2020 Volume 43 Issue 2 Pages 230-239
Cryptococcosis is a potentially lethal disease caused by fungal pathogens including Cryptococcus neoformans and Cryptococcus gattii species complex. These fungal pathogens live in the environment and are associated with certain tree species and bird droppings. This infectious disease is not contagious, and healthy individuals may contract cryptococcal infections by inhaling the airborne pathogens from the environment. Although cleaning a contaminated environment is a feasible approach to control environmental fungal pathogens, prophylactic immunization is also considered a promising method to regulate cryptococcal infections. We review the history of the development of cryptococcal vaccines, vaccine components, and the various forms of immune memory induced by cryptococcal vaccines.
Several mycoses, including cryptococcosis, aspergillosis, and imported mycoses, are caused by pathogenic fungi living in the environment. Although disseminated fungal infections are generally opportunistic, immunocompetent individuals can also contract systemic infections by several fungal pathogens including Cryptococcus gattii and Coccidiodes immitis which inhabit the soil, trees, and dust in certain regions.1,2)
Cryptococcosis is a life-threatening infection caused by inhaling the encapsulated yeasts in Cryptococcus neoformans and C. gattii species complexes.3,4) Cryptococcal cells often disseminate to the central nervous system, leading to meningoencephalitis. C. neoformans generally infects immunocompromised hosts such as AIDS patients, and approximately 220000 cases of cryptococcal meningitis occur among AIDS patients worldwide each year, leading to 180000 deaths annually.5) A retrospective investigation revealed that immunocompetent individuals can also contract C. neoformans infection in Japan.6) In Australia and New Zealand, the original hotspots of C. gattii, immunocompetent individuals are more likely to be infected by C. gattii than immunocompromised hosts.7) Although C. gatii infection has been considered a type of tropical disease, outbreaks of C. gattii infection were reported in Canada and the USA, and immunocompetent individuals also died of C. gattii infection. In the outbreaks, the maximum annual incidence was estimated to be 38 cases (9 cases per million) in British Columbia, Canada, and the mortality rate was in the range of 8.7–33%.8–10)
Systemic cryptococcosis and coccidioidomycosis are designated as category IV and V infectious diseases, respectively, in the Japanese Law of Infectious Disease Control; thus, physicians diagnosing these mycoses must report the occurrence to public health centers. Although the diagnosis and treatment method of mycoses still require specialized experience and knowledge, specific clinical techniques have been established. As a prophylactic approach, vaccines against those mycoses are still under development and are not available in the worldwide clinical setting.
Previous studies developed many experimental vaccines and investigated vaccine-mediated protective immunity against cryptococcosis.11,12) We also developed a dendritic cell (DC)-based vaccine against cryptococcosis caused by the highly virulent C. gattii.13–16) We demonstrated that the DC vaccine improves the survival rate and ameliorates the fungal burden in the lungs after C. gattii infection and that lung resident-memory Th17 cells (lung TRM17) play a role in the vaccine-mediated protective effect.13) Each research group has utilized different antigens, adjuvants, and delivery systems to activate the protective immune memory, including T cells, B cells, and other novel memory cells, against fungal infection. As the progress of vaccine research and development is so rapid, regular overviews of current knowledge are required.
This review focuses on prophylactic vaccines against cryptococcosis. The following sections cover: 1) the history of vaccine development in animal models; 2) antigens and carriers; 3) adjuvants and adoptive cell transfer (ACT) for immunization; and 4) the immune memory contributing to vaccine-mediated protection.
Previous reviews described experimental antifungal vaccines in detail.11,12) Several veterinary vaccines against dermatomycosis, including Insol Dermatophyton, Biocan-M, and RIVAC Mikroderm, are clinically available.17,18) Although vaccines against candidiasis is in human clinical trials, no antifungal human vaccines are yet commercially available.
Experimental vaccines against cryptococcosis are listed in Table 1. As many as possible are included, but there may be some omissions. Cryptococcal vaccines have not yet progressed to clinical trials or for which clinical trials have been discontinued. Note that each vaccine can be characterized by antigen, adjuvant, antigen carrier, route of injection, duration of antifungal effect, and induced protective immune memory.
