NMC Case Report Journal
Online ISSN : 2188-4226
ISSN-L : 2188-4226
CASE REPORT
A Case of Hemorrhagic Cavernoma of the Lumbar Nerve Root
Kazuma DOI, Satoshi TANI
著者情報
ジャーナル オープンアクセス HTML

2026 年 13 巻 p. 553-557

詳細
Abstract

There have been 26 cases of surgically resected intradural extramedullary cavernomas in the lumbar nerve root. Only 4 cases were accompanied by intratumoral hemorrhage. A 63-year-old woman presented with right lower limb paresthesia that had begun 14 and 6 months ago, followed by gradually worsening motor paralysis over the last 2 months. Magnetic resonance imaging revealed a homogeneous intradural extramedullary lesion with niveau at the L4 level. The affected L4 nerve root on the right had thinned and was strongly adherent to the surrounding gliosis plane due to repeated hemorrhage. Therefore, we had no choice but to sacrifice the nerve root, which was thought to be the origin of the tumor. Consequently, total tumor resection was performed. The pathological diagnosis was cavernoma. This is the fifth hemorrhagic case of a cavernoma originating from the lumbar nerve root. Although intradural extramedullary cavernomas in the lumbar nerve roots are rare, they can present with hemorrhage. It should be considered in the differential diagnosis when radiographic imaging shows findings suggestive of niveau.

Introduction

Spinal cavernomas mainly occur in the vertebral bodies, with 3% occurring intradurally.1) Although most spinal cavernomas are located intramedullary, approximately 60 cases of intradural extramedullary (IDEM) cavernomas have been reported.2) The origins of these IDEM cavernomas in the thoracolumbar region were reported to be the cauda equina or nerve roots.1,2) There have been only 26 reported cases of surgically resected IDEM cavernomas in the lumbar nerve root; however, only 4 cases were identified due to intratumoral hemorrhage.1-3) Herein, we present a fifth case of a hemorrhagic IDEM cavernoma originating from the lumbar nerve root with a literature review.

Case Report

Clinical history and neurological examinations

A 63-year-old woman initially experienced pain and paresthesia in her right lower limb 14 months ago. Her symptoms improved with conservative treatment over the course of 1 and a half months. Subsequently, similar symptoms recurred 6 months ago. She had gradually worsening motor paralysis and pain in her right lower limb over the last 2 months. The previous doctor detected the spinal tumor on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and referred her to our outpatient clinic. Her medical history included hypertension, dyslipidemia, and cataracts. There was no family history of von Hippel-Lindau disease or malignancy. Paresthesia and pain were present from the anterior to the lateral side of her right lower limb. Manual muscle testing results (right/left) were as follows: Iliopsoas (3/4), Quadriceps (3/5), Tibialis Anterior (3/4), Extensor hallucis longus (3/5), and Gastrocnemius (4/5). Patellar tendon reflex and bladder bowel function were within normal range.

Radiographical examination

Non-contrast MRI on T1- and T2-weighted images revealed a mixed-intensity IDEM lesion accompanied by niveau at the L4 level (Figure 1A, B, and F). Gadolinium-enhanced MRI showed a homogeneous enhancing lesion along the right L4 nerve root (Figure 1C, D, and G). A fat-suppression sequence detected hemosiderin deposition around the tumor on the caudal side (Figure 1E). Furthermore, an asymptomatic and non-hemorrhagic intradural-intramedullary lesion suggestive of a cavernoma was also identified at the Th12 level (Figure 1C).

Figure 1

Radiographic findings. Non-contrast MRI on T1- and T2-weighted images revealed a mixed-intensity IDEM lesion accompanied by niveau (black arrow) at the L4 level (A, B, and F). Gadolinium-enhanced MRI showed a homogeneous enhancing lesion along the right L4 nerve root (white arrow) (C, D, and G). Furthermore, a blackberry-like, non-enhanced lesion was observed at the Th12 level (C). The fat-suppression sequence detected hemosiderin deposition (white arrowhead) around the tumor at the caudal side (E).

IDEM: intradural extramedullary; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging

