NMC Case Report Journal
Online ISSN : 2188-4226
ISSN-L : 2188-4226
CASE REPORT
Selective n-Butyl Cyanoacrylate Embolization of a Ruptured Aneurysmal Lesion Arising from a Rete-like Collateral Network of the Posterior Inferior Cerebellar Artery
Akira SAITO, Tomoko IKEMOTO, Shunya HANAKITA, Satoshi IIHOSHI
著者情報
ジャーナル オープンアクセス HTML

2026 年 13 巻 p. 559-565

詳細
Abstract

A 58-year-old woman presented with sudden-onset severe headache and decreased consciousness. Computed tomography revealed posterior fossa–predominant subarachnoid hemorrhage. Digital subtraction angiography demonstrated a rete-like collateral network of the left posterior inferior cerebellar artery, an extremely rare vascular anomaly in which the posterior inferior cerebellar artery trunk divides into a plexiform network of small dysplastic channels before reconstituting into distal branches. A 1.5-mm aneurysmal lesion was identified on one channel of this network by superselective angiography and was considered the bleeding source; given its small size and the fragile dysplastic substrate, a pseudoaneurysm could not be excluded. After emergent hematoma evacuation, the aneurysm-bearing channel was selectively occluded with 25% n-butyl cyanoacrylate (0.2 mL). Post-embolization angiography confirmed exclusion of the lesion with preserved distal posterior inferior cerebellar artery perfusion through the remaining channels. Diffusion-weighted imaging at 48 hours showed no new ischemic lesions in the posterior inferior cerebellar artery perfusion territory. The patient was discharged with a modified Rankin Scale score of 2, which improved to 1 at 7 months. A rete-like collateral network of the posterior inferior cerebellar artery is exceedingly rare. Although a ruptured pseudoaneurysm on a hypoplastic and plexiform posterior inferior cerebellar artery has been reported, a ruptured aneurysmal lesion arising from a focal rete-like collateral network of an otherwise normal posterior inferior cerebellar artery, treated by selective channel occlusion, has not previously been described. The multi-channel architecture of this anomaly may permit selective occlusion of an aneurysm-bearing channel while maintaining distal perfusion; however, the potential risk of brainstem perforator infarction must be carefully considered, and further experience is needed before this strategy can be generalized.

Introduction

Rete mirabile is a congenital aberrant arterial network resulting from abnormal embryonic vascular development. In humans, the analogous plexiform configuration encountered in intracranial arteries is increasingly regarded as a secondary rete-like collateral network rather than as a true rete mirabile.1) Although well recognized in other mammalian species, such networks in humans are rare and have been reported primarily in the internal carotid artery, typically in association with hypoplasia or agenesis of the native vessel.1,2) Such a network involving the posterior inferior cerebellar artery (PICA) is exceedingly uncommon. Giragani et al.3) first described this entity in 2018, originally reported as a rete mirabile of the PICA, in a patient presenting with subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH), although no aneurysm was identified.

Separately, aneurysm formation on hypoplastic and plexiform PICA variants has been reported. Hou and Yu described two patients with ruptured pseudoaneurysms arising from hypoplastic and plexiform PICAs, both treated by liquid embolic occlusion of the aneurysm together with the parent vessel.4) Additionally, aneurysms arising from PICA communicating arteries or collateral channels related to PICA variants have been described, highlighting the fragility of these embryonic remnant vessels.5,6)

However, a ruptured aneurysmal lesion arising specifically from a focal rete-like collateral network of an otherwise normal PICA has not been previously reported; the cases of Hou and Yu involved PICAs that were themselves hypoplastic and plexiform throughout, a configuration distinct from this case. We present a patient with posterior fossa–predominant SAH caused by the rupture of a 1.5-mm aneurysmal lesion on a rete-like collateral network of the left PICA, successfully treated by selective channel occlusion with n-butyl cyanoacrylate (NBCA).

Case Report

A 58-year-old woman with a history of hypertension and dyslipidemia presented with sudden-onset left posterior neck pain while stretching. She was transported to a referring hospital, where her consciousness deteriorated from Japan Coma Scale (JCS) 1 to JCS 200 during evaluation. Computed tomography (CT) demonstrated posterior fossa–predominant SAH with intraventricular hemorrhage (Figure 1A). She was transferred to our institution for definitive management. On admission, she was classified as World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies grade 4.

Figure 1

Diagnosis of a rete-like collateral network of the posterior inferior cerebellar artery (PICA) and identification of the ruptured aneurysmal lesion.