Year | Antigen | Adjuvant, carrier, and ACT | Vaccine injection route | Vaccine injection frequency | Suggested protective immunity | Challenge strain | Challenge route | Challenge after vaccination | Protection | Animal strain | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1958 | CPs | Sterile resin, Amberlite XE-67 | s.c. | 3 times on alternate days | ND | C. neoformans 3723, 1523, DU, and RE | i.v. | Day 14 | + | Swiss Webster | 94 |
1960 | Live thin capsular Cn | − | i.p. | 3 times every 10 d | ND | C. neoformans 1148 | i.v. | Day 14 | + | Swiss Webster | 60 |
1960 | Enzymatic decapsulated Cn | − | s.c. | 3 times on alternate days | AMI | C. neoformans 3723 | i.v. | Day 14 | + | Swiss Webster | 59 |
1960 | Formalin-killed Cn | − | s.c or i.p. | 4–8 times every 14 d | ND | C. neoformans strain C | i.v. | Day 7 | + | Swiss Webster | 61 |
1963 | CPs | − | i.v. | Once | AMI | C. neoformans BRI, TRE, and BRY | i.v. | Day 7 | + | ICR | 95 |
1967 | CPs | BGG | s.c or i.p. | >2 times | − | C. neoformans serotype A | i.v. | Day 14 | − | CF-1 | 44 |
1976 | Irradiated acapsular Cn mutant | FA | s.c. or i.d. | 4 times every 4–5 d | ND | C. neoformans P36 | i.p. | Day 12 | + | Swiss Webster | 62 |
1978 | Live or HK Cn | − | s.c. | Once | ND | C. neoformans 145 | i.v. | Day 21 | + | CD-1 | 96 |
1979 | Avirulent pseudohyphal Cn mutant, NU-2-P | − | i.p. | 8 times weekly | CMI (DTH response) | C. neoformans NU-2 | i.v. | Day 14 | + | C57BL/6 | 63 |
1982 | Live Cn | − | s.c. | Once | CMI (DTH response) | C. neoformans 145 | i.v. | Day 21 | + | CBA/J | 97 |
1982 | Fractionated culture supernatant | FA | s.c. | 2 times every week | CMI (DTH response) | C. neoformans serotype A | i.p. | Day 14 | + | BALB/c | 98 |
1983 | Live acapsular Cn mutants 64, 67, and 70 | − | i.p. or s.c. | 8 times every 3–4 d | CMI | C. neoformans 9–401 | i.v. | Day 14 | + | C3H/HeN | 64 |
HK capsular Cn strain | |||||||||||
1994 | Live capsular Cn strain | − | i.t. | Once | CD4+ T cells | C. neoformans 184 | i.v. | Days 42–70 | + | BALB/c | 87 |
1995 | Live capsular Cn strain | − | i.t. | Once | TNF-α and IFN-γ dependent | C. neoformans 184 or ura5 | i.v. | Days 5–42 | + | C.B-17 and BALB/c | 88 |
1996 | GXM | TT, MPL | s.c. | 3 times every 2 weeks | AMI | C. neoformans serotype A | i.v. | Day 9 | + | Swiss Webster | 42 |
1997 | Live capsular Cn strain | − | i.t. | Once | B independent, CD4+ T cell dependent | C. neoformans ura5 | i.v. | Day 56 | + | C57BL/6 and μMT | 20 |
1998 | CneF | FA | s.c. | Once | CMI (DTH response) | C. neoformans 184 A | i.v. | Day 8 | + | CBA/J | 57 |
2001 | P13 | TT, BSA, Alhydrogel | s.c. | >3 times every 2 weeks | AMI | C. neoformans ATCC 24067 | i.v. | Day 24 | + | BALB/c and CBA/n | 43 |
2002 | d25 | FA | s.c. | Once | CMI (DTH response) | C. neoformans H99 | i.v. | Day 7 | + | BALB/c | 55 |
2003 | d25 | FA | s.c. | Once | Th1, IFN-γ dependent, IL-2 independent | C. neoformans H99 | i.v. | Day 7 | + | C57BL/6 and BALB/c | 56 |
2004 | Live capsular Cn strain | − | s.c. | Once | CD8+ T cell dependent | C. neoformans ura5 | i.v. | Day 70 | + | Aβ Null mice | 99 |
2004 | MP | Ribi | i.p. | 2 times every 3 weeks | T cell dependent, B cell independent | C. neoformans B3501 | i.v. | Day 7 | + | C57BL/6 and CBA/J | 21 |
2005 | Live Cn mutant ∆cna1 | − | i.n. | Once | − | C. neoformans H99 | i.n. | Day 28 | − | A/J | 100 |
2006 | HK Cn | FA | s.c. | Once | Th1 | C. neoformans 102/85 | i.p. | Day 4 | + | Wistar rat | 101 |
