【Background】For the evaluation of large joints in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), Larsen grade is usually used. However, this grading system, composed of only6grades (0-5), has several limitations such as ceiling effect within the grade. Therefore, we developed a new radiographic scoring method for large joints in RA (Assessment of Rheumatoid Arthritis by Scoring of Large Joint Destruction and Healing in Radiographic Imaging: ARASHI.
【Objective】The purpose of this study is to evaluate the radiographic damage of hip and knee joints in RA during TNF-blocking therapies by this new radiographic scoring method, and to clarify the pattern of the progression of damage during 2year therapies.
【Patients and Methods】 ʻARASHI status scoreʼ consists of 4 categories; joint space narrowing (0~3points), erosion(0~3points), joint surface (0~6points), and stability (0~4points), (total score range 0-16 points). ʻARASHI change scoreʼ consists of 5 categories; porosis (-1~1 point), joint space narrowing (-1~2 points), erosion (-2~2 points), joint surface (-6~6 points), and stability (-1~1 point), (total score range -11~12 points). Increase in more than 1point of change score was considered as progression of joint damage. Fifty one consecutive patients (6males, 45women, mean age of59. 9 years old) were enrolled in this study. All patients fulfilled the ACR 1987 revised criteria. The joints with history of surgical intervention were excluded from this analysis. The radiographic findings of96hip joints and 86knee joints were evaluated at baseline using the ARASHI status score, and at 2 years after TNF-blocking therapies (infliximab, etanercept or adalimumab) using the ARASHI change score.
【Results】 There were 12 joints (4 hip joints, 8 knee joints) with 3and more points of the status score at baseline. All of these joints resulted in significant increase in the change score during 2-year TNF-blocking therapies. On the other hand, joints with pre-existing status score of 0-2 points showed progression of joint damage only in 6.5% of the hip and knee joints during the follow-up period.
【Conclusion 】 ARASHI scoring method was useful for radiographic assessment of the status and the progression of damage in large weight-bearing joints. In this study, we demonstrated that hip and knee joints with pre-existing damage greater than2points of the status score were highly predisposed to progressive destruction even under TNF-blocking therapies. Therefore, it is prerequisite for the hip and knee joints to be radiographically evaluated not to exceed status score 2 before the start of TNF-blocking therapies.
View full abstract