The number of censuses must be consistent to compare the number of species in bird communities because the cumulative number of species recorded is affected by both the number of censuses and seasons of the censuses. We compared the numbers of bird species and individuals identified from 2,069 route censuses conducted for 10-years in a 1.4 km wooded zone along Tamagawa-josui Canal, Kodaira City, Tokyo, with subsets of those surveys conducted once a month for 10 years, 3 years, and 1 year. Of the total number of species and individuals recorded, the number of bird species were 70.2%, 54.8%, and 41.3%, respectively, and those of individuals were 5.8%, 1.8%, and 0.8%. Although the top 20-30 bird species were consistent in all the surveys, rare species were not recorded by 10-year surveys, low-frequency migratory birds were not recorded by 3-year surveys, and sedentary birds and common migratory birds were recorded by 1-year surveys. The top 10 species in numbers were consistent regardless of the number of surveys and recorded even by 1-year survey. A comparison of data from 36 monthly censuses over 3 years in Kodaira City and the Imperial Palace showed that the numbers of species recorded were 41 in Kodaira City and 67 in the Imperial Palace, respectively. Since 84 species were recorded in the 2,069 censuses in Kodaira City, the numbers of recorded birds are affected by the times of censuses. Therefore, when comparing bird communities, censuses should be conducted throughout the year. One-year censuses can find core species, three-year censuses can discover the major migratory birds, and to find low-frequency migratory birds longer studies are needed. We pointed out that to compare different bird communities, the number of censuses should be aligned.
View full abstract