Article ID: JPR_D_20_00036
Purpose: The aim of this study was to evaluate the stability of single crowns and 3-unit bridges in relation to the implant-abutment complex with and without tube in tube connection.
Methods: 60 specimens with a total of 90 implants (diameter 3.8 mm) were fabricated and distributed into 4 groups: CST (Crown with short tube), CLT (crown with long tube), BNT (Bridge without tube) and BLT (bridge with long tube). All superstructures consisted of one-piece hybrid abutment restorations out of monolithic zirconia, bonded on prefabricated titanium bases and were directly screwed into the implants. Specimen underwent artificial aging (2.000.000 cycles, 120 N, 30° off axis) and were subsequently loaded in an universal testing machine at an angle of 30° until failure. The specimens were examined for damage during and after artificial aging.
Results: During artificial aging, one test specimen of group CLT and two test specimens of group BNT failed. The average failure load was 498.8 (± 34.4) N for CLT, 418.8 (± 41.5) N for CST, 933.1 (± 26.2) N for BLT and 634.4 (± 29.0) N for BNT, with a statistical differences (p ˂ 0.001) between the crown and bridge groups. All tested samples exhibited macroscopic deformations at the implant shoulder, which were more pronounced in the specimens without a tube in tube connection.
Conclusions: Single crowns and 3-unit bridges with a long tube in tube connection showed significantly higher fatigue fracture strength compared to restorations with short or without tube in tube connection.