Journal of Mineralogical and Petrological Sciences
Online ISSN : 1349-3825
Print ISSN : 1345-6296
ISSN-L : 1345-6296
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
The record of geological processes in zircon from polymetamorphosed orthogneisses from the Napier Mountains, Napier Complex, East Antarctica
Piotr KRÓL Monika A. KUSIAKDaniel J. DUNKLEYMartin J. WHITEHOUSESimon A. WILDELars E. AUGLAND
Author information
JOURNAL FREE ACCESS FULL-TEXT HTML

2023 Volume 118 Issue ANTARCTICA Article ID: 230419

Details
Abstract

The Napier Complex in Enderby Land and western Kemp Land is a unique component of the East Antarctic Shield because it records a timeline of crustal growth from the Eo- to Neoarchean. It is mainly composed of enderbitic and charnockitic gneisses and granulites that were metamorphosed at ∼ 2.5 Ga, and locally at ∼ 2.8 Ga, under high- to ultra-high-temperature conditions. Despite generating scientific interest for several decades, the geological history of the complex has not been well constrained. In this study, samples from the Napier Mountains were selected for zircon imaging and U-Pb dating by Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry. They record metamorphic growth, recrystallization, and modification of zircon at 2800-2770, 2740-2720, and 2490-2460 Ma. For the first time, fluid-related alteration at around 2730 Ma is evident in a granitic gneiss from Grimsley Peaks. At the similar time, dioritic gneiss was formed at Mount Marr. Tonalitic and granitic gneisses from Grimsley Peaks yield protolith crystallization ages of around 3210 and 2825 Ma, respectively. The generation of granitic gneiss was coeval with ∼ 2.8 Ga metamorphism in the area. These new data from this little-known part of the complex provide a better understanding of the crustal evolution of the Napier Complex.

INTRODUCTION

Zircon (ZrSiO4) is the mineral of choice for U-Th-Pb geochronology of Archean rocks, as it is chemically and physically robust. It contains radiogenic Pb from the decay of U and Th, but initially excludes Pb from its crystallographic structure during magmatic growth. Moreover, zircon maintains its isotopic signature even during high-grade metamorphic processes because of the extraordinarily low diffusivity of Pb in zircon (Cherniak and Watson, 2001, 2003). It commonly retains accumulated radiogenic Pb despite weathering or metamorphism of the host rock (Hoskin and Schaltegger, 2003). Zircon cathodoluminescence (CL) and back scattered electron (BSE) imaging can reveal a variety of internal structures which can be linked to specific geological processes, including crystallization from a magma, subsolidus recrystallization, dissolution and reprecipitation, or fluid-mediated alteration (Corfu et al., 2003; Harley and Kelly, 2007; Taylor et al., 2016). This imagery can shed light not only on the timing of zircon crystallization but its alteration and recrystallization during metamorphism.

The Napier Complex is one of the least studied regions where early Earth rocks have been preserved. It is likely composed of different crustal domains, each with its own independent geological history (Król et al., 2022) varying in the timing and type of magmatism and metamorphism. This preliminary hypothesis needs to be verified and the extent of each crustal domain needs to be constrained. In this study, we focus on the geochronology of the Napier Mountains, as this region has received little attention compared to more accessible locations, particularly along the coast. Here, we present results obtained on complex zircon grains from orthogneisses from Grimsley Peaks, Mount Marr and Johnston Peak in the Napier Mountains to determine the effects of metamorphism, including the 2.5 Ga high to ultra-high temperature (HT/UHT) event, on the isotopic as well as internal structure of zircon grains. Uranium-Pb geochronology, together with BSE and CL imaging have been used to decipher metamorphic processes in which primary zircon has been recrystallized or there was growth of new zircon domains. Whole-rock geochemistry was also employed to shed more light on possible geotectonic scenarios.

GEOLOGICAL SETTING

The Napier Complex of Enderby Land and western Kemp Land extends along the Antarctic coast between longitudes 48°E and 57°E (Fig. 1). It forms part of the East Antarctic Shield, which records a prolonged history of continental growth and terrane assembly throughout the Proterozoic, with final assembly in the Cambrian (Fitzsimons, 2000; Harley et al., 2013). The geology of the Napier Complex has been reviewed by Sheraton et al. (1987) and recently by Harley et al. (2019). In a more recent paper, Król et al. (2022) also summarized the available magmatic geochronological data from across the complex. The complex is comprised mostly of gneisses and granulites formed under HT to UHT conditions at ∼ 2.5 Ga (Sheraton et al., 1987; Hokada et al., 2008; Clark et al., 2018; Harley et al., 2019) and locally at ∼ 2.8 Ga (Harley and Black, 1997; Hokada et al., 2008; Clark et al., 2018; Król et al., 2020). Orthopyroxene-quartz-feldspar orthogneisses and layered garnet-quartz-feldspar paragneisses constitute the predominant rock-types, with minor mafic components. Orthogneisses vary from tonalite (enderbite), through tonalite-trondhjemite-granodiorite (TTG), to granite (charnockite) in composition. The Napier Mountains (Fig. 1a and 1b) are an inland mountain range, extending about 60 km in a NW-SE direction, and located in the northern Napier Complex, over 100 km south of Proclamation Island. They are characterized by scarce and isolated outcrops in the form of nunataks. Whereas mesoperthite-bearing charnockitic gneisses metamorphosed up to UHT conditions (Harley, 2016) are particularly abundant around Amundsen Bay and in the Tula Mountains (Fig. 1a), two-feldspar gneisses crop out in the Napier Mountains (Sheraton et al., 1987), probably reflecting lower peak metamorphic temperatures. The Napier Mountains region lies outside of the UHT metamorphic domain as outlined by Harley and Motoyoshi (2000), based on the geothermobarometry of garnet-othopyroxene bearing granulites (Harley, 1985) and characteristic mineral assemblages in pelites (Harley et al., 1990 and references therein). The presence of cordierite rather than an assemblage of sapphirine and quartz in metapelites indicates lower P/T conditions in the Napier Mountains (Sheraton et al., 1987), where post-metamorphic pressures were estimated at ∼ 5 kbar (Harley, 1983, 1985). Apart from gneisses and granulites, younger granitic intrusive rocks are also present in the region (Sheraton et al., 1987).

Figure 1. Map of the Napier Complex, modified after Sheraton et al. (1987). (a) Simplified outcrop map. Study area is marked by the dashed red rectangle. Inset shows the position of the Napier Complex within the East Antarctic Shield. (b) Outcrop map of the Napier Mountains. Sample locations are indicated.

The crust of the Napier Complex formed throughout most of the Archean. Eoarchean protoliths for felsic orthogneisses are known from zircon dating at several localities in the Tula Mountains, i.e., Gage Ridge (Kusiak et al., 2013a; Guitreau et al., 2019), Mount Sones (Guitreau et al., 2019), Budd Peak and Mt. Jewell (Król et al., 2020); and at Aker Peaks in the western part of Kemp Land (Kusiak et al., 2021). Younger, Paleo- to Mesoarchean protolith ages for felsic orthogneisses were obtained at Mt. Riiser-Larsen (Hokada et al., 2003), ranging from 3267 ± 5 to 3073 ± 12 Ma in age. Mesoarchean zircon U-Pb ages have also been reported from several localities in the central and northern Napier Complex (Harley and Black, 1997; Kelly and Harley, 2005; Król et al., 2020). Although not precise, Rb-Sr whole-rock ages may indicate protolith formation at this time at Fyfe Hills (3120 +230/−180 Ma; Black et al., 1983b), Mount Tod in Amundsen Bay (2934 +196/−127 Ma; Black et al., 1983b), and at Mount Bride in the Napier Mountains (2840 +220/−280 Ma; Black and James, 1983).

The Napier Complex was locally metamorphosed at ∼ 2.8 Ga as demonstrated by several authors (e.g., Harley and Black, 1997; Hokada et al., 2003; Kelly and Harley, 2005; Kusiak et al., 2013a; Clark et al., 2018; Król et al., 2020). Circa 2850 Ma ages for metamorphic zircon were obtained from gneisses at Mt. Riiser-Larsen (Hokada et al., 2003) in the vicinity of Amundsen Bay, Dallwitz Nunatak (Kelly and Harley, 2005; Kusiak et al., 2013a) and Mount King (Król et al., 2020) in the Tula Mountains, and at Proclamation Island in the northern part of the complex (Kelly and Harley, 2005). Hokada et al. (2003) suggested, based on zircon dating, that this tectono-thermal event continued at least until 2790 Ma. A minimum magmatic age of 2788 ± 24 Ma has been obtained for another gneiss from Mt. King (Król et al., 2020), but its relationship to the ∼ 2.8 Ga metamorphic event remains unresolved. The only known protolith ages for orthogneisses that post-date the ∼ 2.8 Ga metamorphism are from localities in the south-western part of the Napier Complex: at Mt. Bergin (2711 ± 5 Ma) and Mt. Henry (2726 ± 6 Ma, Król et al., 2022); Fyfe Hills (∼ 2741 Ma, Horie et al., 2012) and Tonagh Island (2678 ± 8 Ma, Crowe et al., 2002; 2628 ± 12 Ma, Carson et al., 2002).

Metamorphism at high to ultra-high temperatures occurred at ∼ 2.5 Ga, with metamorphic zircon and monazite ages spanning over 150 Myr., from 2585 to 2420 Ma (Grew and Manton, 1979; Asami et al., 2002; Carson et al., 2002; Kelly and Harley, 2005; Suzuki et al., 2006; Horie et al., 2012; Harley, 2016; Clark et al., 2018; Król et al., 2020, 2022). The oldest vestige of this event is represented by zircon growth in anatectic leucosome from McIntyre Island at 2586 ± 8 Ma (Harley, 2016). Ages from metamorphic zircon between 2550 and 2520 Ma were obtained from Tonagh Island (Carson et al., 2002), Zircon Point (Kelly and Harley, 2005), Fyfe Hills (Horie et al., 2012) and recently from Mount King (Król et al., 2020), Mt Bergin and Mt. Douglas (Król et al., 2022). Zircon growth and/or modification until 2450 Ma has been demonstrated in numerous studies (Black et al., 1983a; Carson et al., 2002; Hokada et al., 2003; Kelly and Harley, 2005; Horie et al., 2012; Takehara et al., 2020; Król et al., 2020; Kusiak et al., 2021; Król et al., 2022). In some samples (e.g., Kelly and Harley, 2005; Król et al., 2020, 2022), two discrete stages of metamorphic zircon growth, at ∼ 2510 and 2480 Ma, have been identified through different Th-U compositions (for example at Budd Peak, Król et al., 2020; and at Mt. Bergin, Król et al., 2022). These two stages are present throughout the Napier Complex, as seen in the compilation of U-Pb zircon ages in Król et al. (2022) and references therein, but the exact process explaining this phenomenon is still not known. Age estimates from metamorphic zircon, monazite and xenotime (Black et al., 1984; Asami et al., 2002) as young as ∼ 2420 Ma have been attributed to slow cooling and/or post-peak fluid activity (e.g., Harley, 2016).

