2023 Volume 64 Issue 10 Pages 2450-2456
The combination of two dielectric-magnetic components in the same composite has been shown to significantly improve the effectiveness of electromagnetic (EM) shielding and microwave absorption (MWA) because they have both a combination of high dielectric and magnetic losses and good impedance matching. The novel Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3/Fe3O4 (BNKT/Fe3O4) composite has been successfully synthesized by a two-step method with wide effective absorption bandwidth (EAB = 16 GHz) in the high-frequency (2–18 GHz). It was evident that the MWA efficiency of the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite has been significantly improved compared with pure Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3 or Fe3O4 materials. In addition, the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite could achieve reflection loss (RL = −39.41 dB, ∼99.99% at 10.16 GHz) with a sample thickness optimal (d = 4.7 mm). This work shows that the novel BNKT/Fe3O4 composite has excellent MWA properties, all contributing to a potential candidate in the electromagnetic wave absorption and shielding fields.
Fig. 5 The 3-D projection (magnitude) of scattering coefficients (S11) and (S21) of the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite with different thicknesses (2.9–5.4 mm) (a), (b); The relationship between reflection loss (dB) and the MWA percentage (%) (c); the RL (d) 2-D contour map (e) and 3-D reflection loss (f) of BNKT/Fe3O4 composite with different thicknesses (2.9–5.4 mm).
In the fourth industrial revolution (Industry 4.0), along with the development of 6 G or Internet of Things (IoT) technology, mobile devices and digital information transmission devices are increasingly popular, with fast transmission speeds towards a more convenient, smarter life.1,2) However, the rapid uncontrolled proliferation of these technological devices can lead to potential dangers with severe consequences.3,4) EM wave pollution is inevitable because many electromagnetic waves (EMW) are still being generated by electronic technology equipment, military radar etc., works around us. Electromagnetic interference has become a severe problem for human health, the operation of e-commerce devices, and national security.1,4,5) To solve the above problem, the attenuation and shielding of EMW are essential, and MWA materials are a research direction that has received great attention.
In the past, there have been many traditional MWA materials, but most of them have not met the requirements of practical applications such as strong absorption, wide absorption bandwidth, ease of manufacture in large quantities, and low cost.2) Fortunately, highly efficient MWA composites have been recently developed based on a combination of complex permeability and permittivity components or impedance matching, microstructure, and interface polarization of the absorbers.6,7) In particular, the fabrication of multiferroic composites (including dielectric and magnetic phases) is an excellent way to improve the shielding of EMW and MWA.8,9) In these composites, the dielectric phase acts as a center of polarization, leading to an increase in dielectric loss. On the other hand, the magnetic phase acts as a magnet, which increases the permeability loss. As a consequence, both the magnetic and electrical losses in the multiferroic composites contribute to enhanced microwave absorption.8)
Among lead-free ferroelectric materials perovskite-based type, bismuth sodium titanate Bi0.5Na0.5TiO3 (BNT), bismuth potassium titanate Bi0.5K0.5TiO3 (BKT), and solid solutions based on these compounds seem to be considered as the choice of the most promising material for energy harvesting applications.10,11) It has been reported that BNT ceramics modified with BKT, Bi1/2(Na1−xKx)1/2TiO3 with x = 0.16–0.20, showed improved dielectric properties, due to a rhombohedral–tetragonal morphotropic phase boundary (MPB). This material has a high relative dielectric constant (εr = 1030) and excellent ferroelectric and piezoelectric properties (d33 = 151 pC N−1, d31 = 46.9 pC N−1) were obtained at the optimal composition of x = 0.20.10) So, Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3 (BNKT) has been widely applied in the fields of energy storage and conversion.10,11) Co et al. prepared BNKT by sol-gel method with RL = −21.72 dB (99.9%) found at 13.66 GHz and a thickness of 3.2 mm. The BNKT has been shown able to be used as EM wave shielding, or MWA materials.12) The characterization studies primarily focus on the improvement of the electrical properties as the effect of dopant and co-dopants at A-, B-site of BNKT or dopant BNKT with different perovskite A′B′O3.11) Modifying the BNKT material is a great way to improve dielectric loss and MWA properties, but it does not seem to meet the requirements of practical applications. In the high-frequency range, the permeability of BNKT is relatively low, which is also the limitation of the material and affects its ability to absorb microwaves.12) To optimize the MWA efficiency and expand the absorption bandwidth, combining BNKT with a magnetic component to improve the MWA properties of the composite is necessary.
