In a previous study, we found that students at an acupuncture and moxibustion vocational school formed their individual identity as practitioners while observing actual practices by instructors, learning about communication techniques, relationships between therapists and patients, and acquiring techniques to improve their awareness as specialists during clinical acupuncture and moxibustion training. In other words, what they learned included three domains of learning; namely, the knowledge, skills, and attitudes that B.S. Bloom proposed as a taxonomy of educational objectives, and specifically contributed to the cultivation of proper attitude. However, as there is a lack of studies focusing on learning processes during clinical training, we examined and analyzed their learning processes in this study.
Subjects were 42 third-year students at an acupuncture and moxibustion vocational school, 21 male and 21 female students (average age: 31.8 ± 6.9 years (mean ± SD)). Subjects were given essay assignments twice during the clinical training period, data from the 71 subjects essays were collected for exploratory analysis using a qualitative study method from the viewpoint of three steps of comprehensive medicine; namely, prompt relief of pain (Step 1), determining of the onset and focus of pain (Step 2), and measures for disease prevention and health creation through self-control (Step 3).
Based on the results of analysis, we extracted 8 categories, 22 sub-categories, and 195 codes. Among the 8 categories, I) “recognizing the need for good manners,” II) “being unaccustomed to performing face-to-face medical examinations,” III) “listening to patients talking about their condition,” and IV) “having counseling skills” were classified into Step 1 while V) “psychological and physical approaches to patients” was classified into Step 2, VI) “patient self-control ability” was classified into Step 3, VII) “forming identities” and VIII) “improving skills” were classified into Other.
Our study clarified that the three steps of comprehensive medicine comprise the process of patients' being released from pain and achieving recovery. It also revealed that students learned professional knowledge, skills, and attitude through the experience of comprehensive medicine while gradually formed their identity. Results also suggested we need to identify categories related to learning processes as the effects of practical training to employ as indicators of the effectiveness of instruction and evaluation for practical training.
The results suggested that students learned the importance of face-to-face medical examinations and counseling skills as well as psychological and physical approaches to patients. Results also clarified that students learned that patients have the ability to exercise self-control. In addition, results showed that students attempt to improve their skills and form their identities as acupuncture and moxibustion practitioners.
View full abstract