Biological and Pharmaceutical Bulletin
Online ISSN : 1347-5215
Print ISSN : 0918-6158
ISSN-L : 0918-6158
Review
Reactivating Circadian Rhythms as a Therapeutic Strategy: Insights from Basic Research
Masao Doi
著者情報
ジャーナル オープンアクセス HTML

2025 年 48 巻 8 号 p. 1165-1171

詳細
Abstract

One of the most significant conceptual changes brought about by the discovery of clock genes and development of circadian-clock mutant mice is the recognition that impaired circadian rhythmicity extends its impact far beyond sleep, driving pathogenesis of a wide variety of disorders such as cancer, obesity, and hypertension. However, despite this growing clinical evidence, chronobiology still lacks a coherent answer to the converse question: can restoration of circadian rhythms ameliorate—or even reverse—such diseases? In this review, three complementary pharmacological strategies—each still in preclinical development—are explored. First, direct modulation of the transcription-translation feedback loop (TTFL)—the core gene-regulatory circuit that generates 24-h rhythms in almost all nucleated cells—is reviewed as an approach to manipulation of cellular circadian biology. Second, the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN)-enriched G-protein-coupled receptor Gpr176 is highlighted as a central-clock target, given its ligand-independent, Gz-mediated control of cAMP signaling and demonstrated ability to reset the master pacemaker. Third, the concept of rhythmic enhancement of output function is introduced and exemplified by describing re-activation of circadian oxidized form of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+)-dependent 3β-hydroxy-steroid dehydrogenase (3β-HSD) activity in the meibomian gland—using nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN)—to restore peripheral clock-driven steroidogenesis in this tissue, which leads to amelioration of meibomian gland dysfunction, a leading cause of dry eye disease. This review aims to highlight the molecular logic of each strategy; both mechanistic insights and safety/efficacy considerations are discussed.

1. INTRODUCTION

Can various diseases be reversed or alleviated by correcting the internal circadian clock? (Fig. 1). Impaired circadian rhythms have been linked to pathogenesis of a wide variety of diseases, including hypertension,1,2) obesity,3) diabetes mellitus,4) cancer,5) polyploidization of liver cells,6) rheumatoid arthritis,7) hepatic metabolism disorders,8) jet-lag syndrome,9) nocturia,10) chronic kidney disease,11,12) pain hypersensitivity,13) and evaporative dry-eye disease,14) among others. This growing evidence supports the potential value of developing drugs targeting the circadian clock system to prevent and treat a broad spectrum of related disorders. However, the lack of clinically validated clock-modulators has thus far delayed proof-of-concept in chronomedicine (Fig. 1, a future direction of chronobiology).

Fig. 1. The Core Question of This Review Regarding the Potential of Circadian Clock Re-Activation

In this review, a series of studies aimed at developing drugs targeting the circadian clock system will be explored. More specifically, this review highlights the logic of three different pharmacological strategies for drugging clock: i) direct transcription-translation feedback loops (TTFL)-mediated cellular clock modulation (see chapter 2.1), ii) central-clock modulation via suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN)-specific G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) (see chapter 2.2), and iii) tissue-specific amplification of peripheral clock outputs (see chapter 2.3). Integrating and comparing these potential approaches, this review argues that reactivating circadian rhythms is a therapeutic avenue that merits further investigation.

2. MOLECULAR LOGIC FOR DRUG DISCOVERY TARGETING CENTRAL AND PERIPHERAL CLOCKS

2.1. Is the TTFL a Viable Therapeutic Target?

Notwithstanding intriguing reports of transcription-independent circadian oscillations of per-oxiredoxin superoxidation in red blood cells,15) the field-wide consensus holds that, in every nucleated cell, whether central or peripheral, individual circadian rhythms are generated by TTFLs.1618) Reinforcing this model, mice carrying a site-specific mutation only at the E′-box element in the promoter of the core clock gene Per2 demonstrate that transcription via this element is essential for establishing cell-autonomous circadian oscillations.19) Similarly, deleting the Cry1 intronic enhancer region, which contains a ROR-responsive element, led to alteration of circadian period.20) These data indicate that the mechanism to generate and maintain 24-h rhythmicity lies in the architecture of the TTFLs in each cell. In this regard, it is worth noting that in the Per2 E′-box mutant cells, all mammalian core clock proteins, including Per1, Per2, Clock, Bmal1, Cry1, Cry2, CK1, DBP, E4BP4, ROR and REV-ERB remain intact, the sole change being the mutated E′-box in the Per2 promoter, indicating that transcription is a critical nodal element for generating rhythmicity (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2. The Mammalian Circadian Clock System

