Purpose: We investigated the operative time (OP) of conventional inguinal hernia repair (CIHR) performed by residents in order to determine the number of operations required to master this surgical technique.
Methods: We compared chronological changes in the OPs of CIHRs for male patients with unilateral inguinal hernia performed by residents A, B, and C who were trained before the adoption of laparoscopic percutaneous extraperitoneal closure (LPEC). These results were compared with the number and OPs of CIHRs performed by residents D and E who were trained after the adoption of LPEC.
Results: Residents A, B, and C performed 127, 124, and 131 CIHRs over a 3-year period, respectively. The OPs for the 61
st to 80
th CIHRs were significantly shorter than those for the 41
st to 60
th (A: 35 ± 6 vs. 41 ± 10, B: 27 ± 7 vs. 33 ± 11, and C: 32 ± 10 vs. 40 ± 15 min; p < 0.05). The 3 residents performed 80 CIHRs for their respective period of 21, 25, and 19 months, and their total numbers of CIHRs for male patients, including those excluded from later analysis, were 93, 104, and 92 in same period. In contrast, residents D and E respectively performed only 34 and 30 CIHRs over 24 months; the OPs of their last 20 CIHRs (40 ± 11 and 39 ± 14 min) were longer than those of the 61
st to 80
th CIHRs performed by residents A, B, and C.
Conclusions: To master the CIHR technique, 100 CIHRs for male patients may be required. It has become difficult for residents to perform a sufficient number of CIHRs since the widespread adoption of the LPEC technique.
View full abstract