HPV-related oropharyngeal cancer is considered to have a better prognosis and higher efficacy of chemoradiotherapy (CRT) than HPV-unrelated oropharyngeal cancer. On the other hand, in recent years, transoral robotic surgery (TORS) has been covered by health insurance in Japan and is considered a good indication for T1/T2 oropharyngeal cancer without extranodal extension. Since HPV-related oropharyngeal cancer often occurs in young people, it is believed that radiotherapy should be avoided or conserved as much as possible. However, although the usefulness of transoral resection for patients with early-stage oropharyngeal cancer has been reported, there are not enough data in Japan comparing it with radiotherapy or chemoradiotherapy. Therefore, it is difficult to decide on a treatment plan for patients with early-stage HPV-related local oropharyngeal cancer, and whether to choose transoral surgery or CRT. In our department, we have developed and performed transoral videolaryngoscopic surgery (TOVS), a non-robotic transoral surgery, as a minimally invasive surgery for early-stage local laryngopharyngeal cancer. Therefore, we conducted a retrospective chart review of cases of early-stage HPV-related oropharyngeal cancer treated with TOVS or CRT at our institution.
This study retrospectively analyzed 29 patients who underwent either TOVS or CRT as initial treatment (18 in the TOVS group and 11 in the CRT group), evaluating treatment outcomes, complications, post-treatment laryngeal function, and positive surgical margins in the TOVS group.
At the 3-year mark, both groups demonstrated 100% overall survival, disease-specific survival and local control. No patients experienced major complications or disabling dysphagia. While positive surgical margins were observed in 3 TOVS cases (16.7%), all were in the anterior wall.
TOVS was associated with good outcomes and 72% of patients in this study were able to preserve radiotherapy. In cases of anterior wall, it is possible to avoid or preserve radiation therapy by setting an adequate resection range.
View full abstract