Scalar-relativistic density functional calculations were applied to the complexation of Eu(III) and Am(III) ions with alkyldithiophosphinic acid (S-donor) and alkylphosphinic acid (O-donor) from the viewpoint of the bonding nature of valence orbitals of a metal ion. Two and four conformers for the S-donor and O-donor complexes, respectively, were optimized at the ZORA-BP86 level. The stabilization energies by complex formation between the metal ions and the ligands toward the hydrated metal ions were estimated at the ZORA-B2PLYP level; these calculations reproduced the experimental Am/Eu selectivities, where the S-donor ligand preferably coordinates to Am(III) ion rather than Eu(III) ion, whereas O-donor ligand selectively coordinates to Eu(III) ion rather than Am(III) ion. Electron population analyses based on the molecular orbitals indicated that the d-orbital electrons in both the Eu and Am complexes participate in bonding covalent interactions with donor atoms and have surprisingly similar contributions. This result suggests that the covalent interaction between the d-orbital electrons in the metal ion and the ligands may be due to the geometrical similarity of the molecular structures of the Eu and Am complexes. In contrast, the contributions of the f-orbital electrons in the metal ions were different in the Eu and Am complexes. In the case of the S-donor complexes, non-bonding and bonding contributions were observed for the Eu and Am complexes, respectively, and in the case of the O-donor complex, bonding and anti-bonding contributions were observed for the Eu and Am complexes, respectively. This result implies that the selectivities of Eu(III) and Am(III) ions were determined by the difference in the participation of their f-orbital electrons, not their d-orbital electrons, in covalent interactions.
View full abstract