SAMPLES AND METHODOLOGY

Four samples representative of intermediate to felsic orthogneisses from the Napier Mountains (Fig. 1) were selected for this study from the archives of Geoscience Australia. The original geochemical and petrographic database of these samples can be found in Sheraton et al. (1987). The samples NMC02 (78285004 in database of Sheraton et al., 1987) and NMC03 (77283989) come from Grimsley Peaks (Fig. 1b). The former is a quartz-feldspar gneiss with potassic feldspar dominant over plagioclase. Orthopyroxene constitutes a minor phase, whereas zircon and opaque minerals are accessory phases. Orthopyroxene and potassic feldspar are commonly altered. Sample NMC03 is an orthopyroxene-quartz-plagioclase gneiss with accessory biotite, apatite, zircon and opaque minerals. Sample NNW01 (77284068) comes from Mount Marr and is a quartz-orthopyroxene-plagioclase gneiss with biotite, zircon and opaque minerals constituting the accessory phases. Sample NNW02 (77284064) from Johnston Peaks is an orthopyroxene-quartz-plagioclase gneiss, with abundant biotite and minor potassic feldspar. Apatite, zircon, and opaque minerals are accessory phases.

Fresh and compositionally uniform samples were selected and pulverized in an agate ball mill for whole-rock analyses of major and trace elements. Analyses were carried out by Bureau Veritas Minerals at ACME Analytical Laboratories, Vancouver, Canada. Major oxides were analyzed by X-ray fluorescence (XRF) spectrometry, whereas trace elements, including rare earth elements (REE), were analyzed by inductively-coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). The volatile content was estimated by loss on ignition (LOI), measured by titration.

For zircon geochronology, samples were reduced in a jaw crusher, sieved, and washed to remove the fines. The magnetic fraction was removed from the concentrate using Carpco and Frantz magnetic separators. Diiodomethane with a density of 3.32 g/cm3 was used to separate the heavy mineral fraction. Zircon grains were hand-picked under a binocular microscope and cast in epoxy resin, together with standard reference materials 91500 (80 ppm U, with an age of 1065 Ma, Wiedenbeck et al., 1995), M257 (561.3 Ma, Nasdala et al., 2008), and OG1 (3465 Ma, Stern et al., 2009). The mounts were ground to reveal the internal structure of the grains, then polished, cleaned in an ultrasonic bath, and coated with ∼ 30 nm of gold.

Zircon imaging and U-Th-Pb isotopic analyses were performed at the Swedish Museum of Natural History. Zircon grains were photographed in reflected light and imaged using a scanning electron microscope (Hitachi S4300) with BSE detector to examine the grain interiors and to choose analytical sites. A Secondary Ion Micro-Probe (SIMS) large geometry CAMECA IMS 1270e7 was used to carry out U-Th-Pb isotopic analyses. Analytical protocols for U-Pb broadly followed those described by Whitehouse and Kamber (2005) and references therein. An O2 primary beam with 23 kV incident energy (−13 kV primary, +10 kV secondary) was generated using an Oregon Physics H201 RF-plasma source and used to sputter zircon. For this study, the primary beam was operated in critically focussed (Gaussian) mode with a small raster retained during analysis to flatten the bottom of the analytical crater. The first analytical session used a 10 nA primary beam yielding a nominal spot size of ∼ 15 µm; the second used a 3 nA primary for a spot size of ∼ 10 µm. Pre-sputtering with a 25 µm raster for 60 seconds, centering of the secondary ion beam in the 3000 µm field aperture (FA), mass calibration optimisation, and optimisation of the secondary beam energy distribution were performed automatically for each run. Field aperture and energy adjustment were done using the 90Zr216O+ species at nominal mass 196 Da. Mass calibration of all peaks in the monocollection sequence was performed at the start of each session; within run mass calibration optimization scanned only the 90Zr216O+ peak, with small drift corrections applied to all mass stations in each run. A mass resolving power (M/ΔM) of ∼ 5400 was used to ensure adequate separation of Pb isotope peaks from nearby HfSi+ species. Ion signals were detected using an axial ion-counting electron multiplier. All analyses were run in fully automated chain sequences. Small within-run linear drift corrections (<0.5%/cycle) were applied to the inter-element ratios (Pb/U and UO2/U) based on the average from the calibration standard in each session (Jeon and Whitehouse, 2021). Data reduction followed the protocols described by Jeon and Whitehouse (2015) and assume a power law relationship between Pb+/U+ and UO2+/U+ ratios with an empirically derived slope in order to calculate actual Pb/U ratios based on those in the M257 zircon standard (Nasdala et al., 2008). Uranium concentrations and Th/U ratio were also referenced to the M257 standard. Common Pb corrections were made only when 204Pb counts statistically exceeded 3x average detector background and assume a 207Pb/206Pb ratio of 0.83 [equivalent to present day Stacey and Kramers (1975) model terrestrial Pb]. The choice of model age for common Pb has a negligible effect on age estimates for samples where the proportion of common 206Pb to total 206Pb is <1%. External spot-to-spot errors on measurements of the calibration standard M257 were propagated to analyses on unknown zircon samples. The Isoplot 3.75 software (Ludwig, 2012) was used to generate concordia plots and to calculate weighted mean ages.

Across both analytical sessions, 39 analyses of 91500 zircon yielded a weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age of 1065 ± 3 Ma (95% confidence, MSWD = 1.12) and a concordia age of 1058 ± 3 Ma (2σ, MSWD = 1.0). The 14 analyses of OG1 exhibit some discordance attributed to Pb loss: 11 analyses yielding a weighted average 207Pb/206Pb age of 3469 ± 3 Ma (95% confidence, MSWD = 1.4).

RESULTS

Geochemistry

Geochemical results for the whole-rock analyses are provided in Table 1 and are compared with published data for other felsic orthogneisses in the Napier Complex (Sheraton et al., 1987; Król et al., 2020, 2022). Gneisses analyzed in this study are intermediate to felsic with SiO2 ranging from 60.3 to 73.9 wt%. Samples NMC03 and NNW02 plot in the granodiorite field on the Total Alkali-Silica (TAS) diagram (Fig. 2a), sample NNW01 plots as diorite, whereas sample NMC02 plots in the granite field. Samples NMC03 and NNW02 also plot in the tonalite field on the normative albite-anorthite-orthoclase triangle diagram (Fig. 2b) of Barker (1979; modified after O’Connor, 1965), whereas sample NMC02 plots as granite (Fig. 2b). The Alumina Saturation Index (A/CNK) ranges from 0.93 to 1.02, i.e., the samples are weakly peraluminous to metaluminous (Fig. 2c). Samples belong to the calc-alkaline series on the AFM diagram (Fig. 2d), with the exception of sample NNW01, which belongs to the tholeiite series. Samples NMC03, NNW01, and NNW02 have low K2O/Na2O <0.75 (Fig. 2e) and low K2O relative to Na2O + CaO. Sample NMCO2 has high K2O of 4.11 wt%, hence a high K2O/Na2O of 1.31. Samples NMC02 and NMC03 plot in the high-Al2O3 field of Halla et al. (2009), whereas the remaining two samples plot in the low Al2O3 field (Fig. 2f). Sample NMW01 has a much lower content of Al2O3 than NMW02 at a similar silica content. Two samples, NNW01 and NNW02, have high contents of mafic oxides (Fe2O3t + MgO + MnO + TiO2) of 8 and 19 wt%, respectively.

Table 1. Whole-rock major and trace element compositions of orthogneisses from the Napier Mountains
Sample NMC02 NMC03 NNW01 NNW02
(78285004) (77283989) (77284068) (77284064)
Grimsley Peaks Grimsley Peaks Mount Marr Johnston Peak
wt%
SiO2 73.9 69.4 60.3 62.2
Al2O3 13.6 16.2 13.3 17.1
Fe2O3t 1.95 2.28 12.80 4.44
CaO 2.06 5.19 4.23 5.98
MgO 0.42 1.12 5.82 3.63
Na2O 3.14 3.79 2.91 3.48
K2O 4.11 0.69 0.54 1.70
MnO 0.02 0.03 0.14 0.07
TiO2 0.20 0.47 0.93 0.60
P2O5 0.04 0.05 0.05 0.14
LOI 0.05 0.03 0.00 0.00
Total 99.5 99.3 101.0 99.3
ppm
Rb 124 3.7 4.8 68.7
Ba 670 753 468 861
Sr 88.5 295 228 304
Ga 15.0 16.7 18.7 19.0
Hf 3.9 4.9 5.3 3.3
Nb 8.5 6.8 7.5 5.0
Ta 0.4 0.3 0.6 0.1
U 1.2 1.2 0.6 0.7
Th 13.3 0.4 11.0 1.5
Pb 2.8 2.5 2.2 1.3
V 17 61 168 89
Cu 1.9 29.8 20.7 0.9
Ni 1.3 12.7 34.5 68.1
Zr 133 203 195 134
Y 9.8 2.6 11.7 7.5
La 40.8 13.6 18.4 18.4
Ce 65.9 15.8 28.2 28.2
Pr 5.86 1.34 2.75 2.75
Nd 18.3 4.4 9.9 9.9
Sm 2.93 0.70 1.67 1.67
Eu 0.86 1.29 1.06 1.06
Gd 2.35 0.69 1.81 1.81
Tb 0.34 0.08 0.26 0.26
Dy 1.95 0.45 1.44 1.44
Ho 0.34 0.09 0.28 0.28
Er 0.91 0.30 0.88 0.88
Tm 0.12 0.04 0.11 0.11
Yb 0.83 0.38 0.66 0.66
Lu 0.14 0.06 0.11 0.11
 
K2O/Na2O 2.68 3.33 3.14 3.14
A/CNK 1.02 0.99 1.02 0.93
A/NK 1.41 2.32 2.48 2.26
Eu/Eu* 0.16 0.14 0.16 0.16
Figure 2. Geochemical characteristics and classification diagrams for orthogneisses, including published data from the Napier Complex (Sheraton et al., 1987; Król et al., 2020, 2022). (a) Total alkalis versus silica (TAS) diagram (Middlemost, 1994). M.-g., Monzogabbro; Peridot. gabbro, Peridotite gabbro. (b) Feldspar classification diagram (Barker, 1979, modified after O’Connor, 1965). Group 1 and Group 2 as defined by Król et al. (2020) represent low- and high-Y-HREE-Nb-Ta orthogneisses, respectively. (c) A/NK = Al2O3/(Na2O + K2O) (mol%) versus A/CNK = Al2O3/(CaO + Na2O + K2O). (d) AFM: (Na2O + K2O) - FeOt - MgO ternary diagram after Irvine and Baragar (1971). (e) K2O/Na2O versus SiO2 diagram. (f) Al2O3 versus SiO2 diagram with high/low-Al2O3 fields after Halla et al. (2009).