(A) Non-contrast computed tomography demonstrating posterior fossa–predominant subarachnoid hemorrhage with intraventricular hemorrhage. (B) Left vertebral artery angiography (anteroposterior view, two-dimensional digital subtraction angiography) demonstrating a plexiform network of multiple small, tortuous channels in the left PICA territory. (C) Three-dimensional rotational angiography (3D-RA) delineating the network and its spatial relationship to the vertebral artery. (D) 3D-RA close-up of the aneurysm-bearing channel demonstrating a 1.5-mm aneurysmal lesion (arrow) arising from one channel of the network, considered the bleeding source. (E) Right vertebral artery angiography (anteroposterior view) demonstrating a mildly hypoplastic right vertebral artery with a normal-caliber right PICA (arrowhead), confirming contralateral collateral support to the posterior fossa circulation.

Emergent digital subtraction angiography (DSA) of the left vertebral artery (VA) revealed an unusual vascular architecture in the left PICA territory: the PICA trunk divided into a plexiform network of multiple small, tortuous channels that subsequently reconstituted into distal PICA branches, consistent with a rete-like collateral network of the PICA (Figure 1B and C). The right VA was mildly hypoplastic; however, the right PICA was present and normal in caliber (Figure 1E). CT angiography (CTA) did not reveal a definite aneurysm. On day 0, the patient underwent emergent craniotomy for posterior fossa hematoma evacuation without definitive aneurysm treatment.

Subsequent three-dimensional rotational angiography (3D-RA) and superselective angiography identified a 1.5-mm aneurysmal lesion arising from one channel of the rete-like collateral network, considered the bleeding source (Figure 1D). No angiographic evidence of VA or PICA dissection was observed.

Given the extremely small size of the lesion (1.5 mm) and the dysplastic vascular substrate, direct coil embolization was considered technically unfeasible. Endovascular treatment was performed on day 1 under general anesthesia via a transfemoral approach. A 6-Fr guiding catheter (FUBUKI; Asahi Intecc Co., Ltd., Aichi, Japan) was positioned in the left VA. A distal access catheter (Phenom Plus; Medtronic, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA) was advanced coaxially through the FUBUKI for intermediate support. Systemic heparinization was maintained with an activated clotting time of approximately 250 seconds. A microcatheter (DeFrictor Nano; Medico's Hirata Inc., Osaka, Japan) was navigated over a microwire (CHIKAI X 10; Asahi Intecc Co., Ltd., Aichi, Japan) superselectively into the aneurysm-bearing channel; a wedged position was not used. Superselective angiography confirmed the aneurysmal lesion and demonstrated that the distal PICA territory was supplied by multiple channels of the rete-like collateral network, suggesting that occlusion of the aneurysm-bearing channel would not compromise distal perfusion (Figure 2A).

Figure 2

Selective NBCA embolization and post-treatment imaging.

(A) Superselective angiography of the aneurysm-bearing channel confirming the aneurysmal lesion (arrow) and demonstrating that the multiple channels of the rete-like collateral network reconstitute into the larger distal PICA, with distal PICA perfusion maintained through these channels. (B) Fluoroscopic image during 25% NBCA injection (0.2 mL), showing the NBCA cast (asterisk); the microcatheter tip (arrowhead) had been advanced to immediately proximal to the aneurysmal lesion. (C) Post-embolization left vertebral artery angiography demonstrating exclusion of the aneurysmal lesion and the aneurysm-bearing channel, with preserved distal PICA perfusion through the remaining channels of the network. (D) Diffusion-weighted imaging obtained 48 hours after embolization showing no new ischemic lesions in the bilateral cerebellar hemispheres, including the PICA perfusion territory. (E) Time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography at 7-month follow-up demonstrating no recanalization of the occluded channel and preserved distal PICA perfusion.

NBCA: n-butyl cyanoacrylate; PICA: posterior inferior cerebellar artery

The microcatheter was then advanced to immediately proximal to the aneurysmal lesion, and selective occlusion of the aneurysm-bearing channel was performed using 25% NBCA (total 0.2 mL) (Figure 2B). A 25% concentration was selected to allow the glue to remain localized within the target channel while minimizing the risk of distal migration, and a total of 0.2 mL was injected. Post-embolization angiography demonstrated complete exclusion of the aneurysmal lesion and the target channel, with preserved distal perfusion of the PICA territory through the remaining channels of the rete-like collateral network (Figure 2C).

Diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI) obtained 48 hours after embolization showed no new ischemic lesions in the bilateral cerebellar hemispheres, including the PICA perfusion territory (Figure 2D). No antiplatelet therapy was administered postoperatively. The patient's neurological status improved progressively. She was discharged with a modified Rankin Scale (mRS) score of 2. At the 7-month follow-up, her mRS improved to 1. Magnetic resonance imaging showed no recurrent hemorrhage, and time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) demonstrated no recanalization of the occluded channel, with preserved distal PICA perfusion (Figure 2E). Written informed consent for publication of this case and the accompanying images was obtained from the patient.

Discussion

The PICA is one of the most variable intracranial arteries, reflecting its complex embryological development. During early embryogenesis, the PICA derives from the primitive lateral vertebrobasilar anastomosis, a transient plexiform network of small channels encircling the developing medulla.7) This network normally coalesces into a single definitive PICA trunk as redundant channels regress. When this regression is incomplete, persistent embryonic channels may give rise to various anatomical variants, including double origin of the PICA (DOPICA), PICA communicating arteries, fenestrations, and, in its most extreme form, a rete-like collateral network in which a segment of the PICA retains its primitive plexiform architecture.1,3,8) In this case, the left PICA had a single origin from the VA but divided distally into a network of multiple small, tortuous channels before reconstituting into distal PICA branches. This architecture is consistent with incomplete regression of the primitive plexiform network at the distal PICA level.

A note on terminology is warranted. The term "rete mirabile" was originally used to describe a physiological arterial meshwork that exists in lower vertebrates but is not part of normal human cerebrovascular development. Ota recently argued that the structures previously labeled rete mirabile in humans are more accurately characterized as secondary "rete-like collaterals" that develop after segmental regression or dysgenesis of an affected artery, and proposed that this preferred term should also apply to plexiform networks observed in intracranial arteries beyond the internal carotid artery, including the PICA.9) We acknowledge this nomenclatural debate and consider the present anomaly equally describable as a focal rete-like collateral network of the distal PICA. We adopt the term "rete-like collateral network of the PICA" throughout this report, in line with this revised concept, while noting that the only previously published case was described as a rete mirabile of the PICA.3) The embryological mechanism is best framed as incomplete regression of the primitive plexiform network rather than as a true physiological rete.

This vascular anomaly must be distinguished from other PICA variants that share superficial angiographic similarities. DOPICA is a separate entity in which the PICA arises from two distinct origins on the VA, representing persistence of both the true PICA and the lateral spinal artery; DOPICA has a reported incidence of 0.36–1.45% on catheter angiography.8,10) PICA fenestration refers to a focal segment of vessel duplication with proximal and distal reunion, without the diffuse plexiform pattern seen in a rete-like collateral network. PICA communicating arteries are arterial bridges connecting bilateral PICAs across the midline at the roof of the fourth ventricle, typically seen when one PICA is hypoplastic or absent.5,6) In contrast, the rete-like collateral network of the PICA is characterized by a diffuse plexiform network of multiple small dysplastic channels replacing a segment of the PICA trunk, without dual origins from the VA and midline communication. In our patient, the single VA origin distinguishes this anomaly from DOPICA, while the diffuse plexiform network of multiple channels, rather than a single focal duplication, distinguishes it from fenestration.

The association between PICA variants and aneurysm formation is well established. The incidence of aneurysm in DOPICA has been reported to range from 50% to 71%, attributed to hemodynamic stress at bifurcation points and inherent wall fragility of embryonic remnant vessels.11) Similarly, PICA communicating artery aneurysms are thought to arise from hemodynamic stress on a thin-walled embryonic remnant carrying blood flow to the contralateral cerebellum.5,6) In a rete-like collateral network, the dysplastic channels composing the network are presumably thin-walled and structurally fragile, rendering them susceptible to aneurysmal change under hemodynamic stress. Several mechanisms may contribute to aneurysm formation and rupture in this setting. The plexiform channels carry redistributed flow with multiple bifurcations and acute angulations, concentrating hemodynamic shear stress at vulnerable points; combined with the deficient mural architecture inherent to these embryonic remnant vessels, this may promote focal wall failure and aneurysmal dilatation, followed by rupture. This case supports this hypothesis: a 1.5-mm aneurysmal lesion arose on one channel of the network and ruptured, causing posterior fossa–predominant SAH. Importantly, given the small size of the lesion, its location on a fragile dysplastic channel, and the acute hemorrhagic presentation, a dissecting or pseudoaneurysmal nature cannot be excluded in the absence of histopathological confirmation. This consideration is consistent with the dissecting pseudoaneurysms reported by Hou and Yu on plexiform PICAs, and it may also account for the absence of a definite aneurysm on initial CTA.

