The purpose of this paper is to clarify the way in which students perceive the structure of the curriculum, and to examine the relationship between students’ perceptions and their educational outcomes. The paper also aims to consider, on the basis of the curriculum evaluation indicators thus obtained and insights aimed at refining evaluation measurement methods, the limitations as well as the possibilities of curriculum evaluation by students.
In recent years, educational evaluations have been much in demand with the aim of fulfilling the requirements of unceasing reform of college education on the one hand and accountability to Japanese society on the other. Within the context of educational evaluations leading to educational improvements, an examination of the relationship between students’ educational outcomes and their education/learning experiences is an extremely significant issue.
Out of a range of methodologies that are available for examining the above issue, student curriculum evaluation is considered to be one of the most useful. However, very few curriculum evaluations of this kind have been conducted in Japan.
Against this background, the present study targeted senior students in 14 universities in order to obtain their curriculum evaluations. In this way, it was possible to grasp the structural perceptions of the curriculum held by students, and at the same time examine the relationship between these and their educational outcomes. The key findings are as follows.
Firstly, the results show clearly that even within the same specialist area, the characteristics of the curriculum offered by each university vary in line with the level of difficulty of its entrance examination. Paralleling these variations, differences could also be seen in the characteristics of students’ learning experiences.
Secondly, it is clear that the influence of the curriculum characteristics, which determine educational outcomes, varies according to the way in which the measurement indicators of educational outcomes are set up. Furthermore, whether or not students are able to achieve satisfactory educational outcomes seems to depend greatly on their learning experiences in actual classes.
View full abstract