Reviews in Agricultural Science
Online ISSN : 2187-090X
Metabolic and Volatile Changes as Candidate Freshness Indicators in Fresh and Minimally Processed Culinary Herbs
Nahar Ashrafun, Kasumi Nakagawa, Manasikan Thammawong, Kohei Nakano
Author information
JOURNAL FREE ACCESS FULL-TEXT HTML
Supplementary material

2026 Volume 14 Issue 4 Pages 46-71

Details
Abstract

Fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs are valued for their aroma, flavor, appearance, and bioactive composition, but their postharvest quality can decline rapidly during storage, handling, and minimal processing. Freshness loss involves visible symptoms such as wilting, discoloration, browning, and decay, as well as internal biochemical, physiological, microbial, and volatile changes that may not be fully captured by conventional visual or sensory assessment. This review synthesizes current knowledge on freshness-related quality attributes, postharvest deterioration processes, and metabolic and volatile profiling approaches in culinary herbs. It summarizes major quality domains, including visual quality and marketability-related changes, sensory acceptability, nutritional and biochemical composition, and volatile composition and aroma quality. It also considers the main postharvest and minimal-processing processes involved in freshness loss, including physiological deterioration, oxidative and membrane-related stress, chilling and wounding responses, microbial activity, and physiological and sensory deterioration induced by unsuitable package atmospheres. By organizing metabolic and volatile changes within a validation-oriented framework for freshness-indicator development, this review emphasizes that storage-responsive compounds should not be treated as indicators by default. Instead, candidate metabolites, volatiles, and volatile fingerprints should be evaluated according to their freshness relevance, linkage to practical quality endpoints, evidence strength, and applicability within defined herb species, processing conditions, and storage contexts. The reviewed evidence indicates that metabolic and volatile changes are most useful when interpreted alongside practical quality outcomes rather than as isolated chemical signals. This perspective can support the development of physiologically interpretable and context-specific freshness indicators and guide future predictive tools for postharvest decision-making in fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs.

1. Introduction

Fresh culinary herbs are widely used as flavoring ingredients, garnishes, salad components, and sources of characteristic aroma in domestic and commercial food preparation. Their value is not limited to sensory contribution, because many culinary herbs also contain diverse bioactive compounds, including phenolics, flavonoids, terpenoids, sulfur-containing compounds, and essential-oil constituents. These compounds contribute to aroma, color, antioxidant activity, antimicrobial potential, and broader functional value. Culinary spices and herbs have been reviewed as important sources of bioactive compounds with relevance to food quality and human nutrition [1]. Aromatic herbs have also been discussed as sources of antioxidant and antimicrobial compounds with applications in food and related fields [2]. More broadly, culinary herbs and spices are recognized for their global use, nutritional contribution, and health-related value [3]. Because fresh herbs are often used in small quantities to deliver intense aroma and flavor, even subtle deterioration in appearance, tissue condition, aroma quality, or volatile composition can substantially reduce their culinary and commercial value.

This review focuses on intact fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs, with particular attention to freshness-related metabolic and volatile changes. In this review, “minimally processed culinary herbs” refers to fresh herb tissues that have undergone one or more limited preparation operations, such as trimming, cutting, washing, sanitizing, surface dewatering after washing, or packaging, while retaining their fresh-like characteristics and remaining metabolically active. “Fresh-cut culinary herbs” are considered a subset of minimally processed herbs and specifically refer to products in which the edible tissues have been cut, chopped, or otherwise physically reduced in size. Thus, the review includes intact fresh leaves, shoots, sprigs, and bunches, as well as washed, trimmed, packaged, or fresh-cut herb products. Dried, cooked, frozen, fermented, or otherwise extensively processed herb products are outside the principal scope, although selected evidence concerning their chemical composition may be used as supporting background where relevant.

Relevant concepts from the broader literature on fresh-cut and minimally processed fruits and vegetables are used selectively when they help explain postharvest deterioration, minimal-processing stress, biomarker interpretation, or validation approaches. However, the primary emphasis remains on culinary herbs rather than fresh-cut produce more broadly. This scope is important because the quality of fresh and minimally processed herbs depends on the combined maintenance of visual, sensory, biochemical, microbial, and volatile attributes.

Maintaining freshness in culinary herbs is challenging because harvested leaves and shoots remain metabolically active after harvest. They continue to undergo water loss, respiration, senescence, oxidative stress, pigment degradation, membrane damage, microbial interactions, and volatile changes. These processes can lead to wilting, discoloration, browning, chilling injury, aroma loss, off-odor development, spoilage, and nutritional or biochemical change. These challenges are especially important in fresh and minimally processed herbs because trimming, cutting, washing, surface dewatering after washing, packaging, and storage can accelerate physiological deterioration and increase susceptibility to microbial and biochemical quality loss. Reviews on fresh and minimally processed fruits and vegetables have shown that shelf-life maintenance depends on controlling physiological deterioration, microbial activity, and quality loss through appropriate postharvest and preservation strategies [4]. Processing and packaging hurdles are also important for maintaining the quality and safety of fresh-cut produce [5]. Although much of this broader evidence comes from fruits and vegetables, the same concepts are relevant to delicate leafy herbs because their marketability depends on maintaining both visual freshness and aroma quality.

Freshness in culinary herbs is multidimensional. It includes visual appearance, texture, aroma, flavor, biochemical composition, microbial status, shelf life, and consumer acceptability. Conventional assessment methods such as visual inspection, marketability scoring, color evaluation, wilting assessment, decay scoring, and sensory judgment remain essential because they reflect practical commercial acceptance. However, these approaches mainly describe visible or perceived quality and may not fully explain the internal metabolic, biochemical, microbial, or volatile processes that precede or accompany quality loss. Biomarker-based studies in fresh-cut produce emphasize that biochemical, microbial, sensory, and external quality changes should be interpreted together when evaluating quality and safety [6]. Therefore, practical freshness assessment in culinary herbs requires integration of visible quality outcomes with internal physiological, metabolic, volatile, and microbial changes.

Metabolomics and volatile profiling provide complementary routes for understanding freshness loss beyond external appearance. In postharvest systems, metabolomic platforms can profile compounds related to quality traits and support the discovery of metabolic markers for chemical phenotyping and storage decisions [7]. For culinary herbs, this approach is relevant because freshness loss may involve antioxidant depletion, osmoprotectant accumulation, pigment degradation, energy imbalance, membrane injury, or senescence-related metabolic shifts. Volatile profiling is equally important because herb value depends strongly on characteristic aroma and the absence of off-odors. Electronic nose systems and related non-destructive technologies can detect volatile fingerprints associated with freshness loss or spoilage and are increasingly used for early postharvest quality monitoring [8]. These approaches can therefore provide useful information on freshness-related changes, especially when they are interpreted together with practical quality outcomes.

Despite increasing research on postharvest quality, metabolomics, volatile profiling, and preservation technologies, evidence remains fragmented for fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs. Previous reviews relevant to this topic have mainly emphasized herb/spice bioactive composition, essential-oil chemistry, aroma constituents, and health-related properties [1, 2, 3], or preservation approaches and general postharvest handling in fresh and minimally processed fruits and vegetables [4, 5]. These areas provide important background, but they have not consistently examined how reported storage-responsive metabolites and volatiles should be evaluated as candidate freshness indicators in culinary-herb contexts. A central challenge is that many compounds may change during storage, chilling exposure, minimal processing, or postharvest treatment, but not all storage-responsive changes are necessarily useful freshness indicators. For a chemical signal to have practical indicator value, it should be related to a defined freshness problem and linked to relevant quality outcomes such as visual decline, aroma loss, off-odor formation, chilling injury, microbial spoilage, sensory rejection, or shelf-life limitation.