Based on the earlier work of Sheraton and Black (1983) and Sheraton et al. (1985), Król et al. (2020, 2022) defined two chemical groups of felsic orthogneiss in the Tula, Raggatt and Scott Mountains of the western and south-western Napier Complex: Group 1 with (Y-HREE)sample/primitive mantle or S/PM <1 and (Nb-Ta)S/PM = 2-7; and Group 2 with higher Y-HREE (Y-HREES/PM = 3-4) and Nb-Ta (Nb-TaS/PM = ∼ 10). These groups are distinct on both the primitive mantle-normalized spider diagram (Fig. 3a) and the chondrite-normalized REE diagram (Fig. 3b). In this study, the analyzed samples have Nb-Ta-Y-HREE contents between Group 1 and Group 2, and thus they cannot be unambiguously assigned to either of these two groups. All samples have negative Ti and Nb-Ta anomalies, but with very variable Nb/Ta ratios. Samples NNW02 and NMC02 have negative P anomalies, whereas sample NNW01 has a positive anomaly (Fig. 3a). There are no systematic differences in terms of large ion lithophile (LIL) elements, with the samples showing highly variable Rb and Th contents of 3.7-123.5 and 0.4-13.3 ppm, respectively. The LREE patterns have steep slopes, with LaN/LuN ratios of 17-30. The pattern of sample NMC03 has a concave-upward slope between Gd and Lu. Similarly, sample NNW01 shows a slight rise between Tb and Lu. Samples NNW01 and NNW02 display moderate positive Eu anomalies, whereas sample NMC03 has a large positive anomaly. Sample NMC02 does not show an Eu anomaly.

Figure 3. (a) Trace element spider diagram with elements normalised to the primitive mantle composition of McDonough and Sun (1995). (b) Rare earth element (REE) diagram normalised to chondrite from McDonough and Sun (1995). Data for the Group 1 and Group 2 fields from Król et al. (2020, 2022).

Geochronology

Representative CL images of analyzed zircon grains are presented in Figure 4. Uranium-Th-Pb isotopic data are presented in Tables 2-5 and plotted on Tera-Wasserburg concordia diagrams (Fig. 5). The reported dates in the text refer to weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb ages with the errors at 2 sigma. Analyses are considered concordant if the error ellipse overlaps the concordia curve.

Figure 4. Representative cathodoluminescence images of zircon in samples from the Napier Mountains. Dashed white circles represent sites of U-Pb analyses, labelled with 207Pb/206Pb ages in Ma. Note that dark circles mark the analytical pits produced by the ion beam. The numbers in the figure refer to the grain numbers in Tables 2-5. Errors are 1 sigma. (a) NMC02. (b) NMC03. (c) NNW01. (d) NNW02. Scale bars are 100 µm.
Table 2. U-Th-Pb data for sample NMC02 (78285004) from Grimsley Peaks
Analysis           Ratiosa Agesa  
(Grain.spot) U
(ppm)
Th
(ppm)
Th/U Pb
(ppm)
206Pbc
(%)b
238U/206Pb ±σ
(%)
207Pb/206Pb ±σ
(%)
206Pb/238U ±σ 207Pb/206Pb ±σ Conc.
(%)c
NMC02_29a* 2091 222 0.11 1423.9 0.00 1.8070 0.64 0.201237 0.32 2839.3 14.7 2836.3 5.3 100.1
NMC02_14a* 261 83 0.32 183.9 {0.00} 1.8259 0.72 0.200688 0.81 2815.5 16.5 2831.8 13.3 99.4
NMC02_13b* 664 251 0.38 490.0 {0.01} 1.7654 1.14 0.200461 0.79 2893.2 26.7 2830.0 12.8 102.2
NMC02_25a* 258 282 1.09 206.9 0.01 1.8511 0.59 0.199587 0.25 2784.4 13.4 2822.8 4.0 98.6
NMC02_18a* 90 121 1.35 77.4 {0.01} 1.8155 0.89 0.198934 0.74 2828.6 20.4 2817.5 12.1 100.4
NMC02_42a 3454 3034 0.88 3126.0 0.00 1.5805 0.57 0.198739 0.19 3160.4 14.4 2815.9 3.1 112.2
NMC02_49a* 1240 632 0.51 915.3 {0.00} 1.8122 0.75 0.198582 0.55 2832.8 17.1 2814.6 9.0 100.6
NMC02_47a 991 600 0.61 751.1 {0.00} 1.7975 0.63 0.198283 0.21 2851.5 14.6 2812.1 3.4 101.4
NMC02_32a 951 635 0.67 735.5 0.00 1.7834 0.63 0.198230 0.43 2869.6 14.7 2811.7 7.0 102.1
NMC02_31a 2605 1725 0.66 2182.2 0.00 1.6364 0.86 0.197987 0.20 3074.4 21.0 2809.7 3.3 109.4
NMC02_33a 1559 1052 0.67 1183.4 0.00 1.8176 0.59 0.197717 0.08 2825.9 13.5 2807.4 1.4 100.7
NMC02_56a 597 274 0.46 437.3 {0.01} 1.8031 0.81 0.197648 0.53 2844.3 18.6 2806.9 8.6 101.3
NMC02_23c 778 319 0.41 569.2 0.24 1.7897 0.89 0.197387 0.89 2861.5 20.6 2804.7 14.6 102.0
NMC02_27a 904 599 0.66 682.4 0.01 1.8231 1.15 0.197338 0.24 2819.0 26.3 2804.3 3.9 100.5
NMC02_28a 998 735 0.74 759.6 0.00 1.8361 0.68 0.197321 0.39 2802.8 15.4 2804.2 6.4 100.0
NMC02_23a 2777 1033 0.37 2090.5 0.00 1.7196 0.66 0.197133 0.17 2955.0 15.5 2802.6 2.9 105.4
NMC02_17a 2719 2453 0.90 2235.3 0.00 1.7537 0.80 0.197124 0.22 2908.7 18.7 2802.5 3.7 103.8
NMC02_10a 525 131 0.25 362.7 0.02 1.8308 0.72 0.196791 0.43 2809.4 16.5 2799.8 7.1 100.3
NMC02_13a 814 368 0.45 604.6 0.00 1.7702 0.72 0.196690 0.25 2886.8 16.9 2798.9 4.1 103.1
NMC02_48a 201 316 1.57 172.4 0.04 1.8990 0.91 0.196294 0.48 2727.1 20.2 2795.6 7.8 97.5
NMC02_55a 656 293 0.45 472.2 0.03 1.8311 0.74 0.196006 0.69 2809.1 16.9 2793.2 11.3 100.6
NMC02_57a 287 196 0.68 218.0 {0.00} 1.8139 0.94 0.195768 0.79 2830.6 21.6 2791.2 12.9 101.4
NMC02_2b 454 42 0.09 300.0 0.10 1.8497 0.73 0.195058 0.83 2786.1 16.5 2785.3 13.6 100.0
NMC02_43b 1830 57 0.03 1178.3 0.00 1.8692 0.67 0.194727 0.28 2762.4 15.1 2782.5 4.6 99.3
NMC02_57b 322 230 0.71 242.8 {0.01} 1.8343 0.77 0.194333 0.56 2805.1 17.5 2779.2 9.3 100.9
NMC02_46a 608 157 0.26 415.9 0.04 1.8508 0.73 0.193943 0.52 2784.8 16.5 2775.9 8.4 100.3
NMC02_30a 614 43 0.07 390.5 0.01 1.9086 0.79 0.193602 0.47 2715.9 17.5 2773.0 7.8 97.9
NMC02_57c 1410 125 0.09 928.0 0.03 1.8491 0.62 0.193101 0.49 2786.8 14.0 2768.8 8.0 100.7
NMC02_33b 514 270 0.52 350.6 0.01 1.9683 1.04 0.192967 0.38 2648.3 22.5 2767.6 6.2 95.7
NMC02_55b 739 374 0.51 522.4 {0.00} 1.8861 0.93 0.192754 0.34 2742.3 20.9 2765.8 5.6 99.1
NMC02_09b 5761 1679 0.29 3947.7 0.01 1.8398 1.25 0.189930 0.17 2798.2 28.3 2741.6 2.8 102.1
NMC02_43a* 1163 182 0.16 761.2 {0.00} 1.8902 0.66 0.188819 0.51 2737.4 14.8 2731.9 8.5 100.2
NMC02_03a* 1352 65 0.05 878.1 0.02 1.8501 0.73 0.188692 0.27 2785.5 16.5 2730.8 4.4 102.0
NMC02_56b* 1017 275 0.27 678.7 0.01 1.8888 0.82 0.188328 0.77 2739.0 18.3 2727.6 12.7 100.4
NMC02_39a* 4885 246 0.05 3232.9 0.02 1.8158 0.58 0.188309 0.11 2828.1 13.3 2727.4 1.8 103.7
NMC02_60a* 1439 81 0.06 904.6 0.01 1.9130 0.60 0.187832 0.57 2710.7 13.4 2723.3 9.4 99.5
NMC02_44a* 1873 1427 0.76 1432.8 0.02 1.8219 0.63 0.187324 0.30 2820.5 14.5 2718.8 4.9 103.7
NMC02_11a 958 81 0.08 603.9 0.00 1.9193 0.63 0.185990 0.49 2703.5 14.0 2707.0 8.0 99.9
NMC02_24a 6056 2184 0.36 7079.5 0.01 1.0904 3.41 0.185968 0.25 4195.5 106.1 2706.8 4.1 155.0
NMC02_23b 1956 621 0.32 1322.4 0.00 1.8825 0.76 0.184689 0.49 2746.5 17.1 2695.4 8.1 101.9
NMC02_15b 2610 726 0.28 1674.7 0.07 1.9686 0.62 0.182193 0.17 2648.0 13.4 2672.9 2.9 99.1
NMC02_53a 1476 529 0.36 935.6 0.04 2.0247 2.10 0.181173 0.84 2587.6 44.8 2663.6 13.9 97.1
NMC02_10b 1396 77 0.06 862.4 0.01 1.9363 0.58 0.180945 0.32 2684.1 12.8 2661.6 5.3 100.8
NMC02_20b 4588 943 0.21 2812.3 0.01 2.0137 0.67 0.179824 0.11 2599.2 14.2 2651.2 1.8 98.0
NMC02_20a 3339 618 0.19 2276.2 0.02 1.7992 0.96 0.179031 0.17 2849.3 22.2 2643.9 2.8 107.8
NMC02_15a 3057 920 0.30 2111.7 0.01 1.8236 0.82 0.178084 0.37 2818.4 18.7 2635.1 6.2 107.0
NMC02_45a 2884 2105 0.73 2160.8 0.22 2.0412 0.90 0.177431 0.37 2570.3 19.2 2629.0 6.2 97.8
NMC02_40a 1514 201 0.13 921.6 0.02 2.0293 0.64 0.176667 0.67 2582.7 13.6 2621.8 11.2 98.5
NMC02_44b 1991 174 0.09 1194.8 0.03 1.9916 0.67 0.172263 0.27 2622.8 14.5 2579.8 4.6 101.7
NMC02_41a 5668 438 0.08 3363.6 0.05 2.0085 0.88 0.169047 0.34 2604.7 19.0 2548.2 5.7 102.2
NMC02_21a 1016 97 0.10 589.6 0.01 2.0599 0.71 0.168724 0.66 2551.0 14.9 2545.0 11.1 100.2
NMC02_9b 1448 94 0.07 834.3 0.01 2.0595 0.63 0.167696 0.36 2551.4 13.2 2534.8 6.1 100.7
NMC02_50b 1404 74 0.05 796.6 {0.00} 2.0819 0.71 0.166749 0.41 2528.7 14.9 2525.3 7.0 100.1
NMC02_46b 2715 132 0.05 1719.1 0.01 1.8871 0.74 0.165769 0.14 2741.1 16.6 2515.4 2.4 109.0
NMC02_27b 1455 152 0.10 820.3 0.00 2.1164 0.57 0.164284 0.20 2494.5 11.9 2500.2 3.3 99.8
NMC02_21b 1934 288 0.15 1156.0 0.00 2.0168 0.60 0.164131 0.37 2595.9 12.8 2498.7 6.3 103.9
NMC02_52a 2307 114 0.05 1304.5 {0.00} 2.0825 0.66 0.164023 0.16 2528.1 13.7 2497.6 2.7 101.2
NMC02_43c 2550 113 0.04 1447.8 {0.00} 2.0708 0.66 0.163674 0.27 2539.9 13.9 2494.0 4.6 101.8
NMC02_50a 1487 76 0.05 829.4 {0.00} 2.1104 0.66 0.163087 0.24 2500.4 13.8 2487.9 4.0 100.5
NMC02_07a 2192 72 0.03 1236.2 0.01 2.0785 0.59 0.163003 0.08 2532.2 12.4 2487.0 1.4 101.8
NMC02_16a 1508 183 0.12 860.1 0.00 2.0968 0.58 0.162709 0.10 2513.8 12.0 2484.0 1.7 101.2
NMC02_06a* 2109 130 0.06 1176.6 0.00 2.1146 0.57 0.162644 0.10 2496.3 11.9 2483.3 1.7 100.5
NMC02_54b* 2824 131 0.05 1655.0 {0.00} 2.0050 0.58 0.162462 0.24 2608.4 12.5 2481.4 4.1 105.1
NMC02_51a* 3902 605 0.16 2428.1 0.04 2.0386 0.85 0.162407 0.14 2573.0 18.2 2480.9 2.4 103.7
NMC02_35a* 2167 364 0.17 1233.1 0.00 2.1245 0.57 0.162308 0.13 2486.6 11.9 2479.8 2.2 100.3
NMC02_32b* 2097 113 0.05 1179.4 0.00 2.0924 0.61 0.162251 0.17 2518.2 12.7 2479.2 2.8 101.6
NMC02_19a* 2971 157 0.05 1674.4 0.00 2.0883 0.57 0.162202 0.08 2522.3 12.0 2478.7 1.3 101.8
NMC02_58a* 2222 128 0.06 1277.8 0.05 2.0511 0.66 0.162187 0.29 2560.1 13.9 2478.6 4.9 103.3
NMC02_36b* 2441 127 0.05 1345.5 0.00 2.1350 0.59 0.162120 0.09 2476.5 12.1 2477.9 1.6 99.9
NMC02_56c 1500 185 0.12 859.9 0.01 2.0855 0.61 0.161840 0.23 2525.0 12.7 2475.0 3.9 102.0
NMC02_26a 1893 54 0.03 1017.9 0.10 2.1762 1.13 0.161215 0.16 2437.4 23.0 2468.4 2.8 98.7
NMC02_59a 266 141 0.53 161.2 0.04 2.1545 1.10 0.160865 0.48 2457.9 22.6 2464.8 8.1 99.7
NMC02_46c 2422 113 0.05 1325.0 0.03 2.1404 0.69 0.157569 0.16 2471.2 14.3 2429.7 2.8 101.7

