We analyzed data for 16 instances of more than one hour of NPPV administered to 13 patients who were admitted to our intensive care unit during a nine-month period. The success rate (avoidance of endotracheal intubation) was 62.5%. During NPPV, patients who did not require intubation (Group S,
N=10) showed significant improvement in P/F ratio (
P<0.01) and significant respiratory rate reduction (
P<0.05). These variables did not change significantly for patients who required intubation (Group F,
N=3). P/F ratio deteriorated during NPPV in Group F (
P<0.01). Patients in Group S required NPPV for less than 30 hours. Two patients in Group F, who were later diagnosed as suffering diaphragmatic nerve paralysis, were intubated after less than 7 hours of NPPV. The other patient was intubated after more than 26 hours of NPPV. We suspect that the failure to avoid extubation in this patient may have been influenced by the criteria used for deciding to reintubate and that this may partly account for the variable results that are often reported for NPPV for patients with acute respiratory failure. In conclusion appropriate criteria for reintubation during NPPV should be investigated.
View full abstract