In this review, validation is considered in terms of whether candidate metabolites, volatile fingerprints, or related chemical signals are relevant to freshness, linked to practical quality endpoints, supported by appropriate evidence, and applicable within defined herb species, processing conditions, and storage contexts. Analytical feasibility is also considered in relation to their potential use in monitoring or predictive freshness assessment. The relationship among postharvest and minimal-processing stress, physiological deterioration, metabolic and volatile responses, and validation of candidate freshness indicators is summarized schematically in Figure 1.

This review examines freshness loss in fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs with emphasis on metabolic and volatile changes associated with postharvest deterioration. Although previous studies have described herb bioactive composition, aroma chemistry, postharvest handling, and preservation strategies, less attention has been given to the criteria by which storage-responsive metabolites and volatiles can be interpreted as freshness indicators. This review therefore integrates evidence on herb quality attributes, deterioration processes, and chemical profiling approaches within a validation-oriented perspective. Rather than treating chemical changes during storage as indicators by default, it considers their relevance in relation to defined freshness problems, practical quality endpoints, evidence strength, and herb- or processing-specific context. This perspective provides a basis for distinguishing general metabolic and volatile responses from candidate indicators with potential value for practical and predictive freshness assessment.

Figure 1: Validation-oriented framework for evaluating candidate freshness indicators in fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs. The framework shows how postharvest and minimal-processing stress can lead to physiological deterioration, metabolic and volatile responses, and candidate freshness-related signals. These signals should be evaluated for freshness relevance, linkage to practical quality endpoints, reproducibility or evidence strength, and applicability within defined herb species, processing conditions, and storage contexts before they are interpreted as practical freshness indicators. Predictive freshness assessment is shown as a conditional application requiring sufficient endpoint-linked and context-supported evidence.

2. Review scope and literature selection

This review was designed as a targeted narrative review with PRISMA-style documentation of the literature-selection process. The PRISMA-style documentation was used to improve transparency in reporting source identification, deduplication, relevance assessment, exclusion, and inclusion, but the review was not designed as a full systematic review. Relevant information from retained sources was extracted using a structured evidence-record approach and synthesized narratively because the aim was to develop a conceptual and validation-oriented interpretation of metabolic and volatile changes as candidate freshness indicators.

No lower publication-year limit was imposed; literature published up to the final search date of 21 May 2026 was considered. The earliest source retained in the final synthesis was published in 1993. Sources were identified using Google Scholar, ScienceDirect, PubMed, publisher databases, relevant journal platforms, manual screening of reference lists from key papers, and a working archive of downloaded full-text records. Search terms combined herb-specific terms with postharvest, freshness, metabolomic, volatile, sensory, microbial, and shelf-life concepts. Herb-focused searches were supplemented by manual reference-list screening and targeted retrieval of selected non-herb model and methodological sources relevant to freshness-indicator development. Records were screened and assessed for relevance by one reviewer using the inclusion and exclusion criteria summarized in Supplementary Table S1. Initial relevance assessment considered titles, abstracts, introductions, and conclusions. Downloaded full-text records were then examined to confirm eligibility, and all retained full-text PDFs were examined during evidence extraction.

For each retained source, relevant information was extracted using a structured evidence-record approach. Extracted information included reference details, source type, herb or product type, storage or treatment condition, measured quality domain, metabolic or volatile variables, analytical method, validation endpoint, evidence role, and relevance to the review framework. The 58 retained sources were classified according to their primary role in the narrative synthesis as direct herb-specific evidence (n = 36), supporting non-herb model evidence (n = 3), general methodological or conceptual evidence (n = 13), or supporting physiological or microbial-context evidence (n = 6). This classification was used to distinguish primary herb-specific evidence from supporting model, methodological, or contextual evidence when interpreting the strength and directness of support in Table 3.

The overall literature-selection process is summarized in the PRISMA-style flow diagram in Figure 2, and detailed exclusion categories are provided in Supplementary Table S2. In brief, the working evidence archive initially contained 184 records. After removal of 75 duplicate, overlapping, or non-unique records, 109 records were screened and assessed for relevance. Of these, 51 records were excluded because they did not meet the review scope or did not provide sufficient relevance to freshness-indicator development. The remaining 58 sources were retained for the final narrative synthesis.

Quantitative meta-analysis was not performed. Here, quantitative meta-analysis refers to statistical pooling of numerical results across comparable studies. Statistical pooling was not appropriate because the retained sources differed in herb species, storage conditions, treatments, analytical methods, measured compound classes, and freshness endpoints. Therefore, the evidence was synthesized narratively rather than statistically. No review protocol was registered before conducting this review. Independent screening by multiple reviewers, formal quality assessment, and risk-of-bias assessment were not performed because the review was designed as a targeted narrative synthesis.

Figure 2: PRISMA-style literature-selection flow for the targeted narrative review. The diagram summarizes record identification, duplicate and overlapping record removal, relevance assessment, exclusion, and inclusion of sources retained for narrative synthesis. Detailed exclusion categories and the evidence-type classification of the 58 retained sources are provided in Supplementary Table S2.

3. Important quality attributes of fresh culinary herbs

3.1 Visual quality and marketability-related changes

Visual quality is one of the first criteria used to judge the freshness and marketability of culinary herbs. Fresh herbs are commonly sold as leaves, sprigs, shoots, bunches, or minimally processed products; therefore, green appearance, uniformity, tissue turgor, and the absence of visible defects are important for consumer and commercial acceptance [9, 10].

Water loss after harvest reduces cell turgor and can cause limpness, flaccidity, shriveling, and wilting. These changes can rapidly reduce the visual appeal and marketability of delicate leafy herbs and are strongly influenced by storage temperature, relative humidity, air movement, handling, and packaging conditions [10, 11]. In this review, turgor loss and wilting are considered visible manifestations of declining hydration status rather than texture in the conventional sensory or mechanical sense used for firmer fruits and vegetables.

Color deterioration is another major cause of reduced marketability, although its occurrence and severity depend on the herb species and storage conditions. Basil is particularly sensitive to chilling temperatures and may develop darkening, browning, necrosis, and tissue collapse during low-temperature storage [10, 12]. In fresh-cut cilantro, package atmosphere can influence visual quality, aroma retention, and off-odor development, indicating that acceptable external appearance does not necessarily ensure the maintenance of aroma quality [13].

Overall visual acceptability and marketability therefore integrate observable characteristics such as greenness, discoloration, wilting, visible injury, and general appearance. However, culinary herbs are valued particularly for their characteristic aroma and flavor, and visual quality alone does not fully represent their freshness. Visual and marketability-related parameters should consequently be interpreted together with sensory, biochemical, volatile, and microbial outcomes. In this review, these observable parameters provide practical freshness endpoints against which candidate metabolic and volatile indicators can be evaluated. The main conventional parameters used to assess freshness and marketability are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1: Conventional quality parameters used to assess freshness and marketability in fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs

