Article ID: 2026-0306
Introduction: Pedicle screw fixation is fundamental to lumbar fusion surgery, yet multiple insertion techniques—freehand (FH), robot-assisted (RA), computed tomography–based navigation (CT-nav), and fluoroscopy-guided (FL) —remain in widespread use. Although advanced navigation technologies aim to improve accuracy and safety, their impact on perioperative efficiency, radiation exposure, and clinical outcomes in routine practice remains controversial. We aimed to compare perioperative characteristics associated with four commonly used techniques in terms of clinical outcomes and radiation exposure in single-level lumbar fusion surgery.
Methods: This retrospective cohort study included patients who underwent single-level lumbar posterior spinal fusion (PSF) or combined PSF with anterior or lateral lumbar interbody fusion between January 2020 and December 2022 at a single institution. Patients were categorized by screw insertion technique: FH, RA, CT-nav, or FL. Demographics, operative data, complications, length of stay (LOS), discharge disposition, and radiation exposure were compared.
Results: A total of 1,225 patients were included. CT-nav and RA had longer operative times than FH and FL, while FL had the shortest operative time and lowest estimated blood loss (EBL). Intraoperative and total radiation exposure were highest in the CT-nav group, followed by the RA and FL groups, with the FH group having the lowest exposure. Postoperative cardiac, pulmonary, and urinary complications were most frequent in the FH group. LOS was longest in the CT-nav group and shortest in the FL group, which also had the highest home discharge rates. No significant differences were found in neurological complications, deep infection, or reoperation rates.
Conclusions: The four clinical groups demonstrated distinct perioperative characteristics. The CT-nav and RA groups had longer operative times, whereas the FL group had shorter LOS and lower EBL. Because of differences in baseline characteristics and surgical procedures among the groups, these findings should be interpreted as descriptive differences among clinical groups rather than effects attributable to the screw insertion techniques themselves.