2007 | Live Cn expressing IFN-γ (H99γ) | − | i.n. | Once | Th1 | C. neoformans H99 | i.n. | Day 70 | + | A/J and BALB/c | 65 |
2009 | Live Cn expressing IFN-γ (H99γ) | − | i.n. | Once | B cell and IL-4R independent, IFN-γ and IL-12 dependent, Th1 | C. neoformans H99 | i.n. | Day 100 | + | BALB/c | 22 |
2011 | Opsonized live Cn | Eosinophils | i.p. | Once | Th1 | C. neoformans 102/85 | i.p. | Day 10 | + | Wistar rat | 78, 79 |
2011 | GalXM | FA, BSA conjugate | i.p. | 4 times every 2 weeks | − | C. neoformans ATCC 24067 | i.v. | Day 1 | − | BALB/c | 45 |
2011 | Live Cn expressing IFN-γ (H99γ) | − | i.n. | Once | T cell dependent and independent immunity | C. neoformans H99 | i.n. | Day 70 | + | BALB/c | 93 |
2013 | Crude proteins extracted from Cn | − | i.n. | 3 times every 4 weeks | AMI, CMI | C. neoformans H99 | i.n. | Day 10 | + | BALB/c | 51 |
2014 | Crude proteins extracted from Cg | − | i.n. | 3 times every 4 weeks | AMI, CMI | C. gattii R265 | i.n. | Day 10 | + | BALB/c | 52 |
2015 | Live Cn mutants ∆sgl1 | − | i.n. | Once | CD4+ T cell independent | C. neoformans H99, and C. gattii R265 | i.n. | Day 30 | + | CBA/J | 66 |
2015 | HK Cg mutant ∆cap60 | DC | i.v. | 2 times every 2 weeks | Th1, Th17 | C. gattii R265 | i.t. | Day 1 | + | C57BL/6 | 14 |
2015 | Live and HK Cn strain overexpressing ZNF2 | − | i.n. | Once | Th1, Th17 | C. neoformans H99 | i.n. | Day 25 or 48 | + | A/J | 67 |
2015 | 1. Live Cn mutant ∆cda1/2/3 or ∆cap59 | GP | s.c. | 3 times every 2 weeks | Th1, Th17 | C. neoformans KN99, and C. gattii R265 | i.n. | Day 14 | + | C57BL/6J | 53 |
2. Alkaline-extracted crude proteins derived from Cn | |||||||||||
2016 | Live or HK Cn mutant ∆cda1/2/3 | − | i.n. | Once | Th1 | C. neoformans KN99, C. gattii R265, and WM276 | i.n. | Day 40 | + | CBA/J, C57BL/6, BALB/c, A/J, and 129 | 68 |
2017 | Live Cn expressing IFN-γ (H99γ) | − | i.n. | Once | Th1 | C. neoformans H99, C. gattii R265, C. bacillisporus WSA87, and C. deneoformans R4247 | i.n. | Day 70 | + | BALB/c | 33 |
2017 | Recombinant proteins, Sod1, Cda1, Cda2, and/or Cda3 | GP | s.c. | 3 times every 2 weeks | ND | C. neoformans KN99, and C. gattii R265 | i.t. | Day 14 | + | C57BL/6, BALB/c, and humanized DR4 mice | 54 |
2018 | Live Cn expressing IFN-γ (H99γ) | − | i.n. | Once | Independent of T cells, B cells, neutrophils, and NK cells, trained Mφ | C. neoformans H99, and C. gattii R265 | i.n. | Day 70 | + | BALB/c | 25 |
2019 | HK Cg mutant ∆cap60 | DC | i.v. | 2 times every 2 weeks | IL-17A dependent, lung TRM17 | C. gattii R265 | i.t. | Days 60–180 | + | C57BL/6 | 13 |
2019 | Live Cn mutant ∆sgl1/∆cap59 | − | i.n. | Once | − | C. neoformans H99 | i.n. | Day 30 | − | CBA/J | 102 |
2019 | Live Cn expressing IFN-γ (H99γ) | − | i.n. | Once | Trained DCs | C. neoformans H99 | i.n. | Day 70 | + | BALB/c | 24 |
Cn: C. neoformans; Cg: C. gattii; HK: heat-killed; ND: not determined; ∆cna1: disruptant of gene coding calcineurin A1, avirulent temperature-sensitive mutant; ∆cda1/2/3: disruptant of three genes coding chitin deacetylase, chitosan-deficient avirulent strain; ∆sgl1: disruptant of gene coding sterylglucosidase-1, avirulent strain accumulating sterylglucosides; ∆cap59, ∆cap60: disruptant of capsule synthesis-related gene, acapsular mutant; ZNF2: gene coding the transcriptional factor, zinc finger protein (the overexpression strain forms hyphae in C. neoformans, and this