日本教育工学雑誌
Online ISSN : 2432-6038
Print ISSN : 0385-5236
教育イノベーションを規定する要因の概観
浜野 保樹中野 照海
著者情報
ジャーナル フリー HTML

1978 年 3 巻 2 号 p. 79-92

詳細
Translated Abstract

This paper gives an overview of educational innovation research and classifies the determinants af-fecting educational innovation processes. After collecting 115 pertinent research reports published in foreign countries as well as in Japan, possible determinants are examined under nine main categories : namely, Determinants for Adoption and lmplementation; Teachers (including,teachers'attitudes toward innovation, sex, age and experience, miscellaneous) ; Learners; Schools (school size, levels of schools, or-ganizational stuctures, principals'leadership, miscellaneous) ; Environment Surrounding School ; Edu-cational Administration ; and Innovation Strategies. After examining the determinants, the following are proposed for future research: 1) It is necessary to differentiate between the two phases of the innovation process, adoption and implementation, and in particular to determine better indices for measuring implementation. 2) There is need to identify better measuring indices for organizational changes rather than those for individual change, since schools are institutions. 3) Since educational innovation, in particular innovation, in schools, is always affected by idiosyncratic factors, and the research results are, accordingly, very specific in nature, it is difficult to derive generalized conclusions from the results. There is need to develop a better research methodology so that the results can be more widely generalized, and hence made applicable to other cases.

References
  • 阿久津喜弘ほか (1978a) 学校・教師の変革をめざして (3). 視聴覚教育,32(4) : 36-41
  • 阿久津喜弘ほか(1978b) 学校・教師の変革をめざして (4). 視聴覚教育,32(5) : 36-40
  • ANDERSON, J.G. (1968) Bureaucracyin Education. The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
  • ATKIN, J.M. (1977) 下からの教育とイソフォーマルな教育.SPoDEK, B. and WALBERG, H. J. 〔編〕佐伯正一,栗田修〔訳〕オープン・ニデュケーション入門,明治図書東京,pp.130-142
  • BALDRIDGE, J.V. (1975) Organizational innovation. In BALDRIDGE, J.V. and DEAL, T. E. (Eds.), Manag-ing Change in Educational Organizations, McCutchan, Berkeley, pp.378-388
  • BALDRIDGE, J.V. and DEAL, T. E. (1975) Overview of change processes in educational organizations. In BALDRIDGE, J.V. and DEAL, T. E. (Eds.), Managing Change in EdtlCational Organizations, McCutchan, Berkeley, pp.1-23
  • BARNES, D. L. (1965) Instructional television. In RoucEK, J.S. (Ed.), Programmed Teaching, Philosophical Library, New York, pp.181-194
  • BERMAN, P. and McLAUGHLIN, M. W. (1974) Federal Programs Supporting Educational Change, Vol. I: A Model of Educational Change. Rand, Santa Monica, CA.
  • BERMAN, P. and PAULY, E.W. (1975) FederalPrograms Supporting Educational Change, Vol. II: Factors Affecting Change Agent Projects. Rand, Santa Monica, CA.
  • BERMAN, P. et al. (1977) Federal Programs Support-ing Educational Change, Vol. VII: Implementation and Continuation. Rand, Santa Monica, CA.
  • BICKEL, R. F. and GILL, F. L. (1972) How to Get New Programs into Elementary Schools, 3: How to Select a New Curriculum. Educational Technology Publications, Englewood Cliffs, N. J.
  • BISHOP, L. K. (1970) Bureaucracy and educational change. Clearing House, 44 : 305-309
  • BRIDGES, E. M. and DEAL, T. E. (1978) Improving the effectiveness of schools. Educ. Technol., 18(2): 23-26
  • BRIDGE, R. G. (1976) Parent participation in school innovations. Teach. Coll. Rec., 77(3): 366-384
  • CALVIN, A. (l96l)Preliminary Reporton theProgramed Textbook Field Studies. Britannica Center for Studies in Learning and Motivation, Chicago
  • CARLSON, R. 0. (1965) Adoption of EdtlCational Innovations. University of Oregon, Oregon
  • CARLSON, R. 0. et al. (1965) Change Processes in the Public Schools. University of Oregon, Oregon
  • CERI (1970) The Management of Innovation in Education. OECD, Paris
  • CERI (1976) New Patterns of Teacher Education and Tasks: Teachers as Innovators. OECD, Paris
  • CHARTERS, W.W. Jr. (1973) Measuring the Implemen-tation of Differentiated Staffing. University of Oregon, Oregon
  • CHARTERS, W.W., Jr. and PELLEGRIN, R. (1973) Barriers to the innovation process: Four case studies of differentiated staffing. Admin. Sci. Quart., 9(1): 3-14.
