Chemical and Pharmaceutical Bulletin
Online ISSN : 1347-5223
Print ISSN : 0009-2363
ISSN-L : 0009-2363
Current Topics-Recent Progress in Study on the Biologically-Active Natural Products-
New Approaches to Drug Discovery for Combating MRSA
Hiroshi Tomoda
Author information
JOURNAL FREE ACCESS FULL-TEXT HTML

2016 Volume 64 Issue 2 Pages 104-111

Details
Abstract

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococuss aureus (MRSA) is a major nosocomial pathogen that has developed resistance to many antibiotics. New anti-infective drugs to prevent and treat MRSA infection are required. Four assay systems were conducted to screen microbial cultures for new anti-infective compounds active against MRSA. Nosokomycins, new members of the phosphoglycolipid family, were discovered from a culture of Streptomyces cyslabdanicus K04-0144 in an MRSA-silkworm infection assay. The target molecule of nosokomycins was suggested to be the transglycosylase of penicillin binding protein (PBP) involved in MRSA peptidoglycan biosynthesis. Spirohexaline, with a hexacycline structure, was isolated from a fungal culture of Penicillium brasilianum FKI-3368 in an enzyme assay of undecaprenyl pyrophosphate (UPP) synthase, which is needed for the synthesis and transport of GlcNAc–MurNAc–pentapeptides from the cytoplasmic membrane site to the external membrane site for peptidoglycan synthesis. Spirohexaline inhibited MRSA growth by the blockade of UPP synthase activity. Cyslabdan, with a cysteine-carrying labdan skeleton, was also discovered from the nosokomycin-producing actinomycete as a potentiator of imipenem activity against MRSA. The molecular target of cyslabdan was identified as FemA, which is involved in the synthesis of a pentaglycine interpeptide bridge in MRSA peptidoglycan. Citridone A with a unique 6-6/5/5-ring system containing a rare phenyl-R-furopyridone skeleton, originally isolated as a potentiator of antifungal miconazole activity, was found to inhibit MRSA yellow pigment production. These new microbial products will serve as lead compounds for developing new anti-infective drugs for combating MRSA.

1. Introduction

The current increase in antibiotic resistant pathogenic microorganisms, including methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), vancomycin resistant Enterococci, and multidrug resistant Gram-negative bacilli has yielded a serious threat to public health.1,2) Therefore, discovery and development of novel antibiotics is in great demand. Considering the moderate state of new antibiotic development by pharmaceutical companies, however, academia can play an important role in discovering new antibiotics and providing potential leads for clinical drugs. Therefore, government should support academia in developing such potential antibiotics or leads, at least to the Phase I stage.

MRSA is a major nosocomial pathogen that has developed resistance to many antibiotics.3) It has been reported that MRSA has become resistant even to vancomycin, the last-resort antibiotic.4) This prompted us to search for new anti-infective compounds active against MRSA from microbial resources. Anti-infective compounds include those that inhibit the growth of pathogens, kill them, control their adaptation, survival or pathogenicity and potentiate antibiotic activity against such pathogens.5,6) On the basis of this anti-infective idea, four assay systems were conducted to screen microbial cultures for new anti-infective compounds active against MRSA. We believe natural products, including microbial metabolites, are the best source for new drug discovery.7) In this review, the rationales, assay (screening) systems, new compounds of microbial origin discovered in the screening systems, and their biological activities are described.

2. Screening for Anti-MRSA Antibiotics in Silkworm Infection Assay

Antibiotic candidates against pathogenic microorganisms are generally screened using in vitro assay systems, such as the traditional paper disk method and microdilution method; however, in most cases, these candidates subsequently show no therapeutic effects in in vivo assays using mammals such as mice, rabbits and monkeys, because the pharmacokinetics, systemic absorption and stability of candidates are poor in the mammal body. Therefore, in vivo studies have been required for developing clinical drugs. However, such studies have several inherent problems, including high costs, animal welfare, ethical issues and so on. To overcome these issues in the discovery of new anti-MRSA antibiotics, we introduced an in vivo-mimic infection assay using silkworms in the early stages of a screening program.