The diagnosis of a rete-like collateral network of the PICA and identification of the bleeding source pose distinct challenges. First, CTA may fail to detect ultra-small aneurysms arising from dysplastic networks; in this case, CTA did not reveal a definite aneurysm, and the bleeding source was identified only by superselective angiography. This parallels the experience with PICA communicating artery aneurysms, where small aneurysms were missed on initial angiography and identified only on repeat studies in four of 11 reported cases.5) Second, the plexiform appearance of a rete-like collateral network may mimic an arteriovenous malformation (AVM) on initial angiographic assessment; Giragani et al.3) noted that their case was initially suspected to be an AVM before the absence of arteriovenous shunting was confirmed. Careful analysis of the arterial phase timing and absence of early venous drainage is essential to differentiate a rete-like collateral network from a true AVM or arteriovenous fistula. Third, when posterior fossa–predominant SAH is encountered without an identifiable source on initial DSA, the possibility of rare PICA variants harboring microaneurysms should be considered, and repeat angiography with superselective injections should be performed.

A rete-like collateral network of the PICA is exceedingly rare. Giragani et al.3) reported the first and only previous case in 2018, described at the time as a rete mirabile of the PICA: a patient with SAH in whom the vermian segment of a bihemispheric PICA (a single PICA supplying both cerebellar hemispheres)12) arising from the right VA was divided into a tangle of ectatic, dysplastic small vessels reforming into a single dominant artery; notably, no aneurysm was identified despite the hemorrhagic presentation, and the patient was managed conservatively.3) Hou and Yu reported two patients with PICAs that were hypoplastic and plexiform, harboring ruptured pseudoaneurysms within the plexiform segment; both were treated by liquid embolic (Onyx) occlusion of the aneurysm together with the parent PICA. One patient developed a postprocedural brainstem infarction but recovered significantly, with only mild residual hoarseness at 1 and a half years, while the other died of pulmonary infection 1 month after the procedure, despite initial postoperative improvement.4) To our knowledge, this case is the first report of a ruptured aneurysmal lesion arising from a focal rete-like collateral network segment of an otherwise normal PICA, treated by selective occlusion of the aneurysm-bearing channel that preserved distal PICA perfusion through the remaining channels of the network. This contrasts with the previously reported plexiform PICA cases of Hou and Yu, in which the PICA itself was hypoplastic and plexiform, necessitating occlusion of the parent vessel together with the aneurysm. The previously reported cases and the present case are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1

Previously Reported Cases of Hemorrhagic Presentation Involving Rete-Like Collateral or Plexiform Networks of the PICA

Study Vascular configuration Aneurysm Presentation Treatment Outcome
DWI: Diffusion-weighted imaging; IVH: intraventricular hemorrhage; MRA: magnetic resonance angiography; mRS: modified Rankin Scale; NBCA: n-butyl cyanoacrylate; PICA: posterior inferior cerebellar artery; SAH: subarachnoid hemorrhage; WFNS: World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies
Giragani et al., 20183) Rete-like collateral network (reported as rete mirabile) of bihemispheric PICA: vermian segment divided into tangle of ectatic/dysplastic vessels No aneurysm identified SAH with IVH Conservative Managed conservatively; improved
Hou and Yu, 20224)—Case 1 Hypoplastic and plexiform PICA Ruptured pseudoaneurysm within plexiform PICA SAH + IVH Onyx occlusion of aneurysm + parent PICA Postprocedural brainstem infarction; significant recovery with mild residual hoarseness (1.5 years)
Hou and Yu, 20224)—Case 2 Hypoplastic and plexiform PICA Ruptured pseudoaneurysm in plexiform PICA SAH Onyx occlusion of aneurysm + parent PICA Died of pulmonary infection 1 month after the procedure
Present case Rete-like collateral network of left PICA: trunk divides into plexiform network of multiple channels Ruptured aneurysmal lesion (1.5 mm) on one channel SAH; WFNS 4 Selective occlusion of aneurysm-bearing channel with 25% NBCA (0.2 mL) DWI (48 h): no new ischemia in PICA territory; mRS 2 at discharge, mRS 1 at 7 months; MRA: no recanalization