Surgical resection and pathological findings

The operation was performed microscopically under motor evoked potential (MEP) monitoring. The patient was positioned prone. After L4 laminotomy and partial L5 laminectomy, the dura mater was opened. An extensive and dark red subarachnoid hemorrhage was observed through the arachnoid membrane, and the black mass lesion seemed to be in the cauda equina (Figure 2A). The serous hematoma was drained after opening the arachnoid membrane. The arachnoid membrane could be sharply dissected from the tumor at the caudal side (Figure 2B). The tumor lesion was accompanied by surrounding gliosis and inherent hematoma. The original tumor capsule was unclear (Figure 2C). In particular, the boundary between the arachnoid membrane attached to the tumor and the gliosis layer was indistinct on the right side and the peripheral portion of the L4 nerve root (Figure 2D). We made the best effort to preserve the nerve root as much as possible during dissection procedures. The affected L4 nerve root had thinned and was strongly adhered to the surrounding gliosis plane due to repeated hemorrhage (Figure 2E). Therefore, it was difficult to circumferentially detach the boundary between the tumor and the nerve root. We evaluated nerve root motor function using the Nerve Integrity Monitoring System (NIM; Medtronic Japan Co., Tokyo, Japan) (Figure 2F); however, no response was detected. Moreover, no free-run electromyography was detected during the dissecting procedures between the cavernoma and the nerve root. Based on these intraoperative findings, we reluctantly decided to sacrifice the nerve root to achieve complete tumor resection, while avoiding rebleeding from any residual tissue. After coagulating and transecting the affected nerve root, the tumor was completely resected without a decrease in MEP. The L4 lamina was reconstructed with a titanium plate.

Figure 2

Intraoperative findings. (A) Subarachnoid hemorrhage was observed through the arachnoid membrane. The tumor (black arrow) seemed to be in the cauda equina. (B) The arachnoid membrane could be sharply dissected from the tumor (black arrow) at the caudal side. (C) The tumor was accompanied by surrounding gliosis and hematoma, and the tumor capsule was unclear. (D) The boundary between the arachnoid membrane attached to the tumor (black arrow) and the gliosis layer was indistinct on the peripheral portion of the L4 nerve root. (E) The L4 nerve root (white arrow) had thinned and was strongly adherent to the gliosis plane around the tumor (black arrow). (F) Nerve root motor function was evaluated by stimulating the L4 nerve root (white arrow) using the Nerve Integrity Monitoring System.

Postoperatively, her motor paralysis had not worsened. Histopathological examination confirmed small vessels and dilated sinusoidal spaces lined by a single layer of endothelial cells (Figure 3A). Variable sized dilated vessels with hyalinized walls contain blood clots and thrombosis (Figure 3B). Entrapped nerve fibers by the tumor lesion were observed (Figure 3C). The pathological diagnosis was cavernoma. Three months after surgery, her motor weakness had improved to the point of walking without assistance (Iliopsoas and Quadriceps 5/5, Tibialis Anterior 4/5, and Extensor hallucis longus and Gastrocnemius 5/5), and her lower-limb symptoms had almost resolved.

Figure 3

(A) Histopathological examination confirmed small vessels and dilated sinusoidal spaces lined by a single layer of endothelial cells. (B) Variable sized dilated vessels with hyalinized walls contain blood clots and thrombosis. (C) Entrapped nerve fibers by the tumor lesion were observed (C). Hematoxylin-eosin (HE) stain; ×40 (A and C), HE stain; ×200 (B).

Discussion

There have been 26 IDEM cavernomas of the lumbar nerve root listed in PubMed (Table 1).1-12) Among these 27 patients, including our case, 21 (77.8%) patients were male. They were 51.8 ± 17.4 years old (13-77 years old). L2 or L3 (n = 15; 55.6%) were the most common levels. Tumors extended to multiple levels in 10 cases (37.0%). Five (18.5%) cases demonstrated hemorrhagic patterns. Tumors were resected totally in all cases after sacrificing the roots involved in the tumors; only one (3.7%) case developed new neurological deficits postoperatively.

Table 1

Surgically Resected Cases of Cavernomas Originated from the Lumbar Nerve Roots

No. Reference Age (years) Sex Lesion levels Hemorrhage Root sacrifice Resection Neurological deficits
F: female, M: male, NA: not assigned
1 Hirsh, 1965 20 M L2–3 (+) (+) Total NA
2 Pagni, 1990 46 M Th12–L1 (−) (+) Total (−)
3 Makino, 1995 67 M L2 (+) (+) Total (−)
4 Moreno, 1995 63 M Th12–L1 (−) (+) Total NA
5 Flavigna, 2004 44 F L4 (−) (+) Total (−)
6 Chung, 2005 52 M L2 (−) (+) Total (−)
7 Caroli, 2007 71 M L3 (−) (+) Total (−)
8 Cecchi, 2007 75 F L3–4 (−) (+) Total (−)
9 Er, 2007 (4) 67 M Th12–L2 (−) (+) Total (−)
10 Miyake, 2007 18 M L1 (−) (+) Total (−)
11 Chun, 2020 74 F L3 (−) (+) Total (−)
12 Khalatbari, 2011 58 M L3 (−) (+) Total (−)
13 Mataliotakis, 2014 (6) 74 M L2–3 (−) (+) Total (−)
14 Takeshima, 2014 (7) 44 M L2–3 (−) (+) Total (−)
15 Yang, 2014 (10) 42 M L3 (−) (+) Total NA
16 33 M L2 (−) (+) Total NA
17 59 M L3 (−) (+) Total NA
18 36 M L2–3 (−) (+) Total (−)
19 Yaltirik, 2016 (8) 13 F L1 (−) (+) Total (+)
20 Golnari, 2017 (1) 60 M L2 (+) (+) Total (−)
21 Sun, 2018 (3) 51 M L2 (+) (+) Total (−)
22 Apostolakis, 2018 (9) 77 M L3 (−) (+) Total (−)
23 Mohamed, 2023 (5) 54 M L4 (−) (+) Total (−)
24 Heredia-Gutiérrez, 2024 (11) 57 M L1–2 (−) (+) Total (−)
25 Calderon, 2024 (12) 42 F L4–5 (−) (+) Total (−)
26 Nguyen, 2025 (2) 39 M L4 (−) (+) Total (−)
27 Our presented case 63 F L4 (+) (+) Total (−)

