We attached an electric outboard motor and an engine outboard motor with the same output to a rubber boat and compared the properties of both navigations. We engaged students in a specialized high school in a new type of problem study to learn energy conversion based on its content and evaluated the learning effect. The practice in the project studies was conducted in a school swimming pool and under such condition that there was no need for any vessel licenses. First of all, we fixed the dinghy with either an electric motor or an oil driven one to the edge of the pool and measured the maximum thrust of each. The results showed that each thrust was approximately 200N. Next, using those results, it was determined that the electric outboard motor can generate the same speed while consuming 16% to 30% of its energy that the oil-driven motor does in its low speed range (about 5.0 to 5.6km/hour). Results of student questionnaires indicated that the farther their learning advanced, the more interest and knowledge the students had in the questionnaire items such as regarding the outboard motor's structure, control, measuring method, and analysis methods. On the other hand, in the questionnaire items such as regarding engine structure, engine operation principle, and method measuring of energy consumption, I could not find clear significant learning effect.
View full abstract