In July 2017, the Marine Accident Investigation Branch of the United Kingdom reported an accident of a fishing vessel resulting in the fatalities of three seafarers. These seafarers were found in a face-down position, while they were wearing lifejackets certified in accordance with the International Conventions for the Safety of Life at Sea and the International Life-saving Appliance (LSA) Code, so-called “SOLAS lifejackets”. Following the research initiated by this accident, the European Commission submitted two documents, emphasizing the necessity of a new righting test method for lifejackets with clothing. The Maritime Safety Committee, at its 101st session, considered these documents and agreed to review the LSA Code and the Revised Recommendation on testing of life-saving appliances, in respect to the in-water performance of SOLAS lifejackets, taking into account that the current righting test of a SOLAS lifejacket is conducted only with a swimming costume.
In order to develop robust testing methods for the righting of lifejackets with clothing, the righting phenomenon of lifejackets with clothing should be examined. The purposes of our preliminary research are to evaluate the repeatability of righting tests with clothing and to obtain fundamental information on such tests. For these purposes, we conducted righting tests with clothing using three human test subjects under various conditions and compared the results of tests conducted just after entering the test basin with dry clothing in order to evaluate the repeatability of the tests. In addition, we repeated the righting tests using the same clothing without getting out of the test basin in order to obtain further information for reference. We further measured the forces required to dive into the water with and without clothing in order to roughly specify the buoyancy of clothing under lifejackets. The test results indicated that righting tests with clothing were sensitive to slight differences in clothing conditions, human actions and time elapsed. Our study showed that the righting test with clothing had poor repeatability and standardization of clothing could not solve the poor repeatability of the righting test with clothing.
View full abstract