strain strongly induced inflammatory response in the lungs after infection); ura5: mutant of orotidine monophosphate pyrophosphorylase which is uracil auxotrophic and can proliferate in medium containing 5-fluoroorotic acid (5-FOA) (wild-type cryptococcal cells used for immunization cannot grow in the medium and thus cryptococcal cells for immunization and challenge are distinguishable on plates containing 5-FOA); Th1: CD4+ helper T cells producing IFN-γ; Th17: CD4+ helper T cells producing IL-17A; μMT mice: B-cell deficient mice; DR4 mice: humanized mice expressing human HLA-DR4 (DRB*0401) and lacking endogenous mouse MHC class II; Aβ null mice: MHC class II-deficient mice in which CD4+ T cells are absent; Protection (+/−): +=immunization improved survival rates or reduced fungal burdens after challenge. Other abbreviations are defined in the main text.
In the early days, whole cryptococcal cells and capsular polysaccharides (CPs) were used as vaccination antigens; in recent years, recombinant cryptococcal cells and antigenic proteins have become available for immunization, as described below. The vaccinations have been administered via the intradermal (i.d.), subcutaneous (s.c.), intraperitoneal (i.p.), intravenous, and intranasal (i.n.) injection routes. To augment pulmonary local immunity more efficiently, intranasal forms are being used in the development of experimental and clinical vaccines against pulmonary infectious diseases including influenza, tuberculosis, pertussis, and pneumococcal infection.19)
Vaccines generally induce memory B cells and antibody-mediated immunity (AMI), while several cryptococcal vaccines depend on T cell-mediated immunity (CMI) including the delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response in a B cell-independent manner.20–22) Since C. neoformans often infects immunocompromised hosts such as AIDS patients, vaccines have also been evaluated in immunodeficient mice lacking T cells, B cells, and/or other immune cells. Those studies provided new insights into what is termed “innate memory” or “trained immunity,” where innate immune cells, including macrophages (Mφ), DCs, and natural killer (NK) cells, exert memory like-responses to antigen reexposure.23–26)
The immune response and susceptibility to infection often differ in various mouse strains, and different cryptococcal strains show different virulence. Outbred mice such as ICR and Swiss mice were used for early vaccine protection assays, but inbred mice, including C57BL/6, BALB/c, and CBA/J strains, have been widely used in more recent studies. In the pulmonary infection model with C. neoformans, C57BL/6 mice showed a higher fungal burden in the lungs 4 weeks postinfection than BALB/c and CBA/J mice, and BALB/c mice showed longer survival times than CBA/J mice.27,28) Because genome-wide studies were performed against standard strains including C. neoformans H99 and C. gattii R265, those standard strains have been commonly used in recent studies evaluating vaccine efficacy. Although there are contradictory data, it is believed that C. gattii R265 isolated in the Vancouver, Canada, outbreak is a more virulent strain than C. neoformans H99.29–33) At present, protective vaccines can ameliorate the fungal burden and improve the survival rate after C. gattii infection, although no vaccine offers complete protection from cryptococcosis caused by highly virulent C. gattii R265.
