The study of the Ch'ieb Yün system should be conducted entirely independent of the Sung dynasty
rhyme
tables. As to the upper ch'ieh characters of the Kuang Yün, Luh Chi-wei divided 51 groups in his “51 Groups of initials of the Kuang Yün, a Formal Proof.”(YJCS 25. 1939. 1-58), and applying the same cross reference method to the T'ang dynasty
rhyme
books, Ling Ta-t'ing proved that there were similar tendencies in these
rhyme
books and the Kuang Yün (YJCS 26. 1939. 129-142). The 319
rhyme
groups, divided by Luh in the same paper, were, as he noticed it, only “the starting point of a study” and not “the result of a study.” The author of this paper classifies the rhymes of Cb'ieb Yün, with reference to the Luh's 51 initial groups and not to the Sung
rhyme
tables, as follows:
I Group chiefly uses the Division II characters.
II Group chiefly uses the Division II characters and Group B of the Division I characters.
III Group chiefly uses the Divsion I characters.
As to the so-called “fan-ch'ieh doublets”(重紐) that appear in the C and D initial Groups of the III
rhyme
Group, some scholars assume the difference in medials (-i-, -ï-) and someone in the principal vowels. Mostly, the lower ch'ieh characters represent the distribution of the class, and A initial Group belonged undoubtedly to the palatal (or closer vowel) class, and B1 Group (側series) to the neutral (or opener vowel) class. But the position of the B2 Group (陟series) within III Group, being not clearly pointed out by fan-ch'ieh, can not be decided. The examination of fanch'ieh show the following pattern:〓The author, then, interprets the doublets as the difference in the initial consonant phonemes: ki-, kji-; pi-, pji-(instead of ki-, ki-; pi), tji-, tci-, tsi-, li-, etc.
As the former interpretations, this one also does not fit the distribution of the Sung
rhyme
tables. The Yün Ching arranges as follows:〓(N. B. A1 includes之, 昌, 食, 式, 時, 而, 以, sub-groups and A
2 includes 子, 七, 疾, 息, 徐sub-groups. In the above table, however, 以sub-group belongs to A
2).
The main problem is the position of A
1 in III Division (except. 以sub-group), and according to the author's view, if such arrangement of the Yün Cbing is acknowledged, the sound shift, from the dorsal consonant (in the Cb'ieb Yün) to apical, must be assumed to have occured between the time of the Cb'ieb Yün and that of compilation of the Yün Cbing: tG->t∫-, tG'->t∫'-, dz>d3-, G->∫-, z->3-. az->3. This phenomena will explain easily why the “30 (or 36) initial alphabets” 三十 (六) 字母compound 之 (tG-) series with 側 (ts-) series and not with 子 (ts-) series.
The Yün Cbing is, therefore, not a mere indication of the Cb'ieb Yün system, but in the interpretation of the latter system it reflects the phonemic system of the time of its compilation.
抄録全体を表示