Using the database of construction record of RC abutments of bridges in the quality attainment system of Yamaguchi prefecture in Japan, thermal stress analysis was conducted to create a crack probability curve, which was compared with that in the Standard Specifications for Concrete Structures (SSCS) of JSCE. When the curve created based on the JCI guideline was compared to that in SSCS, it was found that the position of the former curve was shifted toward the left side compared to the SSCS curve. This was thought to be caused by much higher value of thermal expansion coefficient used in the analysis compared to thermal expansion coefficients measured from specimens made in 21 ready-mixed concrete plants in Yamaguchi prefecture. The authors calculated another curve using the measured thermal expansion coefficient which almost matched the curve of SSCS.
When all available data of abutment lifts was used to make a curve assuming normal distribution for tensile strength and tensile stress, the coefficient of variation for tensile strength and tensile stress was 19%, which was higher than reported in previous studies. When the data was divided into two, that is, before 2010 and after 2010, obtained two different curves showed different shapes. It was found that the coefficient of variation before 2010 was 15%, and this coefficient reduced to 12.5% after 2010 when Yamaguchi system was sophisticated and improved. The reduction in coefficient of variation was thought to be due to that good concreting work was conducted according to Yamaguchi quality attainment system, resulting in improved quality of concrete.
View full abstract