Cryptococcal cells forms capsular layers on the cell surface which can be visualized with the Indian ink method under a microscope. The capsules consist of CPs including glucuronoxylomannan (GXM) and galactoxylomannan (GalXM).34) CPs enable cryptococcal cells to evade anticryptococcal immune systems.35,36) We demonstrated that capsular cryptococcal cells could not be recognized by immune cells without opsonization and that acapsular mutants are immediately engulfed by innate immune cells.14,37,38) Cryptococcal cells can be opsonized with anti-GXM antibody, and opsonized capsular cells are phagocytized by innate immune cells.39,40) Thus, it is reasonable to use GXM or GalXM as vaccine antigens to induce specific antibodies and AMI.
CPs are categorized into the T cell-independent type-2 (TI-2) antigens and poorly immunogenic antigen.41) To enhance the immunogenicity of CPs, previous studies developed CP-protein carrier-conjugated vaccines, and tetanus toxoid (TT),42,43) bovine γ-globulin (BGG),44) and bovine serum albumin (BSA)43,45) have been used as protein carriers. Ten-base peptides mimicking the GXM epitope were screened from a peptide library, and peptide P13 was used for a conjugation vaccine.43,46) Although the GalXM-conjugated vaccine did not prolong survival times when challenged with C. neoformans,45) GXM- or P13-conjugated vaccine significantly increased the survival rate after challenge.42,43) It has not been demonstrated whether CP-based vaccines could protect against C. gattii infection.
3.2. MannoproteinsAs well as common pathogenic fungi, cryptococcal cells express highly mannosylated proteins, referred to as mannoproteins (MPs), on the cell surface and can secrete them to the extracellular space during infection.47,48) Cryptococcal cells require MPs for infection to progress and therefore MPs are feasible targets for vaccine antigens. In contrast to CPs, MPs are T-cell dependent (TD) antigens, and vaccines containing cryptococcal MPs likely induce CMI and AMI for protection against cryptococcosis.49,50) Both crude and single recombinant MPs have been used as vaccine antigens, and it was found that those vaccines significantly improved survival rates and decreased fungal burdens when challenged with C. neoformans and highly virulent C. gattii.21,51–56)
C. neoformans culture filtrate antigen (CneF) is a crude antigen containing GXM, GalXM, and MPs, and MPs can be enriched from the culture filtrate via concanavalin A (ConA) affinity columns.21,57) The following MPs have been identified as protective vaccine antigens: chitin deacetylase (Cda1, Cda2, also known as MP98 and Cda3); and a 25-kDa chitin deacetylase homologue (d25).54–56)
3.3. Other Antigenic ProteinsNon-MPs in the cell wall and cytoplasm were also identified as protective vaccine antigens. Those proteins can be extracted from cryptococcal cells via a mild alkaline extraction technique, the 2-mercaptoethanol method, or a manufactured kit. Superoxide dismutase (Sod1) was identified as the protective vaccine antigen that was the most abundant protein in the mild alkaline extract of C. neoformans acapsular mutant ∆cap59.53,54) It was demonstrated that vaccination with the cytoplasmic proteins significantly prolonged survival times and reduced the fungal burden after the infection challenge with highly virulent C. gattii.52,54)
3.4. Whole-Cell AntigensLike vaccines against other infectious diseases, live or inactivated whole cryptococcal cells have been used for the vaccines.58) In early research, wild-type capsular strains, spontaneous mutants, and mutants generated with random mutagenesis were used for vaccination, and every approach prolonged survival rates after infection challenge.59–64) More recently, the following strains have been constructed using the gene-targeting approach and used for immunization: C. neoformans interferon-γ (IFN-γ)-expressing strain (H99γ); ZNF2 overexpression strain; ∆sgl1 strain; ∆cda1/2/3 strain; ∆cap59 strain; and C. gattii ∆cap60 strain.14,53,65–68) Interestingly, all groups immunized with C. neoformans recombinants had significantly improved survival rates when challenged with highly virulent C. gattii as well as with C. neoformans. Thus, it appears that these immunizations are cross-reactive to C. neoformans and C. gattii infection.
