From January 94 to December 99, we prospectively assigned 463 consecutive children with ALL to receive one of four treatment protocols on the stratification by age, white-cell count and certain risk factors at the time of diagnosis. Patients at low-risk and intermediate-risk (55 percent of the total) were treated for two or three years, receiving an escalating dose of anti-metabolites, consisting of MTX, 6-MP and L-Asp, using none or a small amount of alkylating agents, anthracyclines and etoposide, which have adverse late effects. MTX was increased to a 500 mg/m
2, 24-hour injection without CF rescue, from the 225 mg/m
2 bolus injection which was used in the previous study (CCLSG 911, 874, 841, 811 protocols). 6-MP was also increased to 250 mg/m
2 from 175 mg/m
2 and L-Asp was newly introduced to intermittent injection during the maintenance therapy. After the initial 7 months' chemotherapy, patients at high-risk and high-high-risk were assigned institutionally to 1) uninterrupted chemotherapy for three years or 2) peripheral blood stem cell (PBSC) collection after a mobilization regimen with G-CSF and mega-dose chemotherapy (MCVAC regimen) plus PBSC rescue (PBSC transplantation : PBSCT), with all therapy completed within 9 months. It is noteworthy, that no patients assigned PBSCT were still receiving therapy after the PBSCT, so therapeutic duration was only 25 percent that of chemo-arm patients (9 months versus 36 months). In a combined analysis of all of the patients who underwent PBSCT in their first complete remission (
n=44), hematological engraftment was seen in all but 1 patient who died 6 days after PBSCT due to severe infection with resistant Pseudomonous aeruginosa. At a median follow-up of 90 months, the mean event-free survival rates in the low-risk (
n=106), intermediate-risk (
n=149), high-risk (
n=161), high-high-risk (
n=47) were 71.5 ± 5.3, 82.3 ±3.7, 70.3 ±4.4 and 30.7 ± 22.0 percent, respectively. As compared with our previous protocols, the CCLSG 941 protocol has resulted in improved event-free survival; excepting low-risk group protocol, without using any dose of alkylating agents, anthracyclines and etoposide. Among high-and high-high-risk group, excluding early toxic death (
n=10) and early relapse (
n=13) within 7 months, there is currently significant difference (
p < 0.05) in the event-free survival between chemo-arm and PBSCT-arm (83.0 versus 63.5%). The further evaluation of long-term efficacy and toxicity of the procedure with a large number of patients is feasible.
View full abstract