Tentative reference values for soil diagnostics were calculated from the quantitative relationship between yield levels and soil chemical characteristics in 70 upland fields used for organic farming in Hokkaido. Relative yields in each field were estimated through comparison with that in the nearby conventional field for reference. There were 32, 36, and 2 fields at the lower, comparable, upper levels of elevation, respectively. These fields were separated into the lower level group (LLG; n=32) and the comparable+upper level group (CULG; n=38) for a comparative analysis of soil chemical characteristics, since the number of upper level fields was small. The parameters considered for quantifying soil chemical characteristics (after harvesting) were pH (H2O), electrical conductivity (EC), total carbon (T-C), total nitrogen (T-N), T-C/T-N, exchangeable CaO (Ex-CaO), exchangeable MgO (Ex-MgO), exchangeable K2O (Ex-K2O), Ex-CaO/Ex-MgO, Ex-MgO/Ex-K2O, cation exchange capacity (CEC), base saturation percentage (BSP), nitrogen present as NH4+ (NH4-N), nitrogen present as NO3- (NO3-N), free inorganic nitrogen with incubation (30°C, 4 weeks), autoclave extractable nitrogen (AEN, 105°C, 1 hr), available phosphorus (Truog method), phosphate absorption coefficient, Cl-, and sulfur present as SO42- (SO4-S).
Statistically, CULG had higher NO3-N (P=0.006), SO4-S (P=0.038), AEN (P=0.074), and T-C/T-N (P=0.082); and lower BSP (P=0.013), pH (H2O) (P=0.016), and Ex-MgO/Ex-K2O (P=0.082) values than LLG. Out of the 7 parameters described above, 5 showed a dependence on the applied fertilizer type, but the relationship between application of specific fertilizers and yield levels remained unclear.
Tentative reference values for soil diagnostics were proposed by using the 25 and 75 percentile groups for each parameter measured in CULG fields for defining the lower and upper limits, respectively. Although a detailed comparison of soil properties between the two groups would require all 7 parameters discussed above, only NO3-N and pH (H2O) values are enough for yearly diagnostic checks.
View full abstract