Journal of Prosthodontic Research
Online ISSN : 1883-9207
Print ISSN : 1883-1958
ISSN-L : 1883-1958
Original Articles
Maxillary implant overdentures retained by use of bars or locator attachments: 1-year findings from a randomized controlled trial
G. Carina BovenHenny J.A. MeijerArjan VissinkGerry M. Raghoebar
Author information
JOURNAL OPEN ACCESS

2019 Volume 64 Issue 1 Pages 26-33

Details
Abstract

Purpose: Comparison of outcomes of maxillary implant overdentures retained by use of either locator attachments or bars in a 1-year randomized controlled trial.

Methods: Fifty edentulous participants received four maxillary implants. They were allocated to two groups (n = 25) differing in type of prosthetic attachment used to retain the maxillary prosthesis: either locator attachments or bars were applied. After one year, implant and overdenture survival was assessed. Peri-implant hygiene (Plaque-index, presence of calculus), soft tissue conditions (Gingiva-index, Sulcus Bleeding-index and pocket probing depth) and patient satisfaction (oral health impact profile (OHIP-49), denture complaints questionnaire and general satisfaction score (GSS) ) were compared. The peri-implant bone level was estimated using intra-oral radiographs (student T-test).

Results: Implant survival was 96.7% in the locator group and 97.9% in the bar group. No overdentures had to be remade. Patient satisfaction was significantly greater in the bar group when rated by OHIP-49 sum score and by GSS. When comparing the denture complaints questionnaire and the separate OHIP-49 item scores, no significant difference was found. There was not a significant difference in hygiene and soft tissue conditions. Marginal bone loss was estimated 0.58 ± 0.71 mm for locators and 0.31 ± 0.47 mm for bars.

Conclusions: Maxillary overdentures on four implants retained by bars or locators were compared. Bone loss was within an acceptable range for both groups after 1 year. However, less bone was lost in the bar group. Even though both treatment options improved patient satisfaction, bars seem to be particularly beneficial with regard to OHIP-49 sum score.

Content from these authors

This article cannot obtain the latest cited-by information.

© 2019 Japan Prosthodontic Society

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 (CCBY 4.0), which allows users to distribute and copy the material in any format so long as attribution is given to the Japan Prosthodontic Society.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Previous article Next article
feedback
Top