aValues corrected for common Pb.

bPercentage 206Pb which is non-radiogenic, calculated assuming present-day Stacey and Kramers (1975) common Pb. Figures in parentheses are given when no correction has been applied as 204Pb counts are statistically insignificant.

cConc. (%): concordance = 100 + 100 * [(206Pb/238U)/(207Pb/206Pb) − 1], where ratios refers to age.

*Analyses used for weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age.

Table 3. U-Th-Pb data for sample NMC03 (77283989) from Grimsley Peaks
Analysis           Ratiosa Agesa  
(Grain.spot) U
(ppm)
Th
(ppm)
Th/U Pb
(ppm)
206Pbc
(%)b
238U/206Pb ±σ
(%)
207Pb/206Pb ±σ
(%)
206Pb/238U ±σ 207Pb/206Pb ±σ Conc.
(%)c
NMC03_01a 1249 7 0.01 854.6 0.06 1.7927 0.65 0.224755 0.24 2857.6 14.9 3015.1 3.9 94.8
NMC03_03a 913 164 0.18 595.4 0.07 1.9049 0.83 0.203962 0.37 2720.2 18.4 2858.2 6.1 95.2
NMC03_03b 1553 155 0.10 1015.5 0.01 1.8699 1.21 0.195237 0.71 2761.6 27.3 2786.8 11.6 99.1
NMC03_05b 566 80 0.14 315.7 0.00 2.1579 0.61 0.163390 0.22 2454.6 12.4 2491.0 3.7 98.5
NMC03_06a 182 97 0.54 161.8 {0.01} 1.5647 0.72 0.250889 0.64 3185.5 18.2 3190.4 10.2 99.8
NMC03_06b* 215 131 0.61 195.8 {0.00} 1.5611 0.71 0.257707 0.62 3191.3 18.0 3232.7 9.8 98.7
NMC03_07a 2574 117 0.05 1067.3 0.09 2.8221 1.78 0.157317 0.93 1955.3 30.1 2427.0 15.8 80.6
NMC03_07b 2656 295 0.11 903.3 0.25 3.4183 0.69 0.132081 0.26 1654.2 10.1 2125.8 4.6 77.8
NMC03_08a* 314 206 0.66 275.5 0.02 1.6330 0.78 0.253571 0.27 3079.5 19.1 3207.2 4.3 96.0
NMC03_09a 723 104 0.14 402.0 0.03 2.1582 0.64 0.160752 0.16 2454.3 13.1 2463.6 2.6 99.6
NMC03_09b 2965 230 0.08 1131.2 0.37 3.0282 0.66 0.134226 0.32 1839.5 10.5 2154.0 5.5 85.4
NMC03_10a 257 123 0.48 208.8 {0.01} 1.6790 0.70 0.240323 0.64 3012.0 16.8 3122.1 10.2 96.5
NMC03_11b* 201 36 0.18 115.0 0.02 2.1165 0.63 0.162208 0.27 2494.4 13.0 2478.8 4.6 100.6
NMC03_12a* 458 109 0.24 391.7 0.00 1.5385 0.76 0.254358 0.65 3228.1 19.3 3212.1 10.2 100.5
NMC03_13a 1093 235 0.21 625.1 0.00 2.1352 0.62 0.161794 0.12 2476.3 12.7 2474.5 2.1 100.1
NMC03_16a 2403 27 0.01 1155.7 0.05 2.4400 1.37 0.170002 0.66 2214.2 25.8 2557.7 11.0 86.6
NMC03_17a* 486 125 0.26 279.5 0.00 2.1439 0.60 0.162675 0.17 2467.9 12.4 2483.7 2.9 99.4
NMC03_17b 91 17 0.18 51.0 {0.00} 2.1551 0.68 0.164383 0.40 2457.3 14.0 2501.2 6.7 98.2
NMC03_18a* 294 134 0.45 261.1 0.00 1.5471 0.67 0.254491 0.32 3214.0 17.1 3212.9 5.1 100.0
NMC03_18b* 329 154 0.47 290.2 {0.00} 1.5642 0.70 0.255031 0.82 3186.2 17.7 3216.3 12.9 99.1
NMC03_18c 1904 380 0.20 867.4 0.66 2.6260 0.69 0.142472 0.32 2080.0 12.3 2257.5 5.6 92.1
NMC03_19a 1492 85 0.06 794.5 0.02 2.2403 0.78 0.180782 0.24 2379.1 15.6 2660.1 3.9 89.4
NMC03_20b 637 550 0.86 553.3 0.09 1.6816 0.73 0.232786 0.34 3008.4 17.5 3071.3 5.4 98.0
NMC03_21a 1703 28 0.02 1079.9 0.01 1.8918 0.65 0.195074 0.25 2735.5 14.4 2785.4 4.2 98.2
NMC03_22a 1070 108 0.10 736.9 0.05 1.8058 1.54 0.221481 1.31 2840.9 35.4 2991.5 21.1 95.0
NMC03_24a 1141 14 0.01 764.5 0.01 1.8025 0.61 0.204499 0.29 2845.0 14.1 2862.4 4.8 99.4
NMC03_25a 4581 574 0.13 905.7 0.09 5.6604 1.05 0.083075 0.67 1048.7 10.1 1271.0 13.0 82.5
NMC03_26a 1215 219 0.18 674.3 0.01 2.1827 0.61 0.161430 0.11 2431.3 12.3 2470.7 1.9 98.4
NMC03_27a 143 87 0.61 123.1 {0.01} 1.6370 0.89 0.245864 0.91 3073.5 21.7 3158.3 14.4 97.3
NMC03_28a* 635 462 0.73 580.8 0.02 1.5811 0.75 0.253359 0.39 3159.3 18.7 3205.9 6.1 98.5
NMC03_30a* 340 206 0.61 314.8 0.07 1.5283 0.78 0.257837 0.76 3245.1 19.9 3233.5 12.0 100.4
NMC03_31a 99 34 0.34 66.8 {0.02} 1.9244 0.98 0.201275 1.06 2697.6 21.6 2836.6 17.4 95.1
NMC03_33a* 690 195 0.28 394.6 0.01 2.1710 0.60 0.162478 0.15 2442.3 12.3 2481.6 2.5 98.4
NMC03_34a 1131 60 0.05 663.7 0.03 2.0484 1.49 0.188391 0.47 2562.8 31.6 2728.2 7.8 93.9
NMC03_35a 1576 21 0.01 1054.9 0.01 1.8034 0.97 0.203991 0.30 2843.9 22.3 2858.4 4.8 99.5
NMC03_35b 1304 18 0.01 856.4 0.02 1.8344 0.91 0.201148 0.47 2805.0 20.8 2835.5 7.6 98.9
NMC03_37a 1398 33 0.02 814.2 0.05 2.0650 0.65 0.196307 0.32 2545.8 13.6 2795.7 5.2 91.1
NMC03_38a 3568 234 0.07 1040.0 0.75 3.8863 0.85 0.110699 0.48 1476.1 11.2 1810.9 8.8 81.5
NMC03_39a 1528 32 0.02 949.7 0.08 1.9619 0.81 0.216827 0.66 2655.4 17.6 2957.3 10.7 89.8
NMC03_40a 252 294 1.16 242.5 {0.01} 1.6202 0.92 0.246709 0.44 3098.8 22.8 3163.8 7.0 97.9
NMC03_41a 1616 501 0.31 1061.3 0.08 1.9490 0.80 0.205460 1.02 2669.8 17.4 2870.1 16.6 93.0
NMC03_41b 2281 60 0.03 1152.0 0.01 2.3390 0.75 0.171322 0.48 2294.6 14.5 2570.6 8.0 89.3
NMC03_42a 893 17 0.02 563.6 0.01 1.8912 0.82 0.189606 0.56 2736.2 18.2 2738.7 9.2 99.9
NMC03_43b 1512 28 0.02 937.0 0.06 1.9334 0.67 0.194580 0.55 2687.4 14.8 2781.3 9.0 96.6
NMC03_44a* 832 878 1.06 824.0 {0.00} 1.5532 0.72 0.253680 0.25 3204.1 18.2 3207.9 3.9 99.9
NMC03_45a 1505 69 0.05 769.1 0.03 2.3165 0.82 0.171043 0.52 2313.3 15.9 2567.9 8.7 90.1
NMC03_46a 684 990 1.45 686.9 0.02 1.6251 0.74 0.244367 0.23 3091.3 18.2 3148.6 3.6 98.2
NMC03_48a 351 161 0.46 273.2 {0.01} 1.7328 1.30 0.225908 0.61 2936.9 30.6 3023.3 9.7 97.1
NMC03_48b 1000 87 0.09 616.8 0.11 1.9551 1.86 0.185067 0.25 2663.0 40.6 2698.8 4.2 98.7
NMC03_49a 2497 455 0.18 1217.8 0.01 2.5380 0.97 0.193673 0.47 2141.4 17.7 2773.6 7.8 77.2
NMC03_50a 904 144 0.16 743.8 0.00 1.5682 1.02 0.249614 0.41 3179.9 25.6 3182.3 6.5 99.9
NMC03_51a 1378 57 0.04 780.1 0.08 2.0907 0.61 0.172682 0.33 2519.9 12.7 2583.8 5.4 97.5
NMC03_51b* 551 138 0.25 317.7 0.02 2.1301 0.72 0.162256 0.42 2481.2 14.9 2479.3 7.0 100.1
NMC03_53a 1761 678 0.38 1144.2 0.16 2.0465 0.85 0.221550 0.29 2564.8 18.0 2992.0 4.6 85.7
NMC03_53b* 1888 396 0.21 1099.5 0.01 2.0924 1.17 0.161462 0.58 2518.2 24.4 2471.0 9.8 101.9
NMC03_54a 161 67 0.42 131.6 0.05 1.6424 1.19 0.241205 0.46 3065.5 29.0 3127.9 7.3 98.0
NMC03_55a 197 132 0.67 169.9 {0.02} 1.6388 1.01 0.236567 0.51 3070.8 24.7 3097.0 8.1 99.2
NMC03_55b 1300 59 0.05 845.3 0.01 1.8517 0.79 0.192079 0.20 2783.6 17.9 2760.0 3.3 100.9
NMC03_56a 1398 101 0.07 925.6 {0.00} 1.8297 0.77 0.193487 0.19 2810.8 17.6 2772.0 3.1 101.4