Quality domain Main parameters Freshness information Common assessment approach Key limitation Ref.
Overall visual acceptability Freshness score, appearance, marketability, saleability/rejection score Overall commercial acceptability based on visible quality and defects Visual rating scale; marketability or rejection scoring Subjective; may miss early biochemical or aroma-related deterioration [14] [15] [16]
Leaf color and yellowing Greenness, yellowing, discoloration, dullness Senescence-related color loss and reduced visual appeal Visual color scale; colorimetry or other instrumental color assessment Color is important for acceptance but does not fully represent aroma, flavor, or nutritional quality [14] [15] [17]
Surface defects and browning Brown spots, blackening, bruising, cut-edge browning, visible damage Tissue injury, enzymatic browning, handling damage, or physiological disorder Visual defect score; browning score; colorimetry; image-based inspection Defects show visible quality loss but may not identify the underlying cause [14] [18] [19]
Wilting and turgor loss Limpness, flaccidity, loss of turgidity, shriveling Water-status decline and reduced structural freshness Visual wilting/turgor score; texture or firmness assessment Strongly affected by storage humidity, packaging, handling, and commodity type [11] [14] [15]
Weight loss and dehydration Mass loss, drying, wrinkling, dehydration symptoms Transpiration-related physical deterioration during storage Gravimetric weight-loss measurement Does not directly describe aroma, microbial status, or biochemical freshness [11] [14] [15]
Texture and tissue integrity Firmness, crispness, toughness, broken leaves, tissue collapse Structural condition and handling-related deterioration Texture scoring; firmness measurement; visual damage rating Difficult to standardize for delicate leafy herbs [17] [20]
Decay and visible spoilage Mold, watery breakdown, sliminess, visible decay, undesirable odor Advanced deterioration and loss of marketability Decay/spoilage score; visual inspection; odor assessment; microbial testing when needed Visible spoilage indicates advanced loss but does not alone confirm microbial safety [14] [15] [20]
Sensory acceptability Appearance liking, odor, aroma, taste, texture, overall acceptance Consumer-facing freshness and rejection endpoint Sensory panel; consumer test; hedonic or rejection scale Product-, panel-, and use-context dependent [17] [21]

3.2 Sensory quality and consumer acceptability

Sensory quality links postharvest change with consumer acceptance because culinary herbs are valued not only for appearance but also for characteristic aroma, flavor, taste, and texture. Sensory deterioration may include weaker typical aroma, off-odor development, altered flavor, reduced succulence, or loss of fresh green character [9]. Sensory quality is strongly species-specific because each herb has an expected aroma and flavor identity. In minimally processed parsley, dill, and lovage, sensory attributes such as color, firmness, succulence, taste, and odor declined during refrigerated storage but remained distinguishable among species [17]. In basil, sensory descriptors have been linked with volatile and non-volatile composition, showing that sensory quality has a chemical basis [22, 23].

Storage and packaging conditions can influence sensory acceptability by weakening typical aroma or promoting off-odors. For example, fresh-cut cilantro showed aroma loss and off-odor development under unfavorable package atmospheres, whereas studies on refrigerated fresh-cut mint demonstrate the importance of suitable storage for maintaining sensory-related quality [13, 24].

Consumer acceptability should therefore be treated as a practical freshness endpoint rather than as a synonym for sensory quality. Sensory assessment describes changes in attributes such as aroma, flavor, appearance, taste, and texture, whereas consumer acceptability reflects whether the combined product characteristics remain suitable for purchase and use. Loss of characteristic aroma, development of off-odors, visible deterioration, or unacceptable texture may reduce overall liking and lead to product rejection even when some individual quality attributes remain acceptable. Freshness studies should therefore relate descriptive sensory changes, where possible, to overall acceptance, hedonic ratings, purchase intention, or rejection thresholds [9, 17, 24].

3.3 Nutritional and biochemical quality

Nutritional and biochemical quality represents a less visible but important dimension of freshness in culinary herbs. Unlike visual and textural deterioration, changes in vitamins, minerals, pigments, phenolic compounds, flavonoids, carotenoids, and antioxidant activity may occur without obvious external symptoms. Therefore, nutritional and biochemical quality should be considered alongside visual and sensory attributes when evaluating the overall quality of fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs [9, 25].

Fresh culinary herbs can contribute nutrients and bioactive compounds despite being consumed in relatively small quantities. Fresh-cut chives, coriander, spearmint, and parsley have been reported to contain dietary fiber, minerals, fat-soluble vitamins, and water-soluble vitamins. In these herbs, macronutrient and mineral composition remained relatively stable during refrigerated storage, whereas vitamins and antioxidant capacity varied depending on herb species and compound type [25]. Phenolic compounds and flavonoids are important biochemical quality attributes because they contribute to antioxidant potential and may be associated with plant defense responses after harvest. In parsley, dill, lovage, and celery leaves, differences have been reported in ascorbic acid, total phenolics, total flavonoids, individual phenolic acids, and antioxidant activity, showing that the nutritional and biochemical composition of culinary herbs is species-dependent [26].

Postharvest storage conditions can strongly influence biochemical quality. In fresh-cut mints, refrigerated storage helped maintain surface color, chlorophyll, carotenoids, antioxidant compounds, and essential-oil-related quality [24]. In sweet basil, storage temperature is especially critical because chilling conditions can reduce visual quality while also affecting antioxidant activity and polyphenolic compounds; basil leaves stored at a non-chilling temperature maintained biochemical quality better than leaves exposed to a chilling temperature [12]. Postharvest treatments may also influence biochemical quality. In coriander leaves, short exposure to red or blue LED light during cold storage affected chlorophyll, β-carotene, total phenolic content, quercetin, antioxidant activity, volatile retention, and overall acceptability.

These findings suggest that postharvest conditions can influence biochemical quality and volatile retention in coriander leaves during storage [27]. Nutritional and biochemical quality therefore provides complementary information on herb freshness, especially in studies evaluating shelf life, postharvest treatments, and functional value.

3.4 Volatile composition and aroma quality

The assessment of volatile composition and aroma quality is a central component of culinary-herb freshness because the commercial and sensory value of these products depends strongly on characteristic aroma and flavor. Herb aroma is determined by complex mixtures of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), including terpenes, aldehydes, alcohols, esters, phenylpropenes, and other secondary metabolites. In interpreting these compounds, it is useful to distinguish emitted headspace volatiles from extracted volatile fractions. Headspace volatiles are compounds released from intact or cut herb tissues into the surrounding gas phase and are therefore more closely related to the compounds available for olfactory perception during storage, handling, or use. However, their contribution to perceived aroma depends on concentration, odor thresholds, compound interactions, and matrix effects. By contrast, essential-oil yield refers to the quantity of volatile oil recovered from plant tissue, whereas essential-oil composition describes the relative abundance of compounds within that recovered oil fraction. Extractable volatile fractions provide information on compounds recovered from plant material by extraction-based methods and may reflect internal volatile reservoirs, but they are not necessarily equivalent to emitted headspace aroma. This distinction is illustrated by headspace VOC profiling in basil during postharvest storage [28] and by coriander leaves, in which fresh-leaf headspace aroma and essential-oil composition were analyzed separately [29].

Basil illustrates the relationship between volatile composition and aroma identity. Sweet basil aroma is associated with compounds such as linalool, 1,8-cineole, methyl chavicol, methyl cinnamate, and eugenol, while sensory, metabolomic, and volatilomic studies show that basil flavor perception is linked to both volatile and non-volatile compounds [22, 23].

Other herbs also show species-specific aroma markers. Fresh coriander leaf aroma is dominated by aldehydes, alcohols, esters, and green leaf volatiles, including (Z)-3-hexenyl acetate, (Z)-3-hexenol, decanal, dodecanal, and related unsaturated aldehydes [29]. Mint flavor is associated with monoterpenoids such as menthol, menthone, carvone, and limonene, while refrigerated storage under suitable packaging can help maintain aroma-related quality [24]. Postharvest LED treatment in coriander has also been reported to influence volatile retention together with antioxidant properties and acceptability [27].

Volatile organic compounds, essential-oil composition, and aroma-active markers therefore provide important information on herb identity, sensory quality, and postharvest aroma retention. Together, these visual, sensory, biochemical, and volatile attributes provide the practical quality endpoints against which candidate freshness indicators should be evaluated.