Circadian rhythms are generated in nearly all cells in the body. In each cell, common core clock genes generate circadian rhythmicity (left). At the organismal level, the central clock located in the SCN directs harmonious oscillations of peripheral tissues (middle). GPCRs in the SCN help to generate robust circadian rhythmicity, either positively or negatively regulating cAMP signaling in a time-of-day-dependent manner (right). TTFL, transcription/translation feedback loop; AC, adenylate cyclase.

Drug-discovery efforts targeting core clock proteins within the TTFL have advanced most notably for the transcriptional repressor Cry and the nuclear receptors REV-ERB and ROR, for which potent and selective small-molecule modulators have been identified.2123) Cry2-targeting molecules improve glucose clearance in obese mice and inhibit glioblastoma cell growth in culture.2426) A synthetic REV-ERB agonist decreases obesity, accompanied by changes in expression of metabolic genes in liver, skeletal muscle and adipose tissue, in mice.27) Pharmacologic acceleration of REV-ERB proteolysis enhances the amplitude of circadian gene expression critical for liver metabolism and improves energy homeostasis in mice.28) A ROR agonist, Nobiletin, also acts as a circadian clock amplitude enhancer and helps combat metabolic disorder29) and cancer growth30) in mice. Because REV-ERB and ROR are multi-functional nuclear receptors, their activity affects multiple pathways even beyond the TTFL: The observed therapeutic benefits are likely mediated through a mix of clock-dependent and clock-independent mechanisms—and may even reflect a synergistic interplay of both.31)

The TTFL-targeting drugs necessitate further clinical evaluation from a pragmatic standpoint. Because clock genes are present in virtually all cells in the body (Fig. 2), systemic application is likely to cause complex effects. In both primates and rodents, the phases of rhythmic clock gene expression in the SCN and peripheral tissues are disparate from each other.32,33) Therefore, drugs able to act on core clock-components would likely reset all oscillators simultaneously, jeopardizing the adaptive phasic hierarchy between SCN and peripheral tissues.32,33) To avoid this risk, selective tissue-limited administration of drug may be necessary.

2.2. Avenues for Central Clock Modulation—GPCRs as Promising Targets

The mammalian circadian clock is organized in a systemic hierarchy of multiple oscillators, in which the SCN functions as a master pacemaker at the top of hierarchy3436) (Fig. 2). The SCN harmonizes the phase and amplitude of circadian rhythms of peripheral tissues. Because of this role, the SCN is a unique and ideal target for modulating the entire body clock system.

From a drug-development perspective, GPCRs selectively expressed in the SCN are attractive targets: GPCRs are the largest family of cell-surface receptors and comprise a major source of drug targets with diverse therapeutic applications.37,38) The tissue-expression specificity is also key to confining drug action. Unlike drugs targeting TTFLs, SCN specificity makes it possible to design drugs that affect the central clock (SCN) while having no “direct” effect on peripheral clocks, leaving them subject to SCN-dependent cues, and thereby retaining normal between-tissue phasic organization in the body. However, despite these conceivable (or theoretical) advantages, therapeutic exploitation of SCN-specific GPCRs is still at an early, proof-of-concept stage of basic research, exemplified by studies on Gpr176 (see below).

