In this study, we focused on middle school students’ pointing and gazing and clarified how their reading behaviors differ depending on the electronic media and print used in the context of the class. The study was conducted at one public junior high school, encompassing 15 days of fieldwork, including nine hours of classroom observation and video data collection.
We considered that a variety of print media other than textbooks, along with electronic media, are appropriate place for observing the reading behaviors of students who use them, and we targeted classes held in school libraries. Video recordings of each media-sharing scene for total of 33 9th grade students in a class, separated by one second to yield a total of 3,611 images from 31 scenes featuring print media and 2,394 images from 49 scenes featuring electronic media, were analyzed. A total of 6,005 photos were classified into five reading behaviors to capture the characteristics of the patterns of print and electronic media use. Then, we applied micro-ethnographic methods to analyze two case studies to determine how the distinctive reading behaviors patterns of each medium are generated.
The results showed that pointing, gazing, and co-gazing were important chain patterns and these three reading acts not only occurred frequently, but also occurred for a certain amount of time. Above all, the following two points were identified. First, students adjusted their reading behaviors to their sequential patterns and generation times in seconds, depending on whether they were using electronic or print media. Second, students made effective use of gazing during the action of reading. The study also revealed that the reading behaviors middle school students exhibit when sharing each medium include not only pointing and cogazing, which indicate text comprehension for both students, but also solo gazing, which indicates contemplative thinking and plays an important function in the classroom.
This study also suggests that consideration should be given to media selection in the classroom, such as using electronic media when having students focus on a specific text and using print media when having students discuss a text based on their understanding of it. Time should also be made for students to interact with the media individually.
View full abstract