4. Postharvest freshness loss in fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs

4.1 Water loss, wilting, and loss of tissue integrity

Water loss is one of the earliest physical processes driving postharvest freshness loss in fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs. After harvest, herb leaves remain metabolically active but are separated from the root water supply. Continued transpiration reduces cell turgor, weakens tissue rigidity, and contributes to wilting, flaccidity, shriveling, and loss of marketable appearance during storage [11, 30]. The rate of water loss depends on temperature, relative humidity, air movement, packaging design, and vapor pressure difference between the leaf surface and surrounding air. High temperature and low relative humidity accelerate dehydration, whereas high relative humidity and suitable packaging reduce moisture loss. However, moisture control must be balanced because condensation and free surface water can favor microbial growth and decay [30]. Water loss is closely connected with declining tissue rigidity, respiration, and broader quality deterioration. Herb-specific studies show that low-temperature storage, high relative humidity, and suitable packaging can help reduce weight loss, respiration, pigment loss, and marketability decline, although the optimal conditions depend on the herb species and its chilling sensitivity [31, 32, 33].

4.2 Yellowing, browning, and pigment degradation

Yellowing and browning are major visible symptoms of postharvest freshness loss in culinary herbs. Yellowing is mainly associated with chlorophyll degradation during senescence, whereas browning is commonly linked to oxidation, tissue disruption, chilling injury, and enzymatic reactions. These color changes reduce marketability and may also reflect internal physiological and biochemical deterioration.

Harvested tissues continue to respire under limited photosynthetic activity and nutrient supply, which can promote senescence-related pigment breakdown. In chives and parsley, 1-methylcyclopropene delayed senescence-related deterioration, including chlorophyll degradation and yellowing, although treatment responses differed by commodity and storage context [34, 35]. These responses indicate that ethylene-related sensitivity or ethylene-response modulation may contribute to yellowing and senescence-related freshness loss in some culinary herbs.

Browning is frequently associated with enzymatic oxidation of phenolic substrates after tissue disruption, when enzymes, phenolics, and oxygen come into contact [19]. Low-temperature stress can intensify discoloration in chilling-sensitive herbs such as basil, where chilling injury may involve browning, chlorophyll loss, oxidative damage, lipid peroxidation, and cell-death-related responses [36]. Storage atmosphere and postharvest treatments can modify pigment stability, but their effects are condition-dependent, as illustrated by dill studies involving modified atmosphere storage and salicylic acid treatment [37, 38]. Therefore, yellowing and browning should be interpreted as visible outputs of senescence, oxidative stress, tissue injury, chilling damage, and treatment-dependent pigment responses.

4.3 Aroma deterioration and volatile changes

Aroma deterioration is a major postharvest freshness-loss process because the culinary value of herbs depends strongly on characteristic volatile compounds. After harvest, volatile profiles can change through respiration, altered secondary metabolism, oxidation, tissue injury, microbial activity, and loss of highly volatile compounds. These changes may reduce typical aroma intensity, shift the balance of aroma-active compounds, or promote off-odor formation.

Storage temperature is one of the main factors affecting volatile retention. In chilling-sensitive herbs such as basil, low temperature can reduce volatile emission and alter headspace composition while also contributing to electrolyte leakage and visible tissue injury [28]. Rodeo and Mitcham [39] reported greater chilling injury and loss of aroma volatiles at 5 °C than at 10 or 15 °C, indicating that low temperature may slow metabolism but impair aroma quality when the herb is chilling-sensitive.

Postharvest treatments may preserve or impair aroma depending on treatment intensity, commodity tolerance, and storage context. Studies on cilantro, parsley, spearmint, rosemary, curly parsley, and dill show that irradiation, ozone micro-nano bubble water, essential-oil or ascorbic acid treatments, and essential-oil vapor after vacuum cooling can influence volatile retention, sensory quality, microbial status, and visual acceptability [40, 41, 42, 43, 44]. Aroma deterioration therefore results from interacting volatile loss, altered biosynthesis, tissue injury, microbial activity, storage temperature, and processing operations.

4.4 Oxidative stress, membrane damage, and senescence-related metabolism

Oxidative stress, membrane damage, and senescence-related metabolism provide the internal mechanistic link between external quality loss and cellular deterioration. After harvest, herb tissues remain alive but experience stresses such as water loss, low temperature, darkness, wounding, altered atmosphere, and nutrient deprivation. These stresses disturb cellular homeostasis and can increase reactive oxygen species production. When antioxidant defenses are insufficient, oxidative damage occurs in membrane lipids, proteins, pigments, and other cellular components, accelerating senescence and visible quality loss.

Membrane damage is especially important because it reduces compartmentalization and disrupts metabolic control. In chilling-sensitive basil, low-temperature storage can reduce membrane stability, increase electrolyte leakage, and lead to necrosis, browning, wilting, and loss of marketability. Metabolomic evidence suggests that basil chilling injury is associated with oxidative stress and energy-metabolism disruption: osmoprotectants increased, key antioxidants declined, and carbohydrate-related energy pathways were downregulated during cold storage [45].

In basil, mitochondrial stability also appears to contribute to chilling-injury responses. In sweet basil, methyl salicylate reduced chilling injury by improving mitochondrial antioxidant capacity, maintaining mitochondrial stability, limiting cytochrome c dissipation, suppressing caspase-like enzyme activity, and preserving membrane integrity [46]. In lemon basil, sorbitol reduced chilling injury by enhancing antioxidant enzyme activities, lowering superoxide and hydrogen peroxide accumulation, maintaining mitochondrial respiratory enzyme activity, and delaying ATP depletion [47].

Preharvest and postharvest treatments can modify these internal stress responses. Far-red light during cultivation improved postharvest chilling tolerance in basil, apparently through increased soluble sugars and starch, suggesting that carbohydrate reserves may support stress tolerance [48]. Silicon application also reduced leaf necrosis, fresh weight loss, and electrolyte leakage in postharvest sweet basil [49]. These findings show that visible symptoms such as water loss, discoloration, browning, wilting, and aroma decline often reflect deeper cellular damage involving oxidative stress, antioxidant status, membrane stability, mitochondrial function, and energy metabolism.

4.5 Effects of minimal processing

Minimal processing can accelerate freshness loss by converting intact plant tissues into more vulnerable fresh-cut products. Operations such as trimming, cutting, washing, sanitizing, surface dewatering after washing, packaging, and cooling improve convenience and marketability, but they also expose tissues to mechanical stress, water contact, oxygen, microbial contamination, and altered atmospheres. Compared with intact herbs, minimally processed herbs often deteriorate faster because wounding disrupts cellular compartmentalization, increases exposed surface area, stimulates respiration, and increases susceptibility to enzymatic, microbial, and physiological deterioration.

Tissue wounding is a major cause of processing-related quality loss. Cutting or bruising damages membranes and allows enzymes, substrates, and oxygen to interact, which can accelerate browning, pigment degradation, softening, water loss, and off-odor formation. In fresh-cut produce, appearance and texture deterioration are closely linked with cellular damage, membrane disruption, chlorophyll degradation, and dehydration-related textural changes [50]. Minimal processing also increases microbial risk. Washing can remove soil, exudates, and part of the microbial load, but poorly managed wash water can spread contamination. Sanitizers are therefore needed to reduce microorganisms on product surfaces and maintain wash-water quality, although their effectiveness depends on contact time, organic load, water quality, treatment intensity, and commodity sensitivity [51]. In herbs such as cilantro and coriander, integrated physiological, antimicrobial, and packaging approaches can reduce processing-related deterioration by controlling respiration, microbial growth, sensory loss, and flavor decline [32, 52, 53].

Packaging and the resulting package atmosphere should be regarded as storage conditions rather than freshness-loss processes. Appropriate packaging can reduce water loss and help maintain quality, whereas unsuitable O₂ and CO₂ levels may induce physiological stress, fermentative metabolism, aroma loss, off-odor development, or tissue deterioration [13, 32, 37]. The effect therefore depends on package design, product respiration, storage temperature, and the tolerance of the herb to the resulting atmosphere.

