In this prospective study of the efficacy of postoperative immunochemotherapy after mastectomy, which we started to use in 1977, we compared outcomes after mastectomy only, after mastectomy and chemotherapy, and after mastectomy and immunochemotherapy. In chemotherapy, carboquone was given intravenously in a daily dose of 3 mg on the day of operation and the next two days; and for the next five years, carboquone was given orally in a daily dose of 0.50 or 0.75mg for 40 days and withheld for the next 56 days. In immunochemotherapy, with a same scheduled intravenous carboquone, a static hemolytic streptococcal vaccine, OK-432, was injected intramuscularly two times a week at an initial dose of 0.2 KE. The dose was increased gradually to 2.0 KE during the first two months after the operation. Then, instead of OK-432, a polysaccharide preparation (PSK) from a boiled
Basidiomycetes extract was given a daily dose of 3.0g on the days of carboquone administration. In all, 150 patients agreed to random allocation (envelope method) of one of the three groups. As of April 1997, 91 were alive without recurrence, 11 were alive with recurrence, 37 had died of recurrence, and 11 had died of other causes. The fifteen-year overall survival rate was 61% for the control group with mastectomy only, 80% for group with mastectomy and chemotherapy, and 75% for the group with mastectomy and immunochemotherapy. The fifteen-year relapse-free survival rates in these three groups were 58%, 75%, and 66%, respectively. The results with chemotherapy, added were better than with mastectomy only (p=0.04, log-rank test). When adjusted with Cox regression analysis, overall survival was 72%, 74%, and 74%, respectively, and the relapse-free survival rate was 66%, 68%, and 67%, respectively. Both number of metastatic lymph nodes and carboquone administration were factors in survival (p<0.05 and p<0.05, respectively). Cancer of the contralateral breast was diagnosed, one in each group. Cancer of another organ was observed in seven patients: two were in control group, two were treated by mastectomy and chemotherapy, and three were treated by mastectomy and immunochemothrapy. Compared with the number expected (calculated by a governmental group in Osaka), the number observed was 1.8-2.2 times for all malignancies and 3.1-4.5 times for breast cancer. Carboquone as a postoperative adjuvant improved overall survival and relapse-free survival, but OK-432 or PSK did not. As a standard drug for postoperative treatment of breast cancer carboquone should be useful.
View full abstract