The distribution of the lesions responsible for aphasia unassociated with right-sided hemiparesis was evaluated by cranial computed tomography (CT) among stroke patients. There were 18 patients with this syndrome, in which aphasia was Broca type in 2 patients, Wernicke in 7, transcortical motor in 2, transcortical sensory in 2, amnestic in 2 and global in 3.
The responsible lesions revealed by CT were as follows :
1) Broca aphasia; Aphasic symptoms were atypical of Broca aphasia in these 2 patients because writing or silent reading was preserved, and the lesions were far more localized than in ordinary Broca one.
2) Wernicke aphasia; In this group most patients showed relatively large lesions in the left superior temporal gyms, sometimes extending to supramarginal and angular gyri, which caused such additional symptoms as apraxia without motor paresis in some cases.
3) Transcortical motor aphasia; One patient showed the occlusion of the left internal carotid artery, though without obvious abnormality at CT. In another patient a circumscribed low density lesion was disclosed in the area anterior and superior to so-called Broca 's area.
4) Transcortical sensory aphasia; In this group the lesion involved the borderzone supplied by the left middle and posterior cerebral arteries.
5) Amnestic aphasia; One patient showed a lesion in the left parietal lobe, while in another no remarkable change was demonstrated.
6) Global aphasia; One had multiple isolated lesions in both anterior and posterior speech areas. Another showed a large lesion involving the whole territory of the left middle cerebral artery. In the remaining one a high density area was observed in the left superior temporal, supramarginal and angular gyri, not extending to the fronal lobe beyond wht sylvian fissure.
In summary, in sensory type of aphasia the responsible lesions were distributed in the areas almost compatible with those stated in literature. On the contrary, in aphasias of other types there were some discrepancies between the actual sites of lesion at CT and those predicted on basis of clinical symptoms. For example, in a patient with global aphasia a widespread lesion in the whole territory of the left middle cerebral artery caused no hemiparesis, while in another with this type of aphasia the lesion did not extend to the anterior speech area. In addition, CT revealed no lesions in one patient with transcortical motor and amnestic aphasia, respectively. Therefore, in interpreting CTs of such aphasic patients we must take account of not only the extent of the lesion but also the severity of destruction, that is, whether softening in complete or incomplete, because the extent with reduced blood perfusion could not be identical with that of low density at CT. Furthermore, in face of reduction in cerebral blood flow there may be a difference in threshold of affection between limb motor function and speech one as a higher cortical function, implying the latter usually being more vulnerable.
View full abstract