Minimal processing therefore intensifies freshness loss through interacting processes that include mechanical injury, increased respiration, water loss, enzyme activation, microbial exposure, and physiological or sensory deterioration arising under unsuitable processing and package-atmosphere conditions. Representative studies linking storage conditions, postharvest treatments, quality responses, and freshness-loss processes in culinary herbs are summarized in Table 2. The freshness-loss processes described above generate measurable physiological, metabolic, and volatile changes that can be examined as potential freshness indicators.

Table 2: Representative postharvest storage and treatment studies linking quality responses and freshness-loss processes in fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs

Herb/product form Storage or treatment Main measured domain Key reported response Freshness-loss process represented Ref.

Sweet basil leaves

(three cultivars)

4 or 12 °C; up to 9 d VOCs; chilling injury; electrolyte leakage Volatile emission was lower at 4 °C; selected VOCs were associated with chilling injury and electrolyte leakage. Aroma loss; chilling injury [28]
Sweet basil leaves 4 or 12 °C; up to 12 d Stress metabolites; antioxidants Osmoprotectant-related metabolites increased at 4 °C, while ascorbic acid and rosmarinic acid decreased. Chilling-stress metabolism [45]
Sweet basil branches Ascorbic acid immersion; 6 ± 1 °C; 12 d Oxidative stress; chlorophyll degradation Ascorbic acid reduced chilling injury, oxidative damage, chlorophyll degradation, and cell-death-related responses. Oxidative stress; pigment retention [36]
Spearmint shoots Spearmint essential oil or ascorbic acid dip; 4 °C; 6 d Essential-oil composition shift; oxidative and microbial-quality context Storage and treatments affected essential-oil composition, especially carvone formation; EO and AA treatments also influenced weight loss, oxidative status, and microbial load. Aroma-yield loss; volatile-profile shift [42]
Coriander leaves Red or blue LED treatment; 5 °C; up to 9 d Chlorophyll; antioxidants; volatiles; sensory quality LED treatments influenced antioxidant properties, volatile profile, aroma, and consumer acceptability. Color, aroma, and antioxidant retention [27]
Coriander, fresh-cut (5-cm sections) 10, 20, and 30 °C; 1–5 d Respiration and gas exchange Respiration increased with temperature and storage time and was modelled for MAP design. Temperature-dependent metabolic activity [32]
Coriander (cilantro) leaves 0–3 kGy gamma irradiation; 3 °C; 14 d Aroma; volatiles; visual quality; spoilage Irradiation up to 2 kGy retained aroma, volatiles, color, and visual quality, whereas 3 kGy increased decay and off-odor. Aroma quality; spoilage threshold [40]
Parsley, fresh-cut (stems and leaves) O₃ micro-nano bubble water; 20 °C; 5 d Volatiles; metabolites; physiological quality Treatment preserved sensory quality, reduced physiological deterioration, and altered volatile and metabolite profiles. Senescence and flavor regulation [41]
Chive leaves PVC-covered trays; 0 or 4 °C Pigments; sugars; browning; marketability Storage at 0 °C delayed color change, pigment loss, sugar loss, and marketability decline. Green color retention; shelf-life extension [31]
Chive leaves 1-MCP treatment; 20 or 3 °C storage Yellowing; respiration; oxidative stress; organosulfur compounds 1-MCP reduced yellowing, delayed chlorophyll loss, lowered respiration and oxidative damage mainly at 20°C and affected organosulfur quality. Yellowing control; flavor-precursor quality [34]
Dill leaves with petioles Modified atmosphere storage; 5 °C; 10 d Package gases; chlorophyll; vitamin C; phenolics CO₂-containing atmospheres reduced O₂ decline but caused greater chlorophyll loss, making quality benefit condition-dependent. Altered respiration; chlorophyll loss [37]
Dill bunches Salicylic acid dip + MAP; 0 °C; 25 d plus shelf-life simulation Color; respiration; package gases; visual quality Salicylic acid, especially 1 mM, helped maintain greenness, suppress respiration, and extend marketable quality. Color retention; senescence delay [38]
Rosemary bundles Ascorbic acid, rosemary essential oil, heat, or sodium carbonate; 4 °C; 12 d Aroma; antioxidants; microbial load; visual quality Ascorbic acid and rosemary essential oil better preserved aroma and green appearance; treatment effects differed for microbial control and marketability. Aroma and visual-quality retention [43]
Sage bundles 2, 6, or 20 °C; different RH; 15 d Respiration; pigments; antioxidants; essential-oil profile Lower temperature and high RH reduced weight loss and respiration and helped maintain phytochemicals and aroma quality. Phytochemical and aroma retention [33]
Parsley bunches 1-MCP treatment; dark storage at 25 °C Chlorophyll; protein; ethylene-related responses 1-MCP delayed chlorophyll and protein degradation but induced ethylene biosynthesis. Senescence delay; yellowing control [35]
Curly parsley and dill (stems and leaves) Essential-oil vapor applied under vacuum at the end of vacuum cooling VOC profile; characteristic aroma compounds Essential-oil vapor increased total VOC recovery and enhanced characteristic parsley and dill aroma compounds after processing. Aroma recovery after processing [44]

Abbreviations: 1-MCP, 1-methylcyclopropene; EO, essential oil; MAP, modified atmosphere packaging/storage; RH, relative humidity; VOCs, volatile organic compounds.

5. Chemical profiling for freshness-indicator discovery in culinary herbs

5.1 Need for chemical profiling beyond visual evaluation

Sections 3 and 4 define the major quality outcomes and biological processes involved in herb freshness loss; this section considers how those changes can be translated into candidate chemical indicators. Visual evaluation remains essential for judging marketability in fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs, but it cannot fully describe internal metabolic stress, antioxidant depletion, microbial activity, or volatile-pattern changes. Similar concerns have been reported in fresh-produce research, where visual freshness assessment alone may not fully capture internal chemical changes during storage [54].

Chemical profiling adds explanatory evidence by detecting metabolites and volatile compounds associated with internal freshness status. Metabolomic approaches can reveal shifts related to senescence, stress response, antioxidant status, energy metabolism, and storage injury, whereas volatile profiling can capture aroma loss, volatile-pattern changes, and off-odor development. Together, these approaches can help connect chemical or microbial changes with product quality, safety, and storage outcomes [6, 7, 55].

Therefore, chemical profiling should complement rather than replace visual, sensory, microbiological, and physiological evaluation, especially when candidate signals are interpreted against practical freshness endpoints.

5.2 Metabolomic profiling for biochemical freshness-indicator discovery

Metabolomic profiling is useful for discovering biochemical changes associated with postharvest freshness loss in culinary herbs. In postharvest research, metabolomic platforms have been used to profile compounds associated with organoleptic and health-related quality traits and to support the discovery of candidate metabolic markers [7]. For herbs, this approach is relevant because freshness loss may involve stress responses, antioxidant depletion, membrane injury, senescence, and energy imbalance that are not fully captured by visual scoring.

The value of metabolomics lies in moving from broad chemical profiling to candidate marker discovery. In stored soybean sprouts, comprehensive mass-spectrometric analysis identified abscisic acid as a quantitative freshness marker under different storage temperatures [54]. Soybean sprouts are not culinary herbs, but this study is relevant as a proof-of-concept workflow because it links a metabolite signal with storage condition and freshness decline. Comparable herb-specific metabolomic validation studies remain limited; therefore, future herb research should adapt similar workflows by relating metabolite shifts to practical endpoints such as yellowing, chilling injury, aroma decline, sensory acceptability, or shelf-life termination. Metabolite markers are therefore more robust when their storage-related changes are linked to biologically meaningful freshness references, such as respiratory activity, cumulative storage history, or measurable visual, sensory, or shelf-life decline.