Ferromagnetic Fe3O4 is a typical magnetic material that has attracted more attention than other similar candidates as iron oxides or ferrite spinel oxides (MFe2O4 with M = Co, Ni, Mg, etc.) because of its superior magnetic properties, electronic conductivity, and biocompatibility.13,14) Moreover, superparamagnetic properties and other intrinsic properties, such as a high surface area to volume ratio, make Fe3O4 material and Fe3O4-based composites are used extensively in the research on EM wave shielding and MWA in recent scientific advances, as a component contributing to the magnetic loss of electromagnetic radiation in the GHz range.13,15–18)
Herein, Fe3O4 ferromagnetic material was proposed to combine with Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3 ferroelectric material by a two-step method to improve the magnetic loss, widen the absorption bandwidth and effective MWA of the fabricated novel composite. Accordingly, this article is considered the first report on synthesising multiferroic material in the manner mentioned above. The MWA efficiency expressed by reflection loss mapping was also compared and showed a difference with other material samples. In addition, the MWA mechanism of the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite is also clearly shown.
The chemicals used here are commercial products supplied by Sigma - Aldrich: bismuth nitrate pentahydrate [Bi(NO3)3·5H2O, ≥98%], acetic acid (CH3COOH, ≥99%), titanium (IV) isopropoxide (C12H28O4Ti, ≥97%), ferrous chloride tetrahydrate (FeCl2·4H2O, ≥99%), potassium nitrate (KNO3, ≥99%), acetylacetone (CH3COCH2COCH3, ≥99%), potassium hydroxide (KOH, ≥99%), sodium nitrate (NaNO3, ≥99%), and ferric chloride hexahydrate (FeCl3·6H2O, ≥99%).
2.2 Preparation of Bi1/2(Na0.80K0.20)1/2TiO3 powdersThe Bi1/2(Na0.80K0.20)1/2TiO3 particles were prepared by chemical method (sol-gel).19,20) First, the starting materials: 2.425 g Bi(NO3)3·5H2O, 0.132 g KNO3, and 0.510 g NaNO3 were added to a beaker containing 20 mL acetic acid and 5 mL DI water until completely dissolved. An excess amount of KNO3; NaNO3 was added to compensate for the loss during heating and annealing, as shown in previous works.19) After that, 5 mL acetylacetone and 3 mL titanium isopropoxide were added to the solutions. Using a magnetic stirrer with heating support, the precursor solution mixture was stirred continuously for 5 h at 70°C. Then, the beaker containing the above solution was dried overnight in a vacuum oven at 80°C. The obtained product continues to be calcined at 700°C for 1 h and then finely ground with a mortar.
2.3 Preparation of BNKT/Fe3O4 compositesThe BNKT/Fe3O4 composite was prepared by chemical method (two-step method). First, the prepared BNKT powder was added to 20 mL of DI water before stirring for 30 min. Next, 5.46 g FeCl3·6H2O and 2.03 g FeCl2·4H2O were added to 50 mL of DI water. After that, the salt solution mixture (Fe2+/Fe3+) was magnetically stirred at room temperature for 2 h before adding the BNKT solution. And then, the above solution mixture was adjusted to pH = 12 by slowly adding KOH solution (2 M) with continuous magnetic stirring. The black precipitated product was collected by magnetic separation (permanent magnet), washed several times with DI water, ethanol and then centrifuged. Finally, dry the product at 60°C for 24 h in a vacuum oven, and grind it finely with a mortar to obtain BNKT/Fe3O4 composite.
