Intractable Diseases (24FC1012) and JSPS KAKENHI (24K11299).

References
 

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons [Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International] license.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
feedback
Top