Objective: Tic douloureux is classitied into three types according to its clinical symptoms. This study reports the efficacy of microvascular decompression on the conditions defined according to the International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD-II).
Selection of the Study: Tic douloureux is classified into three types according to its clinical symptoms: Class I: Typical classical trigeminal neuralgia: paroxysmal (lasting for several seconds), typical, with sharp, fulminant pain (but without lingering pain); a recognizable trigger zone; a condition that responds to treatment with Tegretol. Class II: Atypical tic; some with sustained pain; the area associated with pain is near the parietal region, often exhibiting an atypical distribution (such as behind the eye). There may be insensitive areas. Class III: Atypical facial pain syndrome: sustained dull pain dominates the symptoms; the condition may be manifested by such conditions as a cluster headache, maxillary cancer, empyema, Sluder syndrome and post-radiotherapy trigeminal neuralgia (following the application of a gamma knife). The patients were stratified according to the classification method noted above. With special reference to the 1,910 patients with tic douloureux who were treated with microvascular decompression based on the method adapted by Dr. Takanori Fukushima and on previous cases at this hospital, the efficacy of this procedure in the field of neurosurgery, in particular on tic douloureux, was reported. The authors hope that the results will shed some light on the management of pain in the area of the trigeminal nerve and the selection of therapeutic procedures in future.
Results: Microvascular decompression was applied to Class I patients (87% of the patient group). A complete recovery was noted in 96%, while vascular compression was no longer observed in 7%. The condition returned in 6 months to one year in 4%, that failed to achieve a complete recovery. Class II conditions were found in 13%. The complete recovery rate was 70%, while 30% suffered recurrences without vascular compression or insufficient compression (mostly venous compression). Even when there was no vascular compression, the trigeminal nerve was frequently kinked; therefore the arachnoid membrane was detached from the trigeminal nerve to untwist the latter during surgery and a steroid was applied to the region. Only 1% of the patients were designated as Class III. Their pathophysiology differed fundamentally from the others. For those patients, surgery was contraindicated and no recovery was noted. The 3.0 telsa sagittal and coronal MRI images were found to be an effective mode of imaging to examine the status of vascular compression around the nerve.
Conclusion: For Class I of tic douloureux, microvascular decompression is the first therapeutic choice. The results were highly satisfactory. If the patient is elderly and anesthesia is not possible, then stereotactic radiosurgery (therapy using a cyber knife) should be considered. For Class II, the clinical symptoms should be examined carefully and other therapeutic modalities should be taken into consideration. If neurovascular decompression is selected, the procedure must be conducted at facilities with ample experience with this procedure. Microvascular decompression must be avoided for Class III. A surgical cure cannot be expected from a sustained dull headache that is experienced after treatment with a gamma knife.
View full abstract