Phonatory functions were compared among 25 patients with T1 glottic cancer (T1a : 18, T1b : 7) following the combined therapy of laser and radiation, 9 patients with T1-2 following radiation treatment alone, and 40 normal subjects (over 50 years old). Maximum phonation time (sec), air flow rate (ml/sec), vocal velocity index, pitch (Hz), pitch perturbation quotient (%), amplitude perturbation quotient (%), and normalized noise energy (dB) were obtained from the use of a phonatory equipment PS-77 and an acoustic analyser SH-10.
Moreover, phonatory dysfunctions in 6 of 7 patients with T1b glottic cancer were estimated on the basis of extent and depth of laser irradiation, and of post-operative laryngeal findings by fiberscope.
The results were as follows.
1. The mean values of phonatory parameters in normal subjects were MPT : 17.8 sec, AFR : 187 ml/sec, VVI : 45.5, pitch : 147 Hz, PPQ : 1.01%, APQ : 3.34%, and NNE : -11.1 dB respectively.
In comparison with the normal subjects, those values of radiation treatment alone coinsided closely, and those of T1 group indicated distinctly a decline of the aerodynamic functions and a change for the worse of the acoustic characteristics of voices. However, the difference of those parameters were statistically no significant between Tla and Tlb group.
2. After CO
2 laser surgery for T1b, laryngoscopy revealed web formation of the anterior commissure (28%), asynmetry and fibrosis of all affected vocal cords. Degree of the post-operative changes had been affected by the extent more than the depth of laser irradiation in glottis.
3. In T1b group, the mean values of phonatory parameters in the 3 patients with a marked postoperative change were a short MPT (6.2 sec), higher AFR (372 ml/sec) and VVI (104.3), and pitch : 225 Hz, PPQ : 1.79%, APQ : 4.00%, NNE : -5.6 dB, while, those in the 3 with a mild change were MPT : 18.0 sec, AFR : 155 ml/sec, VVI : 34.1, pitch : 146 Hz, PPQ : 0.25%, APQ : 2.56%, NNE : -14.2 dB, respectively.
Because of having the lesion in both vocal cords, CO
2 laser management for T1b glottic cancer has including more complex problems than that for T1a in the insure of favorable post-operative voices. At least, laser irradiation covered wide range of the bilateral vocal cords may be phonetically disadvantage. In the use of CO
2 laser, it is a necessary to control adequately the extent of laser irradiation in a combination with radiation therapy of curative dose.
View full abstract