One hundred and seventy-nine patients with hypertensive intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) were studied to reevaluate the clinical significance of the Fisher's table for local diagnosis of ICH. Subjects consisted of 39 thalamic, 60 putaminal, 30 combined type, 21 subcortical, 13 cerebellar and 16 brain stem hemorrhages. They fulfilled the following conditions, that is, 1st episode of ICH, admission within 3 days of the onset and detailed evaluation by neurologists and by CT. Medical history and the presenting manifestations in the acute stage were investigated, including 17 items listed as of importance for differentiation by Fisher.
The results of the present study were not consistent with the Fisher's well-accepted belief. The important results were as follows :
1) In thalamic hemorrhage, miotic pupil, anisocoria and absent light reflex were noted only in 23%, 36% and 26% respectively, and not so different from those in putaminal hemorrhage, suggesting that they are not characteristic of thalamic hemorrhage.
2) Downward deviation of the eyes (DDE) were observed only in 21% of thalamic hemorrhage, but none in other types of ICH except for combined type ICH, that is, highly suggestive for thalamic lesion.
3) Recurrent severe vomiting without consciousness disturbance at onset, suggests cerebellar or subcortical hemorrhages.
4) Even in brain stem hemorrhage, consciousness disturbance at onset, quadriplegia and miotic pupil were observed only in 50%, 44% and 43%, respectively.
These results probably reflect the current trends in the clinical picture of ICH. Based on these observations, it is strongly suggested that Fisher's table should be reappreciated in many points, especially in thalamic, brain stem and cerebellar hemorrhages. These changes in the clinical pictures of ICH seem to be due to the relative increase of the mild cases as a result of improvement of the medical management especially for hypertension, while Fisher's table was based on the diagnosis by autopsy findings of the patients who may had large and severe hematomas.
View full abstract