On MPs, the mannose polymer mannan is a pathogen-associated molecular pattern that can be recognized by pattern recognition receptors (PRRs) such as a dectin-2 on innate immune cells.69) It was shown that C. neoformans Cda2 recombinant protein prepared in Pichia pastoris was recognized by dectin-2 in B3Z reporter cells and DCs, and recombinant soluble dectin-2 physically bound to C. gattii cells.38,70) Antigen-presenting cells (APCs) such as DCs can uptake MPs via PRRs and process MPs for antigen presentation to naive T cells.71,72) Recombinant proteins generated in Escherichia coli (rCda1, rCda2, rCda3, rd25, and rSod1) are likely lacking glycosylation and similar to CPs are less recognizable as foreign antigens. Adjuvants are substances to compensate for the weak antigenicity of vaccine antigens, and the following adjuvants have been added to cryptococcal vaccines: glucan particles (GPs); Freund’s adjuvant (FA); Ribi adjuvant; monophosphoryl lipid A (MPL); and alhydrogel.73,74)
4.2. ACT for ImmunizationACT is used to administer immune cells to a host. It is commonly used in cancer therapy and is a candidate for antifungal immunotherapy or immunization.75–77)
We have developed a DC vaccine against cryptococcosis caused by highly virulent C. gattii.14) In this approach, DCs were pulsed with the heat-inactivated C. gattii acapsular mutant ∆cap60, and then the antigen-pulsed DCs were transferred to the host. DCs are major APCs, and the antigen-loaded DCs potently induce the cytokine-producing T cells that are responsible for CMI against cryptococcosis.13,14)
It was shown that eosinophils (Eos) can also be used for immunization against cryptococcosis in a rat model.78,79) Eos can phagocytize opsonized cryptococcal cells and present antigens to T cells in a major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-dependent manner.78) The transfer of cryptococcal cell-pulsed Eos (Cn-pulsed Eos) significantly decreased the fungal burden after challenge with C. neoformans.79) Interestingly, Cn-pulsed Eos promoted the proliferation of C. neoformans-specific T cells producing IFN-γ but not interleukin (IL)-4.78) Although there is an advantage that these approaches can induce protective CMI, ACT-based vaccines will not be immediately applied in the clinical setting due to the cost-effectiveness problem.
CP-based vaccine produces plasma B cells that secrete CP-specific antibodies including immunoglobulin M (IgM) and IgG, and some B cells likely become memory B cells that can immediately respond to secondary exposure to CPs via B cell receptors (BCRs).23,80) The unique antigen binding sites of BCRs are identical to those of the secreted antibodies recognizing the CP epitope (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK26884/). CP-based vaccine significantly increases the serum titer of CP-specific antibody, and passive immunization with CP vaccine-induced antiserum significantly prolongs survival time after challenge.42,43) Therefore, AMI appears to be involved in the protective effects of CP-based vaccine.
Anti-GXM monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) including 18B7 and 2H1 were generated from splenocytes of BALB/c mice that received the GXM-TT conjugate vaccine.81,82) Those mAbs can opsonize capsular cryptococcal cells and enhance phagocytes to uptake fungal cells.39,40) Intraperitoneal administration of 18B7 or 2H1 mAb significantly decreased the serum GXM concentration and increased the survival rate after intraperitoneal infection with C. neoformans.81,82) Thus, vaccine-induced AMI may be involved in the opsonization of cryptococcal cells and help the innate immune cells including neutrophils and Mφ to uptake and kill cryptococcal cells.
