Journal of the Japan Association for Philosophy of Science
Online ISSN : 1884-1236
Print ISSN : 0022-7668
ISSN-L : 0022-7668
Volume 51, Issue 1-2
Displaying 1-16 of 16 articles from this issue
Cover
Articles Special Section: Inferentialism as a Philosophical Foundation of Education Sciences
  • Ryo ITO
    Article type: Articles Special Section: Inferentialism as a Philosophical Foundation of Education Sciences
    2024Volume 51Issue 1-2 Pages 1-2
    Published: 2024
    Released on J-STAGE: April 27, 2024
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS
    Download PDF (579K)
  • Yusuke UEGATANI
    Article type: Articles Special Section: Inferentialism as a Philosophical Foundation of Education Sciences
    2024Volume 51Issue 1-2 Pages 3-21
    Published: 2024
    Released on J-STAGE: April 27, 2024
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    This paper examines the role of inferentialism in mathematics education research, a complex, transdisciplinary field. We overview constructivism in mathematics education and the emergence of inferentialism, clarifying our perspective of inferentialism in educational research. The focus is on how inferentialism allows researchers to analyze observable learner expressions, overcoming the limitations of constructivism in empirical educational research. We also discussed the implications of educational research for philosophical issues.

    Download PDF (888K)
  • Hiroki OTANI
    Article type: Articles Special Section: Inferentialism as a Philosophical Foundation of Education Sciences
    2024Volume 51Issue 1-2 Pages 23-35
    Published: 2024
    Released on J-STAGE: April 27, 2024
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    Statistics classes in school education in Japan often fail to narrow down multiple conflicting conclusions into one more persuasive conclusion. This paper analyzes and characterizes a relativistic statistics class from the perspective of inferentialism, thereby examining approaches to avoid relativism. As a result, I pointed out the inclusion of anomalies and the failure to pursue warrants as possible factors in the formation of relativistic norms and discussed strategies to avoid them. Based on the discussion, several challenges in adopting inferentialism as a normative analytical framework for educational phenomena are identified.

    Download PDF (1027K)
  • Shintaro SHIRAKAWA
    Article type: Articles Special Section: Inferentialism as a Philosophical Foundation of Education Sciences
    2024Volume 51Issue 1-2 Pages 37-50
    Published: 2024
    Released on J-STAGE: April 27, 2024
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    In recent years, in Japan, with moral education being designated as a ‘special subject,’ there has been a shift from inculcation-based teaching to one that encourages moral reflection and discussions. Nevertheless, various issues have been identified concerning the methods of discussion and normative education within moral education classes. This paper addresses these problems by reevaluating the foundations of moral education theory from an inferentialist perspective. Given that Robert Brandom’s inferentialism, upon which this paper relies, has certain limitations when applied to moral education, we incorporate John McDowell’s theory of moral sensibility with some modifications, sketching an adapted inferentialism more suitable for moral education.

    Download PDF (854K)
  • Hirotaka SUGITA
    Article type: Articles Special Section: Inferentialism as a Philosophical Foundation of Education Sciences
    2024Volume 51Issue 1-2 Pages 51-56
    Published: 2024
    Released on J-STAGE: April 27, 2024
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    This paper summarizes and comments on the papers by Uegatani, Otani, and Shirakawa included in the special section ‘Inferentialism as a Philosophical Foundation of Education Sciences,’ with a particular focus on the notion of norms used by each author. It explores the possibilities and limitations of inferentialism as a philosophical foundation for education sciences, shedding light on the varied usages of norms within inferentialism and education sciences.

    Download PDF (692K)
Articles
  • Akihiro NISHIYAMA, Shigenori TANAKA
    Article type: Articles
    2024Volume 51Issue 1-2 Pages 57-73
    Published: 2024
    Released on J-STAGE: April 27, 2024
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    We aim to describe the history of Quantum Brain Dynamics (QBD), the hypothesis of memory and consciousness in a brain, and argue about recent perspectives in this article. First we introduce several features in memory in a brain distinguished from computer memory. Next we introduce the holographic brain theory proposed by Pribram which describes the mechanism of memory. Furthermore we show quantum field theoretical approach of memory proposed by Umezawa et al.. We consider concrete degrees of freedom in QBD, namely water electric dipole fields and photon fields, and also discuss the feasibility of spontaneous breakdown of rotational symmetry of electric dipoles, where dipoles are aligned in the same direction, in order to describe memory. Next we introduce dissipative quantum model regarding a brain as an open system, and attempt the integration of QBD and holographic theory. Moreover we consider the consciousness emerging as Bose-Einstein condensate, and estimate its critical temperature. Furthermore we mention our opinions against criticisms with respect to decoherence phenomena. Finally we refer to perspectives on QBD towards solving hard problems in conventional neuroscience.

    Download PDF (1722K)
  • Michiyo NAKANE
    Article type: Articles
    2024Volume 51Issue 1-2 Pages 75-92
    Published: 2024
    Released on J-STAGE: April 27, 2024
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    This paper examines the collaboration of mathematicians and humanists, like philosophers and researchers of French literature, in Japan in discussing Blaise Pascal's mathematical thought from approximately 1940. The mathematicians who realized the difference between mathematics and historical studies of mathematics, and their collaboration with humanists resulted in the fruitful accumulation of their works. As a result, Kokiti Hara, a Japanese scholar of French literature, successfully published internationally influential papers on Pascal's mathematics from 1961 on, before the establishment of the research field of the history of mathematics in Japan in approximately 1970. This process provides an example of how we can integrate the arts and sciences.

    Download PDF (1830K)
  • An Approach Based on Thisness Bundle Theory
    Hiroshi OHATA
    Article type: Articles
    2024Volume 51Issue 1-2 Pages 93-113
    Published: 2024
    Released on J-STAGE: April 27, 2024
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    What is a quantum object? According to individualism, quantum objects are treated as individual objects. Therefore, we can count quantum objects because they are distinct individuals. However, if the individuality of a quantum object is given by its substratum, or primitively, the object would possess a definite position, which contradicts the orthodox interpretation of quantum mechanics. Given this situation, I propose that quantum objects should be regarded as “indefinite multi-located individuals.” A quantum object can exist wholly at multiple locations simultaneously but is probabilistically located with respect to each of those locations. This view is based on the following metaphysical framework: the ontology of thisness bundle theory for quantum objects, and the ideology of property (co-)instantiation with probability.

    Download PDF (872K)
Survey Article
  • Yasushi OGUSA, Takuya NIIKAWA
    Article type: Survey Article
    2024Volume 51Issue 1-2 Pages 115-135
    Published: 2024
    Released on J-STAGE: April 27, 2024
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    This paper examines new biological naturalist theories of consciousness, focusing on Ginsburg and Jablonka, and Feinberg and Mallat as their representatives. In doing so, we compare and analyze the two theories from three perspectives: the signature, the ontology, and the function of consciousness. We point out several significant theoretical differences between them, especially that Ginsburg and Jablonka propose a novel naturalistic teleological understanding of the ontological status of consciousness, whereas Feinberg and Mallat's theory conforms with so-called type-B physicalism.

    Download PDF (896K)
Reports on Activities
Imprint
feedback
Top