  • CHASE, F. S. (1966) School change in prospective. In GoonLAD, J.I. (Ed.), The Changing American School, The 65th Yearbook of NSSE, The Uni- versity of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp.271-306
  • CILLIE,F. (1940) Centralization or Decenrtalization: A Study in Educational Adaptation. Teachers College, New York
  • COLEMAN, J.S. et al. (1966a) Medical Innovation: A Diffusion Study.Bobbs-Merrill, New York;小ロ一元,宮本史郎〔訳〕 (1970)阪売戦略と意思決定.ラティス,東京
  • COLEMAN, J.S. et al. (1966b) Equality of Educational Opportunity. U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D. C.
  • CORWIN, R. G. (1972) Strategies for organizational innovation : An empirical comparison. Am. Sociol. Rev., 37: 441-454
  • CORWIN, R. G. (1973) Reform and Organizational Survival. Wiley, New York.
  • CORWIN, R. G. (1974) Education in Crisis. Wiley, New York
  • CORWIN, R. G. (1975) Innovation in organization: The cases of schools. Social. Educ., 48: 1-37
  • CROWTHER, F. (1972) Factors affecting the rate of adoption of the 1971 Alberta Social Studies Curriculum for Elementary Schools. Master's Thesis, University of Alberta
  • DALIN, P. (1973) Case Studies of Educatinal Innovation: IV, Strategies for In加vation in Education. CERI/OECD, Paris
  • DEAL, T. E. et al. (1975) Organizational infuluences on educational innovation. In BALDRIDGE, J.V. and DEAL, T. E. (Eds.), Managing Change in Educational Organizations, McCutchan, Berkeley, pp.109-132
  • DE LANDSHEERE, G. (1974) The causes of the resistance of teachers to Innovation. In OECD (Ed.), The Teacher and Educational Change: A New Role, OECD, Paris, pp.327-360
  • DOWNEY, L. et al. (1975) The Social Studies in Alberta -1975. L. Downey Research Associates, Edmonton, Alberta
  • DUKE, D. (1978) Toward responsibleinnovation. Educ. Forum, XL ll(2): 351-371
  • EIDELL, T. L. and KITCHEL, J. M. (1968) Knowledge Production and Utilization in Educational Administration. University of Oregon, Oregon
  • EVANS, R. I. (1956) An examination of students' attitude toward television as a medium ofinstruction in a psychology cource. J.Appl. Psychol., 40(1): 32-34
  • EVANS, R.I. (1967) Resistance to Innovation in Higher Education. Jossey-Bass, New York
  • EVANS, W. and SCHEFFLER, J. (1973) Degree of Im-plementation : A first approximation. Paper presented at the Meeting of the American Educational Pesearch Association, New Orleans
  • FISHER, K. M. and MACWHINNEY, B. (1976) AV au-totutorial instruction: A review of evaluative Research. AVCR, 24(3): 229ー261
  • FULLAN, M. (1972) Overview of theinnovative process and the user. Interchange, 3(2): 1-43
  • FULLAN, M. and POMFRET, A. (1977) Research on curriculum and instruction implementation. Rev. Educ. Res., 47(1): 335-397
  • GAGNE, R. M. (1970) The Conditions of Learning, 2nd ed. Holt Rinehart and Winston, New York
  • GIACQUINTA, J. B. (1973) The process of organizational change in schools. In KERLINGER, F. N. (Ed.), Review of Research in Education, F. E. Peacock Publishers, Itesca, Ill., pp.178-208
  • GIACQUINTA, J.B. (1975) Status, risk, and receptivity to innovations in complex organizations. Sociol. Educ., 48: 38-58
  • GILL, F. J. and HARTY, H. (1972) How to Get New Programs into Elementary Schools, 2 : Adminis- trator's Plan Book for Curriculum Change. Edu-cational Technology Publications, Englewood Cliffs, N. J.
  • GOODLAD, J.(1970) Behind the Classroom Door. Jones, Ohio
  • GOTKIN, L. G. and GOLDSTEIN, L. S. (1964) Programed Instruction in the schools. In MrLEs, M. B. (Ed.), In加vation in Education, Teachers College, New York, pp.231-248
  • GROSS, N. et al. (1971) Implementing Organizational Innovations. Basic Books, New York; 河野重男他〔訳〕(1973)学校革新への道, 第一法規出版,東京
  • HAGE, J. and AIKEN, M. (1970) Social Change in Complex Organizatz'ons. Random House, New York
  • 浜野保樹(1977 a) 教育イノベーション研究文献集.日本放送教育学会第22回,日本視聴覚教育学会,第14回参考資料
  • 浜野保樹(1977b) 教育イノベーショソ研究動向の分析.日本放送教育学会第22回,日本視聴覚教育学会第14回研究発表論文集,pp.8-9
  • 浜野保樹 (1978) 教育イノベーションと学校組織.ICU教育研究,21号:129-144
  • HAVELOCK, R. G. (1969) Planning for Innovation. University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
  • HAVELOCK, R. G. (1972) Knowledge Utilization and Dissemination: A Bibliography. University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
  • HAVELOCK, R. G. (1973) The Change Agent's Guide to Innovation in Education, Educational Technology Publications, Englewood Cliffs, N. J.