Herb-specific evidence supports this approach. In basil leaves stored at chilling and non-chilling temperatures, ¹H NMR and GC–MS metabolite profiling showed that chilling injury was associated with accumulation of osmoprotectant-related metabolites and decline of key antioxidants [45]. The same study linked chilling stress with changes in antioxidant defense and carbohydrate-related energy pathways, suggesting that metabolite patterns can reveal biochemical processes underlying reduced shelf life [45]. Therefore, metabolomics should be treated as a discovery and prioritization tool rather than a stand-alone freshness test.

5.3 Volatile profiling for aroma-freshness and off-odor indicators

Volatile profiling is useful for translating aroma freshness and off-odor development into measurable chemical indicators. In culinary herbs, characteristic volatiles can represent desired aroma identity, whereas reductions in total VOC emission, shifts in relative abundance, or atypical volatile patterns may indicate aroma deterioration, physiological responses to unsuitable package atmospheres, microbial activity, or spoilage risk. Therefore, volatile data should be interpreted in relation to relevant sensory, physiological, microbial, or storage-related evidence rather than as aroma composition alone.

For freshness assessment, it is important to distinguish between internal volatile pools and emitted headspace volatiles. Essential-oil yield or extractable volatile composition can describe the volatile reservoir within herb tissues, whereas headspace analysis characterizes compounds released into the surrounding gas phase during storage, handling, or use. Because the sensory importance of those compounds also depends on their concentrations, odor thresholds, interactions, and matrix effects, headspace composition should not be treated as equivalent to perceived aroma quality. Aroma-freshness studies should therefore prioritize emitted headspace VOCs or volatile fingerprints while validating them against sensory endpoints; essential-oil and extractable volatile data should be interpreted as supporting evidence rather than as direct sensory freshness indicators.

An herb-specific example illustrates this point. In basil leaves stored at 4 or 12 °C, HS-SPME–GC–MS profiling showed that storage temperature strongly influenced volatile emission. By combining VOC data with chilling injury score and electrolyte leakage, selected volatiles were proposed as potential markers of chilling injury [28]. This example is important because volatile data were linked with physiological freshness-loss responses, not only with aroma composition.

Off-odor detection provides a related validation model. In fresh-cut lettuce, HS-SPME–GC–MS volatile profiling identified ethyl alcohol, acetaldehyde, and ethyl acetate as quality-related markers under modified atmosphere packaging, while sensory analysis showed that odor quality could decline even when visual quality remained acceptable [56]. Electronic nose responses in fresh-cut green bell pepper also distinguished fresh and spoiled samples and correlated with aerobic plate counts [55]. Although these examples are not culinary herbs, they provide proof-of-concept validation workflows showing how volatile-pattern data can be linked with sensory or microbial evidence in minimally processed products. Their relevance to herbs lies in the validation approach rather than in direct transfer of the specific marker compounds.

Volatile indicators can therefore be considered at two levels: characteristic aroma volatiles that represent desirable herb identity and volatile fingerprints or off-odor signals that represent freshness loss. A recent review also emphasizes that VOC profiles can respond to physiological stress, microbial activity, enzymatic degradation, and chemical oxidation before deterioration is visually obvious [57]. Thus, volatile profiling should be integrated with targeted sensory, microbial, visual, and multivariate validation to identify robust aroma-freshness indicators.

5.4 Criteria for prioritizing candidate freshness indicators

Candidate freshness indicators should be prioritized according to domain relevance, biological meaning, context specificity, reproducibility, and analytical practicality. In fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs, many metabolites, volatile compounds, physiological variables, and biochemical parameters may change during storage, processing, or treatment. However, not every changing compound is a useful freshness indicator. A candidate becomes meaningful only when it represents a recognizable freshness-related process or response, such as color loss, aroma deterioration, off-odor formation, oxidative injury, membrane damage, senescence, microbial spoilage, physiological responses to unsuitable package atmospheres, or biochemical quality change [6].

Candidate indicators should also be interpreted within a defined use context because postharvest chemical responses can vary with commodity type, cultivar, tissue characteristics, storage temperature, and processing condition [7]. Prioritization should therefore favor signals that are biologically interpretable, relevant to a defined freshness problem, reproducible within the intended context, and measurable using methods appropriate to the intended purpose. Detailed validation against specific quality endpoints is considered in Section 5.6.

5.5 Candidate metabolic and volatile freshness indicators in culinary herbs

Candidate freshness-related signals in culinary herbs can be grouped according to the type of quality information they provide. Relevant groups include pigment- and color-related indicators, oxidative-stress and membrane-injury indicators, stress- and senescence-related metabolites, phenolic and antioxidant indicators, characteristic aroma volatiles, volatile fingerprints, Allium-specific sulfur flavor indicators, and supporting physiological variables.

For metabolic indicators, pigment-related compounds are most closely associated with yellowing and visual marketability; oxidative-stress and membrane-injury indicators reflect chilling injury, browning, and tissue deterioration; and stress- or senescence-related metabolites can indicate metabolic reprogramming during storage. In basil, chilling stress has been associated with osmoprotectant accumulation and antioxidant decline, supporting the relevance of stress- and antioxidant-related compounds when they are linked to measurable quality changes [45]. These examples show that metabolic signals are most informative when they can be connected to a specific deterioration process rather than treated as standalone freshness measures [6, 7, 54].

Volatile indicators provide an aroma-specific dimension. Characteristic aroma volatiles can represent herb identity and aroma retention, whereas volatile fingerprints, total VOC emission, off-odor-associated compounds, and electronic-nose patterns may indicate aroma deterioration, physiological responses to unsuitable package atmospheres, microbial activity, or spoilage risk [28, 55, 56, 57]. For Allium herbs, sulfur-containing compounds represent a distinct aroma-related group, although their use as freshness indicators requires species-specific validation. In chive, S-alk(en)ylcysteine sulfoxides (ACSOs), including methiin, alliin, isoalliin, and propiin, are non-volatile precursors of the characteristic sulfur aroma of Allium species. After tissue disruption, these precursors may contribute to the formation of sulfur-containing volatiles through alliinase-mediated reactions. During storage, changes in the ACSO pool may also reflect senescence-related quality responses, as 1-MCP treatment delayed yellowing and membrane damage while increasing isoalliin and total ACSOs in chive [34]. This evidence supports ACSOs as context-specific candidate indicators for chive quality retention, but not as broadly validated freshness markers across Allium herbs. For dill, lovage, and rosemary, available studies mainly describe sensory changes or postharvest quality responses rather than compound-level, endpoint-linked volatile indicators [17, 43]. Therefore, herb-specific volatile-indicator evidence remains limited for these species.

Supporting physiological variables, such as respiration rate and package gas balance, can help interpret metabolic and volatile changes during storage or processing. These candidate groups, their freshness relevance, validation endpoints, analytical methods, evidence levels, and representative references are summarized in Table 3.