Their clinical symptoms are caused by compression of the nerve roots or spinal cord. However, they may sometimes be progressive or present with acute symptoms in case of intra-tumoral hemorrhage.4,5) The rates of bleeding in spinal cavernomas are reported to be approximately 1.4%-4.5%.5) In the case involving hemorrhage, niveau is sometimes observed on axial MRI images.1) The possible mechanisms of neurological deterioration accompanied by tumor growth are mainly hemorrhage and thrombosis.13,14) Surrounding blood vessels and capillaries under increased blood flow and decreased vessel compliance cause primary hemorrhage.13,14) As hyalinization and thickening of vascular walls increase, the vascular channel is dilated by hemodynamic factors.14) Increased flow within the lumens leads to subsequent hemorrhage and repeated hyalinization.14) Narrowing of the hyalinized vascular lumen causes thrombosis.14) In the thrombosed vessels, granulation tissue and thin-walled vessels are often present.13) These fragile vessels may cause repeated hemorrhage.13) Gliosis around the cavernomas is developing, and the hematoma disappeared in the subacute phase.15)

The origins of spinal cavernomas are the blood vessels of the nerve roots, the inner surface of the dura mater, or the pia mater of the spinal cord.4) The roots are sometimes encapsulated with the tumor lesion.4) The origins of IDEM cavernomas are conceived to be the abnormal development of periradicular vessels around the nerve root.4)

MEP mainly reflects the monosynaptic pathway of corticospinal neurons and anterior horn motor neurons.16) Therefore, it is a better indicator of descending neurons in the corticospinal tract than in the segmental motor function.16) The descending neurons have multisynaptic pathways by connecting complexly via the interneurons and propriospinal neurons.16) In surgery for intramedullary spinal cord tumors, MEP monitoring has limitations in predicting postoperative motor weakness, as indicated by a false positive rate of 59% and a false negative rate of 7%.16) MEP monitoring is not the perfect test for predicting functional outcome. In our case, MEP did not decline after dissecting the affected nerve root, and consequently, there were no neurological deficits. Therefore, MEP should be utilized as a supportive tool to determine whether to discontinue manipulation procedures and to detect intraoperative changes in motor signals.16)

More than 95% of published cases reported no new neurological deficits, even after transecting nerve roots. This is because of the long-standing nature of the tumors. The tumors appeared to have acquired plasticity by promoting neighboring nerve roots.2) These nerve roots compensated for the original function of the affected nerve roots.2) It has been reported that no permanent neurological deficits occurred after nerve transection in cases of spinal schwannomas.17) This can be explained by slowly progressing deterioration caused by repeated degeneration and regeneration, as well as by functional compensation by the adjacent non-affected nerves.17) Chronic denervation leads to an increase in acetylcholine receptors, resulting in sprouting axons.18) It was speculated that the epispinal system of motor axons combines with root fibers and joins the anterior roots as functional compensation.18) The overlapping innervation might occur even at the level of a single motor neuron.18) In our presented case, there have been 2 episodes that are compatible with intratumoral hemorrhages. Since the transition may have occurred over the 6 months, we suppose that recovery from postoperative lower limb paralysis may have been achieved at an early stage. Even though the pathological characteristics of the tumors differ, we suppose that similar mechanisms may be involved from the perspective of neuronal plasticity.

Conclusions

This case illustrated an IDEM cavernoma that was completely resected without neurological deficits. This is the fifth reported case of a hemorrhagic cavernoma originating from a lumbar nerve root. Although IDEM cavernomas in the lumbar nerve roots are rare, they can cause hemorrhage. It should be considered in the differential diagnosis when radiographic imaging is suggestive of niveau.

Conflicts of Interest

All authors have no conflict of interest.

Informed Consent

Consent from the patient was obtained.

References
 
© 2026 The Japan Neurosurgical Society

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons [Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International] license.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
feedback
Top