We analyzed transiliac bone biopsy specimens from 46 hemodialysed patients, and the results were compared with a variety of serum biochemical data (parathyroid hormone, bone alkaline phosphatase, 1, 25(OH)
2D
3, etc.) to assess the pathogenesis of renal osteodystrophy and the biochemical diagnostic criteria.
The patients were classified into the following groups: hyperparathyroid bone disease (HPT; n=11); mild lesion (ML; n=18); osteomalacia (OM; n=4); aplastic bone disease (ABD; n=13). HPT patients with a fibrous tissue volume greater than 0.5% were classified as having osteitis fibrosa (OF; n=8). 1) Serum levels of PTH were significantly correlated with the osteoblast surface, osteoclast surface, fibrous tissue volume and bone formation rate. Based on these relationships, we found that serum intact-PTH levels between 85 and 220pg/m
l were associated with normal bone turnover. These findings suggest that moderately elevated serum levels of PTH are necessary to maintain normal bone turnover in hemodialysed patients. 2) Normal intact-PTH levels (≤65pg/m
l) are strong clinical indicators for the diagnosis of ABD, because normal levels of PTH were comparatively deficient in maintaining bone turnover in hemodialysed patients. There was no significant correlation between the frequency of ABD and bone aluminum (AI) surface. A relatively suppressed PTH level is the main pathogenic factor associated with the occurrence of ABD in hemodialysed patients, and AI is not the primary factor in the pathogenesis of ABD. Aging is one of the factors associated with ABD, because the mean age of the ABD group was significantly higher than the other groups, and the prevalence of ABD was significantly higher in patients over 50 years of age. 3) Increased bone AI surface was observed in OM patients. In hemodialysed patients, the deposition of AI in bone impairs mineralization, and thickening of the osteoid in bone surface occurs without increasing osteoid formation. 4) Elevated PTH levels (intact-PTH levels exceeded 400pg/m
l) with marked increments of osteoblast surface, osteoclast surface, bone formation rate and fibrous tissue volume were observed in HPT patients. In HPT patients, we often observed thickening and increments of osteoid, due to relatively delayed mineralization caused by marked increases in osteoid formation. 5) The serum levels of PTH, bone-ALP, BGP and TRACP were significantly correlated to bone histomorphometric parameters, and were useful to differentiate bone histological types in hemodialysed patients. Intact-PTH values>400pg/m
l or M-PTH>30ng/m
l were over 90% sensitive and specific for identifying patients with HPT or OF. Bone-ALP levels greater than the upper normal limits were 100% sensitive and 97% specific for patients with HPT, and were 100% sensitive and 89% specific for OF. Serum TRACP levels greater than the upper normal limits indicate patients with OF (100% sensitive; 93% specific). Serum BGP levels of all HPT patients were greater than 60ng/m
l (73% sensitive; 100% specific). On the other hand, serum intact-PTH levels lower than the normal upper limit (65pg/m
l) were 77% sensitive and 94% specific in patients with ABD. Although 70% of patients with serum intact-PTH levels between 65 and 400pg/m
l were ML patients, it was difficult to make a differential diagnosis between OM and ML.
View full abstract