The relationships between the speed of deterioration in severe asthma attack and clinical characteristics as measured by arterial blood gas values, duration of mechanical ventilation needed, and course of peak inspiratory pressure (PIP) during mechanical ventilation were studied. Twenty-six patients with severe bronchial asthma who underwent mechanical ventilation were classified into 3 groups according to the time interval from the first symptoms of asthma attack to endotracheal intubation: rapid onset group-(ROG: n=9, <3hr), intermediate onset group-IOG (n=9, ≥3hr, but <24hr) and slow onset group-(SOG: n=8, ≥24hr). Mechanical ventilation was adapted in order to achieve optimal tidal volume, respiratory frequency, and inspiratory flow rate compatible with PIP 50cmH
2O or under. Sedatives (diazepam, midazolam) and muscle relaxants (pancuronium, vecuronium) were given intravenously while mechanical ventilation was performed.
ROG showed severe mixed acidosis with extreme hypercapnia (pH=7.01±0.17 (mean±SD), PaCO
2=106±31mmHg, BE=-8.9±7.6mEq·
l-1), high incidence of respiratory arrest, and deeply altered consciousness on admission. Blood gas values of ROG were significantly different from those of SOG (pH=7.23±0.10, PaCO
2=69±10mmHg, BE=-0.9±6.1mEq·
l-1: p<0.05). PIP at the start of mechanical ventilation was high (39±9cmH
2O), but between 30 minutes and 8 hours after the start of mechanical ventilation it suddenly dropped showing no further sign of increased airway responsiveness. One patient in ROG developed subcutaneous emphysema. ROG was characterized by rapid recovery with shorter duration of mechanical ventilation (10±8hr)than IOG (59±26hr) or SOG (63±29hr) (p<0.01).
IOG showed higher PIP at the start of mechanical ventilation than SOG (42±8cmH
2O versus 31±5cmH
2O: p<0.05) and needed prolonged ventilatory support due to long-standing high PIP and/or airway hyper-responsiveness. Three patients in IOG developed subcutaneous emphysema.
In contrast SOG did not show high PIP during mechanical ventilation, but needed prolonged ventilatory support because of a large amount of secretion in the airway and/or hypoxemia.
These findings indicate that there are significant differences in the clinical features and pathogenesis of airway narrowing between the 3 groups, and ROG and IOG have a higher incidence of pulmonary barotrauma due to severe airway narrowing during mechanical ventilation.
View full abstract