共生社会システム研究
Online ISSN : 2759-5471
投稿論文
反出生主義における三つの実践的不可能性と「無限責任」の問題
心情から読み解く〈信頼〉の不在とその行方
上柿 崇英
著者情報
ジャーナル フリー

2023 年 17 巻 1 号 p. 77-100

詳細
抄録
Anti-natalism is an ideology that believes that any life born in the world is harmful, and therefore we should not create new life in the world, and that it would be better to exterminate humans as soon as possible. Anti-natalism has spread rapidly in recent years, with the writings of D. Benetar. This argument is certainly persuasive in principle. However, it is only valid in the ideas, and it is fundamentally impossible to bring it into human reality. In real life, we cannot choose to eliminate a particular pain (impossibility of eliminating pain), and we cannot choose a particular action in a situation at will(impossibility of choice). We cannot grasp our own life as independent of the lives of others, and we cannot hold ourselves responsible for it (impossibility of independence). However, the reason why this ideology strikes a chord with so many people living today is because there is something in it that justifies a particular sentiment held by people. Underlying this sentiment is the belief in unlimited responsibility , the belief that one should take full and unlimited responsibility for all one's actions that include affecting others and creating new life. In real human life, one cannot live alone, but must influence others to live. Likewise, if new lives do not come into being, those who have come before them will face tremendous hardship. There is a distorted world view = human view that denies these many realities and fails in trying to take responsibility that cannot be borne in the first place. This illusion of unlimited responsibility , however, has only recently appeared in history. The more fundamental problem is that modern society lacks the ‹trust› to share responsibility for each other's lives. If we, as a society, continue to be unable to foster the ‹trust› , and if we continue to be mired in the illusion of independence, we will be forced to become more and more anti-natalist.
著者関連情報
© 2023 共生社会システム学会
前の記事 次の記事
feedback
Top