In addition, to ensure more accurate quantification of the mass fraction of each component (BNKT and Fe3O4) present in the composites, we separately fabricated pure Fe3O4 by simple co-precipitation method before making the samples combination. The process of making pure Fe3O4 samples is similar to that of composite samples, but BNKT is not added during the reaction. To ensure that the formation of Fe3O4 is pure and free of other components, thermal annealing and sample storage are important. The process of incubation of samples in a vacuum drying oven at a low temperature of 60°C and storing samples in a vacuum bag is to minimize the oxidation of Fe3O4 to Fe2O3 in the air. The resulting mass of the pure Fe3O4 product is practically completely determined. From there, the actual quantification of BNKT needs to be added during the assembly process, ensuring the correct component ratio.
2.4 MeasurementsThe crystalline structures of BNKT, Fe3O4 and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite were characterized by XRD (D5005 Diffractometer, Bruker, Cu Kα). Scanning electron microscope (SEM, S-4800, Hitachi) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) analysis were used to investigate the morphology and reveal the prepared samples’ elemental composition and chemical properties, respectively. The magnetic hysteresis loops of BNKT, Fe3O4 and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite were analyzed by a vibrating sample magnetometer (VSM, Lakeshore 7404, US). The MWA properties of the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite were determined by the MWA measurement system using the transmission line method. This system consists of a vector network analyzer (VNA, PNA-X N5242A, Keysight) connected to the coaxial waveguide and the prepared sample (coaxial ring type) placed inside. Specifically, the fabricated BNKT/Fe3O4 composite material is mixed with paraffin wax (by the mass ratio of 50%) and then heat pressed to form coaxial rings. These coaxial rings’ outer and inner diameters are ϕout = 7.0 mm and ϕin = 3.05 mm, respectively. The collected data parameters are S matrices (S11 = S22, S21 = S12) in the high-frequency range from 2 to 18 GHz. Use the Nicolson-Ross-Weir (NRW) method to extract the input impedance and calculate the MWA efficiency.
Figure 1 shows the XRD patterns of pure Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3, Fe3O4 and their composites powder in the 2θ ranges of 20°–75°. The fabricated Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3 powder sample has characteristic peaks for perovskite structure, consistent with PDF:01-072-8109. The fabricated BNKT sample did not appear any strange peak picks, this result indicated that the sample did not have any secondary phase or other impurities, which is said to be consistent with previously published studies.21,22) The formation of the MPB (tetragonal - rhombohedral phases) of Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3 sample was demonstrated when the characteristic diffraction peaks (002)/(200) were observed (2θ = 46°–47°).22–25) Figure 1 shows nine diffraction peaks: (111), (220), (311), (222), (400), (422), (511), (440) and (533) at 2θ: 18.4°, 30.3°, 35.7°, 37.35°, 43.4°, 53.9°, 57.5°, 63.1°, and 74.62°, respectively. According to PDF: 01-071-6339, they are believed to be the planes of the Fe3O4 sample.
XRD patterns of samples: pure Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3, Fe3O4 powders and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite.
