Japanese Review of Cultural Anthropology
Online ISSN : 2424-0494
Print ISSN : 2432-5112
ISSN-L : 2432-5112
Volume 23, Issue 2
Displaying 1-7 of 7 articles from this issue
front matter
2021 Japanese Society of Cultural Anthropology Award Lecture
  • Towards a 21st Century Structuralism
    Naoki Kasuga
    2023Volume 23Issue 2 Pages 7-45
    Published: 2023
    Released on J-STAGE: February 28, 2025
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    The straightforward expressions that compose magical acts have made anthropologists question how two completely different categories can be combined. This paper reinterprets magical acts reported in Papua New Guinean ethnography from the point of view of isomorphism in mathematical category theory. First, it is made clear that the set of elements that make up magic in the realm of living things and the similar set in the realm of the spirits are isomorphic; from this it is demonstrated that the two are so much the same that they are interchangeable.

    Furthermore, it necessarily follows from this that operation in the realm of the living corresponds to operation in the realm of the spirits, and conversely, operation in the realm of the spirits also corresponds to operation in the realm of the living. In this way, the concept of isomorphism can succinctly explain the combination of different categories and the pursuit of unique causal relationships, which the study of magic has focused on. All of these are derived from isomorphism and are an inevitable consequence of isomorphism. The limited role of the various characteristics of magic, including metaphorical expressions, becomes clear if one regards them as contrivances and efforts to meet the demands of isomorphism.

    However, the condition for isomorphism—that there is a one-to-one correspondence between the elements of the set on the side of the living and the elements of the set on the side of the spirits—is by no means guaranteed. It seems that the people of Papua New Guinea are aware both of this lack of guarantee and of the way in which they should make efforts; and under these conditions they endeavor to actualize isomorphism, which is to say, they continue to practice magic. Here the important nature of magical acts—that they rely on the idea of isomorphism and aim at the realization of isomorphism—becomes clear.

    The study of magic in anthropology, which has a history and continues to be important, gains a new perspective from the language that embodies mathematics in this way. This topic, which is universal across space-time and moreover does not fit comfortably within the bounds of modern logic, is given a very succinct explanation through the language of mathematics, which has made remarkable progress in the modern era. In this way mathematics can contribute to anthropology and open up anthropology to other modern disciplines. This does not by any means mean quantification, but rather the re-emergence of an approach that re-understands human thought—which is not easily quantifiable—as structure; an approach which may perhaps call itself the structuralism of the 21st century.

    Download PDF (837K)
Submitted Article
  • Ontological Reflections on East African Pastoral Internally Displaced Persons
    Shinya Konaka
    2023Volume 23Issue 2 Pages 47-87
    Published: 2023
    Released on J-STAGE: February 28, 2025
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    The material culture of displacement among East African pastoral internally displaced persons (IDPs) is a subject that has not been addressed by the literature. In a survey of household possessions across three ethnic groups in Northern Kenya (Samburu, Tugen, and Ilchamus), the findings revealed that the natives from each group attempted to save a minimum set of possessions even in times of displacement, which are strongly linked to their owners’ bodies when fleeing. Using an ontological perspective and post-plural comparison, the results of East African pastoralists were compared with South American natives. Consequently, the perspective of savanna nomadic pastoralists can be described as a remarkable merger of their views of humans, things, and animals. In South American natives, however, the three categories are isolated and rendered spatially invisible from each other. From the viewpoint of humanitarian aid, the material culture of displacement can be seen as an important means of survival that is nurtured by the victims themselves.

    Download PDF (1051K)
  • Why were the Monkeys in Costumes and Family Crests Non-photorealistic?
    Hideshi Ogawa, Haruko Ogawa
    2023Volume 23Issue 2 Pages 89-135
    Published: 2023
    Released on J-STAGE: February 28, 2025
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    Japanese monkeys have been variously regarded as hunting targets, crop raiders, deities, and cheap imitators and depicted in statues, pictures, costumes, and kamon (a Japanese family crest). In contrast to the realistic depictions in pictures, simple objects or designs have been used to represent Japanese monkeys. The kukuri-zaru ornament has been composed of two cloths, widely distributed, and used as a component in ritualsof the koshin faith, as a lucky charm, and a toy. The kukuri-zaru design was illustrated by making the kukuri-zaru ornament simpler, composed of two crescents, drawn on costumes, papers, and sword guards, and popular during the Edo era. Saru-mon (kamon using a monkey motif) consists of one or three kukuri-zaru designs. They are all non-photorealistic because of the abstract perception of the monkeys. Japanese people avoided the frequent use of realistic monkeys in kamon because monkeys are morphologically and phylogenetically close to humans.

    Download PDF (1195K)
back matter
feedback
Top