Similar to CP-based vaccine, immunization with cryptococcal proteins or whole cells likely induces the production of antigen-specific B cells that are helped by cognate T cells.49,50) However, those vaccines exert sufficient protective effects in B cell-deficient mice when challenged with C. neoformans.20–22) Thus, rather than AMI, CMI has been the subject of recent major cryptococcal vaccine studies.
5.2. T CellsT cells can be separated into the following different subsets: 1) conventional T cells (CD4+ helper T cells and CD8+ cytotoxic T cells); and 2) unconventional innate-like T cells (γδ T cells, NKT cells, and MAIT cells).83–85) In general, conventional T cells differentiate into memory T cells after immunization with protein antigens, and memory T cells can be divided into the stem cell-like memory, central memory, effector memory, and tissue-resident memory subsets.86) Memory T cells immediately proliferate or produce effector molecules including cytokines and cytotoxic effectors when T cell receptors (TCRs) receive the epitope of protein antigen by APCs during reinfection.86) Protective immunization with cryptococcal proteins or whole cells clearly activates T cells, mainly CD4+ helper T cells, producing inflammatory cytokines including IFN-γ, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α, and IL-17A, and vaccine efficacy was reported to be significantly attenuated under cytokine-deficient conditions.13,14,20–22,56,87,88) Thus, the findings suggest that T-cell-related cytokines including IFN-γ, TNF-α, and IL-17A are required for the protective effect of cryptococcal vaccines using TD antigen.
In general, IFN-γ, TNF-α, and IL-17A play a crucial role in leukocyte recruitment, activation, and granuloma formation. Granuloma consists of tight mononuclear infiltrates surrounding unremovable foreign substances such as cryptococcal cells and it differs from the loose inflammatory infiltrates that are a characteristic pathology of allergic bronchopulmonary mycosis.22) Granuloma is often found in the lungs of protected mice that received a cryptococcal vaccine.13,14,22,89) For example, activated neutrophils expressing the activation markers Siglec-F and CD11c and granuloma are induced 7–14 d postinfection in the lungs of C57BL/6 mice that received the DC vaccine, but not in the lungs of IL-17A knockout (KO) mice. Furthermore, DC vaccine cannot reduce the fungal burden in the lungs of IL-17A KO mice. These results suggest that the DC vaccine requires an IL-17A response, mainly produced by lung TRM17 (described in further detail below), for the protective effect after challenge.13)
H99γ whole-cell vaccine protects against C. neoformans infection in IL-4R KO mice as well as in C57BL/6 mice, but not in IL-12p40, IL-12p35, and INF-γ KO mice.22) The cryptococcal d25-vaccine significantly improved the survival rate of mice in which IL-2 was depleted, but not of INF-γ KO mice.56) These results suggest that several cryptococcal vaccines require CD4+ Th1-related cytokines, including IFN-γ and IL-12.
Tissue-resident memory T cells (TRMs) are newly identified nonvascular T cells found in various nonlymphoid tissues including the lungs, brain, liver, and intestine. Various types of local infection induce the differentiation of circulating memory T cells and TRMs, and CD4+ TRMs can quickly secrete cytokines after responding to secondary exposure to antigen proteins presented by APCs.86) Recent studies have demonstrated that lung TRMs are involved in the protection from pulmonary infectious diseases, and researchers have developed vaccines inducing protective lung TRMs against pulmonary infectious diseases.90) We developed the DC vaccine that strongly induces lung CD4+ TRM secreting IL-17A (lung TRM17).13) Lung TRM17 is detectable in the lung parenchyma for at least 6 months after immunization, and this subset can be reactivated by cryptococcal antigens but not by unrelated antigens derived from Candida albicans, suggesting that lung TRM17 is an antigen-specific T cell. DC vaccine can ameliorate fungal burden in the lungs when infected with C. gattii within 6 months after the final vaccination; suggesting that the long life of lung TRM17 is correlated with the long-term protective effect of DC vaccine.13)
Administration of the immunosuppressive agent FTY720 inhibits lymphocyte egress from lymph nodes and critically decreases circulating T and B cells in blood.91) Although the administration of FTY720 induces lymphopenia, substantial levels of TRMs can be detected in various organs of FTY720-treated hosts.92) DC vaccine exerts protective effects even if the mice receive FTY720 during infection, suggesting that circulating lymphocytes are dispensable and that the protective effects of DC vaccine likely depend on the TRM subset.13)