Our silkworm infection assay was carried out according to established methods.8) Briefly, MRSA culture was injected into the dorsal hemolymph of the fifth instar silkworm. Immediately, a test sample was injected into the hemolymph. If the sample was inactive, all the MRSA-infected silkworms died within 3 d. However, if vancomycin, an anti-MRSA agent clinically used, was injected, all silkworms survived. In the primary screening, those microbial culture samples were selected in which at least three of 5 MRSA-infected silkworms survived following injection. The screening results are summarized in Table 1, including the screening result from the paper disk assay. From 5340 culture samples, the primary hit number was 327 (6.1%) in the paper disk screening and 21 (0.4%) in the silkworm screening. Thus, we found that the hit rate is extremely low in this in vivo-mimic assay, with the expectation that we exclude false-positive or in vivo-inactive samples in the primary screening. Figure 1 shows the compounds isolated in the silkworm screening. Helvolic acid,9,10) isolated from a fungal culture, was structurally related to fusidic acid, a clinically used antibiotic. Acremonidin C was reported to show in vivo efficacy in the mouse infection assay with MRSA.11) Furthermore, gilvocarcin V12) and lavanducyanin,13) originally reported as antitumor compounds, were found to show efficacy in our assay system without toxicity to the host silkworms.

Table 1. Hit Sample Number in MRSA-Silkworm Infection Assay and Paper Disk Assay
SourceTotal number of samplesHit number
Silkworm assayPaper disk assay
Actinomycetes294015184
Fungi24006143
Total534021327
(Hit rate)(100%)(0.4%)(6.1%)
Fig. 1. Anti-MRSA Antibiotics Obtained from in Vivo-Mimic Infection Screening Using Silkworm

From this screening program, new compounds, named nosokomycins A to D, were isolated from a culture of Streptomyces cyslabdanicus K04-0144.8) They are structurally related to moenomycins,14) which consist of a polyprenyl chain, a phosphoglycerate, and a carbohydrate chain (pentasaccharide). Moenomycins were known to inhibit the transglycosylase of penicillin binding protein (PBP) involved in bacterial peptidoglycan biosynthesis,15,16) suggesting that the target molecule of nosokomycins is transglycosylase. We first confirmed that nosokomycins A and B were effective at 50 µg/larva in the silkworms infected with MRSA. Then, from the agar diffusion assay, all nosokomycins showed potent activity against Gram-positive bacteria, including multidrug-resistant MRSA17) (resistant to methicillin, imipenem, ciprofloxacin and tobramycin) with analogous minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) values (0.125–0.25 µg/mL). Furthermore, nosokomycins B and D exhibited moderate activity against Gram-negative bacteria.18) From the population analysis using 54 clinically isolated MRSAs, nosokomycins A to D completely inhibited almost all the MRSAs at 0.50, 0.25, 1.0 and 0.50 µg/mL, respectively, while vancomycin, arbekacin and linezolid did at 1.0, 1.0 and 2.0 µg/mL, respectively.18) These findings indicated that nosokomycins are as potent as, or even more potent than, current clinically used anti-MRSA antibiotics.

From this silkworm screening, in collaboration with Sekimizu’s group, new anti-MRSA antibiotics named lysocins were discovered in the bacterial culture of Lysobacter sp. RH2180-5.19) Lysocin E showed potent in vitro activity against MRSA and in vivo efficacy in the mouse model. Hamamoto et al. revealed that the mechanism of action lies in its specific interaction with bacterial menaquinone.19) We expect that these compounds discovered in the silkworm assay will be developed as practically useful anti-MRSA drugs.

3. Screening for Inhibitors of MRSA Undecaprenyl Pyrophosphate Synthase

Undecaprenyl pyrophosphate (UPP) is a key lipid involved in the biosynthesis of bacterial peptidoglycan.20) In the bacterial cell wall synthetic pathway, as shown in Fig. 2, UPP is needed for the synthesis and transport of hydrophilic GlcNAc–MurNAc–pentapeptides across the hydrophobic environment of the cytoplasmic membrane to the externally located sites of polymerization. Enzymes involved in peptidoglycan synthesis are anticipated to be ideal targets for the development of novel antibiotics.

