This paper examined the grammatical ability of 300 Japanese learners. Grammatical ability was operationalized through tasks entailing five grammatical choices. Specifically, this study addressed whether the students chose particular grammatical forms for contextually appropriate reasons and whether the students who made appropriate grammatical choices could use their knowledge in production tasks. Two separate studies (Study 1 and Study 2) were conducted. In Study 1, the students were given imaginary contexts and were asked to choose appropriate sentences and describe reasons for their choices. In Study 2, the students, who were also given imaginary contexts, were asked to complete production tasks; they were also asked to complete the tasks of Study 1. These studies yielded the following three results. First, the mean percentage of appropriate reasons for providing correct answers was 34.4%, which indicated that the students were notably lacking in knowledge of the grammatical choices to be made in context. Second, among the students who provided appropriate reasons, only 38.2% used the forms correctly in the production tasks, which indicated that having appropriate knowledge of grammatical choices was insufficient in itself for effective production. Third, the proficient students were likely to understand the grammatical choices explained in teaching materials, which indicated a positive effect of teaching grammatical choices. Thus, this paper provides evidence to suggest that the students should augment their knowledge of grammatical choices by heightening awareness of context.
View full abstract