5.3. Trained Innate Immune CellsThere is a new paradigm referred to as “innate immune memory” or “trained immunity,” where innate immune cells exert memory-like responses against reexposure to antigens in the absence of T cells and B cells.26) Surprisingly, H99γ vaccine significantly prolonged survival time in B cell-deficient mice in which CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, neutrophils, and NK cells were also depleted by specific antibodies, suggesting that nonconventional memory cells are involved in vaccine-mediated protection from cryptococcosis.25,93) In this model, spleen Mφ or DCs were isolated 70 d after the final immunization with H99γ, and then those immune cells were restimulated by cryptococcal cells or unrelated antigens, including lipopolysaccharide (LPS), C. albicans, and Streptococcus aureus. As a result, the vaccine induced-Mφ and DCs secreted greater amounts of inflammatory cytokines, including IL-2, IL-4, and IFN-γ, than in the case of Mφ and DCs isolated from nonimmunized mice.24,25) In general, innate immune memory has less strict antigen specificity compared with conventional acquired immunity and can cross-react against other pathogens.26) However, unrelated antigens, including LPS, C. albicans, and S. aureus, did not induce the cytokine recall response in H99γ-trained Mφ and DCs. These results suggest that H99γ-trained Mφ and DCs can be specifically recalled by crytptococcal antigens.24,25) This trained immunity may be a new solution to protect against cryptococcosis in immunocompromised hosts lacking CD4+ T cells.
The outline of the mechanism of cryptococcal vaccine is shown in Fig. 1. TI-2 and TD antigens have been used in combination with various adjuvants, nanoparticles, and ACT to develop cryptococcal-protective vaccines. TI-2 antigen-based vaccines produce cryptococcus-specific antibodies and enhance AMI including opsonization of cryptococcal cells after reinfection. However, it has not been demonstrated whether vaccines inducing AMI can protect against highly pathogenic C. gattii infection. Recent studies have focused on cryptococcal vaccines inducing CMI. It was demonstrated that several vaccines inducing CMI significantly increase survival rates and decrease fungal burdens in various mice strains when infected with C. gattii. Those vaccine studies also newly identified the potentially protective immune memory, including lung TRM17 and H99γ-trained Mφ/DCs.13,24,25) Future studies will be needed to develop vaccines that are effective in immunodeficient hosts lacking CD4+ T cells, such as AIDS patients, and can offer complete protection against cryptococcosis caused by highly virulent C. gattii.
In cryptococcal vaccines, various antigens including CPs, MPs, cytosolic proteins, and whole cells have been used with the vaccine enhancers shown in Table 1. It was demonstrated that DCs and Eos could be used for ACT to induce protective CMI. Although CP-based vaccines protect against C. neoformans infection via AMI, there is no evidence that CP-based vaccines protect against cryptococcosis caused by highly virulent C. gattii. Cryptococcus-specific antibody and T cell responses cannot directly remove cryptococcal cells, and those immune responses induce innate immunity to suppress fungal growth. Vaccine-induced AMI can increase opsonization of cryptococcal cells via specific antibodies, and vaccine-induced CMI generally requires inflammatory cytokines including IFN-γ, TNF-α, and IL-17A to recruit and activate innate immune cells, including granulocytes, Mφ, and DCs. Granuloma is a typical pathological finding in the lungs of protected mice that received cryptococcal vaccines. Granuloma likely suppresses fungal growth through the tight mononuclear infiltrates surrounding unremovable cryptococcal cells. It was shown that novel immune memory such as lung-resident CD4+ TRMs and innate immune memory were induced by cryptococcal vaccines, in addition to conventional immune memory.
Our research was supported by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology of Japan (KAKENHI 17K18385 and 17K10040); Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development (AMED 19fk0108049, JP19fk0108045, and JP19fk0108094); and Takeda Science Foundation.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.