Fig. 2. Biosynthetic Pathway of Cell Wall Peptidoglycan

UPP synthase produces UPP by consecutive condensation reactions of one farnesyl pyrophosphate (FPP) with 8 isopentenyl pyrophosphates (IPP). UPP synthase inhibitors, therefore, will cause specific growth inhibition of bacteria including MRSA. Accordingly, an enzyme assay for UPP synthase was conducted using recombinant MRSA UPP synthase. The amount of pyrophosphate produced by the enzyme was determined according to the established method.21) IPP-derived pyrophosphate was hydrolyzed by inorganic pyrophosphatase22) to determine the amount of phosphate. As a practical screening strategy, a total of 12118 cultures (5941 actinomycetes and 6177 fungi) were first screened for antimicrobial activity against S. aureus and Bacillus subtilis. As a result, 949 showed antimicrobial activity. Next, they were evaluated in the UPP synthase assay, and 123 culture samples were selected (1.0%). Finally, four compounds were purified and identified, as shown in Fig. 3. Among these, spirohexaline and epi-trichosetin were new compounds. Spirohexaline and structurally related viridicatumtoxin were isolated from a fungal culture of Penicillium brasilianum FKI-3368.22) These compounds inhibited UPP synthase activity with IC50 values of 9.0 and 4.0 µM, and exhibited anti-MRSA activity with MICs of 1.56 and 6.25 µg/mL, respectively. From further selectivity studies, these were found to more selectively inhibit UPP synthase than the functionally related enzymes, octaprenyl pyrophosphate synthase from Escherichia (E.) coli and mammalian dehydrodolichyl pyrophosphate synthase. epi-Trichosetin (Fig. 3) was isolated, along with the known stereoisomer trichosetin, from a fungal culture of Fusarium oxysporum FKI-4553.23) Both epi-trichosetin and trichosetin moderately inhibited UPP synthase activity, with IC50s of 82 and 30 µM, respectively, and thus exhibited anti-MRSA activity. These inhibitors will be evaluated by silkworm infection assay to define their potential for further developmental studies.

Fig. 3. Microbial UPP Synthase Inhibitors Discovered from Target-Based Screening

4. Screening for Potentiators of Imipenem Activity against MRSA

MRSA is resistant to β-lactam drugs, including imipenem, the most common clinically used β-lactam. One of our screening ideas for combatting MRSA was to search for compounds that could restore imipenem activity against MRSA.

This screening system was based on a common technique, namely, comparing the anti-MRSA activity of samples by a paper disk method in the presence and absence of imipenem to select microbial culture samples that show anti-MRSA activity only in the presence of imipenem. More than 10000 culture samples were screened, and two cultures, Aspergillus sp. FKI-2136 and Streptomyces cyslabdanicus K04-0144, were selected. The former fungus was found to produce new tetracyclic quinones, designated stemphones B to G24,25) (Fig. 4). The latter strain26) produced four new compounds: three cyslabdans with a labdan-type diterpene structure connecting to an N-acetylcysteine residue via thioether linkage,27,28) and nosokophic acid, predicted to be a biosynthetic intermediate of moenomycins.29) The stereochemistry of these compounds was determined in part by nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) experiments and degradation studies. Recent study of the total synthesis of cyslabdan enabled the determination of complete relative and absolute stereochemistry.30) As described above, nosokomycins were also isolated from the same culture of this actinomycete. Thus, Streptomyces cyslabdanicus K04-0144 is a versatile microbe that produces three kinds of unique compounds, cyslabdans, nosokophic acid and nosokomycins, for combatting MRSA. These findings indicate the high potentiality and importance of microbial sources.

Fig. 4. New Microbial Imipenem Potentiators against MRSA Discovered from Phenotype-Based Screening

Recently, analysis of the genome sequence of S. cyslabdanicus K04-0144 revealed that a set of four genes, cldA, cldB, cldC, and cldD, were involved in the biosynthesis of cyslabdan.31) These gene products were found to form a key epoxy intermediate from three IPPs and one dimethylallyl pyrophosphate (DMAPP). Subsequently, an intermediate was converted into mycothiol-S-conjugate through a non-enzymatic nucleophilic reaction, which was finally hydrolyzed to generate cyslabdan. This labdan-type diterpene backbone connecting to an N-acetylcysteine residue via thioether linkage is very rare among bacterial metabolites. This study provided an important biosynthetic insight into this diterpene family.

All of the compounds listed in Fig. 4 enhanced the imipenem activity against MRSA; however they themselves showed no activity against MRSA.24,32) Furthermore, a comparative study with a microdilution method indicated that cyslabdan is the most active in enhancing imipenem activity against MRSA (Table 2). Interestingly, cyslabdan had no restoration activity in combination with other typical antibiotics (streptomycin, vancomycin, tetracycline and ciprofloxacin).33) Furthermore, among β-lactam drugs, cyslabdan effectively restored carbapenem activity against MRSA by over 1000-fold. Similarly, the potentiation of stemphone C and nosokophic acid tended to be selective towards β-lactam drugs.24,29)

