The purpose of this paper is to report on mistaken descriptions made in reports on a field exercise by university students taking a school teacher course, regarding the depositional environments of gravel beds, and to discuss the causes of the mistakes. Four cases of the mistakes were found. Case 1: mistaking the rock names of gravel as the name of the beds. Case 2: mistaking the depositional environments of gravel beds with those of the host rocks of gravel. Case 3: mistaking the current environments as the depositional environments of the gravel beds. Case 4: unclear and inappropriate usages of logic in the reports. These four mistakes were most likely caused by an inadequate understanding of the processes of gravel bed formation (Cases 1, 2, and 3); by low awareness regarding the use of accurate words and phrasing (Case 1); and by low awareness regarding writing logical sentences (Case 4). In particular, the percentage of the students who made the mistake shown in Case 2 was 47.3%, showing that their understanding was insufficient regarding the processes of gravel bed formation.
View full abstract