aValues corrected for common Pb.

bPercentage 206Pb which is non-radiogenic, calculated assuming present-day Stacey and Kramers (1975) common Pb. Figures in parentheses are given when no correction has been applied as 204Pb counts are statistically insignificant.

cConc. (%): concordance = 100 + 100 * [(206Pb/238U)/(207Pb/206Pb) − 1], where ratios refers to age.

*Analyses used for weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age.

Table 4. U-Th-Pb data for sample NNW01 (77284068) from Mount Marr
Analysis           Ratiosa Agesa  
(Grain.spot) U
(ppm)
Th
(ppm)
Th/U Pb 206Pbc
(%)b
238U/206Pb ±σ
(%)
207Pb/206Pb ±σ
(%)
206Pb/238U ±σ 207Pb/206Pb ±σ Conc.
(%)c
NNW01_01a 1740 1368 0.79 1145.7 0.01 2.0978 0.64 0.16544 0.10 2512.6 13.3 2511.5 1.7 100.0
NNW01_02a 1254 216 0.17 899.7 0.01 1.6987 1.04 0.18000 0.31 2984.0 24.8 2652.5 5.2 112.5
NNW01_02b 506 195 0.39 355.9 0.01 1.8300 0.76 0.18954 0.62 2810.3 17.3 2737.8 10.2 102.6
NNW01_03a 674 901 1.34 497.7 0.01 2.0698 0.94 0.16651 0.15 2540.8 19.7 2522.4 2.5 100.7
NNW01_04a 243 212 0.87 169.6 0.02 2.0137 0.66 0.17844 0.80 2598.8 14.0 2637.3 13.3 98.5
NNW01_04b 324 201 0.62 260.1 {0.00} 1.7275 0.76 0.21800 0.99 2944.2 18.0 2966.0 15.9 99.3
NNW01_05a 269 145 0.54 167.1 {0.01} 2.1168 0.60 0.16564 0.30 2494.1 12.4 2514.1 5.0 99.2
NNW01_06a* 673 464 0.69 421.1 0.01 2.1587 0.58 0.16203 0.15 2453.7 11.9 2476.5 2.5 99.1
NNW01_07b* 939 358 0.38 549.1 0.00 2.1652 0.57 0.16168 0.13 2447.7 11.6 2473.2 2.2 99.0
NNW01_08a* 644 472 0.73 406.7 0.01 2.1597 0.58 0.16305 0.41 2452.7 11.8 2486.9 6.9 98.6
NNW01_09b 169 197 1.16 116.8 {0.01} 2.1391 0.60 0.16002 0.30 2472.5 12.4 2455.8 5.1 100.7
NNW01_10a 198 137 0.69 125.7 0.01 2.1385 0.64 0.16832 0.40 2472.8 13.2 2540.2 6.7 97.3
NNW01_11a 153 136 0.89 106.0 {0.01} 2.0380 0.63 0.17279 0.74 2573.6 13.4 2584.9 12.3 99.6
NNW01_12a 2617 599 0.23 1611.2 0.00 1.9949 1.42 0.16660 0.45 2619.2 30.6 2523.7 7.6 103.8
NNW01_13a 435 441 1.01 294.1 0.01 2.1316 0.64 0.16338 0.22 2479.5 13.2 2490.2 3.7 99.6
NNW01_14a 71 25 0.35 47.5 {0.01} 1.9168 0.72 0.18703 0.52 2706.4 16.0 2716.2 8.5 99.6
NNW01_15a 360 385 1.07 271.1 0.01 1.9552 0.63 0.18335 0.20 2662.5 13.8 2682.7 3.3 99.2
NNW01_17a* 169 191 1.13 114.0 {0.01} 2.1881 0.74 0.16219 0.30 2426.4 14.9 2478.6 5.1 97.9
NNW01_17b* 561 380 0.68 347.5 0.01 2.1838 0.59 0.16238 0.22 2430.3 12.0 2480.3 3.6 98.0
NNW01_18a 484 201 0.42 298.7 0.02 2.0675 0.64 0.16875 0.55 2542.9 13.4 2544.2 9.2 100.0
NNW01_19a* 627 357 0.57 384.2 0.01 2.1523 0.58 0.16241 0.22 2459.9 12.0 2480.5 3.7 99.2
NNW01_19b* 193 78 0.40 110.5 {0.01} 2.2292 0.81 0.16268 0.30 2389.0 16.1 2483.7 5.1 96.2
NNW01_21a 571 328 0.57 706.1 0.00 1.2323 0.67 0.37744 0.16 3830.0 19.4 3821.5 2.4 100.2
NNW01_21b 602 322 0.53 721.7 0.00 1.2632 0.58 0.37692 0.12 3759.0 16.5 3819.4 1.7 98.4
NNW01_23a 653 539 0.82 423.3 0.01 2.1517 0.58 0.16482 0.20 2460.3 11.8 2505.4 3.4 98.2
NNW01_24a 411 304 0.74 260.4 0.01 2.1614 0.64 0.16351 0.30 2451.2 13.1 2491.8 5.0 98.4
NNW01_25a 410 327 0.80 284.7 0.01 2.0217 0.67 0.18423 0.18 2590.5 14.4 2690.8 2.9 96.3
NNW01_27a 366 143 0.39 220.9 0.02 2.1178 0.90 0.17108 0.58 2492.7 18.6 2566.8 9.8 97.1
NNW01_28a* 583 75 0.13 320.0 {0.00} 2.1843 0.59 0.16229 0.19 2429.9 11.9 2479.7 3.2 98.0
NNW01_28b 120 53 0.44 72.8 {0.02} 2.1290 0.77 0.17194 0.62 2482.2 15.8 2576.6 10.3 96.3
NNW01_30a* 808 389 0.48 477.7 0.00 2.1854 0.58 0.16168 0.14 2428.8 11.8 2473.0 2.3 98.2
NNW01_31a* 143 84 0.59 86.8 0.01 2.1741 0.64 0.16137 0.33 2439.1 13.0 2469.0 5.6 98.8
NNW01_34a 551 429 0.78 391.9 0.00 1.9534 0.60 0.18195 0.44 2664.8 13.0 2670.4 7.2 99.8
NNW01_35a 256 277 1.08 178.0 0.03 2.1029 0.88 0.16808 0.29 2507.3 18.4 2536.9 5.0 98.8
NNW01_36* 766 485 0.63 469.2 0.01 2.1811 0.57 0.16143 0.14 2432.7 11.6 2470.2 2.4 98.5
NNW01_37a 466 198 0.43 317.8 0.01 1.9123 0.80 0.18939 0.76 2711.4 17.6 2736.4 12.5 99.1
NNW01_37b* 201 196 0.98 130.4 {0.01} 2.2156 0.60 0.16137 0.33 2401.2 12.1 2470.0 5.6 97.2
NNW01_38a 3778 960 0.25 2509.7 0.00 1.8828 0.68 0.18203 0.51 2746.1 15.2 2671.2 8.4 102.8
NNW01_38b 1841 456 0.25 1156.8 0.01 1.9820 0.86 0.17698 0.46 2632.9 18.6 2623.9 7.6 100.3
NNW01_40b 1000 101 0.10 615.8 {0.01} 1.9658 0.86 0.18318 0.79 2650.9 18.8 2681.9 13.1 98.8
NNW01_41a 3055 98 0.03 1727.5 {0.00} 2.0731 0.64 0.16364 0.14 2537.6 13.5 2493.7 2.3 101.8
NNW01_42a 167 234 1.40 124.0 {0.02} 2.0808 1.04 0.16496 0.82 2529.5 21.7 2507.2 13.8 100.9

aValues corrected for common Pb.

bPercentage 206Pb which is non-radiogenic, calculated assuming present-day Stacey and Kramers (1975) common Pb. Figures in parentheses are given when no correction has been applied as 204Pb counts are statistically insignificant.

cConc. (%): concordance = 100 + 100 * [(206Pb/238U)/(207Pb/206Pb) − 1], where ratios refers to age.

*Analyses used for weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age.