Table 2. Potentiating Activity of Imipenem of Stemphones, Cyslabdans and Nosokophic Acid against MRSA
CompoundMIC (µg/mL) of imipenema)Potentiation ratio (fold)b)
None+Compound
Stemphone
B160.03533
C160.03533
D160.06267
E160.03533
F160.06267
G16161
Cyslabdan160.0151067
Cyslabdan B160.125128
Cyslabdan C160.03533
Nosokophic acid160.03533

a) Potentiating activity of imipenem against MRSA is evaluated by measuring the MIC value of imipenem against MRSA in the absence and presence of the compounds of 10 µg/mL. b) Potentiation ratio is expressed as MIC value in the absence of a compound/MIC value in the presence of a compound.

To identify the molecular target responsible for cyslabdan’s unique biological activity, cyslabdan-binding proteins were searched in an MRSA lysate, leading to the identification of FemA, which is involved in the synthesis of the pentaglycine interpeptide bridge in MRSA peptidoglycan.33) Furthermore, analysis of peptidoglycan accumulated in cyslabdan-treated MRSA, and the inhibition of FemA enzymatic activity by cyslabdan, supported the conclusion that the primary molecular target of cyslabdan is FemA.

Our working hypothesis for the mechanism of the synergic action of cyslabdan is illustrated in Fig. 5. When MRSA is treated with cyslabdan, FemA is inhibited, resulting in the accumulation of monoglycyl and nonglycyl murein monomers, intermediates of peptidoglycan. However, cyslabdan alone has almost no effect on the growth of MRSA and methicillin-susceptible Staphylococcus aureus (MSSA), indicating that at least PBP, and possibly PBP2′, recognize monoglycyl murein monomers as a substrate and crosslink them to build the peptidoglycan. On the other hand, in combination with imipenem and cyslabdan, the growth of MRSA is completely inhibited, indicating that imipenem-insensitive PBP2′ cannot crosslink monoglycyl and nonglycyl mureins, resulting in the failure of MRSA peptidoglycan formation. Importantly, this model highlights the differences of PBP and PBP2′ in their substrate specificity. Accordingly, blocking the supply of the pentaglycyl substrates favorable for PBP2′ would be an effective approach for combating MRSA by combination therapy with β-lactam drugs. To the best of our knowledge, cyslabdan is the first identified FemA inhibitor, which positions it as a lead compound for the development of new types of anti-MRSA drugs.

Fig. 5. A Working Hypothesis on the Mechanism of Synergic Anti-MRSA Action in Combination with Imipenem and Cyslabdan

Four cases are shown here: a) no treatment, b) in the presence of imipenem, c) in the presence of cyslabdan, and d) combination of imipenem and cyslabdan.

5. Screening for Inhibitors of MRSA Yellow Pigment Production

S. aureus, including MRSA, produces a yellow pigment called staphyloxanthin (STX).34,35) Recently STX has been recognized as one of the important virulent factors of S. aureus.36) STX, located in the cell membrane, plays an important role in enhancing the survival and infectivity of S. aureus in host cells.37) STX is composed of glucose, prenyl and fatty acyl residues. Liu et al. reported that a mutant that lacked the CrtM (squalene synthase) gene involved in STX production failed to survive in a mouse host.38) This finding indicated that inhibitors of STX production could be new anti-infective drugs against MRSA. Several known compounds, BPH-652,38) zaragozic acid,39) 7-benzyloxyindoles40) and flavones,41) were reported to inhibit STX production. Among these, BPH-652, an inhibitor of squalene synthase, proved in vivo efficacy, blocking the infection of S. aureus in the host mice.42) Based on this background, we began a search for STX inhibitors from natural sources. A new agar plate assay was conducted in which STX was produced by MRSA under specific conditions.43) Microbial culture sample-containing paper disks (test samples) were placed on an MRSA agar plate, and white zone-showing samples (meaning that yellow pigment (STX) production was inhibited while MRSA grew normally) were selected. A total of 45000 cultures were screened, and 27 samples (0.06%) showed a white zone. Ultimately, three types of new compounds, citridone A,44) graphiumins45) and tylopilusins46,47) (Fig. 6), were discovered.