The treatment strategy in this case was guided by the unique multi-channel architecture of the rete-like collateral network. For ultra-small aneurysms (1.5 mm), direct coil embolization is technically challenging due to limitations in microcatheter stability, coil sizing, and the risk of procedural rupture. Liquid embolic agents allow definitive exclusion of a target channel when superselective catheterization is feasible. NBCA-based parent artery occlusion has been reported as a definitive option for distal PICA aneurysms when collateral circulation is adequate.13,14) In our patient, the inherent redundancy of the rete-like collateral network provided a built-in safety margin: selective occlusion of the aneurysm-bearing channel achieved hemorrhage control, while the remaining channels maintained distal PICA perfusion, as confirmed by post-embolization angiography and by the absence of new ischemic lesions in the PICA territory on 48-hour DWI. Furthermore, although the right VA was mildly hypoplastic, the right PICA was present and normal in caliber, providing an additional level of collateral security to the posterior fossa circulation. The PICA and the anterior inferior cerebellar artery (AICA) maintain a well-recognized reciprocal relationship in their cerebellar supply territories, such that one frequently enlarges to compensate when the other is hypoplastic. The redundant channels of a PICA rete-like collateral network may be regarded as an analogous, intrinsic compensatory mechanism operating within the PICA territory itself; in addition, a reciprocal AICA supply may further buffer the distal territory after channel occlusion, although the AICA contribution was not formally quantified in this case. This multi-level collateral architecture, comprising the remaining channels of the ipsilateral network, the contralateral PICA, and the potential AICA–PICA reciprocity, likely contributed to the absence of ischemic complications in this case.

This treatment principle parallels the experience in DOPICA and PICA communicating artery aneurysms, where occlusion of one channel or parent vessel may be tolerated when alternative pathways supply the distal territory.5,6,10) However, unlike DOPICA, where the two channels arise from separate origins on the VA and supply distinct medullary perforators, the channels in a rete-like collateral network originate from a single PICA trunk and divide distally into a plexiform network. This distinction is clinically important: whereas the perforator territory of each DOPICA channel can often be inferred from its origin and course, the perforator anatomy within a rete-like collateral network is unpredictable. The plexiform channels of such a network located near the medulla may give rise to perforating branches supplying the brainstem, and occlusion of these branches carries a substantial risk of medullary or brainstem infarction. Critically, such perforators may not be visualized even on superselective angiography; therefore, NBCA embolization of a channel within a rete-like collateral network carries a potential risk of brainstem infarction that cannot be fully excluded by angiographic assessment alone. Meticulous superselective angiographic evaluation is essential before channel occlusion, and this potential risk must be weighed carefully against the benefit of definitive hemorrhage control in each case.

This report has several limitations. First, this is a single-case observation without histopathologic confirmation of the vascular anomaly; the embryological interpretation is therefore inferential. Second, the nomenclature applied to this anomaly remains contested, as discussed above; further angiographic and embryological characterization of similar cases will be required to establish a unified terminology. Third, the bleeding source was not identified on initial CTA or VA DSA and was demonstrated only by 3D rotational and superselective angiography; this diagnostic pathway underscores the technical difficulty of detecting microaneurysms within plexiform networks and may not be reproducible in all centers. Fourth, although 7-month follow-up MRA demonstrated no recanalization, this duration is insufficient to exclude delayed recanalization or de novo aneurysm formation, and continued long-term surveillance is warranted, as recanalization after distal PICA treatments has been reported.14)

Conclusions

We report a case of a ruptured aneurysmal lesion arising from a rete-like collateral network of the PICA, successfully treated by selective NBCA embolization of the aneurysm-bearing channel. In this case, the multi-channel architecture of the network appeared to provide an inherent safety margin for selective channel occlusion, preserving distal perfusion. However, as this is a single case with limited follow-up, the safety of this approach should not be generalized; the perforator anatomy within such networks is unpredictable, and NBCA embolization carries a potential risk of brainstem infarction that may not be excluded even by superselective angiography. Meticulous superselective angiographic evaluation is essential to assess collateral adequacy before treatment, and further experience is needed to define the role of this strategy.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank the medical staff involved in the care of the patient. Artificial intelligence was used to assist with English language editing. The scientific content, data, conclusions, and all final decisions regarding the manuscript are entirely the authors' own work.

Conflicts of Interest

All authors have no conflict of interest.

References
 
© 2026 The Japan Neurosurgical Society

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons [Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International] license.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
feedback
Top