Table 3: Candidate metabolic, volatile, physiological, and microbial-context indicators for freshness evaluation in fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs

Indicator group Candidate examples Freshness domain and validation endpoint Analytical approach Evidence level by reference
Pigment and color-related indicators Chlorophylls; carotenoids; greenness values; yellowing score Color retention, yellowing, browning, and visual marketability; validate against greenness, hue angle, browning, yellowing, or marketability score Colorimetry; image analysis; spectrophotometry; HPLC where applicable [24] H-G [27] H-G [31] H-G [34] H-G [35] H-G [36] H-G [37] H-G
Oxidative stress, membrane injury, and energy status ROS; H₂O₂; MDA; electrolyte leakage; antioxidant enzymes; glutathione; mitochondrial stability; ATP-related responses Oxidative senescence, chilling injury, membrane damage, browning, wilting, and tissue deterioration; validate against chilling injury score, electrolyte leakage, visible damage, wilting, firmness, or shelf-life limit Biochemical assays; conductivity measurement; enzyme assays; LC-MS, GC-MS, or NMR where applicable [28] H-G* [34] H-G [36] H-S* [45] H-G* [46] H-S* [47] H-S*
Stress- and senescence-related metabolites Amino acids; sugars; organic acids; osmoprotectant-related metabolites; carbohydrate-related metabolites; storage-responsive metabolites Stress response, metabolic reprogramming, senescence, chilling-stress metabolism, and possible energy imbalance; validate against freshness score, yellowing, chilling injury, sensory acceptability, or shelf-life limit GC-MS; LC-MS; NMR; targeted metabolite assays [7] G [45] H-G* [54] M
Phenolic and antioxidant indicators Total phenolics; flavonoids; rosmarinic acid; chicoric acid; ascorbic acid; antioxidant capacity Biochemical quality, antioxidant response, and stress-related biochemical change; validate against pigment retention, antioxidant retention, chilling injury, sensory acceptability, or marketability Phenolic and antioxidant assays; HPLC; LC-MS [24] H-M [25] H-M [27] H-G [34] H-G [36] H-G [45] H-M*
Characteristic aroma volatiles Linalool; 1,8-cineole; eugenol; methyl chavicol; methyl cinnamate; citral; carvone; limonene; coriander aldehydes; herb-specific aroma-active compounds Retention or alteration of characteristic herb aroma and culinary identity; validate against odor, aroma, taste, sensory acceptability, or flavor descriptors HS-SPME-GC-MS; GC-MS; sensory profiling; GC-O where applicable [22] H-G* [23] H-G* [24] H-G* [27] H-G [28] H-M* [29] H-M
Volatile fingerprint and off-odor indicators Total VOC emission; selected VOC signatures; volatile-profile shifts; off-odor-associated compounds; validated sensor or electronic-nose patterns Aroma deterioration, off-odor formation, physiological responses to unsuitable package atmospheres, spoilage risk, and freshness-state discrimination; validate against off-odor score, sensory acceptability, package O₂/CO₂ balance, microbial load, rejection score, or shelf-life limit HS-SPME-GC-MS; validated sensor/electronic-nose analysis; multivariate classification or regression [28] H-G* [40] H-M* [55] M [56] M [57] G
Allium-specific sulfur flavor indicators S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides; isoalliin; PeCSO; total ACSOs; sulfur-associated aroma compounds Flavor potential and sulfur-aroma quality in Allium herbs; validate against sulfur aroma, taste, sensory acceptability, yellowing, or marketability HPLC; LC-MS/QTOF or high-resolution MS; targeted organosulfur analysis; GC-MS for sulfur volatiles where applicable [34] H-M*
Physiological and microbial context Respiration rate; O₂ consumption; CO₂ production; package O₂/CO₂ balance; ethylene production or response; microbial load where relevant Physiological activity, interpretation of package O₂/CO₂ conditions, senescence and storage-stress context, and microbial-spoilage context; validate against weight loss, wilting, package gas balance, microbial counts, or shelf-life limit Gas analysis; headspace O₂/CO₂ analysis; respiration measurement; ethylene analysis; microbial enumeration; weight-loss measurement [32] S [34] S [35] S [37] S [55] M+S [56] M+S

Evidence level: H-S, strong direct herb-specific support; H-G, good direct herb-specific support; H-M, moderate direct herb-specific support; M, model or proof-of-concept evidence from non-herb fresh or minimally processed produce; G, general methodological or conceptual support; S, supporting physiological or microbial-context evidence; M+S, model or proof-of-concept evidence with supporting physiological or microbial-context evidence. Evidence levels are assigned to each reference according to how directly that source supports the specific indicator row. An asterisk (*) indicates relatively strong or moderate evidence within a limited scope, such as basil-focused chilling-injury evidence, basil-focused aroma evidence, context-limited volatile-marker evidence, or Allium-specific sulfur-flavor evidence.

Note: Listed compounds, physiological variables, microbial measures, and analytical signals should be interpreted as candidate or supporting indicators whose relevance depends on herb species, storage or processing condition, analytical method, and validation endpoint. Non-herb studies are included only as methodological or proof-of-concept models. Abbreviations: ACSOs, S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides; PeCSO, S-(2-carboxypropyl) cysteine sulfoxide.

5.6 Validation strategy and practical considerations

Validation is the critical step that separates a storage-responsive chemical change from a useful freshness indicator. A metabolite, volatile compound, VOC fingerprint, or instrumental signal should not be considered an indicator merely because it changes during storage, chilling exposure, minimal processing, or postharvest treatment. It becomes meaningful when it represents a defined freshness-related problem, has biological or sensory relevance, and can be linked to measurable quality outcomes [6, 7]. The required level of validation should depend on the intended use of the signal. A compound may be useful as a context-specific candidate within one herb and storage condition, whereas broader application or predictive use requires stronger evidence across biological materials, treatments, and quality endpoints. This tiered interpretation is especially relevant for VOC-based assessment because VOC profiles may respond to physiological stress, microbial activity, enzymatic degradation, and chemical oxidation before visible deterioration becomes evident [57].

A practical validation pathway should begin by defining the freshness domain that the signal is expected to represent. In culinary herbs, this domain may involve visual deterioration, aroma loss, off-odor formation, chilling injury, microbial spoilage, or shelf-life limitation. Herb studies that measure color retention, yellowing, aroma, decay, and marketability provide examples of domain-specific assessment [31, 40]. This distinction is important because a signal that is useful for one freshness problem may not be informative for another. For example, pigment-related changes are most relevant to visual marketability, whereas volatile fingerprints may be useful for interpreting chilling injury [28], aroma deterioration or physiological responses to unsuitable package atmospheres [13, 37, 56], and spoilage-related changes [55, 56]. Package atmosphere itself should be regarded as a storage condition or environmental factor rather than a deterioration process. However, excessive CO₂ accumulation, low-O₂ stress, or other unsuitable atmospheric conditions may induce physiological and metabolic responses that contribute to aroma loss, off-odor development, or tissue deterioration. Candidate signals should therefore be judged according to the quality problem or stress response they are expected to represent rather than treated as universal freshness markers.

Microbial-context indicators are currently supported mainly through microbiological endpoints rather than fully validated microbe-derived chemical markers. In herb-specific studies, microbial quality has commonly been assessed using culture-based parameters, including microbial growth, coliform or E. coli counts, visible decay, and overall quality, as reported for fresh-cut cilantro [52]. These parameters are useful for validating freshness-related deterioration because they can be interpreted together with sensory quality, off-odor development, decay incidence, and shelf-life limits. Evidence for specific microbe-related volatile or sensor-based markers in culinary herbs remains limited. Therefore, electronic-nose responses correlated with aerobic plate counts, as demonstrated in fresh-cut green bell pepper, should be regarded as supporting methodological evidence rather than direct herb-specific validation [55]. Similarly, volatile compounds associated with off-odor development, including ethanol, acetaldehyde, and ethyl acetate, provide useful model evidence from non-herb fresh-cut products but require herb-specific validation before they can be interpreted as freshness indicators in culinary herbs [56].

The next step is to evaluate the strength and directness of the available evidence. As summarized in Table 3, the strongest support comes from direct herb-specific studies that connect chemical or physiological signals with relevant quality outcomes. For chilling-injury-related indicators, basil currently provides the clearest validation case. VOC profiles have been linked with chilling-injury scores and electrolyte leakage [28], while metabolomic evidence connects chilling symptoms with osmoprotectant accumulation, antioxidant depletion, and energy-related metabolic shifts [45]. Physiological studies further associate basil chilling injury with oxidative damage, membrane injury, mitochondrial instability, cell-death activation, and ATP depletion [46, 47]. Evidence from chive, coriander or cilantro, parsley, dill, and mint also supports the relevance of commodity-specific indicators, although validation strength differs among herbs, storage conditions, endpoints, and indicator groups.