The diffraction peaks of the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite, which can be indexed as Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3 (denoted by ◆) or Fe3O4 (denoted by ●) without any additional phase detected. This proves that BNKT/Fe3O4 composites have been successfully prepared by a simple co-precipitation method. No significant difference was found in the XRD spectrum of the BNKT component of the composite sample compared with the pure BNKT sample. This means that during the fabrication process of the composite, the crystal structure of BNKT is stable enough to meet the fabrication requirements. According to calculations, the amount of Fe3O4 is more than that of BNKT in composite (3 times), so the intensity of characteristic peaks of BNKT component also has a weakening.26)
Figure 2 shows the SEM images of Fe3O4 and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite samples. The pure Fe3O4 has a spherical shape, quite uniform size, and tends to agglomerate into a cluster of particles (Fig. 2(a)). For the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite, the small spherical particles indicated as Fe3O4 are scattered around the surface of the BNKT particles with larger sizes. It can be seen that the BNKT powder used in the co-precipitation process has significantly reduced the aggregation of Fe3O4 particles. As a result, the interface between the dielectric and magnetic phases is improved dramatically (Fig. 2(b)). From the XRD, and SEM results, that can be confirmed that the Fe3O4 particles were successfully prepared and adhered to the surface of the BNKT particles. For SEM images, Fiji software was used to estimate the corresponding grain size distributions of Fe3O4 and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite.2,27) The pure Fe3O4 sample showed a relatively narrow particle size distribution and about 20.91 nm of average grain size (D), as shown in the insets Fig. 2(a). After combining the two components BNKT and Fe3O4, the particle size distribution has widened (the insets in Fig. 2(a)) and the average particle size has also increased to about 57.73 nm. The BNKT/Fe3O4 composite material showed significantly improved particle dispersion. Compared with Fe3O4, the composite sample shows a closer contact between the BNKT and Fe3O4 phases, which increases the polarization interface loss.2)
SEM images of samples: pure Fe3O4 powders (a) and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite (b). The insets are the corresponding grain size distributions of the Fe3O4 powders and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite.
The elemental composition and chemical properties of the pure Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3 and the Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3/Fe3O4 composite are shown by the EDX analysis integration as shown in Fig. 3. Figure 3(a) showed that all the expected elements such as Bi, K, Na, Ti and O were found. Furthermore, in addition to the chemical elements mentioned above, the element Fe is also found in the EDX spectrum of the Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3/Fe3O4 composite (Fig. 3(b)). It proves that the EDX results also provide evidence for the successful synthesis of Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3/Fe3O4 mixture, which is consistent with the results of XRD and SEM.
EDX spectra of samples: pure Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3 (a) and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite (b).
The magnetic hysteresis (M-H) loops of pure Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3, Fe3O4 particles, and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite were measured, shown in Fig. 4. The magnetization curves in Fig. 4(a)–(c) indicated the saturation magnetization (Ms), residual magnetization (Mr) and coercivity (Hc) of samples. The large Ms of the sample is beneficial for magnetic storage and magnetic loss during microwave energy dissipation. Therefore, it can be said that the MWA efficiency of the materials is closely related to their Ms value of them. The Ms value of BNKT/Fe3O4 (about 35.56 emu.g−1) is lower than that of pure Fe3O4 (46.25 emu.g−1). The decrease in Ms of the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite is attributed to two main reasons: (i) the reduced mass ratio of Fe3O4 particles (the main component) and (ii) the amount of BNKT powder which has an almost negligible magnetic contribution compared to Fe3O4 - the main component. However, it is clear that BNKT mixed with Fe3O4 significantly improved the Ms value, which is expected to strengthen the MWA efficiency of the composite. In addition, the Hc of the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite is higher than that of Fe3O4, which may be due to the sizeable magneto-crystalline anisotropy in the composite. The increase in Hc can be traced back to the residual stresses, the amount of BNKT introduced, and defects created during the synthesis of composite materials.8)
Magnetic hysteresis loops of pure Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3 (a); BNKT/Fe3O4 composite (b) and Ms, Hc, and Mr values of pure Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3; Fe3O4 powders and BNKT/Fe3O4 composite (c), (d). The insets are samples Bi1/2(Na0.8K0.2)1/2TiO3, BNKT/Fe3O4 composite with magnet, and the local magnification image of M-H loops.