  • 平田賢一ほか (1976) 授業における新しい教授メディアの利用を予測する変数.視聴覚教育研究,7号:40-54
  • HOUSE, E. R. (1974) ThePolitics of Educational Inno-vation. McCutchan, Berkeley
  • HURT, H. T. and TEIGEN, C. W. (1977) The develop- ment of a measure of perceived organizational innovativeness. In RUBEN, B. D. (Ed.), Communication Yearbook 1, Transaction Books, New Brunswick, pp.377-385
  • 今栄国晴 (1976) 教育機器不使用動機の分析.愛知教育大学教育工学センター,研究レポートモノグラフ,第1号:32-37
  • JAMISON, D. T. et al. (1978) The Costs of Educational Media. Sage, Beverly Hills
  • KAHN, A. K. (1968) Adoption and internalization of educational innovations among teachers in the pilot secondary schools of West Pakistan. Ph. D. Thesis, Michigan State University, East Lan-sing
  • KATZ, E. et al. (1963) Traditions of research of the diffusion. Am. Sociol. Rev., 28: 237-253
  • 北岡 武 (1976) 授業における教育機器利用の実態調査と各種教育機器の利用・特性の分析.愛知教育大学教育工学セソター,研究レポートモノグラフ第1号:5-21
  • 北岡 武 (1978) 我国における新しい授業媒体の普及と利用現状.平田賢一ほか,我国における教育イノベーションの普及過程,愛知教育大学教育工学センター, pp.19-32
  • KLINGENBERG, A. J. (1967) A Study of Selected Administrative Behaviors among Admistrators from Innovative and Non-Innovative Public School Districts, AFinal Report. Michigan State Uni-versity, East Lansing
  • LIONBERGER, H.F. (1960) Adoption of New Ideas and Practices. Iowa State.University Press, Ames
  • LIPPITT, R. (1967) The teacher as innovator, seeker and sharer of new practices. In MILLER, R. I. (Ed.), Perspectives on Educational Change, Appleton-Century-Crofts, New York, pp.307-324
  • LUKAS, C. and WOHLLEB, C. (1972) Implementation of Head Start Planned Variation: 1970-1971,Part 1 and 2. Huron Institute, Chicago
  • MAHAN, J.M. and GILL, F. J. (1972) How to Get New Programs into Elementary Schools, 1 : How to Install a New Curriculum. Educational Technology Publications, Englewood Cliffs, N. J.
  • MANN, D. (1976a) Making change happen? Teach. Coll. Rec., 77(3): 313-322
  • MANN, D. (1976b) The politics of training teachers in schools. Teach. Coll. Rec., 77 (3)-: 323-338
  • MANN, D. (1977) Participation, representation, and control.In SCRIBNER, J.D. (Ed.), The Politics of Education, The 76th Yearbook of NSSE, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp.67-93
  • MANN, D. (1978) The user-driven systems and a modest proposal.Teach. Coll. Rec., 79 (3): 389-412
  • McMULLEN, T. (1973) Organization and relations with the school. In CERI {Ed.), Creativity of the School, OECD, Paris-, pp. 62-83
  • MORT, P.R. (1964) Studies on educational innovation from the institute of administrative research : An overview. In MILES, M. B. (Ed.), Innovation in Education, Teachers College, New York, pp.317-329
  • 牟田博光,坂元昂 (1974) 教育における技術革新の規定要因に関する一研究.視聴覚教育研究,6号:23- 35
  • NAUMANN-ETIENNE, M. (1974) Bringing about open education : Strategies for innovation. Ph. D. Thesis, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
  • NELSON, M. and SIEBER, S. D. (1976) Innovations in urban secondary schools. Sch. Rev. February: 213-231
  • ORLOSKY, D. E. and SMITH, B. O. (1972) Educational change: Its origins and characteristics.PhiDelta Kappan, 53(7): 412-413
  • O'TOOLE, J.F., Jr. (1964) Teachers'and principals' attitudes toward programed instruction in the elementary school.AVCR, 12:431-439
  • OWENS, R. G. and STEINHOFF, C.R. (1976) Admin-istering Change in Schools. Prentice-Hall, New York;岸本幸次郎〔監訳〕(1977)学校経営の革新.明治図書東京
  • PELLEGRIN, G. J. (1967) An Analysis of Sources and Processes in Education. University of Oregon, Oregon
  • PINCUS, J. (1974) Incentives for innovation in the public schools. Rev. Educ. Res., 44(1): 113-144
  • RENKER, M. M. and BUCH, S. J. (1972) How to Get New Programs into Elementary Sclwols, 5 : How to Develop a Pupil-Assessment System for a New Curriculum. Educational Technology Publications, Englewood Cliffs, N. J.