Gpr176 is an SCN-enriched orphan GPCR that can set the pace of the SCN clock39,40)—thus, this GPCR might be a target for drug discovery for circadian clock treatment. Gpr176 undergoes asparagine (N)-linked glycosylation, a post-translational modification required for its proper cell-surface expression.41) Although its endogenous ligand remains unknown, this orphan receptor has the ability to exhibit ligand-independent basal activity.39,42) Gpr176 couples to the unique G-protein subclass Gz (or Gx) and participates in reducing cAMP production during the night.39)

The regulator of G-protein signaling 16 (Rgs16) is equally important for the regulation of cAMP synthesis in the SCN,43,44) suggesting an interplay between Gpr176 and Rgs16 in the regulation of circadian cAMP pathway in the SCN45) (Fig. 2). In the SCN of Gpr176−/− mice, expression of neuromedin U (Nmu) and neuromedin S (Nms) is markedly up-regulated, and this compensatory increase preserves the mice’s normal phase-resetting responses to light.40)

Another interesting feature of Gpr176 is its rhythmic expression in the SCN, peaking during the night.39) The neuropeptide vasoactive intestinal polypeptide (VIP) and its cognate receptor Vipr2 signaling is necessary for cells in the SCN to synchronize their timekeeping,46,47) and a genetic ablation of Vipr2 in the SCN leads to reduced expression of Gpr176,48) suggesting a counterbalancing between Vipr2-Gs signaling and Gpr176-Gz signaling in the SCN (see a Yin-Yang model depicted in Fig. 2). At the mRNA level, light causes a rapid downregulation of Gpr176 expression in cholecystokinin (CCK)-positive neurons in the SCN.49) These mRNA data suggest that circadian clock-dependent and light dependent Gpr176 activity in the SCN is likely controlled by both its unknown ligand and the amount of receptor expressed. In spite of this wealth of information of gene expression and knockout mouse data studying Gpr176, we have little information about its ligand.50) Substantial additional effort—including cell-based high-throughput screening as well as structure-guided virtual screening—will be necessary to drive drug discovery for Gpr176.5154)

2.3. Reactivation of Rhythmic Output Pathways in Specific Peripheral Tissues

Besides directly targeting the rhythm-generation mechanism (i.e., oscillator or TTFL) itself, an equally possible avenue is to manipulate the circadian clock’s output pathways (i.e., outputs) (Fig. 3, left). Although the TTFL machinery is common to all tissues, each tissue converts this oscillator’s signal into diverse, tissue-unique functional output rhythms. Pharmacologically amplifying these specific output rhythms offers two advantages: (i) precision—interventions can be confined to the tissue of interest, and (ii) functional efficacy—by acting directly on the effector pathway, interventions can be effective and specific (Fig. 3, left). I term this strategy rhythmic enhancement of output function. Its potential can be exploited, in principle, in any tissue; while I apply it to the meibomian gland, a peripheral tissue in the eyelid (see below).

Fig. 3. A Strategy for Rhythmic Enhancement of Output Function

(Left) A conceptual diagram of enhancement of circadian rhythm of specific output. (Right) A graphic summary depicting the effect of rhythmic enhancement of steroidogenic activity in the meibomian gland leading to improvement of meibomian gland function. MGD, meibomian-gland dysfunction.

The meibomian glands in the eyelids produce oil (meibum) to the ocular surface to prevent dehydration (dry eye). Androgens are generated inside this tissue through a mechanism of local intracrine activity.14,55) Canonically, hormones are produced by endocrine organs and delivered to target tissues. However, for steroids, the concept of “intracrinology,” whereby hormones are synthesized in the tissue where they exert their effect without being released into blood circulation, has been proposed55) and identified for a number of tissues including the meibomian gland14) (Fig. 3, right). The circadian clock regulates this local intracrine activity through nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+)-dependent circadian 3β-hydroxy-steroid dehydrogenase (3β-HSD) activity. Age-associated reduction in 3β-HSD activity caused meibomian gland dysfunction (MGD) leading to evaporative dry eye disease.14,56) Conversely, reactivation of circadian 3β-HSD activity by boosting its coenzyme NAD+ availability (through topical nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) application) improved glandular cell proliferation and alleviated MGD and accompanying dry eye phenotype.14) These data exemplify a model-case in which (re)activation of a specific output rhythm can reverse local tissue disorder.

