Next generation sequencer (NGS) has allowed the precise profiling of complex microbial communities in nature. This methodology has been introduced into research of gastrointestinal microbiota which is composed of 100 trillion cells of several hundred species. However, recent developments in NGS technology have obliged us to update the platform of microbiota analysis. In this study, we compared and validated the results obtained using 454 pyrosequencer (Roche), which has hitherto mainly been used for gut microbiota analysis, and a MiSeq (Illumina) which recently incorporated remarkable technological advances. We also validated the accuracy of taxonomic classification obtained from different variable regions of 16S ribosomal RNA genes. The V3-V4 region showed the best results for accuracy of taxonomic classification. In contrast, V6-V8 showed less bias for the bacterial composition of higher taxonomic levels, but all variable regions generated more or less bias for certain bacteria groups due to the universal primers used. Finally, UniFrac-PCoA data generated by different NGS data sets were compared using Procrustes analysis, and were shown to be robust regardless of variable regions and sequencers. Among a variety of NGSs, MiSeq is suitable for gut microbiota analysis in terms of running cost and operability, and can be more generally used for gastrointestinal tract microbial research.
View full abstract