Table 5. U-Th-Pb data for sample NNW02 (77284064) from Grimsley Peaks
Analysis           Ratiosa Agesa  
(Grain.spot) U
(ppm)
Th
(ppm)
Th/U Pb 206Pbc
(%)b
238U/206Pb ±σ
(%)
207Pb/206Pb ±σ
(%)
206Pb/238U ±σ 207Pb/206Pb ±σ Conc.
(%)c
NNW02_02a 1765 197 0.11 1002 - 2.1021 0.63 0.162694 0.12 2508.5 13.2 2483.8 2.1 101.0
NNW02_02b 2526 264 0.10 1428 - 2.1075 0.61 0.163000 0.08 2503.2 12.6 2487.0 1.4 100.7
NNW02_03a 1752 226 0.13 975 {0.00} 2.1520 0.71 0.161609 0.12 2460.2 14.5 2472.6 2.0 99.5
NNW02_03b 1948 320 0.16 1072 - 2.1982 0.60 0.162101 0.09 2417.1 12.2 2477.7 1.5 97.6
NNW02_04a* 286 59 0.21 163 {0.01} 2.1442 0.61 0.163105 0.23 2467.7 12.5 2488.1 3.9 99.2
NNW02_05a 1637 158 0.10 929 - 2.1030 0.66 0.165961 0.18 2507.6 13.7 2517.3 3.1 99.6
NNW02_06a 1554 607 0.39 1042 {0.01} 1.9278 1.14 0.183139 0.84 2693.8 25.1 2681.5 13.9 100.5
NNW02_07a 1529 320 0.21 879 - 2.1223 0.63 0.162095 0.10 2488.8 13.0 2477.6 1.7 100.5
NNW02_08a 2177 192 0.09 1233 - 2.0950 0.63 0.161868 0.10 2515.6 13.2 2475.3 1.7 101.6
NNW02_09a 1536 193 0.13 870 - 2.1130 0.60 0.162072 0.12 2497.8 12.4 2477.4 2.0 100.8
NNW02_11a 1945 436 0.22 1116 - 2.1327 0.60 0.161451 0.10 2478.7 12.3 2470.9 1.7 100.3
NNW02_12a 1256 251 0.20 717 {0.00} 2.1315 0.62 0.161733 0.13 2479.8 12.8 2473.9 2.1 100.2
NNW02_13b 1582 307 0.19 900 - 2.1376 0.60 0.162065 0.11 2473.9 12.3 2477.3 1.9 99.9
NNW02_14a* 1449 246 0.17 824 - 2.1280 0.60 0.163041 0.16 2483.2 12.4 2487.4 2.6 99.8
NNW02_16a 1221 78 0.06 702 - 2.0621 0.68 0.168591 0.51 2548.8 14.3 2543.7 8.6 100.2
NNW02_16b 1635 347 0.21 935 - 2.1336 0.60 0.162450 0.12 2477.9 12.4 2481.3 2.0 99.9
NNW02_17a* 125 19 0.15 70 {0.01} 2.1513 0.62 0.164160 0.34 2460.9 12.8 2499.0 5.8 98.5
NNW02_18a 1127 192 0.17 635 - 2.1427 0.60 0.161370 0.12 2469.1 12.4 2470.1 1.9 100.0
NNW02_19a 1282 280 0.22 731 - 2.1453 0.61 0.161429 0.11 2466.6 12.5 2470.7 1.8 99.8
NNW02_20a 1776 238 0.13 1000 - 2.1301 0.61 0.162221 0.12 2481.2 12.6 2478.9 2.0 100.1
NNW02_21a 374 75 0.20 211 0.01 2.1567 0.61 0.161383 0.22 2455.8 12.4 2470.2 3.7 99.4
NNW02_22a 1185 267 0.23 680 - 2.1341 0.60 0.161524 0.11 2477.3 12.4 2471.7 1.9 100.2
NNW02_23a 983 37 0.04 554 {0.00} 2.0871 0.62 0.166855 0.29 2523.5 12.9 2526.3 4.9 99.9
NNW02_23b 1438 99 0.07 809 - 2.1012 0.61 0.163204 0.19 2509.4 12.7 2489.1 3.2 100.8
NNW02_24a 1247 136 0.11 693 - 2.1469 0.60 0.162045 0.11 2465.1 12.4 2477.1 1.8 99.5
NNW02_26a 1709 408 0.24 984 {0.00} 2.1315 0.60 0.161864 0.09 2479.8 12.3 2475.2 1.6 100.2
NNW02_27a 595 154 0.26 335 - 2.1926 0.67 0.162000 0.16 2422.2 13.5 2476.6 2.7 97.8
NNW02_28a 1255 241 0.19 713 - 2.1385 0.61 0.162662 0.14 2473.1 12.5 2483.5 2.4 99.6
NNW02_29a 1805 259 0.14 1024 - 2.1151 0.70 0.160648 0.20 2495.8 14.4 2462.5 3.3 101.4
NNW02_30a 1416 147 0.10 789 - 2.1378 0.60 0.162441 0.10 2473.8 12.4 2481.2 1.7 99.7
NNW02_31a* 404 108 0.27 233 0.01 2.1419 0.60 0.163180 0.19 2469.9 12.4 2488.9 3.2 99.2
NNW02_32a* 347 79 0.23 195 0.02 2.1819 0.60 0.162575 0.25 2432.1 12.2 2482.6 4.1 98.0
NNW02_33a 1188 242 0.20 673 - 2.1508 0.61 0.161061 0.11 2461.3 12.6 2466.8 1.9 99.8
NNW02_33b 1454 178 0.12 804 - 2.1626 0.62 0.160841 0.11 2450.2 12.6 2464.5 1.8 99.4
NNW02_34a* 276 61 0.22 155 0.01 2.1737 0.62 0.162668 0.23 2439.7 12.6 2483.6 3.9 98.2
NNW02_35a 1511 284 0.19 858 - 2.1388 0.61 0.161472 0.10 2472.8 12.5 2471.1 1.7 100.1
NNW02_35b 1619 250 0.15 903 - 2.1612 0.60 0.162345 0.11 2451.5 12.3 2480.2 1.8 98.8
NNW02_36a 1886 82 0.04 1078 {0.00} 2.0702 0.64 0.171415 0.47 2540.5 13.4 2571.5 7.8 98.8
NNW02_37a 2155 326 0.15 1207 - 2.1491 0.60 0.162323 0.09 2462.9 12.4 2480.0 1.5 99.3
NNW02_37b 1484 301 0.20 844 - 2.1446 0.61 0.162437 0.16 2467.3 12.5 2481.2 2.7 99.4
NNW02_38a 1571 128 0.08 873 - 2.1311 0.61 0.161561 0.10 2480.2 12.5 2472.1 1.6 100.3
NNW02_38b 844 248 0.29 525 0.03 2.0169 1.04 0.174205 0.38 2595.8 22.2 2598.5 6.4 99.9
NNW02_40a 2541 296 0.12 1419 - 2.1390 0.60 0.162292 0.08 2472.7 12.3 2479.7 1.3 99.7
NNW02_41b 1283 45 0.04 730 0.01 2.0781 0.90 0.173025 0.61 2532.5 18.8 2587.1 10.2 97.9
NNW02_42a 840 177 0.21 523 0.01 2.0001 0.76 0.183027 1.12 2613.7 16.4 2680.5 18.5 97.5
NNW02_42b 1550 294 0.19 879 {0.00} 2.1440 0.59 0.161748 0.20 2467.9 12.1 2474.0 3.4 99.8
NNW02_43a 2011 159 0.08 1119 - 2.1259 0.68 0.162379 0.19 2485.3 14.1 2480.6 3.2 100.2
NNW02_44a 1592 619 0.39 1223 {0.00} 1.7290 0.70 0.214354 0.49 2942.1 16.4 2938.8 7.8 100.1
NNW02_44b 1501 167 0.11 846 {0.00} 2.1172 0.90 0.162549 0.20 2493.7 18.7 2482.3 3.4 100.5
NNW02_45a 1581 173 0.11 888 {0.00} 2.1229 0.66 0.161392 0.20 2488.2 13.6 2470.3 3.3 100.7
NNW02_46a 2459 544 0.22 1680 0.01 1.8400 0.79 0.198499 0.48 2798.0 18.1 2813.9 7.9 99.4
NNW02_46b 1958 147 0.08 1097 {0.00} 2.1144 0.66 0.163074 0.17 2496.5 13.7 2487.8 2.9 100.3
NNW02_47a 1041 247 0.24 751 0.03 1.7670 0.97 0.220021 0.49 2891.1 22.7 2980.8 7.9 97.0
NNW02_48a 3401 1384 0.41 2264 - 1.9364 0.68 0.176535 0.25 2684.0 14.8 2620.6 4.2 102.4
NNW02_49a 2024 391 0.19 1202 {0.00} 2.0558 0.66 0.166675 0.32 2555.2 14.0 2524.5 5.4 101.2
NNW02_49b 1627 208 0.13 929 {0.00} 2.1028 0.75 0.163164 0.26 2507.9 15.6 2488.7 4.5 100.8
NNW02_50a 2615 848 0.32 1752 - 1.9159 0.81 0.193717 0.35 2707.4 17.9 2774.0 5.8 97.6
NNW02_51b 928 192 0.21 644 0.01 1.8303 0.95 0.210242 0.51 2810.0 21.8 2907.4 8.3 96.6
NNW02_51c 2589 228 0.09 1466 {0.00} 2.0954 0.58 0.161607 0.17 2515.2 12.0 2472.5 2.9 101.7
NNW02_52a* 272 59 0.22 153 {0.02} 2.1785 0.78 0.163204 0.47 2435.3 15.8 2489.1 7.9 97.8
NNW02_53a 1262 198 0.16 714 {0.00} 2.1297 0.60 0.162025 0.31 2481.6 12.4 2476.9 5.1 100.2
NNW02_54a 554 738 1.33 573 {0.00} 1.5541 0.82 0.248357 0.46 3202.6 20.8 3174.3 7.3 100.9
NNW02_54b 1362 277 0.20 781 {0.01} 2.1236 0.68 0.161813 0.21 2487.5 14.1 2474.7 3.6 100.5
NNW02_55a 3254 283 0.09 1846 {0.00} 2.0908 0.62 0.162156 0.15 2519.8 12.9 2478.3 2.6 101.7
NNW02_55b 1519 147 0.10 851 0.01 2.1191 0.64 0.160428 0.20 2491.9 13.3 2460.2 3.4 101.3
NNW02_56a 3924 4724 1.20 2892 - 2.0434 1.76 0.172878 0.20 2568.0 37.3 2585.7 3.4 99.3
NNW02_58a 1003 89 0.09 559 {0.01} 2.1265 0.75 0.162394 0.31 2484.7 15.5 2480.7 5.3 100.2
NNW02_59a 1819 239 0.13 1065 0.01 2.0579 0.63 0.168633 0.34 2553.1 13.3 2544.1 5.8 100.4
NNW02_60a 1714 259 0.15 966 - 2.1338 0.63 0.162893 0.20 2477.6 13.0 2485.9 3.4 99.7

aValues corrected for common Pb.

bPercentage 206Pb which is non-radiogenic, calculated assuming present-day Stacey and Kramers (1975) common Pb. Figures in parentheses are given when no correction has been applied as 204Pb counts are statistically insignificant.

cConc. (%): concordance = 100 + 100 * [(206Pb/238U)/(207Pb/206Pb) − 1], where ratios refers to age.

*Analyses used for weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age.

Figure 5. Tera-Wasserburg concordia diagrams of zircon U-Pb analyses of orthogneisses from the Napier Mountains. Error ellipses are 1 sigma. Ages along the concordia are in Ma. Colored ellipses represent data used for age calculation. (a) NMC02. (b) NMC03. (c) NNW01. (d) NNW02. Inset in (c) is an extension of concordia, whereas the inset in (d) is an enlargement of the part of the diagram marked with the dashed rectangle. Ellipses in this latter are color-coded according to U content shown in legend at the bottom of the inset.