Direct herb-specific evidence should be clearly distinguished from model or methodological evidence derived from non-herb products. Studies involving soybean sprouts, fresh-cut green bell pepper, and fresh-cut lettuce are included in this review because they demonstrate general validation approaches that may be adapted for culinary herbs. Soybean sprouts illustrate metabolite-marker selection using cumulative respiratory activity as a freshness-related reference [54]. Fresh-cut green bell pepper demonstrates electronic-nose validation against microbial spoilage [55]. Fresh-cut lettuce shows how volatile profiles can be linked with sensory quality and off-odor development under modified-atmosphere packaging [56]. These studies do not demonstrate that the same metabolites, volatile compounds, or sensor responses are valid indicators in culinary herbs. Their relevance lies in the validation strategy—linking a candidate chemical or instrumental signal with an independently measured freshness endpoint—rather than in direct transfer of the identified markers between products.

Candidate signals should then be tested against endpoints that match their intended freshness domain. Visual and pigment-related signals can be compared with greenness, yellowing, browning, wilting, marketability, or rejection limits, depending on the study objective; these endpoints are commonly used in herb-storage studies such as those involving chive and basil [31, 36]. Aroma-related signals can be evaluated against characteristic odor, off-odor, flavor descriptors, sensory acceptability, or aroma shelf life, as demonstrated in basil and cilantro studies [22, 40]. Spoilage-related signals are strongest when assessed against microbial counts, visible decay, off-odor development, or shelf-life termination, as illustrated by studies on cilantro and fresh-cut green bell pepper [40, 55]. Physiological variables such as respiration rate, package O₂ and CO₂ balance, ethylene response, electrolyte leakage, and weight loss can support interpretation by explaining the processes associated with metabolic and volatile changes [28, 32, 35].

The predictive value of candidate indicators can be evaluated at several levels. Correlation analysis may be useful for initial screening, whereas regression, classification, or chemometric modelling can provide stronger evidence when freshness-state prediction or classification is the intended application. Approaches such as partial least squares regression, principal component analysis, discriminant analysis, and hierarchical clustering can help determine whether metabolic or volatile profiles distinguish acceptable from unacceptable freshness states. Basil VOC–chilling-injury modelling provides a direct herb example in which VOC profiles were related to chilling-injury scores and electrolyte leakage using PLS-based analysis [28]. Soybean sprouts illustrate metabolite-marker selection using respiratory CO₂ production as a freshness-related reference [54]. Fresh-cut green bell pepper demonstrates electronic-nose classification and PLS prediction against aerobic plate counts [55], while fresh-cut lettuce shows how volatile profiling can identify VOCs associated with sensory quality and off-odor development under modified-atmosphere packaging [56]. When predictive models are developed, cross-validation and, where feasible, independent validation samples should be used to reduce the risk of overinterpreting experiment-specific associations.

For broader or routine application, biological reproducibility and context specificity are important. Comparative herb studies show that postharvest responses can differ among species, including chives, coriander, spearmint, and parsley, in relation to color, vitamins, phenolics, flavonoids, and antioxidant capacity [25]. Variation may also occur among cultivars of the same herb species. Studies comparing basil and coriander cultivars demonstrate cultivar-dependent differences in visual responses, characteristic aroma profiles, and volatile composition [12, 22, 29]. Such differences may influence both the baseline abundance and the storage-related response of a candidate metabolite or volatile. Cultivar-dependent variation may be particularly relevant when candidate indicators are minor or low-abundance compounds because differences in their baseline abundance can complicate comparisons of storage-related responses [7, 22, 29].

Preharvest growing conditions may provide an additional source of variation by influencing the metabolic state of the product before harvest. Available basil studies show that preharvest light conditions can modify carbohydrate reserves, nutritional composition, and subsequent chilling-related responses [48, 58]. Therefore, an apparent storage-related chemical difference may reflect not only postharvest deterioration but also cultivar and preharvest history. A signal validated in one cultivar, cultivation treatment, or production context should consequently remain context-specific until its relationship with the relevant freshness endpoint has been confirmed under representative biological and growing conditions. Validation studies should report the herb species, cultivar, analyzed plant part, relevant cultivation conditions, harvest stage, storage conditions, processing treatment, and sampling time so that the transferability of the proposed indicator can be evaluated.

Biochemical enrichment should also be distinguished from validated freshness retention. Increases in phenolics, antioxidants, sugars, or other metabolites should not automatically be interpreted as improved freshness unless they correspond to better visual, sensory, physiological, or shelf-life outcomes. This caution is supported by herb studies in which biochemical changes were interpreted together with acceptability, yellowing, membrane damage, or chilling-injury responses [27, 34, 45]. Evidence that preharvest high-light treatment improved basil nutritional value without improving postharvest chilling tolerance further demonstrates that an increase in a desirable biochemical component does not necessarily indicate improved postharvest freshness [58].

Finally, practical application requires consideration of analytical feasibility. Discovery platforms such as LC–MS, GC–MS, NMR, and HS-SPME–GC–MS are valuable for identifying and prioritizing candidate indicators, whereas routine freshness monitoring may require simpler targeted assays or validated sensor-based methods [6, 7, 57]. In many cases, robust freshness assessment may benefit from validated multi-marker panels rather than reliance on a single universal compound. Such panels could integrate visual, physiological, metabolic, volatile, sensory, and microbial information to support freshness classification, shelf-life prediction, and postharvest decision-making for fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs.

6. Conclusion and future prospects

Freshness in culinary herbs cannot be adequately assessed from external appearance alone. Visual quality, texture, color, aroma, and sensory acceptability remain essential for marketability, but they represent only part of the postharvest response. Freshness loss reflects interacting physiological, biochemical, volatile, and microbial processes that vary among herb species, cultivars, storage temperatures, processing intensity, and packaging environments. Therefore, freshness assessment in fresh and minimally processed herbs should integrate visible quality changes with internal chemical and biological responses.

This review shows that metabolic and volatile changes are most useful when they are interpreted as part of an evidence-based freshness-assessment framework rather than as isolated chemical responses. The current evidence base is promising but uneven. Indicators related to basil chilling injury, oxidative stress, membrane damage, energy status, pigment loss, and selected aroma changes have relatively stronger herb-specific support, whereas broader metabolomic markers, off-odor fingerprints, electronic-nose responses, and sensor-based approaches still require further validation in culinary herbs. By organizing candidate signals within a validation-oriented framework, this review helps distinguish preliminary chemical responses from indicators with practical postharvest meaning.

Future research should focus on strengthening herb-specific validation across species, cultivars, growing conditions, harvest stages and seasons, storage temperatures, packaging systems, processing intensities, and sampling times. A signal that performs well in one herb or treatment context should not be assumed to apply broadly until it is tested against relevant quality outcomes. As endpoint-linked datasets become available, validated metabolic and volatile indicators could be integrated into predictive or decision-support models. In practice, robust freshness monitoring is likely to depend on multi-marker panels that combine visual, physiological, metabolic, volatile, sensory, and microbial information to support postharvest decision-making and quality management for fresh and minimally processed culinary herbs.

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Nahar Ashrafun: Conceptualization, Methodology, Investigation, Data curation, Visualization, Writing – original draft. Kasumi Nakagawa: Supervision, Writing – review & editing. Manasikan Thammawong: Supervision, Writing – review & editing. Kohei Nakano: Supervision, Conceptualization, Writing – review & editing.

Data availability statement

No new experimental data were generated or analyzed in this study. The literature-search strategy, inclusion and exclusion criteria, and evidence-selection summary are provided in the supplementary tables. Additional review-process materials are available upon reasonable request.

Use of generative AI and AI-Assisted technologies:

The authors used ChatGTP to improve English grammar and readability. The authors reviewed and edited the output and take full responsibility for the content of the manuscript.

References
 
© 2026 The Uniited Graduate Schools of Agricultural Sciences, Japan
feedback
Top