The MWA efficiency of the BNKT/Fe3O4 mixture was determined by the wire method through a vector network analyzer in the high frequency (2–18 GHz). From the data parameters of the matrix S (S11 and S21) measured by the instrument, the RL of the composite samples with different thicknesses was calculated by the NRW method, using the following equations:13,28)
\begin{equation} RL_{\text{(dB)}} = 20\log |(Z_{\textit{in}} - Z_{0})/(Z_{\textit{in}} + Z_{0})| \end{equation} | (1) |
\begin{equation} \Gamma = (Z_{\textit{in}} - Z_{0})/(Z_{\textit{in}} + Z_{0}) \end{equation} | (2) |
\begin{equation} Z_{\textit{in}} = Z_{0}\sqrt{\mu_{r}/\varepsilon_{r}} \tanh [j(2\pi fd)/c\sqrt{\mu_{r}\varepsilon_{r}}] \end{equation} | (3) |
Where Zin is the normalized input impedance of the absorber, and Z0 (= 376.7 Ohm) is the impedance of free space. μr and are the relative complex permeability and permittivity, j is the imaginary unit, f is the frequency of an incident wave, d is the thickness of the sample, c is the speed of the EMW in free space and Γ is the reflection coefficient. Writing the sum and the difference of the scattering coefficients as follows:28)
\begin{equation} \text{V}_{1} = \text{S}_{21} + \text{S}_{11};\ \text{V}_{2} = \text{S}_{21} - \text{S}_{11}; \end{equation} | (4) |
And if:
\begin{equation} \text{X} = (1 - \text{V}_{1}\text{V}_{2})/(\text{V}_{1} - \text{V}_{2}) \end{equation} | (5) |
Then it can be shown that Γ may be obtained from the scattering coefficients since:
\begin{equation} \Gamma = \text{X} \pm \sqrt{\text{X}^{2} - 1} \end{equation} | (6) |
The appropriate sign is chosen so that |Γ| ≤ 1. Figure 5(a)–(b) shows the 3-D projection (magnitude) of scattering coefficients (S11) and (S21) of the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite with different thicknesses (2.9–5.4 mm).
The 3-D projection (magnitude) of scattering coefficients (S11) and (S21) of the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite with different thicknesses (2.9–5.4 mm) (a), (b); The relationship between reflection loss (dB) and the MWA percentage (%) (c); the RL (d) 2-D contour map (e) and 3-D reflection loss (f) of BNKT/Fe3O4 composite with different thicknesses (2.9–5.4 mm).
The relationship between reflection loss (dB) and the microwave absorption percentage (%) is given in Fig. 5(c).29) Accordingly, at the reflection loss value of −10 dB and −20 dB, the rate of MWA is 90% and 99%, respectively. Usually, we are interested in RL values less than −10 dB because 90% is considered a criterion for evaluating a material that can be a microwave absorber or not. The material with a lower RL below −20 dB and a wide absorption bandwidth is a candidate for excellent wave absorbers. The thickness of the sample is a factor of interest because it also greatly affects the reflection loss of the material.3,13) Figure 5 shows the RL (d) 2-D contour map (e) of BNKT/Fe3O4 composite with different thicknesses (2.9–5.4 mm). It can be seen that all samples of different thicknesses have a maximum RL of less than −10 dB, and many samples have achieved RL values lower than −20 dB. That indicates the ability to MWA excellent of composite samples with wide effective absorption bandwidth. In the X-band region, the samples exhibit higher EMW absorption efficiency than other bands, such as samples with thicknesses of 4.35 mm and 5.40 mm, the value of the maximum RL is −37.29 dB (at 11.20 GHz) and −36.88 dB (at 8.39 GHz) (>99.9%), respectively. Especially with the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite sample, which has a thickness of 4.70 mm, the maximum reflected loss value (RLmax) it can achieve is −39.41 dB (∼99.99%) at 10.16 GHz and EAB of 16 GHz (2–18 GHz). As the thickness increases, the RL increases peak absorption intensity, and the peak position moves to a lower frequency. Thus, it is possible to change the thickness of the composite sample to change the ability to absorb radar waves. However, increasing the thickness too much will affect of the material impedance, consume it, and possibly reduce its ability to absorb EMW. Therefore, the optimal absorption layer thickness of a wave absorbing material must always satisfy two conditions: phase condition and shift-length effect.1,3) Figure 5(f) shows the 3-D reflection loss of BNKT/Fe3O4 composite with different thicknesses (2.9–5.4 mm). It can be concluded that BNKT/Fe3O4 had a better microwave absorbing performance than other reports with the single phase Fe3O4, Bi0.5(Na0.8K0.2)0.5TiO3, BaTiO3 or composites such as Fe3O4/BaTiO3, Fe3O4@BaTiO3/RGO and BaFe12O19@Fe3O4.9,12,17,30–33) The MWA capacity of some materials and composites is listed in Table 1.