The time-dependent and tissue-specific enhancement of rhythmic intracrine activity appears important to normalize meibomian gland function. To restore this rhythm, NMN-containing eye drop was supplied to mice specifically during daytime, which is when the endogenous meibomian intracrine activity is in its daily peak phase.14) On the other hand, night-time eye-drop administration of NMN was less effective than the daytime application, indicating that appropriately timed up-regulation resembling the endogenous circadian rhythm is essential to draw the maximum drug effect.

The potential merit of topical (re)activation of local intracrine activity also involves fewer potential side-effects on extra-meibomian tissues. For example, the same NAD+-dependent 3β-HSD enzyme is known to contribute to aldosterone production in the adrenal gland.5762) Abnormally activated 3β-HSD activity in this tissue leads to hyperaldosteronism, associated with salt-sensitive hypertension in mice2) and is linked to idiopathic hyperaldosteronism in humans.62) Therefore, avoidance of off-site activation of 3β-HSD enzymatic activity (for example, in the adrenal gland) is critical for drug-development and safety evaluation.

Clinically, the loss of sex-steroid hormones in men (andropause) and women (menopause) is a critical hallmark of aging. Both male and female express 3β-HSD in the meibomian gland.14,63) Androgen metabolites, namely, 5α-androstane-3,17-dione, 3α-hydroxy-5α-androstan-17-one, and 3β-hydroxy-5α-androstan-17-one, have been identified to be secreted in meibum samples regardless of genders.63) These metabolic biomarkers may serve to assess meibomian gland activity in clinical settings. Future clinical study will therefore require evaluating the impact of “circadian” NMN application on these markers in patient cohorts. This might become a representative trial for rhythmic enhancement of output function for new drug-discovery.

3. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE DIRECTION

This review explored the potential of leveraging three complementary circadian strategies—TTFL modulation, SCN-specific GPCR targeting, and tissue-specific rhythmic enhancement of output function—to create next-generation chronotherapeutics. It is my view that these strategies will enable us to propose new drugs and therapies for disease groups that are still in need of novel medications, such as MGD and sleep disorders. Importantly, such strategies may be effective in addressing the age-related natural decrease in circadian rhythmicity and restoring clock function in older populations to alleviate age-associated diseases.64,65)

Although this review focused on drug-based chronomedicine, the circadian system is also remarkably responsive to drug-free behavioral cues. Preclinical studies show that regularly timed exercise, structured feeding schedules, and the resulting predictable fluctuations in core body temperature can robustly amplify peripheral clock rhythms and restore rhythmic gene expression across multiple tissues.6669) Harnessing such lifestyle-driven entrainment signals not only offers a low-cost, low-risk means of reinforcing endogenous clocks but may also act synergistically with TTFL-, SCN-, or output-focused therapeutics to maximize clinical benefit. On the basis of pharmacological interventions designed to strengthen (or re-activate) endogenous circadian rhythms, these approaches may help to restore temporal coordination of behavior and physiologies and thereby modulate disease outcomes. I envisage that insights gleaned from circadian-clock research over the coming decade will not only satisfy fundamental scientific curiosity but also shape the development of novel therapeutic approaches to improve human health and wellness.

Acknowledgments

I thank Dr. Hitoshi Okamura, Professor Emeritus, Department of Systems Biology, Graduate School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Kyoto University, Japan for his continued guidance to our laboratory research. I also thank all previous and current staffs in my laboratory: Dr. Yoshiaki Yamaguchi, Dr. Takahito Miyake, Dr. Emi Hasegawa, and Dr. Yoichi Tanaka for their support. This work and studies described in this review were supported in part by research grants from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology of Japan (22H04987 and 24H02306), the Cyclic Innovation for Clinical Empowerment of the Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development (JP22pc0101069), SRF, the Basis for Supporting Innovative Drug Discovery and Life Science Research program of the Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development (JP21am0101092), and Astellas Foundation for Research on Metabolic Disorders.

Conflict of Interest

The author declares no conflict of interest.

Notes

This review of the author’s work was written by the author upon receiving the 2024 Pharmaceutical Society of Japan Award for Divisional Scientific Promotion.

REFERENCES
 
© 2025 Author(s).
Published by The Pharmaceutical Society of Japan.

This article is licensed under a Creative Commons [Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International] license.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
feedback
Top