Sample NMC02, granitic gneiss, Grimsley Peak. The zircon grains are mostly anhedral and equant, with some tabular grains (Fig. 4a) 50-270 µm in length, with aspect ratios ranging from 1:1 to 3:1. Zircon domains are characterized by moderate to weak CL response. Some grains have chaotic or patchy zonation, manifested as moderately luminescent patches and lobes in the weakly luminescent domains. Some grains have prismatic cores (e.g., grains 10 and 49) with oscillatory zonation, locally truncated by zones without visible zonation. There are also grains that are moderately luminescent and do not show any zonation. One grain is an elongate prism with broad banded zoning that is conformable with elongation of the prism faces (grain 57).

A total of 73 analyses were performed (Table 2 and Fig. 5a). Zircon ages range from 2836 to 2430 Ma. The data form three main groups: one from ∼ 2864 to 2780 Ma, another from 2740 to 2700 Ma and the youngest group with an age of 2500 Ma. Within these groups there are many normal and reversely discordant data. Moreover, there are some concordant data between 2700 and 2500 Ma. The zircon grains have high U and Th contents up to 6000 and 3000 ppm, respectively (Fig. 6a and 6b). Almost all the <2.6 Ga zircons have >1000 ppm of U and <600 ppm Th, in contrast to older zircon that has U contents as low as 90 ppm and Th up to 3000 ppm (Fig. 6b). The Th/U ratio varies from 0.03 to 1.57 (Fig. 6c). The zircon with ages <2.6 Ga has Th/U <0.2, whereas the ratio for older zircon is more variable. Forty-one data are discordant, 33 of which are reversely discordant. The most reversely discordant data come from zircon with U contents greater than 2500 ppm (Fig. 6d).

Figure 6. Plots of zircon geochemical properties for the samples from the Napier Mountains. Age refers to 207Pb/206Pb apparent zircon age. (a), (e), (i), and (l) U content in ppm versus Age in Ma. (b), (f), (j), and (n) Th content in ppm versus Age in Ma. (c), (g), (k), and (o) Th/U versus Age in Ma. (d), (h), (l), and (p) U content in ppm versus % discordance. Level of discordance is calculated as follows: 100 * [(206Pb/238U)/(207Pb/206Pb) − 1], where ratios refers to age. White symbols denote discordant data, which represent data with error ellipses not overlapping the concordia curve (a)-(d) NMC02, (e)-(h) NMC03, (i)-(l) NNW01, and (m)-(p) NNW02.

The six oldest statistically equivalent data, represented by prismatic cores (e.g., grains 14 and 49; Fig. 4a), provide the most reliable estimate for the time of protolith crystallization (Fig. 5a), recording a weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age of 2826 ± 6 Ma (MSWD = 1.4). The 6 data from more luminescent patches and lobes replacing weakly luminescent grains have a weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age of 2727 ± 3 Ma (MSWD = 0.87; Fig. 5a). The 8 data from moderately luminescent domains without visible zoning (e.g., grain 35, Fig. 4a), and commonly cutting other domains (grain 19, Fig. 4a), record a weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age of 2479 ± 2 Ma (MSWD = 0.97; Fig. 5a). This age is interpreted as zircon replacement/recrystallization during a metamorphic event.

Sample NMC03, tonalitic gneiss, Grimsley Peak. The zircon grains are mostly anhedral to subhedral with rounded terminations and elongate prisms (Fig. 4b). They are 50-180 µm in length, with aspect ratios ranging from 1:1 to 3:1, similar to the previous sample. Most grains have oscillatory zonation (grain 23; Fig. 4b), typical of growth in a fractionating magma (Corfu et al., 2003; Schaltegger and Davies, 2017). However, some have more highly luminescent cores that are rounded or truncated. There are also thin, highly luminescent seams in the concentrically zoned outer domains, indicative of recrystallization (Grant et al., 2009). Such structures suggest resorption of magmatic cores and domains. Irregular, patchy and convoluted zoning is also present in some grains. The outer domains of anhedral grains tend to be broad and without visible zonation (grain 13; Fig. 4b).

Fifty-nine U-Pb spot analyses were performed, with 33 analyses being discordant (Table 3 and Fig. 5b). Zircon dates range from 3234 to 1271 Ma. The uranium contents can exceed 5000 ppm (Fig. 6e). There is no correlation between U content and age for zircon with ages between 3.0 and 2.5 Ga, but for <2.5 Ga grains U content increases with a decrease in age. Thorium contents range between 7 and 990 ppm and there is no correlation with age (Fig. 6f). The Th/U ratio for >3.0 Ga zircon ranges between 0.15 and 1.45 (Fig. 6g). Most of the 3.00 to 2.49 Ga data have Th/U < 0.1, whereas for 2.90-2.80 Ga zircon the Th/U values are ∼ 0.2, The level of discordance rises with U content (Fig. 6h).

The eight oldest statistically equivalent data, represented by the prismatic cores with oscillatory zoning, provide the most reliable estimate for the time of protolith crystallization. These define a weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age of 3210 ± 4 Ma (MSWD = 1.8, n = 8; Fig. 5b). The 5 data from broad outer domains without visible zoning record a weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age of 2481 ± 3 Ma (MSWD = 0.53, Fig. 5b), defining recrystallization during metamorphism.

Sample NNW01, dioritic gneiss, Mount Marr. Zircon grains are anhedral to subhedral with aspect ratio ranging from 1:1 to 2:1 (Fig. 4c). Some grains have luminescent cores with oscillatory zoning, typical of magmatic growth. However, many cores have broad banding or sector zonation and may be prismatic or rounded. Some grains also show progressive zonation, exhibiting a sequence from weak, to high, to weak luminescence (grain 4; Fig. 4c). The two inner zones may cut the cores, whereas the outer rim cuts both cores and inner zones.

Forty-two U-Pb analyses were performed, of which 18 are discordant, including 5 reversely discordant data. The concordant ages range from ∼ 2966 to 2456 Ma (Fig. 5c), with one grain preserving a core with an Eoarchean age of ∼ 3820 Ma (grain 21; Fig. 4c). Ages of oscillatory-zoned domains spread along concordia from 2720 down to 2490 Ma, but it is not possible to determine whether these are cogenetic with variable Pb loss or represent discrete events. Domains without visible zonation, those with sector zoning, and the rims have ages younger than 2494 Ma. These record a weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age of 2475 ± 3 Ma (MSWD = 1.4, n = 12; Fig. 5c), interpreted to represent the (re)crystallization of zircon during a metamorphic event. The U contents vary from 71 to 3778 (Fig. 6i) and Th contents from 25 to 1368 ppm (Fig. 6j). However, most have values below 1000 ppm for both elements. The Th/U ratio is also variable, with values between 0.03 and 1.40 (Fig. 6k). There is no relationship between the age and Th and U contents or Th/U ratio. Most of the domains with U contents above 1000 ppm are reversely discordant (Fig. 6l).

Sample NNW02, tonalitic gneiss, Johnston Peak. Zircon grains are mostly subhedral, varying from elongate to more rounded in shape (Fig. 4d). They are 50-200 µm in length, with aspect ratios ranging from 1:1 to 4:1. Most grains are weakly luminescent and have chaotic or subtle concentric zoning in the form of broad bands. Rarely, weakly distinguishable, rounded cores are preserved (e.g., grains 4 and 42; Fig. 4d), which may be cut by weakly luminescent zones. Locally, some highly luminescent and irregular seams are present within the weakly luminescent domains, especially near the grain rims (Fig. 4d). Sector zoned, highly luminescent zircon is represented by more stubby to rounded grains, some of which have highly luminescent cores, mostly with chaotic zoning, although broad banded zonation is locally present.

A total of 69 analyses were performed (Table 5 and Fig. 5d). The ages range from 3174 to 2460 Ma, with 17 discordant data, 4 of which are reversely discordant. The contents of U and Th range from 79 to 3923 (Fig. 6m) and from 18 to 848 ppm (Fig. 6n), respectively, although there are two exceptions with 1383 and 4724 ppm of Th. The Th/U of >2600 Ma zircon is 0.1 to 0.6, but for the <2600 Ma grains it varies between 0 and 0.3 (Fig. 6o). There is no relationship between the content of actinides and the age. The level of discordance is low and is not greater than ±4.5% (Fig. 6p).

Highly luminescent rims, together with sector and chaotically zoned zircon, have ages between 2499 and 2482 Ma. Importantly, these are older than most of the weakly luminescent inner domains with chaotic zonation, which have ages between 2487 and 2462 Ma. Eight statistically equivalent data from the older population give a weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age of 2487 ± 6 Ma (MSWD = 1.5; n = 8; Fig. 5d), which is interpreted to represent the age of zircon (re)crystallization during a metamorphic event.

DISCUSSION

Reverse discordance and Th-U ratio systematics

Thorium and U contents, as well as Th/U ratio, reveal considerable variation among the zircon grains in this study (Fig. 6). This is true not only for zircon of different genesis, i.e., magmatic or metamorphic, but also within the same generation. This is best reflected in the sample from Mount Marr (NNW01, Fig. 6k). In the literature, Th/U ratio has been used to distinguish metamorphic from igneous zircon (Hoskin and Black, 2000; Rubatto, 2002), although such differences are not systematic, and high Th/U zircon has been recognized in many high-grade metamorphic rocks (e.g., Hokada et al., 2004; Kelly and Harley, 2005; Santosh et al., 2007; Król et al., 2020, 2022). This study adds to known examples from the Napier Complex (Hokada et al., 2004; Kelly and Harley, 2005; Guitreau et al., 2019; Król et al., 2020, 2022) and points to variable metamorphic Th/U being a common phenomenon within the complex. The differences in Th/U in metamorphic zircon can be attributed to the presence or absence of certain co-existing minerals or phases (including melt or fluid) that partition Th over U, especially monazite and allanite (Rubatto, 2017; Yakymchuk et al., 2018). This is particularly complex as the major element composition is variable, and hence the stability of such minerals.

Many U-Pb analyses in this study are discordant, including reversely discordant data (Fig. 6). As shown in Figure 6d, 6h, 6l, zircon domains with high U contents over 1500 ppm are commonly (reversely) discordant. This is in accord with the observation of Black et al. (1991) that the most U-rich zircon shows the greatest reverse discordance. This may be a result of either, the high-uranium matrix effect as described by White and Ireland (2012), or inhomogeneity of Pb at the micron scale (Kusiak et al., 2013a, 2013b). The matrix effect affects only Pb/U ages and results in a horizontal trend in Terra-Wasserburg diagrams, which may be the case for the ∼ 2720 and 2500 Ma reversely-discordant populations in sample NMC02 from Grimsley Peak (Fig. 5a). Kusiak et al. (2013a, 2013b) demonstrated inhomogeneity of Pb at the micron scale in zircon from the Napier Complex, confirming the presence of unsupported radiogenic Pb as a result of U and Th radioactive breakdown and production of nanoclusters and metallic Pb nanospheres (Kusiak et al., 2015; Whitehouse et al., 2017). This affects the U-Pb system at the micro- and nanoscale, causing 206Pb/238U ages to be spuriously older. This may be the case for the ∼ 2800 Ma grains in sample NMC02, where there is a correlated reverse discordance in which both the 206Pb/238U and 207Pb/206Pb ages get apparently older.