The combination of oscillations of two components of electric and magnetic fields perpendicular to each other has created EMW that propagates through space.34) In this work, the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite material absorbs EMW generated by interacting with not only one but two fields (electrical and magnetic fields) to promote light-matter interactions in the region 2–18 GHz of the EM spectrum, which is an effective method to create EMW absorbing materials. Based on the above discussion and analysis, conclusions can be drawn about the main possible EMW absorption mechanisms of BNKT/Fe3O4 composites. Firstly, the resonance results from dielectric loss of BNKT and magnetic loss of Fe3O4 play an integral part in enhancing the MWA ability. The magnetic loss of Fe3O4 nanoparticles came from the eddy current loss (frequency: 8–18 GHz) and the natural resonance (frequency: 2–8 GHz). Secondly, the unique structure, nanometer size of the BNKT, Fe3O4 component phases or the anchoring of the Fe3O4 particles on the BNKT surface leads to impedance matching, multiple reflections, scattering and refraction of the EMW in the BNKT/Fe3O4 composite material, which results in improved EM attenuation. In addition, the dielectric loss also derived from the defects causing dielectric polarization and interface polarization (BNKT and Fe3O4). The increased dielectric loss resulted in improving the EM absorption efficiency of the material synthesis of BNKT/Fe3O4.
The novel Bi1/2(Na0.80K0.20)1/2TiO3/Fe3O4 composite was prepared by a chemical method (two-step), a combination of sol-gel and co-precipitation methods. The X-ray diffraction measurement results show that the characteristic diffraction peaks with a distinct two-phase structure attributed to BNKT and Fe3O4, confirming that the composite has been fabricated successfully. The Fe3O4 particles with a grain size of about 20.91 nm were scattered around the BNKT particles. The combination of two electrical and magnetic components (corresponding to BNKT and Fe3O4) leads to changes in structure and morphology but also in the properties of Bi1/2(Na0.80K0.20)1/2TiO3/Fe3O4 composite compared with the original pure components. The significantly enhanced MWA efficiency of composites is attributed to a combination of large dielectric loss, magnetic loss, and good impedance matching, as well as an improvement in interface polarization between components. In particular, when stuffed Bi1/2(Na0.80K0.20)1/2TiO3/Fe3O4 with 50% paraffin to create a mixture of BNKT/Fe3O4/paraffin, it has proven itself to be a good candidate for applications in EM shielding or MWA. With thickness d = 4.7 mm, the Bi1/2(Na0.80K0.20)1/2TiO3/Fe3O4 composite sample showed the maximum reflection loss RLmax = −39.41 dB (>99.9%) at the frequency f = 10.16 GHz. More importantly, the sample can cover almost the entire measuring frequency from 2 to 18 GHz with effective absorption bandwidth EAB = 16 GHz. Therefore, the Bi1/2(Na0.80K0.20)1/2TiO3/Fe3O4 composite with a simple fabrication process, large quantity, and low cost are said to have excellent prospects for developing superior microwave absorption devices and technologies, which can be applied to solve big and really urgent problems in reality.
Nguyen Dang Co, ID VNU.2021.NCS.06, thanks The Development Foundation of Vietnam National University, Hanoi for sponsoring this research. Nguyen Dang Co was funded by the Master, PhD Scholarship Programme of Vingroup Innovation Foundation (VINIF), code VINIF.2022.TS.016. This research has been done under the research project QG.21.31 “Study and fabrication equipment to support monitoring, warning, and control of river water salinity for agriculture and response to climate change” of Vietnam National University, Hanoi.