Fig. 6. Microbial STX Inhibitors Discovered from Phenotype-Based Screening and Citridone A Derivatives

Citridones, originally isolated as potentiators of miconazole activity against Candida albicans from the culture broth of Penicillium sp. FKI-1938,48,49) were found to inhibit yellow pigment production without growth inhibition of MRSA. Among these, citridone A was the most potent, with an IC50 of 37.9 µM in the liquid culture. Citridone A has a 6-6/5/5-ring system containing a rare phenyl-R-furopyridone skeleton. Because of its unique structure and biological properties, two groups have already been subjected to total synthesis.50,51) To understand the structure–activity relationship, 11 citridone A derivatives were synthesized. Of these, three derivatives, 1, 2 and 3, showed moderate inhibition with IC50s ranging from 76.8 to 101 µM (Table 3). These findings indicated that the 4,5,6a-trimethyl-4,6a-dihydro-3aH-cyclopentafuran skeleton in citridones is responsible for the inhibition of MRSA yellow pigment production.

Table 3. Inhibition of Yellow Pigment Production by Compounds
CompoundPaper disk assayLiquid culture assay
20 µg/6 mm disk (mm)IC50 (µM)
Citridone A1637.9
Derivative 113101
Derivative 21576.8
Derivative 31577.5
Graphiumin A10N.T.
Graphiumin I16120
Graphiumin J15133
(±)-Tylopilusin A9N.T.
(±)-Tylopilusin B8N.T.
Tylopilusin C8N.T.

N.T.; Not tested.

Ten new thiodiketopiperazines graphiumins, A to J, were isolated from the culture of the marine-derived fungus Graphium sp. OPMF00224. The structures of these graphiumins, including absolute configuration, were elucidated by spectroscopic analyses and chemical methods. Graphiumins, I and J, moderately inhibited the yellow pigment production of MRSA, with IC50s of 120 and 133 µM, respectively (Table 3).

Diphenolic racemates, (±)-tylopilusin A and (±)-tylopilusin B, and tylopilusin C, were isolated from the fruiting bodies of Tylopilus eximius. The racemates tylopilusins A and B, were separated into each enantiomer, and absolute configuration was assigned by electronic circular dichroism calculations. Each showed moderate inhibition of MRSA yellow pigment production by the paper disk method (Table 3).

Further experiments are needed to investigate the target molecules and in vivo efficacy of the STX inhibitors.

6. Conclusion

Microorganisms have historically provided a number of practically useful compounds, including antibiotics, cholesterol-lowering drugs, immunosuppressants and so on. It is a general understanding that microbial products are structurally diverse and thus have a potential role in the discovery of drugs with novel mechanisms of action.

Based on this belief, anti-infective drugs active against MRSA were sought from microbial metabolites in the 4 original screening systems. Phosphoglycolipid nosokomycins were discovered from an actinomycete culture as an anti-MRSA antibiotic in the in vivo-mimic screening system using silkworms. Nosokomycin A also proved in vivo activity against MRSA in the mouse infection system. Spirohexaline was discovered from a fungal culture to be an inhibitor of UPP synthase in the target-based screening system. The compound exhibited anti-MRSA activity, indicating that UPP synthase is a potential target to block MRSA growth. Cyslabdans and nosokophic acid were discovered from the same nosokomycin-producing actinomycete, and shown to be potentiators of imipenem activity against MRSA in phenotype-based screening systems. Cyslabdans are the first microbial products having a labdan structure, which was often reported from plant metabolites. The target molecule of cyslabdan was revealed (FemA), indicating that it is the first identified inhibitor of FemA, which is involved in the synthesis of a petaglycine interpeptide bridge in MRSA peptidoglycan. Citridones were re-discovered from a fungal culture as inhibitors of yellow pigment STX production in MRSA in the phenotype-based screening system. Citridone A has a unique 6-6/5/5-ring system containing a rare phenylfuropyridone skeleton.

Thus, these microbial products have unique structures and intriguing biological activities. Furthermore, some provided new potential targets in the development of anti-MRSA drugs, and others are also expected to provide new targets for further studies on mechanisms of action. The fundamental screening studies described herein, and these microbial compounds discovered, will likely lead to the development of practically useful drugs for combatting MRSA.

Acknowledgments

The author is grateful to Dr. Junji Inokoshi, Dr. Ryuji Uchida, Dr. Nobuhiro Koyama and Dr. Takashi Fukuda for their significant help in the preparation of this manuscript. I also express sincere thanks to all the members of my laboratory. This work was supported financially by Grants from KAKENHI B 21310146 of the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology of Japan, and from the Uehara Memorial Foundation.

Conflict of Interest

The author declares no conflict of interest.

References
 
© 2016 The Pharmaceutical Society of Japan
feedback
Top