Post-magmatic modification of zircon

Metamorphic and recrystallized zircon observed in the Napier Complex samples display domains that are characterized by different structures seen in CL. The internal structures can be divided into those that existed prior to metamorphism and have been subsequently modified, and those that grew as a result of metamorphic processes. Examples of the modification of primary zircon are domains with high luminescent patches and lobes invading the weaker luminescent domains, commonly in elongate prisms, pointing to a primary magmatic origin for the zircon. This feature may be the result of high temperature annealing or coupled dissolution-reprecipitation due to fluid alteration (e.g., Vavra et al., 1999; Corfu et al., 2003; Harley and Kelly, 2007; Geisler et al., 2007; Taylor et al., 2014, 2016) after crystallization from a melt. These features are observed only in ∼ 2720 Ma zircon in Grimsley Peak sample NMC02. Given that this sample is granitic with a high silica content of ∼ 74%, it has more potential to contain and be affected by fluids than the tonalitic sample from the same locality (NMC03).

The 2480-2460 Ma zircon varies not only in internal structure but also in Th-U systematics (Figs. 4 and 6). In the gneiss from Johnston Peak (NNW02), primary zonation is rarely preserved, and appears to have been obliterated or altered through recrystallisation. Nonetheless, many zircon grains retain their original morphology and aspect ratio, and are ascribed to be of magmatic origin (see also Hoskin and Black, 2000; Corfu et al., 2003; Hoskin and Schaltegger, 2003). However, the U-Pb system in such domains is disrupted to varying degrees, resulting in a spread of the data along concordia from ∼ 2600 to ∼ 2460 Ma, so local preservation of original zoning is no guarantee of closed system behavior during high-grade metamorphism.

Several samples have zircon with sector zoning, which may be of igneous (Hanchar and Miller, 1993) or metamorphic origin (Watson and Liang, 1995). However, these grains have equant, rounded grain morphologies, similar to so-called ‘soccerball’ grains (Vavra et al., 1999), typical for many UHT terrains (Hokada and Harley, 2004; Harley and Kelly, 2007) and interpreted to be the result of growth from a partial melt (Kelly and Harley, 2005). Some grains are composed of multiple components with a distinct core, commonly with an igneous morphology. They may also feature a metamorphic overgrowth, which results in a more equant grain shape. Some grains display truncation of the internal structures by broad domains with no visible zonation. These grains are typical of metamorphic supra-solidus growth at high temperature (Schaltegger et al., 1999; Corfu et al., 2003), characteristic of granulitic-facies metamorphism.

Timing of geological events in the Napier Mountains

Significance of ∼ 3.2 and 2.8 Ga ages. The present study provides new ages for protolith crystallization at 3210 ± 4 and 2826 ± 6 Ma for a tonalitic and a granitic gneiss, respectively, from Grimsley Peaks. The older age is similar, but slightly younger, than an age of 3267 ± 5 Ma and older than an age of 3073 ± 12 Ma reported for felsic orthogneisses at Mt. Riiser-Larsen (Hokada et al., 2003), a locality ∼ 125 km to the WSW. It is also older than the 2988 ± 23 Ma age (Kelly and Harley, 2005) of protolith crystallization, ∼ 100 km to the N on Proclamation Island. Mesoarchean magmatic activity, however, seems to be restricted to the northern part of the Napier Complex and part of the Tula Mountains, based on available data. The much younger age of ∼ 2825 Ma for the granitic gneiss from Grimsley Peaks overlaps with the timing of high-grade metamorphism in the Mt. Riiser-Larsen area (Kelly and Harley, 2005; Clark et al., 2018), and at Proclamation Island and a part of the Tula Mountains (Harley and Black, 1997; Kelly and Harley, 2005; Kusiak et al., 2013a; Clark et al., 2018; Król et al., 2020) where ages from 2850 to 2790 Ma have been recorded. A younger minimum age of 2788 ± 24 Ma for granitic gneiss has also been obtained from Mt. King in the eastern Tula Mountains (Król et al., 2020). Circa 2800 Ma protoliths from Grimsley Peaks and Mount Marr both represent the generation of syn-metamorphic rocks. Both belong to geochemical Group 2, having elevated Nb-Ta-Y-HREE contents that are interpreted to represent protoliths generated at shallower depths than the rocks of Group 1, which have low values of Nb-Ta-Y-HREE. In both localities the magmatic rocks crystallized before the ∼ 2.8 Ga metamorphic event (Król et al., 2020).

Granitic gneiss sample NMC02 from Grimsley Peaks shows evidence of a metamorphic event around 2800 Ma based on the spread of data along concordia from ∼ 2825 to 2770 Ma. A concordant date from a rim surrounding an older core (grain 57, Fig. 4), and from more chaotic zones are also interpreted to be generated during metamorphism, providing a lower limit for this event at ∼ 2770 Ma. However, this is 20 Myr younger than the estimate of the last stage of this tectono-metamorphic event at around 2790 Ma from previous workers (Hokada et al., 2003). The tonalitic gneiss sample (NMC03) from Grimsley Peaks, also contains some zircon grains with concordant dates between 2800 and 2700 Ma. These may be a result of either the late vestiges of ∼ 2.8 Ga metamorphism, as in the granitic gneiss, or may represent ∼ 3210 Ma grains partially affected by ∼ 2500 Ma UHT metamorphism.

The granitic gneiss sample (NMC02) from Grimsley Peaks also contains zircon with evidence of recrystallization in the form of patches and lobes that have relatively low U and higher luminosity than the zircon it is replacing; features typical of fluid-induced recrystallization (Mathieu et al., 2001; Taylor et al., 2016). The U-Pb systematics of such domains may have completely reset the initial values, allowing accurate dating of fluid alteration and constraining fluid-rock interaction (Taylor et al., 2014). An estimate of the timing of that replacement has been calculated at 2727 ± 3 Ma, an age not previously reported for metamorphic activity, although similar to magmatism in the southeastern Napier Complex (Król et al., 2022). The cause of such fluid ingress remains speculative, but it may have been triggered by the expulsion of fluids due to crystallization of melts related to either magmatism or metamorphism at high (Harley, 2016) or ultra-high temperatures (Clark et al., 2018).

Chronology of ∼ 2.5 Ga magmatic and metamorphic events. It has been well established that (ultra-)high temperature metamorphism occurred in the Napier Complex between 2585 and 2420 Ma (Harley, 2016, Clark et al., 2018, Harley et al., 2019 and references therein; Król et al., 2020, 2022; Kusiak et al., 2021). This study provides new data regarding this event in the Napier Mountains. The dioritic gneiss sample (NNW01) from Mount Marr contains zircon with oscillatory-zoned domains that spread along concordia from 2720 Ma down to 2490 Ma, typical of growth in a fractionating magma. The domains without visible zonation, together with sector zoning and rims, can be ascribed to (re)crystallization during metamorphism, and have younger ages of ∼ 2490 Ma. As such, 2490 Ma may constitute a minimum age for crystallization of the dioritic protolith and the maximum age for zircon growth or recrystallization during metamorphism. This sample differs from the other rocks studied here, distinguished by its tholeiitic affinity and having much lower Al2O3 for a given SiO2 content. It cannot be unequivocally determined whether the dioritic gneiss represents a protolith crystallized at ∼ 2720 Ma, with younger data representing those domains disturbed during the ∼ 2500 Ma event, or if it crystallized at ∼ 2490 Ma with data extending from 2720 to 2490 Ma representing inherited zircon incorporated during magma transport and eruption and variously affected by subsequent metamorphism. Given that there is no cross-cutting relationship to the zoning in these ∼ 2720 Ma zircon grains, unequivocally implying a xenocrystic/inherited origin, the preferred scenario is that this rock represents crystallization of the dioritic protolith at ∼ 2720 Ma. The rock, however, incorporated Eo- and Mesoarchean zircon, and although only one grain recorded an Eoarchean age, it is likely evidence for the presence of Eoarchean crust in the area.

The two samples from Grimsley Peaks (NMC02 and NMC03) record ages of ∼ 2480 Ma for recrystallization of, or overgrowth on, older zircon grains. This is similar to ∼ 2475 Ma ages of new growth, including overgrowth on older zircon, for the dioritic gneiss for Mount Marr (NNW01). A slightly older age of ∼ 2486 Ma for new growth of metamorphic zircon is represented by sector-zoned grains in tonalitic gneiss sample NNW02 from Johnston Peak, followed by solid-state replacement of magmatic zircon at ∼ 2460 Ma. As outlined above, the samples studied here provide evidence for extensive zircon growth and solid-state replacement at ∼ 2490 Ma, preceded by earlier dioritic magmatism. Along with the lack of strong evidence for extensive metamorphic zircon growth before 2500 Ma, this contrasts with the metamorphic record from other localities in the Napier Complex, where metamorphic zircon growth occurred as early as ∼ 2520 Ma (Harley and Black, 1997; Król et al., 2020, 2022).

CONCLUSIONS

Zircon grains from the Napier Mountains with an igneous protolith record an array of different structures and morphologies related to a variety of processes, including mineral growth and modification during metamorphism and fluid-mediated alteration. These zircon grains display a range of U and Th contents and Th/U ratios, the latter atypical of what is traditionally perceived as ‘metamorphic’ values. The ∼ 2800 Ma metamorphic event is recorded in zircon from Grimsley Peaks with data extending down to 2770 Ma, which prolongs the duration of this event by ∼ 20 Myr when compared to the earlier date of 2790 Ma (Hokada et al., 2003). These zircon grains were also affected by ∼ 2730 Ma fluid-mediated alteration, creating patchy zonation in primary magmatic grains. All the samples in this study contain zircon that was intensely modified between 2490 and 2460 Ma, which contrasts with the lack of evidence for recrystallization and growth before 2500 Ma, as is common elsewhere in the Napier Complex. The recognition of Mesoarchean igneous activity in the Napier Mountains is established by protolith ages for tonalitic and granitic gneiss of ∼ 3210 and 2825 Ma, respectively. The generation of younger granites at this locality was synchronous with the ∼ 2.8 metamorphic event.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This research was funded by NCN grants UMO2019/34/H/ST10/00619 to MAK and received support from the SYNTHESYS+ Project which is financed by European Community Research Infrastructure Action under the H2020 Integrating Activities Programme, Project number 823827 to PK. The NordSIMS facility operates as a Swedish Research Council funded national infrastructure (grant # 2017-00671 at time of analysis); this is NordSIMS contribution 735. We thank Heejin Jeon and Kerstin Lindén for technical assistance. Chris Carson and Alix Post are thanked for help, discussion, and especially for access to legacy samples stored at Geoscience Australia and collected by the Bureau of Mineral Resources during Australian National Antarctic Research Expeditions. We thank M. Guitreau and M. Takehara for their constructive comments and T. Hokada for editorial handling of the manuscript.

REFERENCES
 
© 2023 Japan Association of Mineralogical Sciences
feedback
Top