  • RENKER, M. M. et al. (1972) How to Get New Programs into Elementary Schools, 4 : How to Use Data to Make Curriculum Installation Decisions. Educational Technology Publications, Englewood Cliffs, N. J.
  • ROGERS, E. M. (1962) Diffusion of Innovations. Free Press, New York;藤竹暁〔訳〕(1966)技術革新の普及過程.培風館,東京
  • ROGERS, E. M. (1965) What are innovators like? In CARLSON, R. O. et al. (Eds.), Change Processes in thePublic Schools, University of Oregon, Oregon, pp.55-61
  • ROGERS, E. M. (1968) The communication of inno- vations in a complex institute. Edttc. Rec., 49: 67-77
  • ROGERS, E. M. (1972) Key concepts and models. In Sow, R.A. and RoGERS, E. M. (Eds.), Inducing Technological Change for Economic Growth and Development, Michigan State University Press, East Lansing, pp.85-101
  • ROGERS, E. M. and AGARWALA-ROGERS, R. (1976) Communication in Organizations. Free Press, New York
  • ROGERS, E. M. and SHOEMAKER, F. F. (1971) Communi-cation of Innovations. Free Press, New York
  • ROGERS, E. M. et al. (1968) Dijfusion of Educational Innovations in the Government Secondary Schools of Thailand. Michigan State University, East Lansing
  • ROSS, D. H. (1955) Measuring institutional quality of school systems. Teach. Coll. Rec., 57: 172-177
  • ROSS, D. H. (1958) Administration for Adaptability. Metropolitan School Study Council, New York
  • RYAN, B. and GROSS, N. C. (1943) The diffusion of hybrid seed corn in two Iowa Communities. Rural Sociol., 8: 15-24
  • SCHRAMM, W. (1977) Big Media Little Media Sage, Beverly Hills
  • SHOEMAKER, F. F. (1971) System variables and educational innovativeness in Thai government secondary schools. Ph.D. Thesis, Michigan State University, East Lansing
  • SIEBER, S. D. (1975) Organizational influences on innovative role. BALDRIDGE, J.V. and DEAL, T. E. (Eds.), Managing Changein Ed1,tcational Organ- izations, McCuthan, Berkley, pp.75-97
  • SILBERMAN, C. E. (1970) Crisis in the Classroom. Random House, New York;山本正〔訳〕(1973)教室の危機サイマル出版会,東京
  • SMITH, L. M. and KEITH, P. M. (1971) Anatomy of Educational Innovation. Wiley, New York
  • SPODEK, B. and MANOLEKES, T. (1977) オープン・エデュケーションにおける教育現場での現職教育. SPODEK, B. and WALBERG, H.J.〔編〕,佐伯正一,栗田 修〔訳〕オープン・エデュケーション入門,明治図書,東京,pp.143-164
  • STOLUROW, L. M. (1962) Implications of current re-search and future trends. J. Educ. Res., 55: 519- 527
  • 椙山正弘 (1975) アメリカ教育の現実.福村出版,東京 TOBIAS, S. (1963) Teachers' attitudes towards pro-gramed instructional terms. J.Program. Instruct., 2: 25-29
  • TOBIAS, S. (1966) Teaching machines and programed instruction. AVCR, 14(1): 99-106
  • TOBIAS, S. (1971) Dimensions of teachers' attitudes toward instructional media. In RIPPLE, R. E. (Ed.), Readings in Learning and Human Abilities, 2nd ed. Harper & Row, New York, 151-156
  • 辻 功 (1964) 日本の教師の放送教育観.放送教育研究集録,10: 136-160
  • 辻 功 (1965) 学校放送受容過程の分析.NHK総合放送文化研究所年報,第10集:147-164
  • WESTLEY, B. H. and JACOBSON, H.K. (1962a) Di-mensions of teachers'attitudes toward instructional television. AVCR, 10: 179-185
  • WESTLEY, B. H. and JACOBSON, H.K. (1962b) Teacher participation and attitudes toward instructional television. AVCR, 10: 328-333
  • WOODS, T. E. (1967) The Administation of Educational Innovation. University of Oregon, Oregon
  • ZALTMAN, G. and DUNCAN, R. (1977) Strategies for Planned Change. Wiley, New York
  • ZALTMAN, G. et al. (1973) Innovations and Organizations. Wilet, New York
  • ZALTMAN, G. et al. (1977) Dynamic Educational Change. Free Press, New York
 
© 1978 日本教育工学会
feedback
Top